‘Governance transitions’ and minority nationalist parties’ pressure for welfare state change: Evidence from Welsh and Scottish elections – And the UK’s ‘Brexit’ referendum
Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online December, 2017
‘Governance transitions’ and minority nationalist parties’ pressure for welfare state change: Evidence from Welsh and Scottish elections – And the UK’s ‘Brexit’ referendum
This study is concerned with welfare state development and the intersection between the twin global phenomena of sub-state nationalism and ‘governance transitions’. Specifically, how minority nationalist parties (MNPs) use discourse to exert pressure for welfare change. Accordingly, here, we explore their discourse in Scottish and Welsh elections, and the UK ‘Brexit’ referendum on European Union membership. The findings reveal how pressure for welfare change is framed using key tropes including nation-building, extending social protection and resistance to central government programmes. The wider significance to understanding global social policy lies in the following: (1) revealing the discursive processes associated with multi-level welfare state dynamics, (2) demonstrating how MNPs and governance transitions combine to pressure for welfare state change, and (3) showing how the resultant territorialisation of policy discourse advances ‘sub-state’ models of social citizenship.
AboucharA (1971) Regional welfare and measured income differentials in Canada. Review of Income and Wealth17(4): 363–369.
2.
AlvessonMKarremanD (2000) Varieties of discourse: On the study of organizations through discourse analysis. Human Relations53(9): 1125–1149.
3.
AndersonB (1991) Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism, Revised and extended edn. London: Verso.
4.
BacheIFlindersM (2004) Multi-Level Governance. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
5.
BantingK (1987) The Welfare State and Canadian Federalism. Montreal, QC, Canada: McGill-Queen’s.
6.
BantingKCosta-FontJ (2010) Decentralization, welfare, and social citizenship in contemporary democracies Introduction. Environment and Planning C: Government and Policy28(1): 381–388.
7.
BauböckRGuiraudonV (2009) Realignments of citizenship: Reassessing rights in the age of plural memberships and multi-level governance. Citizenship Studies13(5): 439–453.
8.
BelandD (2005) Ideas and social policy: An institutionalist perspective. Social Policy & Administration39(1): 1–18.
9.
BelandDLecoursA (2005) The politics of territorial solidarity: Nationalism and social policy reform in Canada, the United Kingdom, and Belgium. Comparative Political Studies38(6): 676–703.
10.
BelandDLecoursA (2006) Sub-state nationalism and the welfare state: Quebec and Canadian federalism. Nations and Nationalism12(1): 77–96.
11.
BelandDLecoursA (2008) Nationalism and Social Policy: The Politics of Territorial Solidarity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
12.
BeresfordP (2016) All Our Welfare. Bristol: Polity Press.
13.
BeveridgeW (1943) The Pillars of Security. London: Allen & Unwin.
14.
BirrellDGrayA (2014) Welfare reform and devolution: Issues of parity, discretion and divergence for the UK government and the devolved administrations. Public Money & Management34(3): 205–212.
15.
BlythM (2002) Great Transformations: Economic Ideas and Institutional Change in the Twentieth Century. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
16.
BoockmannBThomsenSHuberMet al. (2013) Should welfare administration be centralized or decentralized? Evidence from a policy experiment. German Economic Review16(1): 13–42.
17.
BrodieJ (1997) Meso-discourses, state forms and the gendering of liberal-democratic citizenship. Citizenship Studies1(2): 223–242.
18.
Butt PhilipA (1975) The Welsh Question: Nationalism in Welsh Politics.Cardiff: University of Wales Press.
19.
CaracelliVGreeneJ (1993) Data analysis strategies for mixed-method evaluation designs. Educational Evaluation and Policy Analysis15(2): 195–207.
20.
CarlJ (2003) European integration and multiple identities: Changing allegiances in post–devolution UK?Perspectives on European Politics and Society4(3): 475–500.
21.
CastlesF (2005) Social expenditure in the 1990s: Data and determinants. Policy and Politics33(3): 411–430.
22.
ChaneyP (2013) Electoral discourse analysis of civil conflict resolution: the case of Northern Ireland in UK state-wide elections 1970-2010. Irish Political Studies28(1): 1–19.
23.
CoakleyJ (2012) Nationalism, Ethnicity and the State. Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
24.
CobbRRossM (1997) Agenda setting and the denial of agenda access: Key concepts. In: CobbRRossM (eds) Cultural Strategies of Agenda Denial. Lawrence, KS: University Press of Kansas.
25.
Costa-FontJ (2010) Does devolution lead to regional inequalities in welfare activity?Environment and Planning – Part C28(3): 435–451.
26.
DardanelliP (2003) Ideology and rationality: The Europeanization of the Scottish National Party. 8th EUSA International Conference. Nashville, USA, 27–29 March 2003.
27.
DawsonRRobinsonJ (1963) Inter-party competition, economic variables, and welfare policies in the American states. Journal of Politics2: 265–289.
28.
DeaconA (2002) Perspectives on Welfare. Buckingham: Open University.
29.
DeaconR (2012) Devolution in the United Kingdom. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.
30.
Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) (2011) Local Support to Replace Community Care Grants and Crisis Loans for Living Expenses in England: Government Response to the Call for Evidence. London: DWP.
31.
Diaz-SerranoLRodríguez-PoseA (2015) Decentralization and the welfare state: What do citizens perceive?Social Indicators Research120(2): 411–435.
32.
DrakefordM (2007) Social justice in a devolved Wales. Benefits15(2): 171–178.
33.
EbbinghausB (ed.) (2011) The Varieties of Pension Governance: Pension Privatization in Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
34.
EzcurraRRodríguez-PoseA (2011) Decentralization of social protection expenditure and economic growth in the OECD Publius. The Journal of Federalism41(1): 146–157.
35.
Esping-AndersenG (1990) Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism. Cambridge: Polity Press and Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
36.
FaguetJ (2013) Decentralization and governance. World Development53: 2–13.
37.
FerreraM (2005) The Boundaries of Welfare: European Integration and the New Spatial Politics of Social Protection. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
38.
FischerF (2003) Deliberative Policy Analysis. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
39.
FitzpatrickA (2002) Welfare Theory: An Introduction. London: Palgrave Macmillan.
40.
FoucaultM. (1980) Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other Writings 1972–1977. Brighton: Harvester Press.
41.
GallegoRSubiratsJ (2012) Spanish and regional welfare systems: Policy innovation and multi-level governance. Regional & Federal Studies22(3): 269–288.
42.
GambleA (2016) Can the Welfare State Survive?Malden, MA: Polity Press.
43.
GellnerEBreuillyJ (2010) Nations and Nationalism, 2nd edn.Ithaca, NY: Cornell University Press.
44.
GeorgeVPageR (eds.) (1995) Modern Thinkers on Welfare. London: Harvester.
45.
GoffmanE (1974) Frame Analysis. Cambridge: Harvard University Press.
46.
GreerS (2010) How does decentralisation affect the welfare state? Territorial politics and the welfare state in the UK and US. Journal of Social Policy39(2): 181–201.
47.
GreveB (2013) The Routledge Handbook of the Welfare State. London: Routledge.
48.
GurtooAUdayaadithyaA (2014) Welfare schemes in India: Decentralization dynamics and Stakeholder influences. International Journal of Sociology and Social Policy34(3–4): 154–165.
HayekF (1994 [1945]) The Road to Serfdom. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
51.
HemerijckA (2012) Changing Welfare States. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
52.
HepburnE (2006) Scottish autonomy and European integration. The response of Scotland’s political parties. In: McGarryJKeatingM (eds) European Integration and the Nationalities Question. London and New York: Routledge.
53.
HutchinsonJSmithA (1995) Nationalism. Oxford and New York: Oxford University Press.
54.
IllifeJ (1987) The African Poor: A History. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
55.
IvankovaNCreswellJStickS (2011) The application of a multiphase triangulation approach to mixed methods. Journal of Mixed Methods Research6: 184–198.
56.
JægerMKvistJ (2003) Pressures on state welfare in post-industrial societies: Is more or less better?Social Policy & Administration37(6): 555–572.
57.
JakimowT (2014) Decentralised governance as sites for self-formation: A comparison of practices of welfare distribution in Telangana, India, and Central Lombok, Indonesia. International Journal of Asian Studies11(2): 161–185.
58.
JamesA (1928) Defining public welfare as a function of government in Virginia. Social Forces6(4): 622–626.
59.
JenningsE (1979) Competition, constituencies, and welfare policies in American States. American Political Science Review73: 414–429.
60.
Johnston ConoverPCreweISearingD (1991) The nature of citizenship in the United States and Great Britain: Empirical comments on theoretical themes. The Journal of Politics53: 800–832.
61.
JütersonkeOStuckiP (2007) Consolidating content and discourse analysis. Paper presented at the annual meeting of the international studies association 48th annual convention, Chicago, IL, 3–6 April 2007.
62.
KatzM (1986) In the Shadow of the Poorhouse: A Social History of Welfare in America. New York: Basic Books.
63.
KayJ (2009) The Economics of Small State. Hume Occasional Paper No. 81. Edinburgh: The David Hume Institute.
64.
KazepovY (2010) Rescaling Social Policies: Towards Multilevel Governance in Europe. Farnham: Ashgate Publishing.
65.
KeyV (1956) American State Politics: An Introduction. New York: Knopf.
66.
KleinmanM (2002) A European Welfare State?: European Union Social Policy in Context. Houndmills, Basingstoke, Hampshire: Palgrave.
67.
Le GalesPLequesneC (1998) Regions in Europe: The Paradox of Power. London: Routledge.
68.
LiebermanRShawG (2000) Looking inward, looking outward: The politics of state welfare innovation under devolution. Political Research Quarterly53(2): 215–240.
69.
López-SantanaMMoyerR (2012) Decentralising the active welfare state: The relevance of intergovernmental structures in Italy and Spain. Journal of Social Policy41(4): 769–788.
70.
LynchP (1996) Minority Nationalism and European Integration. Cardiff: University of Wales Press.
71.
McBrideSMcNuttS (2007) Neoliberalism in the Canadian Welfare State Ideology, national and international conditioning frameworks, and policy change in British Columbia. Global Social Policy7(2): 177–201.
72.
McKeeA (2003) Textual Analysis. London: Sage.
73.
MitchellJ (1998) Member state or Euro-Region? The SNP, Plaid Cymru, and Europe. In: BakerDSeawrightD (eds) Britain For and Against Europe: British Politics and the Question of European Integration. Oxford: Clarendon Press.
74.
MitchellJMitchellA (2011) Devolution in the UK. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
75.
MooneyGScottG (2011) Social justice, social welfare and devolution: Nationalism and social policy making in Scotland. Poverty & Public Policy3(4): 2–21.
76.
MooneyGScottG (eds) (2012) Social Justice and Social Policy in Scotland. Bristol: Policy Press.
77.
MorganK (1971) Welsh nationalism: The historical background. Journal of Contemporary History6(1): 153–172.
78.
NagelJ (2004) Transcending the national/ ssserting the national: how stateless nations like Scotland, Wales and Catalonia react to European integration. Australian Journal of Politics and History50(1): 57–74.
79.
NeundorfAAdamsJ (2016) The micro-foundations of party competition and issue ownership: The reciprocal effects of citizens’ issue salience and party attachments. British Journal of Political Science1: 1–22.
80.
ObingerH (2005) Federalism and the Welfare State: New World and European Experiences. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
81.
ObingerHStarkePMoserJet al. (2010) Transformations of the Welfare State: Small States, Big Lessons. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
OffeC (1984) Contradictions of the Welfare State. Cambridge MA: The MIT Press.
84.
PapacharissiZ (2008) News frames terrorism: A comparative analysis of frames employed in terrorism coverage in US and UK newspapers. The International Journal of Press/Politics13(1): 52–74.
85.
PavoliniERanciC (2008) Restructuring the welfare state: Reforms in long-term care in Western European countries. Journal of European Social Policy18(3): 246–259.
86.
PetmesidouM (1996) Social protection in Greece: A brief glimpse of a welfare state. Social Policy and Administration30(4): 324–347.
87.
PiersonP (1994) Dismantling the Welfare State? Reagan, Thatcher, and the Politics of Retrenchment. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
88.
PiersonP (1995) Fragmented welfare states: Federal institutions and the development of social policy. Governance8(4): 449–478.
89.
PivenFClowardR (1971) Regulating the Poor: The Functions of Poor Relief. New York: Pantheon.
90.
Plaid Cymru (1990) An Independent Wales—the Future Beyond.Cardiff: Plaid Cymru.
91.
Plaid Cymru (1999) The Manifesto of Plaid Cymru: The Party of Wales. Cardiff: Plaid Cymru.
92.
Plaid Cymru (2003) Manifesto 2003. Cardiff: Plaid Cymru.
93.
Plaid Cymru (2007) Make a Difference. Cardiff: Plaid Cymru.
94.
Plaid Cymru (2011) Ambition is Critical: A Manifesto for a Better Wales. Cardiff: Plaid Cymru.
95.
Plaid Cymru (2016) The Change Wales Needs. Cardiff: Plaid Cymru.
96.
PriceALevingerB (2011) The Flotilla Effect: Europe’s Small Economies through the Eye of the Storm - A Report for Jill Evans MEP. Cardiff: Plaid Cymru.
97.
PriorDBarnesM (2011) Subverting social policy on the front line: Agencies of resistance in the delivery of services. Social Policy and Administration45(3): 264–279.
98.
RapoportA (2013) Global citizenship themes in the social studies classroom: Teaching devices and teachers’ attitudes. The Educational Forum77(4): 407–420.
99.
RauhutDKahilaP (2012) Youth unemployment, ageing and regional welfare: The regional labour market policy response to ageing in Sweden. European Spatial Research and Policy19(1): 111–127.
100.
RhodesR (1997) Understanding Governance: Policy Networks, Governance, Reflexivity and Accountability. Buckingham: Open University Press.
101.
Rodríguez-PoseAGillN (2003) The global trend towards devolution and its implications. Environment & Planning C Government and Policy21(3): 333–351.
102.
Sabates-WheelerRDevereuxS (2007) Social protection for transformation. IDS Bulletin38: 23–28.
103.
SchmidtV (2002) Does discourse matter in the politics of welfare state adjustment?Comparative Political Studies35(2): 168–193.
104.
Scottish National Party (1974) Scotland’s Future. Edinburgh: Scottish National Party.
105.
Scottish National Party (SNP) (1999) Enterprise, Compassion, Democracy. Edinburgh: SNP.
106.
Scottish National Party (SNP) (2003) The Complete Case For A Better Scotland. Edinburgh: SNP.
107.
Scottish National Party (SNP) (2007) It’s Time. Edinburgh: SNP.
108.
Scottish National Party (SNP) (2011) Re-Elect A Scottish Government Working For Scotland. Edinburgh: SNP.
109.
Scottish National Party (SNP) (2016) Re-Elect. Edinburgh: SNP.
110.
SellersJLidstromA (2007) Decentralization, local government, and the welfare state. Governance – An International Journal of Policy Administration and Institutions20(4): 609–632.
111.
SevincECivanA (2013) The effect of European Union membership on welfare. Review of European Studies5(1): 48–59.
112.
ShanahanEJonesMMcBethM (2011) Policy narratives and policy processes. The Policy Studies Journal39(3): 535–561.
113.
SheeleyA (2012) Devolution and welfare reform: Re-evaluating ‘success’. Social Work57(4): 321–331.
114.
SteinerS (2008) How important is the capacity of Local Governments for Improvements in Welfare? Evidence from decentralised Uganda, IDEAS Working Paper Series. Available at: https://ideas.repec.org/p/bwp/bwppap/4308.html (accessed 17 April 2016).
115.
StillerS (2010) Ideational Leadership in German Welfare State Reform: How Politicians and Policy Ideas Transform Resilient Institutions. Amsterdam: Amsterdam University Press.
116.
StoerSMagalhãesA (2002) The reconfiguration of the modern social contract: New forms of citizenship and education. European Educational Research Journal1(4): 692–704.
117.
SwedlowB (2014) Advancing policy theory with cultural theory. Policy Studies Journal42(4): 465–483.
118.
Taylor-GoobyP (2004) New Risks, New Welfare: The Transformation of the European Welfare State. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
119.
Taylor-GoobyP (2005) Ideas and Welfare State Reform in Western Europe. Basingstoke: Palgrave Macmillan.
120.
ThomsonK (2002) Regional welfare system developments in Russia: Community social services. Social Policy & Administration36(2): 105–122.
121.
ThrelfallM (2007) The social dimension of the European Union: Innovative methods for advancing integration. Global Social Policy7(3): 271–293.
122.
TitmussR (1958) Essays on the Welfare State. London: Allen & Unwin.
123.
ToubeauSWagnerM (2016) Party competition over decentralisation: The influence of ideology and electoral incentives on issue emphasis. European Journal of Political Research55(2): 340–357. DOI: 10.1111/1475-6765.12133.
124.
VampaD (2014a) Territorial mobilization and sub-state welfare governance in Italy and Spain Comparing four regional case studies, Paper circulated at the 2014 ECPR conference, Glasgow. Available at: http://ecpr.eu/events/panellist.aspx?EventID=12 (accessed 24 April 2016).
125.
VampaD (2014b) The sub-state politics of welfare in Italy: Assessing the effect of territorial mobilization on the development of region-specific social governance. Regional & Federal Studies24(4): 473–491.
126.
Van DijkT (1981) Episodes as units of discourse analysis. In: DeborahT (ed.) Analyzing Discourse: Text and Talk. Georgetown: Georgetown University Press, pp. 177–195.
127.
VisBVan KersbergenK (2013) Towards an open functional approach to welfare state change: Pressures, ideas, and blame avoidance. Public Administration91(4): 840–854.
128.
WilenskyH (1975) The Welfare State and Equality. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.
