In a broader research project about students’ perceptions of their rights
in New Zealand high schools, the first author conducted an interview with a group of
students that was noticeably different from her interviews with groups of students
at three other high schools. This article was prompted in the first instance by a
sense of this ‘noticeably different’ interview being a
‘failure’ because of the limited spoken text elicited. In this
article we demonstrate what we can learn from data regarding embodiment, the
interview setting, silence, laughter and, in the process, we attempt to practise
‘uncomfortable reflexivities’ advocated by Pillow (2003). We
argue that an apparently ‘failed’ interview has a great deal to
teach us about the theory and practice of qualitative research and the tenuous
nature of the production of knowledge. We finish by identifying how our experience
of this ‘failed’ interview informs our current research.
Agee, J.
(2002)
‘“Winks Upon Winks”: Multiple Lenses on
Settings in Qualitative Educational Research’
, Qualitative Studies in Education15(5):
569-585
.
2.
Alder, C.
and
Sandor, D.
(1990)
‘Youth Researching Youth’
, Youth Studies9(4):
38-42
.
3.
Alderson, P.
(2000) ‘Children as Researchers. The Effects of
Participation Rights on Research Methodology’, in
P. Christensen
and
A. James
(eds) Research With Children. Perspectives and Practices, pp.
241-257.
London: Falmer Press
.
4.
Alton-Lee, A.
and
Nuthall, G.
with
Patrick, J.
(1993)
‘Reframing Classroom Research: A Lesson from the Private World of Children’
, Harvard Educational Review63(1):
50-84
.
5.
Biklen, S.
(2004)
‘Trouble in Memory Lane: Adults and Self-retrospection in
Researching Youth’
, Qualitative Inquiry10(5):
715-730
.
6.
Bingley, A.
(2002) ‘Research Ethics in
Practice’, in
L. Bondi
,
H. Avis
,
R. Bankey
,
A. Bingley
,
J. Davidson
,
R. Duffy
,
V. Einagel
,
A. Green
,
L. Johnston
,
S. Lilley
,
C. Listerborn
,
S. McEwan
,
M. Marshy
,
N. O’Connor
,
G. Rose
,
B. Vivat
and
N. Wood
(eds) Subjectivities, Knowledges, and Feminist Geographies, pp.
208-222.
Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers
.
7.
Bishop, R.
(1996) Collaborative Research Stories
Whakawhanaugatanga.
Palmerston North: Dunmore Press
.
8.
Bishop, R.
(1998)
‘Freeing Ourselves from Neo-colonial Domination in Research:
AMāori Approach to Creating Knowledge’
, Qualitative Studies in Education11(2):
199-219
.
9.
Boler, M.
(1999) Feeling Power. Emotions and Education.
New York: Routledge
.
10.
Bondi, L.
(2002)
‘Empathy and Identification: Conceptual Resources for Feminist Fieldwork’
, ACME: International Journal of Critical Geography2:
64-76
.
11.
Bondi, L.
,
Avis, H.
,
Bankey, R.
,
Bingley, A.
,
Davidson, J.
,
Duffy, R.
,
Einagel, V.
,
Green, A.
,
Johnston, L.
,
Lilley, S.
,
Listerborn, C.
,
McEwan, S.
,
Marshy, M.
,
O’Connor, N.
,
Rose, G.
,
Vivat, B.
and
Wood, N.
(eds) (2002) Subjectivities, Knowledges, and Feminist
Geographies.
Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield Publishers
.
12.
Bourdieu, P.
(1977) Outline of a Theory of Practice (translated by
Richard Nice).
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
13.
Bourdieu, P.
(1990) The Logic of Practice.
Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press
.
14.
Brice Heath, S.
(1986) ‘Questioning at Home and at School: A
Comparative Study’, in
M. Hammersley
(ed.) Case Studies in Classroom Research, pp.
104-132.
Milton Keynes: Open University Press
,
15.
Burawoy, M.
(1991) ‘Reconstructing Social
Theories’, in
M. Burawoy
,
A. Burton
,
A. Arnett Ferguson
,
K. Fox
,
J. Gamson
,
N. Gartrell
,
L. Hurst
,
C. Kurzman
,
L. Salzinger
,
J. Schiffman
and
S. Ui
(eds) Ethnography Unbound. Power and Resistance in the Modern
Metropolis, pp. 8-27.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
.
16.
Christensen, P.
and
James, A.
(eds) (2000) Research With Children. Perspectives and
Practices.
London: Falmer Press
.
17.
Clark, C.
and
Moss, P.
(1996)
‘Researching With: Ethical and Epistemological Implications of
Doing Collaborative, Change-oriented Research with Teachers and Students’
, Teachers College Record97(4):
518-548
.
18.
Cook-Sather, A.
(2002)
‘Authorizing Students’ Perspectives: Toward Trust,
Dialogue, and Change in Education’
, Educational Researcher31(4):
3-14
.
19.
Davies, B.
(1991)
‘The Concept of Agency: A Feminist Poststructuralist Analysis’
, Social Analysis30:
42-53
.
20.
Davis, K.
(1997) ‘Embodying Theory. Beyond Modernist and
Postmodernist Readings of the Body’, in
K. Davis
(ed.) Embodied Practices. Feminist perspectives on the Body, pp.
1-23.
London: Sage
.
21.
DeVault, M.
(1995)
‘Ethnicity and Expertise. Racial-ethnic Knowledge in Sociological Research’
, Gender and Society9(5):
612-631
.
22.
Dyck, I.
(1997) ‘Dialogue with Difference: A Tale of Two
Studies’, in
S. Roberts
,
H. Nast
and
J.P. Jones III
(eds) Thresholds in Feminist Geography, pp.
183-202.
Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield
.
23.
Fine, M.
(1994) ‘Working the Hyphens. Reinventing Self
and Other in Qualitative Research’, in
N. Denzin
and
Y. Lincoln
(eds) The Handbook of Qualitative Research, pp.
70-82.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
24.
Fine, M.
,
Weis, L.
,
Weseen, S.
and
Wong, L.
(2000) ‘For Whom? Qualitative Research,
Representations, and Social Responsibilities’, in
N. Denzin
and
Y. Lincoln
(eds) The Handbook of Qualitative Research, pp.
107-131. Second edition.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
25.
Foucault, M.
(1978) History of Sexuality, Volume 1.
New York: Vintage Books
.
26.
Frankenberg, R.
(1993) White Women, Race Matters. The Social Construction of
Whiteness.
London: Routledge
.
27.
Freire, P.
(1998) Pedagogy of Freedom. Ethics, Democracy and Civic
Courage.
London: Rowman and Littlefield
.
28.
Gibson-Graham, J.K.
(1994)
‘“Stuffed if I Know!”: Reflections on
Postmodern Feminist Social Research’
, Gender, Place and Culture1(2):
205-224
.
29.
Hazel, V.
(1994)
‘Disjointed Articulations: The Politics of Voice and Jane Campion’sThe Piano’, Women’s Studies Journal10(2):
27-40
.
30.
hooks, b.
(1992) Black Looks. Race and Representation.
Boston, MA: South End Press
.
31.
Irwin, K.
(1992) ‘Towards Theories of Māori
Feminisms’, in
R. Du Plessis
(ed.) Feminist Voices. Women’s Studies Texts for Aotearoa/New
Zealand, pp. 1-21.
Auckland: Oxford University Press
.
32.
Jones, A.
(1988) ‘Which Girls are “Learning to
Lose”? Gender, Class, Race and Talking in the
Classroom’, in
S. Middleton
(ed.) Women and Education in Aotearoa, pp.
143-152.
Wellington: Allen and Unwin with Port Nicholson Press
.
33.
Jones, A.
(1991)
‘Is Madonna a Feminist Folk-hero, is Ruth Richardson a Woman?
Postmodern Feminism and Dilemmas of Difference’
, Sites23:
84-100
.
34.
Jones, A.
(1999)
‘The Limits of Cross-cultural Dialogue: Pedagogy, Desire and
Absolution in the Classroom’
, Educational Theory49(3):
299-316
.
35.
Kamler, B.
,
Maclean, R.
,
Reid, J.
and
Simpson, A.
(1994) ‘Shaping Up Nicely. The Formation of
Schoolgirls and Schoolboys in the First Month of School’. A
report to the Gender Equity and Curriculum Reform Project, Department of Employment,
Education and Training.
Canberra: Australian Government Publishing Service
.
36.
Kawharu, I.
(1989) Waitangi: Māori and
PākehāPerspectives of the Treaty of Waitangi.
Auckland: Oxford University Press
.
37.
Kehily, M.
and
Nayak, A.
(1997)
‘“Lads and Laughter”: Humour and the
Production of Heterosexual Hierarchies’
, Gender and Education9(1):
69-87
.
38.
Lansdown, G.
(1994) ‘Children’s
Rights’, in
B. Mayall
(ed.) Children’s Childhoods: Observed and Experienced,
pp. 33-44.
London: Falmer Press
.
39.
Larner, W.
(1995)
‘Theorising “Difference” in Aotearoa/New Zealand’
, Gender, Place and Culture2(2):
177-190
.
40.
Lather, P.
(1991) Getting Smart. Feminist Research and Pedagogy With/in
the Postmodern.
New York: Routledge
.
41.
McDowell, L.
(2002)
‘Masculine Discourses and Dissonances: Strutting
“Lads”, Protest Masculinity, and Domestic Respectability’
, Environment and Planning D: Society and Space20:
97-119
.
42.
Magolda, P.
(2002)
‘Pushing Boundaries: An Ethnographic Study of Life in and Beyond
a Feminist Classroom’
, Qualitative Studies in Education15(5):
513-544
.
43.
Mazzei, L.
(2003)
‘Inhabited Silences: In Pursuit of a Muffled Subtext’
, Qualitative Inquiry9(3):
355-368
.
44.
Miles, M.
and
Huberman, A.
(1994) Qualitative Data Analysis. An Expanded
Sourcebook.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage
.
45.
Mita, M.
(1989)
‘Through a Māori Lens’
, New Zealand Listener, 14 October:
30-31
.
46.
Mohanram, R.
(1998) ‘(In)visible Bodies? Immigrant Bodies and
Constructions of Nationhood in Aotearoa/New Zealand’, in
R. Du Plessis
and
L. Alice
(eds) Feminist Thought in Aotearoa/New Zealand, pp.
21-28.
Auckland: Oxford University Press
.
47.
Moje, E.
(2000)
‘Changing our Minds, Changing our Bodies: Power as Embodied in
Research Relations’
, Qualitative Studies in Education13(1):
25-42
.
48.
Morrow, V.
and
Richards, M.
(1996)
‘The Ethics of Social Research with Children: An Overview’
, Children and Society10:
90-105
.
49.
Nairn, K.
(1997) ‘Hearing From Quiet Students: The
Politics of Silence and of Voice in Geography Classrooms’, in
S. Roberts
,
H. Nast
and
J.P. Jones III
(eds) Thresholds in Feminist Geography, pp.
93-115.
Lanham, MD: Rowman and Littlefield
.
50.
Nairn, K.
(1999)
‘Embodied Fieldwork’
, Journal of Geography98:
272-282
.
51.
Nairn, K.
(2001)
‘Young People’s Participation - What Does it Mean for
Libraries and Librarians?’
, Australasian Public Libraries14(1):
25-31
.
52.
Nairn, K.
and
Smith, A.B.
(2002)
‘Secondary Students’ Experiences of Bullying at School
and their Suggestions for Dealing With It’
, Childrenz Issues6(1):
16-22
.
53.
Nairn, K.
and
Smith, A.B.
(2003a)
‘Taking Students Seriously: Their Rights to be Safe at School’
, Gender and Education15(2):
133-149
.
54.
Nairn, K.
and
Smith, A.B.
(2003b)
‘Young People as Researchers in Schools: The Possibilities of
Peer Research’
. Paper presented at American Educational Research Association
Conference, Chicago, 21-25 April.
55.
Nash, R.
(1999)
‘Social Capital, Class Identity, and Progress at School: Case Studies’
, New Zealand Journal of Educational Studies34(2):
267-280
.
56.
Orange, C.
(1987) Treaty of Waitangi.
New Zealand: Allen and Unwin
.
57.
Ormond, A.
(2001)
‘Voice of Māori Youth: The Other Side of Silence’
, International Journal of Critical Psychology4(2):
49-60
.
58.
Panelli, R.
,
Nairn, K.
and
McCormack, J.
(2002)
‘“We Make Our Own Fun”: Reading the Politics
of Youth With(in) Community’
, Sociologia Ruralis42(2):
106-130
.
59.
Park, J.
,
Suaalii-Sauni, T.
,
Anae, M.
,
Liam I.
,
Fuamatu, N.
and
Mariner, K.
(2002) ‘Late Twentieth-century Auckland
Perspective on Samoan Masculinities’, in
H. Worth
,
A. Paris
and
L. Allen
(eds) The Life of Brian: Masculinities, Sexualities and Health in New
Zealand, pp. 43-55.
Dunedin: University of Otago Press
.
60.
Pillow, W.
(2002)
‘When a Man does Feminism Should he Dress in Drag?’Qualitative Studies in Education15(5):
545-554
.
61.
Pillow, W.
(2003)
‘Confession, Catharsis, or Cure? Rethinking the Uses of
Reflexivity as Methodological Power in Qualitative Research’
, Qualitative Studies in Education16(2):
175-196
.
62.
Pratt, M.
(2002) ‘Arts of the Contact
Zone’, in
J. Wolff
(ed.) Professing in the Contact Zone, pp.
1-20.
Urbana, IL: National Council of Teachers in English
.
63.
Probyn, E.
(1991)
‘This Body Which is Not One: Speaking the Embodied Self’
, Hypatia6(3):
111-124
.
64.
Punch, S.
(2002)
‘Interviewing Strategies with Young People: The ‘Secret
Box’, Stimulus Material and Task-based Activities’
, Children and Society16(1):
45-56
.
65.
Ramazanoglu, C.
with
Holland, J.
(2002) Feminist Methodology. Challenges and Choices.
London: Sage
.
66.
Reay, D.
(1996)
‘Dealing with Difficult Differences: Reflexivity and Social Class
in Feminist Research’
, Feminism and Psychology6(3):
443-456
.
67.
Reinharz, S.
(1994) ‘Toward an Ethnography of
“Voice” and
“Silence”’, in
E.J. Trickett
,
R.J. Watts
and
D. Birman
(eds) Human Diversity. Perspectives on People in Context, pp.
178-200.
San Francisco: Jossey-Bass Publishers
.
68.
Roman, L.
(1993) ‘White is a Color! White Defensiveness,
Postmodernism, and Anti-racist Pedagogy’, in
C. McCarthy
and
W. Crichlow
(eds) Race, Identity and Representation in Education, pp.
71-88.
New York and London: Routledge
.
69.
Rose, G.
(1997)
‘Situating Knowledges: Positionality, Reflexivities and Other Tactics’
, Progress in Human Geography21(3):
305-320
.
70.
Smith, A.B.
,
Gaffney, M.
and
Nairn, K.
(2004)
‘Health Rights in Secondary Schools: Student and Staff Perspectives’
, Health Education Research19(1):
1-13
.
71.
Smith, A.B.
,
Nairn, K.
,
Taylor, N.
and
Gaffney, M.
(2003)
‘Staff and Student Perspectives on Children’s Rights in
New Zealand Secondary Schools’
, Childrenz Issues7(1):
9-16
.
72.
St. Pierre, E. Adams
(1997)
‘Methodology in the Fold and the Irruption of Transgressive Data’
, Qualitative Studies in Education10(2):
175-189
.
73.
Tagaloa, F.
(2000) ‘The Rights of the Samoan
Child’, in
A.B. Smith
,
M. Gollop
,
K. Marshall
and
K. Nairn
(eds) Advocating For Children. International Perspectives on
Children’s Rights, pp. 97-108.
Dunedin: University of Otago Press
.
74.
Taylor, N.
,
Smith, A. B.
and
Nairn, K.
(2001)
‘Rights Important to Young People: Secondary Student and Staff Perspectives’
, International Journal of Children’s Rights9:
137-156
.
75.
Tuhiwai Smith, L.
(1999) Decolonizing Methodologies: Research and Indigenous
Peoples.
Dunedin: University of Otago Press
.
76.
Tuhiwai Smith, L.
(2001)
‘Troubling Spaces’
, International Journal of Critical Psychology4(2):
167-182
.
77.
Valentine, G.
(1999)
‘Being Seen and Heard? The Ethical Complexities of Working with
Children and Young People at Home and at School’
, Ethics, Place and Environment2(2):
141-153
.
78.
Walker, R.
and
Goodson, I.
(1977) ‘Humour in the
Classroom’, in
P. Woods
and
M. Hammersley
(eds) School Experience. Explorations in the Sociology of
Education, pp. 196-227.
New York: St. Martin’s Press
.
79.
Wall, M.
(2000) ‘The Popular and Geography. Music and
Racialized Identities in Aotearoa/New Zealand’, in
I. Cook
,
D. Crouch
,
S. Naylor
and
J. Ryan
(eds) Cultural Turns/Geographical Turns: Perspectives on Cultural
Geography, pp. 75-87.
Harlow: Longman
.
80.
Wilson, M.
(1995) ‘Constitutional Recognition of the Treaty
of Waitangi: Myth or Reality?’, in
M. Wilson
and
A. Yeatman
(eds) Justice and Identity. Antipodean Practices, pp.
1-17.
Wellington: Bridget Williams Books
.
81.
Yates, L.
(2003)
‘When Young People Talk to You, What Does it Mean?’
. Paper presented at American Educational Research Association
Conference, Chicago, 21-25 April.
