Optimization via genetic algorithm of a variable-valve-actuation spark-ignition engine based on the integration between 1D/3D simulation codes and optimizer
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online April, 2023
Optimization via genetic algorithm of a variable-valve-actuation spark-ignition engine based on the integration between 1D/3D simulation codes and optimizer
In this work, a turbocharged spark ignition engine equipped with a variable valve actuation device is investigated to numerically optimize the Brake specific fuel consumption (BSFC) at different loads and speeds by employing a genetic algorithm. The engine is preliminary analyzed at the test bench under both part and full load operations and different valve strategies. A system schematization is realized in a 1D code. The developed model is integrated with user-defined sub-models for the description of the in-cylinder processes, and then is validated over the measurements. A 3D CFD model of a single cylinder is developed in a commercial code and validated against experimental mean in-cylinder pressure and combustion indicators. The validated 1D engine model is coupled to an external optimizer, to identify the optimal calibration, performing multi-variable and multi-objective optimizations with the adoption of the MOGA genetic algorithm. The latter aims at minimizing the BSFC in a BMEP sweep, at fixed speed, while controlling the load through the Inlet Valve Closure (IVC) at fully opened throttle valve. The optimization results show that an advanced control of the intake valve strategy allows a maximum BSFC advantage of 26% at medium/high loads and medium speeds, if compared to the manufacturer-advised engine calibration. The outcomes of the optimization process are also confirmed by the 3D CFD tool. The latter not only contributes to the tuning of the 1D model, but it also provides an in-depth on detailed 3D aspects, such as turbulence and knock, that could not be assessed via a simplified 1D approach. The presented methodology represents a valuable tool to refine the virtual calibration of VVA engines and to support the design phase, thus remarkably reducing the experimental efforts. Moreover, it is a promising example of integration between 1D and 3D CFD tools.
ReitzRDOgawaHPayriR, et al. IJER editorial: the future of the internal combustion engine. Int J Engine Res2020; 21(1): 3–10.
2.
EU Regulation 2019/631 of 17 April 2019. Setting CO2 emission performance standards for new passenger cars and for new light commercial vehicles and repealing regulations (EC) N.443/2009 and (EU) N.510/2011.
3.
WeiHZhuTShuGTanLWangY. Gasoline engine exhaust gas recirculation – a review. Appl Energy2012; 99: 534–544.
4.
TornatoreCSianoDMarchittoLIacobacciAValentinoGBozzaF. Water injection: a technology to improve performance and emissions of downsized turbocharged spark ignited engines. SAE Int J Engines2017; 10(5): 2319–2329.
5.
ShaikAMoorthiNSVRudramoorthyR. Variable compression ratio engine: a future power plant for automobiles - an overview. Proc IMechE, Part D: J Automobile Engineering2007; 221(9): 1159–1168.
6.
IIhakMITangozSAkansuSOKahramanN. Alternative fuels for internal combustion engines. In: CarlucciAP (ed.) The future of internal combustion engines. London: Intechopen book series, 2019.
7.
LanzanovaTNoraMDZhaoH. Investigation of early and late intake valve closure strategies for load control in a spark ignition ethanol engine. SAE Int J Engines2017; 10(3): 858–872.
8.
TeodosioLPirrelloDBerniFDe BellisVLanzafameRD’AdamoA. Impact of intake valve strategies on fuel consumption and knock tendency of a spark ignition engine. Appl Energy2018; 216: 91–104.
9.
XuJGuoTFengYSunM. Numerical investigation of miller cycle with EIVC and LIVC on a high compression ratio gasoline engine. Sci Prog2021; 104(2): 368504211023640.
10.
WangYGePLiuTGongCDongD. Quantitative analysis of the influence saliency of VVA and EGR on the fuel economy and mixture combustion characteristics of a turbocharged spark ignition engine. ACS Omega2021; 6: 31017–31025.
11.
MilloFLuisiSBoreanFStroppianaA. Numerical and experimental investigation on combustion characteristics of a spark ignition engine with an early intake valve closing load control. Fuel2014; 121: 298–310.
12.
LuisiSDoriaVStroppianaAMilloF, et al. Experimental investigation on early and late intake valve closures for knock mitigation through Miller cycle in a dowsized turbocharged engine. SAE paper 2015-010760, 2015. DOI: 10.4271/2015-01-0760.
13.
KnopVMattioliL. An analysis of limits for part load efficiency improvement with VVA devices. Energy Convers Manag2015; 105: 1006–1016.
14.
BattistoniMGrimaldiCNMarianiF. Numerical study on SI engine part load operating conditions using different VVA strategies. Paper No. ICEF2011-60205, pp.943-953. DOI: 10.1115/ICEF2011-60205.
15.
LiYNingZLüMZhiXLuoX. Simulation study on effect of late-intake-valve-closing Atkinson cycle on the performance of a direct injection engine based on fuel economy. E3S Web Conf2021; 260: 01017.
16.
IacovanoCBerniFBarbatoAFontanesiS. A preliminary 1D-3D analysis of the Darmstadt research engine under motored condition. In: (2020) E3S Web of Conferences, Rome, Italy, 15–16 September 2020, vol. 197, no. 06006. ATI Rome, Italy: Associazione Termotecnica Italiana. DOI: 10.1051/e3sconf/202019706006.
17.
De BellisVBozzaFFontanesiSSeveriEBerniF. Development of a phenomenological turbulence model through a hierarchical 1D/3D approach applied to a VVA turbocharged engine. SAE Int J Engines2016; 9(1): 506–519.
18.
TeodosioLDe BellisVBozzaFTufanoD. Numerical Study on the potentials of variable compression ratio concept applied to a downsized turbocharged VVA spark ignition engine. SAE paper 2017-240015, 2017. DOI: 10.4271/2017-24-0015.
19.
BozzaFDe BellisVGiannattasioPTeodosioLMarchittoL. Extension and validation of a 1D model applied to the analysis of a water injected turbocharged spark ignited engine at high loads and over a WLTP driving cycle. SAE Int J Engines2017; 10(4): 2141–2153.
20.
AndraeJC. Comprehensive chemical kinetic modeling of toluene reference fuels oxidation. Fuel2013; 107: 740–748.
21.
KlimstraJ. The knock severity index – A proposal for a knock classification method. SAE paper 841335, 1984. DOI: 10.4271/841335.
22.
HohenbergG. Advanced approaches for heat transfer calculations. SAE Paper 790825, 1979. DOI: 10.4271/790825.
23.
ChenSFlynnP. Development of a single cylinder compression ignition research engine. SAE Paper 650733, 1965. DOI: 10.4271/650733.
24.
BerniFFontanesiS. A 3D-CFD methodology to investigate boundary layers and assess the applicability of wall functions in actual industrial problems: a focus on in-cylinder simulations. Appl Therm Eng2020; 174. DOI: 10.1016/j.applthermaleng.2020.115320
25.
BerniFCicaleseGBorghiMFontanesiS. Towards grid-independent 3D-CFD wall-function-based heat transfer models for complex industrial flows with focus on in-cylinder simulations. Appl Therm Eng2021; 190: 1359–4311.
26.
BerniFCicaleseGFontanesiS. A modified thermal wall function for the estimation of gas-to-wall heat fluxes in CFD in-cylinder simulations of high performance spark-ignition engines. Appl Therm Eng2017; 115: 1045–1062.
27.
ColinOBenkenidaA. The 3-zones extended coherent flame model (Ecfm3z) for computing premixed/diffusion combustion. Oil & Gas Science and Technology - Revue d’IFP Energies nouvelles, Institut Français du Pétrole2004; 59(6): 593–609.
28.
RulliFFontanesiSd’AdamoABerniF. A critical review of flow field analysis methods involving proper orthogonal decomposition and quadruple proper orthogonal decomposition for internal combustion engines. Int J Engine Res2021; 22: 222–242.
29.
Del PecchiaMPessinaVBerniFd’AdamoAFontanesiS. Gasoline-ethanol blend formulation to mimic laminar flame speed and auto-ignition quality in automotive engines. Fuel2020; 264(116741): DOI: 10.1016/j.fuel.2019.116741
30.
BruneauxGPoinsotTFerzigerJH. Premixed flame–wall interaction in a turbulent channel flow: budget for the flame surface density evolution equation and modelling. J Fluid Mech1997; 349: 191–219.
31.
BerniFBredaSLugliMCantoreG. A numerical investigation on the potentials of water injection to increase knock resistance and reduce fuel consumption in highly downsized GDI engines. Energy Proc2015; 81: 826–835.
32.
LafossasFCastagneMDumasJHenriotS. Development and validation of a knock model in spark ignition engines using a CFD code. SAE Paper 2002-01- 2701, 2002.
33.
d’AdamoABredaSBerniFFontanesiS. Understanding the origin of cycle-to-cycle variation using large-eddy simulation: similarities and differences between a homogeneous low-revving speed research engine and a production DI turbocharged engine. SAE Int J Engines2018; 12(1): 45–56.
34.
D’AdamoABredaSIaccarinoS, et al. Development of a RANS-Based knock model to infer the knock probability in a research spark-ignition engine. SAE Int. J. Engines2017; 10(3): 722–739.
35.
MurataTIshibuchiH. MOGA: Multi-objective genetic algorithms. In: Proceedings of International Conference on evolutionary computation, Perth, WA, Australia, 29 November–1 December 1995, pp. 289–294. New York: IEEE. DOI: 10.1109/ICEC.1995.489161.
36.
CoelloCACvan VeldhuizenDALamontGB.
Evolutionary algorithms for solving multi-objective problems. New York: Kluwer Academic/Plenum Plublishers, 2002.
37.
SivanandamSNDeepaSN.
Introduction to genetic algorithms. Berlin: Springer Publisher, 2008.
38.
BozzaFDe BellisVTeodosioLGimelliA. Numerical analysis of the transient operation of a turbocharged diesel engine including the compressor surge. Proc IMechE, Part D: J Automobile Engineering2013; 227(11): 1503–1517.
39.
SenAKAshSKHuangBHuangZ. Effect of exhaust gas recirculation on the cycle-to-cycle variations in a natural gas spark ignition engine. Appl Therm Eng2011; 31(14-15): 2247–2253.
