The purpose of this article is to identify the professional discourse on girls over time, and to examine the extent and the ways in which feminist ideas and theories are expressed in this discourse, and in particular, in the scholarly social work body of knowledge in Israel. Thus, the article presents a feminist-historical analysis of research on girls in conditions of distress published in Israel during the years 1970–2010.
Findings
Four main theoretical discourses were found through an analysis of 107 publications: the pathological discourse; the discourse of vulnerability; the discourse of agency; and the intersectional discourse. The findings show that the number of studies on girls and the use of feminist discourses in them are on the rise. The girls’ characteristics, their sexual behavior, and its connections to the characteristics of their families are three focuses of the research all through the years. However, major differences were discovered in the ways these issues were interpreted in accordance with the guiding discourse adopted by each individual study.
Applications
The choice of a specific discourse leads to different social work practice with girls. In order to develop feminist practices with girls and to apply the most appropriate one, one should recognize the different available discourses, and their potentialities to the field.
AbramsL. S. (2002) Rethinking girls ‘at-risk’: Gender, race, and class intersections and adolescent behavior. Journal of Human Behavior in the Social Environment6(2): 49–66.
2.
Abu-Sif, A. (2009). Physical and psychological violence against adolescent girls in the Negev Bedouin society (Unpublished master’s thesis) [in Hebrew]. Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Be’er Sheva.
3.
AltheideD. L. (1987) Ethnographic content analysis. Qualitative Sociology10(1): 65–77.
4.
Apter, Y., & Zaslavsky, T. (2001). Curriculum and professional training for immigrant girls in distress from the Former Soviet Union and Ethiopia [in Hebrew]. Tel-Aviv, Israel: Tel-Aviv University, The Forum for Children and Youth.
5.
Amitai, G. (2010). Risk factors for social deviance among adolescent girls with learningdisabilities or major academic difficulties (Unpublished doctoral dissertation) [in Hebrew]. Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Jerusalem.
6.
BergerR.ShechterY. (1987) Adolescent girls in distress: A high-risk intersection [in Hebrew]. Society & Welfare7(4): 344–346.
7.
BergmanZ.TeichnerN.TenneD. (1976) The rehabilitation of underprivileged girls in an open institution. Crime and Social Deviance4(4): 3–15.
8.
ChalfonA. (1975) Girls in trouble [in Hebrew]. Saad15(2): 36–58.
9.
Cochva, S. (2007). The effect of boarding school education on the perception of sex roles and subjective wellbeing in girls at risk (Unpublished master’s thesis) [in Hebrew]. Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv.
10.
Cohen, T. (1995). The perception of parent-daughter relationship by ordinary girls and girls indistress (Unpublished master’s thesis) [in Hebrew]. Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan.
11.
CrenshawK. (1989) Demarginalizing the intersection of race and sex: A black feminist critique of antidiscrimination doctrine, feminist theory and antiracist politics. University of Chicago Legal Forum140: 139–167.
12.
GilliganC. (1982) In a different voice: Psychological theory and women’s development, Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
13.
GringeriC. E.RocheS. E. (2010) Beyond the binary: Critical feminisms in social work. Affilia25(4): 337–340.
14.
GolanM.KomemM.Kay-TzadokA. (2008) To see the light, to lighten the darkness: On the Girls for Girls, mentoring program [in Hebrew]. In: HovavM.MellH.GolanM. (eds) Therapeutic interventions with at-risk adolescents, Tel Aviv, Israel: Carmel, pp. 195–218.
15.
GonickM. (2004) The ‘mean girl’ crisis: Problemataizing representations of girls’ friendships. Feminism & Psychology14(3): 395–400. doi:10.1177/0959353504044641.
16.
GonickM.RenoldE.RingroseJ.WeemsL. (2009) Rethinking agency and resistance: What comes after girl power?Girlhood Studies2(2): 1–9. doi:10.3167/ghs.2009.020202.
17.
GunnarssonB. L. (1997) On the socio-historical construction of scientific discourse. In: GunnarssonB. L.LinellP.NordbergB. (eds) The construction of professional discourse, New York, NY: Longman, pp. 99–126.
18.
HallC.SarangiS.SlembrouckS. (1997) Moral construction in social work discourse. In: GunnarssonB. L.LinellP.NordbergB. (eds) The construction of professional discourse, New York, NY: Longman, pp. 265–291.
19.
HarrisA. (2004) All about the girl: Culture, power, and identity, New York, NY: Routledge.
20.
HicksS. (2008) Thinking through sexuality. Journal of Social Work8(1): 65–82. doi:10.1177/1468017307084740.
21.
HeyV. (2009) The girl in the mirror: The psychic economy of class in the discourse of girlhood studies. Girlhood Studies2(2): 10–32. doi:10.3167/ghs.2009.020203.
22.
HoweD. (1994) Modernity, postmodernity and social work. British Journal of Social Work24(5): 513–532.
23.
IedemaR. (2005) The tension between professional and institutional discourse: An applied linguistic analysis of hospital communication. Journal of Applied Linguistics2(3): 243–252. doi:10.1558/japl.v2i3.243.
24.
Kahan-StrawczynskiP.YurovichL.KonstantinovV.EfratiR. (2005) Characteristics and needs of adolescent girls in the care of the Service for Women and Girls of the Ministry of Social Affairs [in Hebrew], Jerusalem, Israel: Myers-JDC-Brookdale Institute.
25.
KatzavN. (1972) Working and learning girls and disconnected girls [in Hebrew], Jerusalem, Israel: Prime-Minister Committee for Children and Youth in Distress.
26.
Katzav, R. (2009). Homeless addicted young women: Their experiences and their perceived needs (Unpublished master’s thesis) [in Hebrew]. Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv.
27.
KearneyM. C. (2009) Coalescing: The development of girls’ studies. NWSA Journal21(1): 1–33. doi:10.1353/nwsa.0.0065.
28.
Keisary, A. (2001). The joining of girls in distress to Arab Men as a function of their style of attachment and taking risks tendency (Unpublished master’s thesis) [in Hebrew]. Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan.
29.
KennedyA. C. (2008) Eugenics, ‘degenerate girls,’ and social workers during the Progressive era. Affilia23(1): 22–37. doi:10.1177/0886109907310473.
30.
Komem, M., Golan, M., Dolev, T., & Yovel, D. (2005). Adolescent girls on the map. In G. Rahav, Y. Wozner, & M. Wander-Schwartz (Eds), Youth in Israel 2004 (pp. 191–208) [in Hebrew]. Ramat Aviv, Israel: Bob Shapell School of Social Work, Tel Aviv University and the Interdisciplinary Center for Policy Study and the Treatment of Children and Youth.
31.
Krumer-Nevo, M., & Komem, M. (2013). Intersectionality and critical social work with girls: Theory and practice. British Journal of Social Work. doi:10.1093/bjsw/bct189.
32.
LevinL.Weiss-GalI. (2011) Social work education in Israel at the dawn of the 21st century. In: StanleyS. (ed.) Social work education in countries of the East: Issues and challenges, Hauppauge, NY: Nova Science Publishers, pp. 191–207.
33.
LipkinE. (2009) Girls’ studies, Berkeley, CA: Seal Press.
Ministry of Welfare (1975) A report on the implementation of the recommendations by the Prime-Minister Committee for Children and Youth in Distress [in Hebrew], Jerusalem: Author.
36.
Ministry of Welfare (2008) The policy of treating girls in distress [in Hebrew]. Social Work Regulations, 17.1.3, Jerusalem: Author.
37.
Miro-JaffeI.Haj-YahiaL. (2007) A ‘Warm Home’ for adolescent girls and unmarried women in Pardes and Shfaram [in Hebrew], Jerusalem: National Insurance Institute.
Mor, M. (2008). ‘Go back, move forward’: The meaning of the Youth Improvement Unit in thelives of girls who graduated from the Unit (Unpublished master’s thesis) [in Hebrew]. Ben-Gurion University of the Negev, Be’er Sheva.
40.
MumbyD. K.ClairR. P. (1997) Organizational discourse. In: Van DijkT. A. (ed.) Discourse as social interactionVol. 2: London, England: Sage, pp. 181–205.
41.
Nachmias, S. (1975). Social care for girls in distress (Unpublished master’s thesis) [in Hebrew]. Tel-Aviv University, Tel-Aviv.
42.
ParkY. (2006) Constructing immigrants: A historical discourse analysis of the representations of immigrants in US social work, 1882–1952. Journal of Social Work6(2): 169–203. doi:10.1177/1468017306066673.
43.
PeledE.Krumer-NevoM. (2013) Feminist social work. In: HovavM.LawentalE.KatanY. (eds) Social work in Israel, Tel-Aviv, Israel: Am Oved, Kav Adom, pp. 479–505.
44.
RapoportT. (1989) ‘Between margarine and iron’: Girls in distress’ arenas of socialization and friendship [in Hebrew], Jerusalem, Israel: The Hebrew University.
45.
RapoportT. (1993) Tow patterns of girlhood: Inconsistent sexuality-laden experiences across socialization institutions and socio-cultural milieu [in Hebrew]. Megamot35(1): 5–22.
46.
RimmermanY. (1976) The wayward girl: Her problems and her distress [in Hebrew]. Saad3: 25–42.
SamuelsG. M.Ross-SheriffF. (2008) Identity, oppression, and power: Feminisms and intersectionality theory. Affilia23: 5–9. doi:10.1177/0886109907310475.
49.
Sasson-Blustien, P. (2005). The treatment experience as perceived by ‘distressed girls’(Unpublished master’s thesis) [in Hebrew]. University of Haifa, Haifa.
50.
Schorr-Levy, O. (2001). Relations between attitudes of girls in distress toward sex and sexual behavior and attitudes of their mothers (Unpublished master’s thesis) [in Hebrew]. Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan.
51.
Schwartz, Y. (2003). ‘The border between Heaven and Hell’: The social construction of the exclusion of the Ultra-Orthodox girl in distress in her relations with the educational system, her family, the community and the social services. (Unpublished master’s thesis) [in Hebrew]. Bar-Ilan University, Ramat-Gan.
52.
Steinberg, O. (1995). Delinquent girls in Israel (Unpublished doctoral dissertation). The Hebrew University of Jerusalem, Jerusalem.
53.
Steiner, Y. (1979). Girls in distress: Knowledge, attitudes and sexual behavior (Unpublished master's thesis) [in Hebrew]. University of Haifa, Haifa.
54.
Tenne, D. (1987). Girls in distress: Therapeutic aspects [in Hebrew]. Jerusalem, Israel: The Hebrew University, the School of Social Work and the School of Education.
55.
TenneD.GoldsteinA. (1984) Regression of girls in distress [in Hebrew]. Crime and Social Deviance12: 7–22.
56.
TiceK. W. (1998) Tales of wayward girls and immoral women: Case records and the professionalization of social work, Champaign: University of Illinois Press.
57.
WeilL. (1984) The relative treatment satisfaction of clients and their caseworkers in the Unit for Girls in Distress [in Hebrew]. Society and Welfare6: 55–68.
58.
YoungJ. (2009) Moral panic: Its origins in resistance, ressentiment and the translation of fantasy into reality. British Journal of Criminology49: 4–16. doi:10.1093/bjc/azn074.
