The present study analyzed survey data from 970 tourists to evaluate their Lake Erie wine region experience. Using structural equation modeling, an adapted scale of the experience economy’s 4Es (i.e. educational, esthetic, entertainment, and escapist experiences) proved reliable and valid for measuring rural wine tourism. This study contributes new information to research examining the 4Es applied to tourism venues by showing the 4Es’ impact on tourist response to loyalty for an entire destination. Structural modeling demonstrated the dominance of the esthetic experience in predicting positive memories and destination loyalty in the wine tourism context. Education played a significant but lesser role in creating memories and satisfaction but not in destination loyalty. Although the esthetic experience’s preeminence was consistent with other findings, these results contradict Pine and Gilmore’s assertion that simultaneous incorporation of the 4Es is necessary.
AdamsMQ (2006) Nautical wine tourism: A strategic plan to create a nautical wine trail in the Finger Lakes wine tourism region of New York State. In: CarlsenJWallingfordCS (eds) Global Wine Tourism: Research, Management and Marketing, Wallingford, UK: CAB International, pp. 225–241.
2.
AjzenI (1991) The theory of planned behavior. Organizational Behavior and Human Decision Processes50(2): 179–221.
3.
AlantKBruwerJ (2004) Wine tourism behaviour in the context of a motivational framework for wine regions and cellar doors. Journal of Wine Research15(1): 27–37.
4.
AlegreJCladeraM (2009) Analyzing the effect of satisfaction and previous visits on tourist intentions to return. European Journal of Marketing43(5/6): 670–685.
5.
Ali-KnightJCarlsenJ (2003) An exploration of the use of ‘extraordinary’ experiences in wine tourism. In: LockshinLRungieC (eds) Proceedings of the International Colloquium in Wine Marketing, Wine Marketing Group, Adelaide: University of South Australia. Available at: http://academyofwinebusiness.com/?page_id=465 (accessed 21 October 2013).
6.
Ali-KnightJChartersS (2003) Winery as educator: Do wineries provide what the wine tourist needs?Australian and New Zealand Wine Industry Journal16(6): 79–86.
7.
AlonsoAFraserRACohenDA (2007) Investigating differences between domestic and international winery visitors in New Zealand. International Journal of Wine Business Research19(2): 114–126.
8.
AndersonJCGerbingDW (1988) Structural equation modeling in practice: A review and recommended two-step approach. Psychological Bulletin103(3): 411–423.
9.
ArnouldEPriceL (1993) River magic: Extraordinary experience and the extended service encounter. Journal of Consumer Research20(1): 24–45.
10.
AxelsenMSwanT (2010) Designing festival experiences to influence visitor perceptions: The case of a wine and food festival. Journal of Travel Research49(4): 436–450.
11.
BagozziRPYiY (1988) On the evaluation of structural equation models. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science16(10): 74–94.
12.
BarberN (2009) Wine consumers information search: Gender differences and implications for the hospitality industry. Tourism & Hospitality Research9(3): 250–269.
13.
BaronRKennyDA (1986) The moderator-mediator variable distinction in social psychological research: Conceptual, strategic, and statistical considerations. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology51(6): 1173–1182.
14.
BoulianneS (2013) Examining the gender effects of different incentive amounts in a web survey. Field Methods25(1): 91–104.
15.
BrownGPHavitzMEGetzD (2006) Relationship between wine involvement and wine-related travel. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing21(1): 31–46.
16.
BruwerJ (2003) South African wine routes: Some perspectives on the wine tourism industry’s structural dimensions and wine tourism product. Tourism Management24(4): 423–435.
17.
BruwerJAlantK (2009) The hedonic nature of wine tourism consumption: An experiential view. International Journal of Wine Business Research21(3): 235–248.
18.
California Wine Institute (2011) California wine profile 2010. Available at: http://www.wineinstitute. org/files/CA_EIR_Flyer_2011_final.pdf (accessed 11 January 2013).
19.
CarlsenJ (2004) A review of global wine tourism research. Journal of Wine Research15(1): 5–13.
20.
CarmichaelB (2005) Understanding the wine tourism experience for winery visitors in the Niagara Region, Ontario, Canada. Tourism Geographies7(2): 185–204.
21.
ChandralalLValenzuelaF-R (2013) Exploring memorable tourism experiences: Antecedents and behavioural outcomes. Journal of Economics, Business and Management1(2): 177–181.
22.
ChartersSAli-KnightJ (2000) Wine tourism—a thirst for knowledge?International Journal of Wine Marketing12(3): 70–81.
23.
ChartersSPettigrewS (2005) Is wine consumption an aesthetic experience?Journal of Wine Research16(2): 121–136.
24.
ChenC-FTsaiCD (2007) How destination image and evaluative factors affect behavioral intentions?Tourism Management28(4): 1115–1122.
25.
ChiCGQuH (2008) Examining the structural relationships of destination image, tourist satisfaction and destination loyalty: An integrated approach. Tourism Management29(4): 625–634.
26.
CohenEBen-NunL (2009) The important dimensions of wine tourism experience from potential visitors’ perception. Tourism and Hospitality Research9(1): 20–31.
27.
ColmanT (2008) Wine Politics: How Governments, Environmentalists, Mobsters, and Critics Influence the Wines We Drink, Berkley, CA: University of California Press.
28.
Cornell University (n.d.) Lake Erie Regional Grape Program at CLEREL. Available at: http://lergp.cce.cornell.edu/ (accessed 15 January 2013).
29.
CreswellJW (2008) Educational Research: Planning, Conducting, and Evaluating Quantitative and Qualitative Research, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education Inc.
30.
CroninJJTaylorSA (1992) Measuring service quality: A re-examination and extension. Journal of Marketing56(3): 55–68.
31.
CurrenPJWestSGFinchJF (1996) The robustness of test statistics to nonnormality and specification error in confirmatory factor analysis. Psychological Methods1(1): 16–29.
32.
CurtinS (2005) Nature, wild animals and tourism: An experiential view. Journal of Ecotourism4(1): 1–15.
33.
EusebioCVieiraAL (2013) Destination attributes’ evaluation, satisfaction and behavioural intentions: A structural modeling approach. International Journal of Tourism Research15(1): 66–80.
34.
EvansMPollardCHolderG (2008) Discover North Carolina wines: A wine tourism visitor profile study, Final report, Appalachian State University: Boone, NC, February.
35.
FishbeinMAjzenI (1975) Belief, Attitude, Intention, and Behavior: An Introduction to Theory and Research, Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley.
36.
FornellCLarckerDF (1981) Evaluating structural equation models with unobservable variables and measurement error. Journal of Marketing Research18(1): 39–50.
37.
FountainJChartersS (2010) Generation Y as wine tourists: Their expectations and experiences at the winery-cellar door. In: BenckendorffPMoscardoGPendergastD (eds) Tourism and Generation Y, Wallingford, UK: CAB International, pp. 47–57.
38.
FournierSMickDG (1999) Rediscovering satisfaction. Journal of Marketing63(4): 5–23.
39.
FraserRAAlonsoACohenD (2008) Wine tourism experiences in New Zealand: An exploration of male and female winery visitors. Acta Turistica20(1): 39–65.
40.
GallowayGMitchellRGetzD (2008) Sensation seeking and the prediction of attitudes and behaviours of wine tourists. Tourism Management29(5): 950–966.
41.
GetzDBrownG (2006) Critical success factors for wine tourism regions: A demand analysis. Tourism Management27(1): 146–158.
42.
GetzDCarlsenJ (2008) Wine tourism among generations X and Y. Tourism56(3): 257–270.
43.
GilmoreJHPineBJII (2002) Differentiating hospitality operations via experiences: Why selling services is not enough. Cornell Hotel and Restaurant Administration Quarterly43(3): 87–96.
44.
GriffinTLoerschA (2007) The determinants of quality experiences in an emerging wine region. In: CarlsenJWallingfordCS (eds) Global Wine Tourism: Research, Management and Marketing, Wallingford, UK: CAB International, pp. 80–92.
45.
HairJFBlackWCBabinBJ (2010) Multivariate Data Analysis: A Global Perspective, Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education Inc.
46.
HallCMJohnsonGCambourneB (2000) Wine tourism: an introduction. In: HallCMLongoAMMitchellRJohnsonG (eds) Wine Tourism around the World: Development, Management and Markets, Oxford, UK: Elsevier, pp. 1–23.
47.
HashimotoATelferDJ (1999) Marketing ice wine to Japanese tourists in Niagara: the case of Inniskillin Winery. International Journal of Wine Marketing11(2): 29–41.
48.
HashimotoATelferDJ (2003) Positioning an emerging wine route in the Niagara Region: Understanding the wine tourism market and its implications for marketing. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing14(3): 61–76.
49.
HayesDMacLeodN (2007) Packaging places: Designing heritage trails using an experience economy perspective to maximize visitor engagement. Journal of Vacation Marketing13(1): 45–58.
50.
HedeA-M (2008) Food and wine festivals: Stakeholders, long-term outcomes and strategies for success. In: HallCMSharplesL (eds) Food and Wine Festivals and Events around the World: Development, Management and Markets, Burlington, MA: Elsevier, pp. 85–100.
HolbrookMBHirschmanEC (1982) The experiential aspects of consumption: Consumer fantasies, feelings, and fun. Journal of Consumer Research9(2): 132–140.
53.
HosanySWithamM (2010) Dimensions of cruisers’ experiences, satisfaction, and intention to recommend. Journal of Travel Research49(3): 351–364.
54.
HuangSHsuCHC (2009) Travel motivation: Linking theory to practice. International Journal of Culture, Tourism and Hospitality Research3(4): 287–295.
55.
KelleyKPreacherKJ (2012) On effect size. Psychological Methods17(2): 137–152.
56.
KimJ-H (2010) Development of a scale to measure memorable tourism experiences. European Journal of Tourism Research3(2): 123–126.
57.
KimK (2008) Analysis of structural equation model for the student pleasure travel market: Motivation, involvement, satisfaction, and destination loyalty. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing24(4): 297–313.
KozakM (2001) Repeaters’ behavior at two distinct destinations. Annals of Tourism Research28(3): 785–808.
60.
KozakMBigneEAndreuL (2004) Satisfaction and destination loyalty: A comparison between non-repeat and repeat tourists. Journal of Quality Assurance in Hospitality & Tourism5(1): 43–59.
61.
LamTHsuCHC (2004) Theory of planned behavior: Potential travelers from China. Journal of Hospitality & Tourism Research28(4): 463–482.
62.
LarsenS (2007) Aspects of a psychology of the tourist experience. Scandinavian Journal of Hospitality and Tourism7(1): 7–18.
63.
LeiMLomaxRG (2005) The effect of varying degrees of nonnormality in structural equation modeling. Structural Equation Modeling: A Multidisciplinary Journal12(1): 1–27.
64.
LuoXHomburgC (2007) Neglected outcomes of customer satisfaction. Journal of Marketing71(2): 133–149.
65.
MacKinnonDP (2008) Introduction to Statistical Mediation Analysis, New York, NY: Taylor and Francis.
66.
MarchRWoodsideAG (2005) Testing theory of planned versus realized tourism behavior. Annals of Tourism Research32(4): 905–924.
67.
MartinEWilliamsP (2003) Directions in British Columbia wine tourism policy. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management15(6): 317–323.
68.
McIntoshAJSiggsA (2005) An exploration of the experiential nature of boutique accommodations. Journal of Travel Research44(1): 74–81.
69.
MendesJDCde VallePOGuerreiroMM (2010) The tourist experience: Exploring the relationship between tourist satisfaction and destination loyalty. Tourism58(2): 111–126.
70.
MitchellR (2006) Influences on post-visit wine purchase (and non-purchase) by New Zealand winery visitors. In: HallCMLongoAMMitchellRJohnsonG (eds) Wine Tourism around the World: Development, Management and Markets, Oxford, UK: Elsevier, pp. 95–109.
71.
MitchellRHallCM (2006) Wine tourism research: The state of play. Tourism Review International9(4): 307–332.
72.
MKF ResearchLLC (2007) The Impact of Wine, Grapes, and Grape Production on the American Economy 2007: Family Businesses Building Value, Helena, CA: MKF Research, LLC.
73.
MKF ResearchLLC (2009) The Economic Impact of Pennsylvania Wine and Grapes: Update 2007, Helena, CA: MKF Research, LLC.
74.
MottiarZQuinnD (2004) Couple dynamics in household tourism decision making: Women as the gatekeepers?Journal of Vacation Marketing10(2): 149–160.
75.
MuthenBKaplanD (1985) A comparison of some methodologies for the factor analysis of non-normal Likert variables. British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology38(2): 171–189.
76.
NovelliM (2004) Wine tourism events: Apulia, Italy. In: YeomanIRobertsonMAli-KnightJDrummondSMcMahon-BeattieU (eds) Festival and events management—an international arts and culture perspective, Oxford: Elsevier, Butterworth-Heinemann, pp. 229–345.
77.
NunnallyJCBernsteinIH (1994) Psychometric Theory, New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.
OryDTMokhtarianPL (2010) The impact of non-normality, sample size and estimation technique on goodness-of-fit measures in structural equation modeling: Evidence from ten empirical models of travel behavior. Quality & Quantity44(3): 427–445.
80.
PetersG (1997) American Winescapes: The Cultural Landscapes of America’s Wine Country, Boulder, CO: Westview Press.
81.
PikkemaatBPetersMBoksbergerP (2009) The staging of experiences in wine tourism. Journal of Hospitality Marketing & Management18(2): 237–253.
82.
PineBJ IIGilmoreJH (1998) Welcome to the experience economy. Harvard Business Review76(4): 97–105.
83.
PineBJ IIGilmoreJH (1999) The Experience Economy: Work is Theatre & Every Business a Stage, Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
84.
PineBJ IIGilmoreJH (2011) The Experience Economy: Work is Theatre & Every Business a Stage, Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.
85.
PizamAMansfeldY (1999) Consumer Behavior in Travel and Tourism, Binghamton, NY: Hawthorn Press.
86.
PullmanMEGrossMA (2003) Welcome to your experience: Where you can check out anytime you’d like, but you can never leave. Journal of Business Management9(3): 215–232.
87.
PrahaladCKRamaswamyV (2004) Co-creation experiences: The next practice in value creation. Journal of Interactive Marketing18(3): 5–14.
88.
Quadri-FelittiDFioreAM (2012) Experience economy constructs as a framework for understanding wine tourism. Journal of Vacation Marketing18(1): 3–15.
89.
SchreiberJBNoraAStageFK (2006) Reporting structural equation modeling and confirmatory factor analysis results: A review. The Journal of Educational Research99(6): 323–338.
90.
SharpleyRRobertsL (2004) Rural tourism—10 years on. The International Journal of Tourism Research6(3): 119–124.
91.
SparksB (2007) Planning a wine tourism vacation? Factors that help to predict tourist behavioural intentions. Tourism Management28(5): 1180–1192.
92.
Stonebridge Research (2010) The economic impact of grapes, grape juice and wine on the New York economy, 2008. Prepared for the New York Grape and Wine Foundation, Napa: CA, Stonebridge Research Group, LLC.
93.
TassiopoulosDNuntsuNHaydamN (2004) Wine tourists in South Africa: A demographic and psychographic study. Journal of Wine Research15(1): 51–63.
94.
TaylorRGWoodallSWandschneiderP (2004) The demand for wine tourism in Canyon County, Idaho. International Food & Agribusiness Management Review7(4): 58–75.
95.
TelferDJ (2000) The Northeast wine route: Wine tourism in Ontario, Canada and New York State. In: HallCMLongoAMMitchellRJohnsonG (eds) Wine Tourism around the World: Development, Management and Markets, Oxford, UK: Elsevier, pp. 253–271.
96.
TungVWSRichieJRB (2011) Exploring the essence of memorable tourism experiences. Annals of Tourism Research48(4): 1367–1386.
97.
UrryJ (1995) Consuming Places, London and New York: Routledge.
98.
WargenauACheD (2006) Wine tourism development and marketing strategies in Southwest Michigan. International Journal of Wine Marketing18(1): 45–60.
99.
WeaverPAMcClearyKWJihoH (2009) Identifying leisure travel market segments based on preference for novelty. Journal of Travel & Tourism Marketing26(5/6): 568–584.
100.
WilkinsH (2011) Souvenirs: What and why we buy. Journal of Travel Research50(3): 239–247.
101.
WilliamsA (2006) Tourism and hospitality marketing: Fantasy, feeling and fun. International Journal of Contemporary Hospitality Management18(6): 482–495.
102.
WilliamsPW (2001) Positioning wine tourism destinations: An image analysis. International Journal of Wine Marketing13(3): 42–58.
103.
WilliamsPWKellyJ (2001) Cultural wine tourists: Product development considerations for British Columbia’s resident wine tourism market. International Journal of Wine Marketing13(3): 59–76.
104.
WilliamsJMacKinnonDP (2008) Resampling and distribution of the product methods for testing indirect effects in complex models. Structural Equation Modeling15(1): 23–51.
105.
WoodsideAGCaldwellMAlbers-MillerN (2004) Broadening the study of tourism: Introduction to the special issue on the consumer psychology of travel/tourism behavior. Journal of Travel and Tourism Marketing17(1): 1–7.
106.
YoonYUysalM (2005) An examination of the effects of motivation and satisfaction on destination loyalty: A structural model. Tourism Management26(1): 45–56.
107.
YuanJJangS (2008) The effects of quality and satisfaction on awareness and behavioral intentions: Exploring the role of a wine festival. Journal of Travel Research46(3): 279–288.
