Advanced turbulence and combustion modeling for the study of a swirl-assisted natural gas spark-ignition heavy-duty engine

Abstract

Increasing demands on higher performance and lower fuel consumption and emissions have led the path for internal combustion engine development; this race is nowadays directly related to CO₂ emissions reduction. To drive engine development and reduce the time-to-market, the employment of numerical analysis is mandatory. This requires a continuous improvement of the simulation models toward real predictive analyses able to reduce the experimental R&D efforts. In this framework, 1D numerical codes are fundamental tools for system design, energy management optimization, and calibration. The present work is focused on the improvement of the phenomenological turbulence model, originally conceived to describe turbulence evolution in tumble-promoting engines. The turbulence model is developed with reference to a SI heavy-duty CNG engine derived from a diesel engine. In this architecture, due to the flat cylinder head, turbulence is also generated by swirl and squish flow motions, in addition to tumble motion. The presented turbulence model is validated against 3D CFD results, demonstrating to properly predict turbulence and swirl/tumble evolution under two different operating conditions, without the need for any case-dependent tuning. The developed turbulence model is coupled to a phenomenological combustion model based on the fractal geometry theory applied to the flame front surface, where the turbulence is assumed to support flame propagation through an enhancement of the flame front area with respect to the laminar counterpart. The combustion model is validated against an extensive experimental dataset, composed of 25 operating points at different engine rotational speeds and loads. The numerical/experimental comparisons of global performance parameters are satisfactory, leading to maximum errors around ±2% for the BSFC, ±2° for the main combustion events, and ±1 bar for the in-cylinder peak pressure. Burn rate profiles are very well captured by the combustion model at changing operating conditions, not requiring any case-dependent tuning. The presented results demonstrate that the turbulence/combustion models could constitute a reliable virtual test facility, contributing to supporting and driving experimental activities.

Keywords

Modeling turbulence swirl-assisted engine fractal combustion natural Gas engine heavy-duty engine

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Steffen

Broadgate

Deutsch

Gaffney

, et al. The trajectory of the anthropocene: the great acceleration. Anthr Rev, 2015; 2(1): 81–98.

Annual European Union greenhouse gas inventory 1990–2020 and inventory report 2022, https://www.eea.europa.eu//publications/annual-european-union-greenhouse-gas-1. Accessed November 12, 2022.

IARC: diesel engine exhaust carcinogenic. International Agency for Research on Cancer, Press Release No. 213, 12th June, 2012.

Alamia

Magnusson

Johnsson

Thunman

. Well-to-wheel analysis of bio-methane via gasification, in heavy duty engines within the transport sector of the European Union. Appl Energy 2016; 170: 445–454.

Blanco

Nijs

Ruf

Faaij

. Potential of power-to-methane in the EU energy transition to a low carbon system using cost optimization. Appl Energy 2018; 232: 323–340.

Wheeler

Stein

Hunter

. Effects of charge motion, compression ratio, and dilution on a medium duty natural gas single cylinder research engine. SAE Int J Engines 2014; 7(4): 1650–1664.

Johansson

Olsson

. Combustion chambers for natural gas SI engines part I: fluid flow and combustion. SAE paper 950469, 1995.

Heywood

J B

. Internal combustion engine fundamentals. Vol. 930. New York: Mcgraw-Hill, 1988.

Borgnakke

Arpaci

Tabaczynski

. A model for the instantaneous heat transfer and turbulence in a spark ignition engine. SAE Paper 800287, 1980.

10.

Morel

Mansour

. Modeling of turbulence in internal combustion engines. SAE paper 820040, 1982.

11.

Morel

Keribar

. A model for predicting spatially and time resolved convective heat transfer in bowl-in-piston combustion chambers. SAE paper 850204, 1985.

12.

Grasreiner

Neumann

Luttermann

Wensing

Hasse

. A quasi-dimensional model of turbulence and global charge motion for spark ignition engines with fully variable valvetrains. Int J Engine Res 2014; 15(7): 805–816.

13.

Fogla

Bybee

Mirzaeian

Millo

Wahiduzzaman

. Development of a K-k-ε phenomenological model to predict in-cylinder turbulence. SAE Int. J. Engines 2017; 10(2): 562–575.

14.

Bozza

De Bellis

Berni

D’Adamo

Fontanesi

Iorio

. Refinement of a 0D turbulence model to predict tumble and turbulent intensity in SI engines. Part I: 3D analyses. SAE paper 2018-01-0850, 2018.

15.

De Bellis

Bozza

Fontanesi

Severi

Berni

. Development of a phenomenological turbulence model through a hierarchical 1D/3D approach applied to a VVA turbocharged engine. SAE Int. J. Engines 2016; 9(1): 506–519.

16.

Bozza

Teodosio

De Bellis

Fontanesi

Iorio

. Refinement of a 0D turbulence model to predict tumble and turbulent intensity in SI engines. Part II: Model concept, validation and discussion. SAE paper 2018-01-0856, 2018.

17.

Bozza

Teodosio

De Bellis

Fontanesi

Iorio

. A refined 0D turbulence model to predict tumble and turbulence in SI engines. SAE Int J Engines 2019; 12(1): 15–30.

18.

Kim

Song

. Development of quasi-dimensional turbulence model for spark-ignition engine with physical analysis of tumble: energy-based tumble model focusing on energy intake and turbulence production. Appl Energy 2019; 252: 113455.

19.

De Bellis

Severi

Fontanesi

Bozza

. Hierarchical 1D/3D approach for the development of a turbulent combustion model applied to a VVA turbocharged engine. Part II: Combustion model. Energy Procedia 2014; 45: 1027–1036.

20.

De Bellis

Bozza

Tufano

. A comparison between two phenomenological combustion models applied to different SI engines. SAE paper, 2017-01-2184, 2017.

21.

Matthews

Chin

. A fractal-based si engine model: comparisons of predictions with experimental data. SAE paper 910079, 1991.

22.

Poulos

Heywood

. The effect of chamber geometry on spark-ignition engine combustion. SAE paper 830334, 1983.

23.

Demesoukas

Caillol

Higelin

Boiarciuc

. Zero-dimensional spark ignition combustion modeling – a comparison of different approaches. SAE paper 2013-24-0022, 2013.

24.

Richard

Bougrine

Font

Lafossas

Le Berr

. On the reduction of a 3D CFD combustion model to build a physical 0D model for simulating heat release, knock and pollutants in SI engines. Oil Gas Sci Technol 2009; 64(3): 223–2425.

25.

Perlman

Frojd

Seidel

Tuner

Mauss

. A fast tool for predictive IC engine in-cylinder modelling with detailed chemistry. SAE paper 2012-01-1074, 2012.

26.

Rakopoulos

Michos

Giakoumis

. Thermodynamic analysis of SI engine operation on variable composition biogas-hydrogen blends using a quasi-dimensional, multi-zone combustion model. SAE Int J Engines 2009; 2(1): 880–910.

27.

Verhelst

Sheppard

. Multi-zone thermodynamic modelling of spark-ignition engine combustion-an overview. Energy Convers Manag 2009; 50(5): 1326–1335.

28.

Franke

Wirth

Peters

. New aspects of the fractal behaviour of turbulent flames. In: Twenty-third symposium (international) on combustion, Orleans, 1990.

29.

Gatowsky

J A

Heywood

. Flame photographs in a spark-ignition engine. Combust Flame 1984; 56: 71–81.

30.

Gouldin

. An application of fractals to modeling premixed turbulent flames. Combust Flame 1987; 68(3): 249–266.

31.

Franken

Sommerhoff

Willems

, et al. Advanced predictive diesel combustion simulation using turbulence model and stochastic reactor model. SAE paper 2017-01-0516, 2017.

32.

Riccardi

De Bellis

Sforza

, et al. Advanced turbulence model for SI combustion in a heavy-duty NG engine. SAE paper 2022-01-0384, 2022.

33.

Lucchini

D’Errico

Paredi

Sforza

Onorati

. CFD modeling of gas exchange, fuel-air mixing and combustion in gasoline direct-injection engines. SAE paper 2019-24-0095, 2019.

34.

Sforza

Lucchini

Gianetti

D’Errico

. Development and validation of SI combustion models for natural-gas heavy-duty engines. SAE paper 2019-24-0096, 2019.

35.

Sforza

Lucchini

Gianetti

, et al. A 3D-CFD methodology for combustion modeling in active prechamber SI engines operating with natural gas. SAE paper 2022-01-0470, 2022.

36.

North

Santavicca

. The fractal nature of premixed turbulent flames. Combust Sci Technol 1990; 72(4–6): 215–232.

37.

Amirante

Distaso

Tamburrano

Reitz

. Laminar flame speed correlations for methane, ethane, propane and their mixtures, and natural gas and gasoline for spark-ignition engine simulations. Int J Engine Res 2017; 18(9): 951–970.

38.

Amirante

Distaso

Tamburrano

Reitz

. Analytical correlations for modeling the laminar flame speed of natural gas surrogate mixtures. Energy Procedia 2017; 126: 850–857.

39.

Riccardi

Tufano

Beatrice

Bozza

De Bellis

Napolitano

. Toward predictive combustion modeling of CNG SI engines in 1D simulation tools. SAE paper 2020-01-2079, 2020.

40.

Teodosio

De Bellis

Bozza

. Combined effects of valve strategies, compression ratio, water injection, and cooled EGR on the fuel consumption of a small turbocharged VVA spark-ignition engine. SAE Int J Engines 2018; 11(6): 643–656.

41.

De Bellis

Malfi

Teodosio

Giannattasio

Di Lenarda

. A novel laminar flame speed correlation for the refinement of the flame front description in a phenomenological combustion model for spark-ignition engines. SAE Int J Engines 2019; 12(3): 251–271.

42.

Blizard

Keck

. Experimental and theoretical investigation of turbulent burning model for internal combustion engines. SAE paper 740191, 1974.

43.

Keck

Heywood

Noske

. Early flame development and burning rates in spark ignition engines and their cyclic variability. SAE paper 870164, 1987.

44.

Peters

. Laminar flamelet concepts in turbulent combustion. Symp Int Combust 1988; 21(1): 1231–1250.

45.

Bates

. Flame imaging studies of combustion completion in a SI four-stroke engine. Combustion science and Technology, 1995; 105(1-3): 1–18