This article explores the relevance of global/local to understanding ways of `doing
boy/girl' (Butler, 1999; Connell, 2005; Haywood and Mac an Ghiall, 2003) and the
contribution that visual sociology can make to this. Using quantitative and
qualitative methods to analyse 10—12 year olds' texts and drawings, the
article concludes that despite the highly globalized and rapidly changing nature of
the society, Ireland is still very far away from a situation where: `What gender
identity is, and how it is expressed, has become itself a matter of multiple
options' (Giddens, 1991: 81). It suggests that globalization supports hegemonic ways
of `doing boy' and that global elements can be used to extend the repertoire of ways
of `doing girl'. It also suggests that drawings can provide insights into the way in
which global idioms become part of young people's perception of each other and their world.
Albrow, M.
(2004) `Travelling Beyond Local Cultures', in
F.J. Lechner
and
J. Boli
(eds) The Globalisation Reader (2nd Edition), pp.
133—40.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
2.
Baker, J.
,
Lynch, K.
,
Cantillon, S.
and
Walsh, J.
(2004) Equality: From Theory to Action.
Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan
.
3.
Beck, U.
(1992) Risk Society: Towards a New Modernity.
London: Sage
.
4.
Beck, U.
and
Beck-Gernsheim, E.
(2002) Individualization.
London: Sage
.
5.
Becker, H.S.
(1998) `Visual Sociology, Documentary Photography and
Photojournalism: Its (Almost) All a Matter of Context', in
J. Prosser
(ed.) Image Based Research: A Sourcebook for Qualitative
Researchers, pp. 84—96.
London: Falmer Press
.
6.
Bell, L.
(1998) `Public and Private Meanings in Diaries: Researching
Family and Childcare', in
R. Edwards
and
J. Ribbens
(eds) Feminist Dilemmas in Qualitative Research: Public Knowledge and
Private Lives, pp. 72—86.
London: Sage
.
7.
Bennett, A.
(2000) Popular Music and Youth Culture.
Basingstoke: Macmillan
.
8.
Bjerrum Nielsen, H.
(2004) `
European Gender Lessons: Girls and Boys at Scout Camps in Denmark,
Portugal, Russia and Slovenia
', Childhood: Global Journal of Child Research11(2):
207—26
.
9.
Bryman, A.
(1992) `Quantitative and Qualitative Research: Further
Reflections on their Research', in
J. Brannen
(ed.) Mixing Methods: Quantitative and Qualitative Research , pp.
57—78.
Aldershot: Avebury
.
10.
Butler, J.
(1999) Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of
Identity. London and New York:
Routledge
.
11.
Cameron, D.
(ed.) (1998) The Feminist Critique of Language
(2nd Edition).
London: Routledge
.
12.
Clancy, P.
(2001) College Entry in Focus: A Fourth National Survey of
Access to Higher Education.
Dublin
: Higher
Education Authority
.
13.
Cleary, A.
(2005) `
Death Rather than Disclosure: Struggling to be a Real Man', IrishJournal of Sociology14(2):
155—76
.
14.
Connell, R.W.
(1987) Gender and Power.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
Connell, R.W.
(2005) `
Growing Up Masculine: Rethinking the Significance of Adolescence in the
Making of Masculinities', IrishJournal of Sociology14(2):
11—28
.
Corcoran, M.
,
Gray, J.
and
Peillon, M.
(2003) `Local Sentiment and Sense of Place in a New Suburban
Community', Unpublished Manuscript,
NUIM
.
19.
Cso
(2004) Women and Men in Ireland .
Dublin: Government Publications
.
20.
Deacon, D.
,
Bryman, A.
and
Fenton, N.
(1998) `
Collison or Collusion? A Discussion and Case Study of the Unplanned
Triangulation of Quantitative and Qualitative Research Methods
', International Journal of Social Research Methodology1(1):
47—63
.
21.
Devine, D.
(2003) Children, Power and Schooling: How Childhood is
Structured in School.
Stoke-on-Trent: Trentham Publications
.
22.
Devine, D.
,
Nic Ghiolla Phadraigh, M.
and
Deegan, J.
(2004) `Time for Children, Time for Change? Children's Rights
and Welfare in Ireland During a Period of Economic Growth', in
A.M. Jensen
,
A. Ben-Arieh
,
G. Conti
,
D. Kutsar
,
M. Nic Ghiolla Phadraigh
and
H.W. Nielsen
(eds) Children's Welfare in Ageing Europe Vol. 1, pp.
211—71.
Trondheim: Norwegian Centre For Child Research
.
23.
Espad
(2004) The European School Survey Project on Alcohol and
other Drugs: Report 2003. URL (consulted 18 April 2006): http://www.espad.org/reports.html
24.
Fahey, T.
,
Hayes, B.C.
and
Sinnott, R.
(2005) Conflict and Consensus.
Dublin : IPA
.
25.
Giddens, A.
(1991) Modernity and Self-Identity: Self and Society in the
Late Modern Age.
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
26.
Giddens, A.
(1994) `Living in a Post Traditional Society', in
U. Beck, A. Giddens and S. Lash, Reflexive Modernization, pp.
56—109.
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
27.
Ging, D.
(2005) `
A “Manual on Masculinity”? The Consumption and Use of
Mediated Images of Masculinity among Teenage Boys in Ireland', Irish Journal OfSociology14(12):
29—52
.
28.
Gray, B.
(2004) Women and the Irish Diaspora.
London: Routledge
.
29.
Haywood, C.
and Mac an
Ghiall, M.
(2003) Men and Masculinities: Theory, Research and Social PracticeBuckingham: Open University Press
.
30.
Haywood, C.
,
Popoviciu, L.
and Mac an
Ghiall, M.
(2005) `
Feminisation and Schooling: Re-masculinisation, Gendered Reflexivity and
Boyness', IrishJournal of Sociology14(2):
193—212
.
31.
Hbsc
(2004) Health Behaviour in School-Aged Children: Irish
Report. URL (consulted 20 March 2006): http://www.hbsc.org/countries.html
32.
Jagger, E.
(2002) `Marketing
Molly and Melville: Dating in a Postmodern Consumer Society
', Sociology35(1):
39—57
.
33.
James, A.
,
Jenks, C.
and
Prout, A.
(1998) Theorizing Childhood.
Cambridge : Polity Press
.
34.
Keohane, K.
and
Kuhling, C.
(2004) Collison Culture.
Dublin: Liffey Press
.
35.
Leonard, M.
(2003) `
Children's Drawings as a Methodological Tool: Reflections on the Eleven
Plus System in Northern Ireland'
, Paper given to Sociological Association of Ireland
Conference , Cavan.
36.
Lodge, A.
(2004) `Interviewing the Vampire Slayers: Active Media
Consumption, Imagination and Gendered Identity', in
J. Deegan
,
D. Devine
and
A. Lodge
(eds) Primary Voices: Equality, Diversity and Childhood in Irish Primary
Schools, pp. 164—82.
Dublin : IPA
.
37.
Lodge, A.
(2005) `
Gender and Children's Social World: Esteemed and Marginalised Masculinities
in the Primary School Playground', IrishJournal of Sociology14(2):
177—92
.
38.
Lodge, A.
and
Flynn, M.
(2001) `Gender Identity in the Primary School
Playground ', in
A. Cleary
,
M. Nic Ghiolla Phadraigh
and
S. Quin
(eds) Understanding Children, State, Education and Economy, Vol 1,
pp. 175—96.
Cork: Oak Tree Press
.
39.
Lynch, K.
and
Lodge, A.
(2002) Equality and Power in Schools: Redistribution,
Recognition and Representation.
London: Routledge
.
40.
McGinnity, F.
,
Russell, H.
,
Williams, J.
and
Blackwell, S.
(2005) Time Use in Ireland 2005.
Dublin : ESRI
.
41.
Morrow, V.
(19 9 8) `
If You Were a Teacher, it Would be Harder to Talk to You: Reflections on
Qualitative Research with Children in School
', International Journal of Social Research Methodology1(4):
297—314
.
42.
Ni Laoire, C.
(2005) `“
You're Not a Man At All!” Masculinity, Responsibility and
Staying on the Land in Contemporary Ireland', IrishJournal of Sociology14(2):
94—114
.
43.
O'Brien, M.
,
Alldred, P.
and
Jones, D.
(1996) `Children's Constructions of Family and Kinship
', in
J. Brannen
and
M. O'Brien
(eds) Children in Families: Research and Policy, pp.
84—100.
London: Falmer Press
.
44.
O'Connor, P.
(1998) Emerging Voices: Women in Contemporary Irish
Society .
Dublin: Institute of Public Administration
.
45.
O'Connor, P.
(2000) `
Ireland: A Man's World?
', The Economic and Social Review31(1):
81—102
.
46.
O'Connor, P.
(2005a) `
Local Embeddedness in a Global World
', Young: Nordic Journal of Youth Research13(1):
9—26
.
47.
O'Connor, P.
(2005b) `
Young People's Constructions of the Self: Late Modern Constructs and Gender Differences
', Sociology40(1):
107—24
.
48.
O'Connor, P.
,
Haynes, A.
and
Kane, C.
(2004) `
Relational Discourses: Social Ties with Relatives and Friends'
, Childhood: Global Journal of Child Research11(3):
361—82
.
49.
O'Connor, P.
,
Smithson J.
and
Das Dores Guerreiro, M.
(2002) `Young People's Awareness of Gendered
Realities', in
J. Brannen
,
S. Lewis
and
A. Nilsen Young Europeans
, Work and Family, pp. 89—115.
London: Routledge
.
50.
O'Dowd, L.
(1987) `Church, State and Women: The Aftermath of
Partition ', in
C. Curtin
,
P. Jackson
and
B. O'Connor
(eds) Gender and Society, pp.
3—36.
Galway: Galway University Press
.
51.
O'Toole, F.
(2003) After the Ball.
Dublin: New Island
.
52.
Paulgaard, G.
(2002) `
Local Identities in a Globalised World
', Young: Nordic Journal of Youth Research10(3):
95—107
.
53.
Pole, C.
(2005) `
Tight Fit: Children's Agency and Fashion'
, Paper presented at the European Sociological Association
Conference in Torun, Poland, 9—13 September.
54.
Prosser, J.
(1998) `The Status of Image-Based Research', in
J. Prosser
(ed.) Image Based Research: A Sourcebook for Qualitative
Researchers, pp. 97—112.
London: Falmer Press
.
55.
Punch, S.
(2002) `
Research with Children: The Same or Different to Research with Adults'
, Childhood: Global Journal of Child Research9(3):
321—42
.
56.
Renold, E.
(2004) `“
Other” Boys: Negotiating Non-Hegemonic Masculinities in Primary School
', Gender and Education16(2):
247—66
.
57.
Roche, C.
(2005) `Celtic Cubs in Late Modernity? Young Women and Social
Change in Ireland', PhD thesis submitted to
the University of Limerick
.
58.
Roth, J.
(2002) `Global or Local? New Identities in a Unified
Europe ?',
Agora Debats
/
Jeunesses: Youth and Globalisation
Special Issue: 91—100.
59.
Rygaard, J.
(2003) `
Youth Culture, Media and Globalisation Processes
', Young: Nordic Journal of Youth Research11(4):
291—307
.
60.
Skeggs, B.
(1997) Formations of Class and Gender.
London: Sage
.
61.
Stanley, L.
(2000) `From “Self-Made Women” to
“Women Made Selves”, Audit Selves, Simulation and
Surveillance in the Rise of Public Women', in
T. Coslett
,
C. Lury
and
P. Summerfield
(eds) Feminism and Autobiography, pp.
40—60.
London: Routledge
.
62.
Thomson, R.
,
Bell, R.
,
Holland, J.
,
Henderson, S.
,
Mc Grellis, S.
and
Sharpe, S.
(2002) `
Critical Moments: Choice, Chance and Opportunity in Young People's
Narratives of Transition
', Sociology36(2):
335—54
.
63.
Tovey, H.
and
Share, P.
(2003) A Sociology of Ireland (2nd Edition).
Dublin: Gill and Macmillan
.
64.
Watson, J.L.
(2004) `Mc Donald's in Hong Kong', in
F.J. Lechner
and
J. Boli
(eds) The Globalisation Reader (2nd Edition), pp.
125—32.
Oxford: Blackwell
.
65.
Wakefield, H.
and
Underwager, R.
(1998) `The Application of Images in Child Abuse
Investigations ', in
J. Prosser
(ed.) Image Based Research: A Sourcebook for Qualitative
Researchers, pp. 176—94.
London: Falmer Press
.
66.
Wetton, N.
and
McWhirter, J.
(1998) `Images and Curriculum Development in Health
Education ', in
J. Prosser
(ed.) Image Based Research: A Sourcebook for Qualitative
Researchers, pp. 263—84.
London: Falmer Press
.
67.
Willis, P.
(1990) Common Culture.
Open University : Milton Keynes
.
68.
Whelan, C.
and
Fahey, T.
(1994) `Marriage and the Family', in
C. Whelan
(ed.) Values and Social Change in Ireland, pp.
45—81.
Dublin: Gill and MacMillan
.
69.
Write Now
(1999) `Information for Schools',
Dublin Millennium Committee
, Unpublished.
