Community activists, supervised by macro-intervention social workers, can realize the potential to go from passive consumers of social services to producers of appropriate responses to the needs of their communities. While the literature describes the influence of religious and cultural characteristics on the effectiveness of such interventions, the question of whether there are differences in personal resources and community activity between activists from different cultures has yet to be investigated. The current study compared community activists from the ultra-Orthodox sector in Israel, a traditional society, with activists from the general population, examining personality traits defined in the literature as critical for community activists (self-esteem, mastery), aspects of community activity (client participation, representation, level of activity), and outcomes of community activity (dimensions of well-being). The sample consisted of 351 activists, 163 from the ultra-Orthodox population and 188 from the general population.
Findings
The findings reveal significant differences between the two groups, with higher levels of most personal and community variables found among the activists from the general population. This is consistent with the literature and may be attributed to the insularity of the ultra-Orthodox sector, which keeps itself apart from society at large. Interestingly, despite the resource deficits in this community, its activists reported higher levels of personal well-being.
Applications
The findings have implications for researchers and practitioners. They indicate the importance of working closely with the leaders of traditional societies and designing unique methods of social work intervention to enhance the activists’ personal resources and community characteristics, while maintaining cultural sensitivity.
AndrewsF. M.RobinsonJ. P. (1991). Measures of subjective well-being.
San Diego, CA:
Academic Press.
2.
AustinM. J. (2004). Changing welfare services. Case studies of local welfare reform programs.
New York:
Haworth.
3.
Band-WintersteinT.FreundA. (2015).
Is it enough to ‘speak haredi’? Cultural sensitivity in social workers encountering Jewish ultra-Orthodox clients in Israel. British Journal of Social Work,
45(3), 968–987.
4.
BaumN. (2010).
Jewish Israeli social work students’ attitudes to the prospect of being assigned an Israeli Arab client.Journal of Ethnic & Cultural Diversity in Social Work,
19, 143–170.
5.
BaumeisterR. F.CampbellJ. D.KruegerJ. I.VohsK. D. (2003).
Does high self-esteem cause better performance, interpersonal success, happiness or healthier lifestyles?American Psychology Society,
4(1), 1–44.
6.
Ben-ZurH. (2003).
Happy adolescents: The link between subjective well-being, internal resources and parental factors.Journal of Youth and Adolescence,
32(2), 67–79.
7.
BoehmA.StaplesL. (2004).
Empowerment: The point of view of consumers.Families in Society: The Journal of Contemporary Social Services,
85(2), 270–280.
8.
BradburnN. M. (1969). The structure of psychological well-being.
Chicago, IL:
Aldine.
9.
BucknerJ. C. (1988).
The development of an instrument to measure neighborhood cohesion.American Journal of Community Psychology,
16, 771–791.
10.
BurnsM.StoreyK.CertoN. J. (1999).
Effect of service learning on attitudes toward students with severe disabilities. Education and Training in Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities,
34(1), 58–65.
11.
BustinE. (2002).
Hakesher bein arakhim, hadrakha, ha'atzma veshituf lekohot le-vein tfisat efektiviut be-avoda kehilatit [Values, supervision, empowerment, and involvement of clients and their relationship to perceived effectiveness in community work] (Unpublished doctoral dissertation), Bar Ilan University (Hebrew).
12.
CaplanK. (2003).
The internal popular discourse of Israeli Haredi women. Archives des Sciences Sociales des Religions,
123, 77–101.
13.
ChaiK. (2000). Protestant-Catholic-Buddhist: Korean Americans and religious adaptation in greater Boston (Unpublished doctoral dissertation), Harvard University, Cambridge, MA.
14.
ChaskinR. J.BrownV.VenkateshS.VidalA. (2007). Building community capacity.
New York:
Aldine Transaction.
15.
CheckowayB. (2011).
Community development, social diversity, and the new metropolis.Community Development Journal,
46(2), ii5–ii14.
16.
CicognaniE.PiriniC.KeyesC.JoshanlooM.RostamiR.NosratabadiM. (2008).
Social participation, sense of community and social well being: A study on American, Italian and Iranian university students.Social Indicators Research,
89(1), 97–112.
17.
CohenJ. (1969). Statistical power analysis for the behavioural sciences.
New York:
Academic Press.
18.
ColemanS. J. (1988).
Social capital and the creation of human capital.American Journal of Sociology,
94, 95–121.
19.
Coleman-BrueckheimerK.SpitzerJ.KoffmanJ. (2009).
Involvement of Rabbinic and communal authorities in decision-making by Haredi Jews in the UK with breast cancer: An interpretative phenomenological analysis. Social Science and Medicine,
68, 323–333.
20.
ComptonB. R.GalawayB.CournoyerB. R. (2005). Social work processes (7th ed.).
Belmont, CA:
Brooks/Cole.
21.
DehanN.AviramU. (2010).
Making training in social work accessible for the Israeli Ultra-Orthodox (Haredi) Community – An experimental program of the Hebrew University for training Haredi women in social work. Social Security,
82, 113–143.
22.
DeweesM. (2001).
Building cultural competence for work with diverse families: Strategies from the privileged side.Journal of Ethnic & Cultural Diversity in Social Work,
9(3/4), 33–51.
23.
DhaliwalS.Yuval-DavisN. (2015). Introduction. In: DhaliwalS.Yuval-DavisN. (Eds), Women Against Fundamentalism: Stories of dissent and solidarity (pp. 7–51).
London, UK:
Lawrence & Wishart.
24.
EversoleR. (2012).
Remaking participation: Challenges for community development practice.Community Development Journal,
47(1), 29–41.
25.
FaraciP.CannistraciS. (2015).
The short index of self-actualization: A factor analysis study in an Italian sample.International Journal of Psychological Research,
8(2), 23–33.
26.
FreundA.Band-WintersteinT. (2013).
Between tradition and modernity: Social work-related change processes in the Jewish ultra-orthodox society in Israel. International Journal of Intercultural Relations,
37, 422–433.
27.
GlaeserE.LaibsonD.ScheinkonanJ. A.SoutterC. L. (2000).
Measuring trust. Quarterly Journal of Economics,
115, 811–846.
28.
HarelH. (2002). Me’ut ve-zehut: Ha-kesher bein ha-khasifa le-khevra ha-yehudit le-vein giboosh “zehut ha-ani” ve-giboosh ha-zehut ha-etnit shel mitbagrot araviot [Minority and identity: The relationship between exposure to Jewish society and the shaping of “self-identity” and ethnic identity among female Arab teens] (Unpublished master’s thesis), Bar Ilan University, Ramat Gan,
Israel (Hebrew).
29.
HedgesL.OlkinI. (1985). Statistical methods for meta-analysis.
New York:
Academic Press.
30.
HeskinA. D. (1991). The struggle for community.
Boulder, CO:
Westview Press.
31.
HobfollS. E.WalfischS. (1984).
Coping with a threat to life: A longitudinal study of self-concept, social support, and psychological distress.American Journal of Community Psychology,
12, 87–99.
32.
Israel Central Bureau of Statistics. (2013). Pnei ha-khevra be-yisrael: Yisrael mi-ayin ve-le’an? [The face of Israeli society: From where to where?]. Statistical Abstract of Israel 2011, Report No. 6. Jerusalem, Israel: The author (Hebrew).
33.
ItzhakyH.BustinE. (2012). Avodah kehilatit be-yisrael: Bein avar le-atid [Community work in Israel: Between past and future]. In HovavM.ELawental.KatanJ. (Eds), Social work in Israel.
Tel Aviv, Israel:
Hakibbutz Hameuhad (Hebrew).
34.
ItzhakyH.YorkA. S. (1994).
Different types of client participation and the effects on community social work intervention. Journal of Social Services Research,
19, 85–98.
35.
ItzhakyH.YorkA. S. (2003).
Leadership competence and political control: The influential factors. Journal of Community Psychology,
31(4), 371–381.
36.
ItzhakyH.ZanbarL.LevyD.SchwartzC. (2015).
The contribution of personal and social resources to well-being and sense of belonging to the community among community activists. British Journal of Social Work,
45(6), 1678–1698.
37.
JeffriesA. (1996). Modeling community work: An analytic framework for practice. In WeilM. (Ed.), Community practice: Conceptual models (pp. 101–125).
New York:
The Haworth Press.
38.
KatzoverY. (1999).
Masa el eretz ha-khatzerot [Journey to the Land of the Hasidic Courts].Panim,
9, 24–31 (Hebrew).
39.
KernisM. H. (2003).
Toward a conceptualization of optimal self-esteem.Psychological Inquiry,
14(1), 1–26.
40.
KosicA. (2007). Motivation for civic participation of immigrants: The role of personal resources, social identities, and personal traits. Politics: Working paper no. 11. Oldenburg, Germany: Interdisciplinary Centre for Education and Communication in Migration Processes, University of Oldenburg.
41.
LedwithM. (2005).
Personal narratives/political lives: Personal reflection as a tool for collective change.Reflective Practice,
6(2), 255–262.
42.
LevyD.ItzhakyHZanbarL.SchwartzC. (2012).
Sense of cohesion among community activists engaging in volunteer activity. Journal of Community Psychology,
70(6), 735–746.
43.
LoweS. S. (2000).
Creating community: Art for community development.Journal of Contemporary Ethnography,
29(3), 357–386.
LumD. (Ed.). (2003). Culturally competent practice: A framework for understanding diverse groups and justice issues (2nd ed.).
London, UK:
Thomson.
46.
MakarosA.ItzhakyH. (2013).
Effectiveness of micro-and macro-level intervention at times of economic crisis.Journal of Social Work,
13(6), 563–581.
47.
MatarassoF. (2007).
Common ground: Cultural action as a route to community development.Community Development Journal,
42(4), 449–445.
48.
McMillanD. W.ChavisD. M. (1986).
Sense of community: A definition and theory. Journal of Community Psychology,
14(1), 6–23.
49.
MendoncaM. (2000).
Personal mastery in ethical leadership.Med-Law,
19(4), 855–862.
50.
Ministry of Social Affairs and Social Services. (2003). Hafalat ovdim smach miktzoi’im be-makhlakot le-sherutim hevrati’im be-rashuyut mekomiot [Operating para-professional workers in the social services departments of local authorities]. Jerusalem, Israel: Division of Personal and Social Services, Individual and Family Welfare Service (Hebrew).
51.
MizrahiT. (2006). Models of client and citizen participation in welfare programs in the U.S.
Jerusalem:
Israeli Ministry of Social Affairs.
52.
NewbroughJ. R.ChavisD. M. (1986).
Psychological sense of community. Journal of Community Psychology,
14, 3–5.
53.
OhmerM. L. (2004). Citizen participation and its effects in neighborhood organizations: The influence of perceived organizational characteristics and effectiveness (Unpublished doctoral dissertation), University of Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania.
54.
PearlinL. I.SchoolerC. (1978).
The structure of coping.Journal of Health and Social Behavior,
19, 2–21.
55.
PopovskyM. A. (2010).
Special issues in the care of ultra-orthodox Jewish psychiatric in-patients.Transcultural Psychiatry,
47, 647–672.
56.
PutnamD. R. (2000). Bowling alone: The collapse and revival of American community.
New York:
Simon & Schuster.
57.
RosenbergM. (1965). Society and adolescent self-image.
Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press.
58.
RothmanJ. (2007).
Multi modes of intervention at the macro level.Journal of Community Practice,
15(4), 11–40.
59.
SchiemanS.NguyenK.ElliottD. (2003).
Religiosity, socioeconomic status, and the sense of mastery. Social Psychology Quarterly,
66(3), 202–221.
60.
SeipelM. M. O. (2003).
Global poverty: No longer an untouchable problem. International Social Work,
46(2), 191–207.
61.
ShyeS.LazarA.DuchinR.GidronB. (2000). Philanthropy in Israel: Patterns of the giving and volunteering of the Israeli public.
Beer-Sheva:
Israel Center for Third Sector Research, Ben Gurion University of the Negev.
62.
SueD. W.SueD. (2003). Counseling the culturally diverse: Theory and practice (4th ed.).
New York:
John Wiley & Sons.
63.
SuwanakulS. (2009).
The determinants of noneconomic factors affecting economic growth. Journal of the American Academy of Business,
15, 104–109.
64.
SwindellD. (2000).
Issue representation in neighborhood organizations: Questing for democracy at the grassroots.Journal of Urban Affairs,
22, 123–137.
65.
ThoitsP. A.HewittL. N. (2001).
Volunteer work and well-being.Journal of Health and Social Behavior,
42(2), 115–131.
Van HookM. P.RiveraJ. O. (2004).
Coping with difficult life transitions by older adults: The role of religion. Social Work & Christianity,
31(3), 233–253.
68.
WeilM.GambleD. N. (2005). Evolution, models and the changing context of community practice. In WeilM. (Ed.), The handbook of community practice (pp. 117–149).
Thousand Oaks, CA:
Sage.
69.
WilliamsC.GrahamM. (2013). Travelling hopefully: Race/ethnic relations and social work research: A transnational dialogue. In: WilliamsC.GrahamM. (Eds), Social work in Europe: Race and ethnic relations.
London, UK:
Routledge.
70.
WitztumE. (1999). Tipul integrativi estrategi ragish tarbut beukhlusiot datiot veharediot [Culturally sensitive integrative strategic therapy with religious and ultra-Orthodox populations]. In RabinC. (Ed.), Lihiyot shoneh beyisrael: Motza adati vemin betipul beyisrael [Being different in Israel: Ethnicity and gender in Israeli therapy (pp. 83–95).
Tel Aviv, Israel:
Ramot Press (Hebrew).
71.
ZanbarL.ItzhakyH. (2013a).
Effectiveness perception: Contributing resources among community activists in a traditional society. Social Development Issues,
35(2), 70–92.
72.
ZanbarL.ItzhakyH. (2013b).
Community activists’ competence: The contributing factors. Journal of Community Psychology,
41(2), 249–263.
73.
ZanbarL.ItzhakyH. (2014).
The contribution of macro-intervention social worker to the success of volunteer community activists.Voluntas,
25(1), 92–108.
74.
ZhangS.AndersonS. G.ZhanM. (2011).
Differentiated Impact of bridging and bonding social capital on economic well-being: An individual level perspective. Journal of Sociology & Social Welfare,
38, 119–142.
75.
ZimmermanM. A.RappaportJ. (1988).
Citizen participation, perceived control, and psychological empowerment. American Journal of Community Psychology,
16, 725–750.
