Although criminologists in the US and Europe continue to explore issues of
immigration, race, and ethnicity in the context of crime, they have yet to examine
the detention of asylum seekers. Still, this is a social phenomenon that requires
serious consideration since in many instances such policies and practices violate
international standards for the protection of refugees. This work takes a critical
look at the detention of persons fleeing persecution by situating it an expanding
culture of control stoked by the criminology of the other. The article
offers evidence of a steady increase in the reliance on detention of asylum seekers
in the US, UK, France, Germany, and Italy. Indications of a conservative shift in
criminological thought affecting crime—and asylum—policy are
addressed alongside concerns for human rights in a post-September 11 world.
American Civil Liberties Union
(1998) In Search of Asylum. Available at:
http://www.aclu.org (accessed: 5 May)
2.
Amnesty International
. (2003) ‘Amnesty International condemns
Ashcroft’s ruling to indefinitely detain non-U.S. citizens, including
asylum-seekers’. Press Release: 28 April.
3.
Anafé (Association Nationale d’Assistance aux
Fronti`eres pour les Etrangers) (2003a, March) Violences polici`eres en zone
d’attente. Paris: Anafé.
4.
Anafé (Association Nationale d’Assistance aux
Fronti`eres pour les Etrangers) (2003b, March) Zone d’attente: 10 ans
apr`es, les difficultés persistent. Paris: Anafé.
5.
Anderson, C.
(2003) ‘Ashcroft rules on immigrants
detention’.
Associated Press
4 April: EV-12.
6.
Angel-Ajani, A.
(2003)
‘A Question of Races?’
, Punishment & Society5(4):
433-448
.
7.
Asylum Protection News 21 (2003)
‘Court TV film, inspired by Lawyers Committee case, shines a
light on U.S. detention of asylum seekers’
.
EV-1-EV-6
.
8.
Asylum Protection News 22 (2004)
‘Tibetan nun detained in Virginia jail denied parole again’
.
EV-1-EV-4
.
9.
Austin, J.
,
M. Bruce
,
L. Carroll
,
P. McCall
and
S. Richards
(2003)
‘The Use of Incarceration in the United States’
, Critical Criminology: An International Journal10(1):
17-41
.
10.
Baker, E.
(1996)
‘From “Making Bad People Worse” to
“Prison Works”: Sentencing Policy in England and Wales
in the 1990s’
, Criminal Law Forum7(3):
639-671
.
11.
Bauman, Z.
(1998) Globalization: The Human Consequences.
Cambridge:Polity Press
.
12.
Best, J.
(1999) Random Violence: How We Talk about New Crimes and New
Victims.
Berkeley, CA: University of California Press
.
13.
Blomberg, T.
and
S. Cohen
(2003) Punishment and Social Control, 2nd
Edition.
New York: de Gruyter
.
14.
Bottoms, A.
(1995) ‘The Philosophy and Politics of
Punishment and Sentencing’, in
C. Clarkson
and
R. Morgan
(eds) The Politics of Sentencing Reform, pp.
88-102.
Oxford: Clarendon Press
.
15.
Bottoms, A.
and
R. Preston
(1983) The Coming Penal Crisis.
Edinburgh: Scottish Academic Press
.
16.
Bralo, Z. (1998) ‘(Un)cool Britannia: Discourse Analysis of
Construction of Refugees in the UK Press’.Unpublished Master’s
thesis, Department of Social Psychology, London School of Economics and Political Science.
17.
Calavita, K.
(2003)
‘A “Reserve Army of Delinquents”: The
Criminalization and Economic Punishment of Immigrants in Spain’
, Punishment & Society5(4):
399-414
.
18.
Calavita, K.
(2005) Immigrants at the Margins: Law, Race and Exclusion in
Southern Europe.
Cambridge: Cambridge University Press
.
19.
Chambliss, W.
(1999) Power, Politics, and Crime.
Boulder, CO: Westview
.
20.
Chivigny, P.
(2003)
‘The Populism of Rear: Politics of Crime in the Americas’
, Punishment & Society5(1):
77-96
.
21.
Christie, N.
(1986) Crime Control as Industry.
New York: Routledge
.
22.
Cohen, R.
(1994) Frontiers of Identity: The British and the
Others.
London: Longman
.
23.
Cohen, S.
(1985) Visions of Social Control.
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
24.
Cohen, S.
(2001) States of Denial: Knowing about Atrocities and
Suffering.
Cambridge: Polity
.
25.
Cohen, S.
(2002) Folk Devils and Moral Panics: The Creation of the Mods
and Rockers (3rd edition).
London: Routledge
.
26.
Cole, D.
(2003) Enemy Aliens: Double Standards and Constitutional
Freedoms in the War on Terror.
New York: The New Press
.
27.
Cole, D.
and
J. Dempsey
(2002) Terrorism and the Constitution: Sacrificing Civil
Liberties in the Name of National Security.
New York: Free Press
.
28.
Cowell, A.
(2004)
‘Britain joins others in Europe in limiting immigrant workers’
, New York Times, 24 February:
A8
.
29.
De Giorgi, A.
(2005)
‘Europe: New Penal State or New Citizenship?’
, European Society of Criminology Annual Congress,
Cracow, Poland, 31 August- 3 September.
30.
Douglas, M.
(1992) Risk and Blame: Essays in Cultural Theory.
London: Routledge
.
31.
Dunbar, I.
and
A. Langdon
(1998) Tough Justice: Sentencing and Penal Policies in the
1990s.
London: Blackstone
.
32.
Fekete, L.
(2002) Racism: The Hidden Cost of September 11th.
London: Institute of Race Relations
.
33.
Garland, D.
(2001) The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in
Contemporary Society.
Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press
.
34.
Garland, D.
(2002) Mass Imprisonment: Social Causes and
Consequences.
London: Sage Publications
.
35.
General Accounting Office
(2003) Better Management Oversight and Internal Controls
Needed to Ensure Accuracy of Terrorism-related Statistics.
Washington, DC: General Accounting Office
.
36.
Geniesse, P.
(2003)
‘Prisoners with No Crime’
, Sojourners MagazineNov.- Dec.:
EV-1-EV-2
.
37.
Glassner, B.
(1999) The Culture of Fear: Why Americans are Afraid of the
Wrong Things.
New York: Basic Books
.
38.
Greenberg, D.
(2002)
‘Striking Out in Democracy’
, Punishment & Society4(2):
237-252
.
39.
Guebre-Christos, G.
(2002)
‘Letter from UNHCR regional representative Guenet Guebre-Christos
to attorney Rebecca Sharples of the Florida Immigrant Advocacy Center (15 April)’
, reproduced in 79 Interpreter Releases630: 29 April 2002.
40.
Hale, C.
(1996)
‘Fear of Crime: A Review of the Literature’
, International Review of Victimology4:
79-150
.
41.
Heath, T.
and
R. Hill
(2002) Asylum Statistics United Kingdom 2001.
London: RDSO
.
42.
Home Office
(1990) Crime, Justice and Protecting the Public.
London: HMSO
.
43.
Horowitz, J.
(2004)
‘Italy bangs the door shut on castaways from Africa’
, New York Times, 22 July:
A4
.
44.
Human Rights Watch
(2002)
‘Presumption of Guilt: Human Rights Abuses of Post-September 11 Detainees’
, Human Rights Watch14(4) August.
45.
Jackson, A.
(2003)
‘The Detention of Asylum Seekers in the UK: Bail for Immigration Detainees’
, Feminist Review73:
118-122
46.
Joly, D.
,
L. Kelly
and
C. Nettleton
(1997) Refugees in Europe: The Hostile New Agenda.
London: Minorities Rights Group International
.
47.
Jones, B.
(2003)
‘Asylum seeker feels sting of post-9/11 immigration laws: A
“culture of no” casualty’
, New York Newsday, 3 November:
EV-1-EV-4
.
48.
Kanstroom, D.
(2000)
‘Deportation, Social Control, and Punishment: Some Thoughts About
Why Hard Laws Make Bad Cases’
, Harvard Law Review113:
1890-1935
.
49.
Kaye, R.
(1998) ‘Redefining Refugee: The UK Media
Portrayal of Asylum Seekers’, in
K. Koser
and
H. Lutz
(eds) The New Migration in Europe: Social Constructions and Social
Realities, pp. 163-182.
London: Macmillan Press
.
50.
Keller, A.
(2003) From Persecution to Prison: The Health Consequences of
Detention for Asylum Seekers.
New York: Physicians for Human Rights
.
51.
Kommer, M.
(1994)
‘Punitiveness in Europe—A Comparison’
, European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research2(1):
29-43
.
52.
Kommer, M.
(2004)
‘Punitiveness in Europe Revisited’
, Criminology in Europe3(1):
8-12
.
53.
Koser, K.
and
H. Lutz
(1998) The New Migration in Europe: Social Constructions and
Social Realities.
London: Macmillan Press
.
54.
Lawyers Committee for Human Rights
(2003)
‘Operation Liberty Shield quietly terminated: Future of detained
asylum seekers still unclear’
, Asylum Protection News15 (15 May):
1-4
.
55.
Lawyers Committee for Human Rights
(2004) In Liberty’s Shadow: U.S. Detention of
Asylum Seekers in the Era of Homeland Security.
New York: Lawyers Committee for Human Rights
.
56.
Lea, J.
(2002) Crime and Modernity.
London: Sage Publications
.
57.
Mailman, S.
and
S. Yale-Loehr
(2003)
‘Detaining and Criminalizing Asylum Seekers’
, New York Law Journal 28 April:
EV-1-EV-9
.
58.
Malloch, M.S.
and
E. Stanley
(2005)
‘The Detention of Asylum Seekers in the UK: Representing Risk,
Managing the Dangerous’
, Punishment & Society7:
53-71
.
59.
Medici Senza Frontiere (2004, January) ‘Rapporto sui Centri di
Permanenza Temporanea e Assistenza’. Available at:
http://www.msf.it/msfinforma/dossier/missione_italia/CPT_FINALE.pdf
(accessed: 20 January)
60.
Melossi, D.
(1998) ‘Remarks on Social Control, State
Sovereignty and Citizenship in the New Europe’, in
V. Ruggiero
,
N. South
and
I. Taylor
(eds) The New European Criminology. Crime and Social Order in
Europe, pp. 52-63.
London: Routledge
.
61.
Melossi, D.
(2003)
‘In a Peaceful Life: Migration and the Crime of Modernity in Europe/Italy’
, Punishment & Society5(4):
371-398
.
62.
New York Times (2004)
‘Blair reconsiders stance on Union immigration’
, 5 April:
A9
.
63.
New York Times (2004)
‘Hiding the refugee problem offshore’
, 20 October:
A26
.
64.
Oxfam
(2001) Asylum: The Truth behind the Headlines.
London: Oxfam
.
65.
Pratt, J.
(2000) ‘Dangerousness and Modern
Society’, in
M. Brown
and
J. Pratt
(eds) Dangerous Offenders: Punishment and Social Order, pp.
35-48.
London: Routledge
.
66.
Ratner, M.
(2003) ‘Making Us Less Free: War on Terrorism or
War on Liberty?’, in
S. Aronowitz
and
H. Gautney
(eds) Implicating Empire: Globalization & Resistance in the 21st
Century World Order, pp. 31-46.
New York: Basic Books
.
67.
Refaie, E.
(2001)
‘Metaphors we Discriminate By: Naturalized Themes in Austrian
Newspaper Articles about Asylum Seekers’
, Journal of Socio-linguistics5(3):
352-371
.
68.
Robinson, V.
(2003) Spreading the ‘Burden?’London: Polity Press
.
69.
Sassen, S.
(1999) Guests and Aliens.
New York. The New Press
.
70.
Schmid, E.
(2003) A Permanent State of Terror?London: Campaign Against Criminalising
Communities in Association with Index on Censorship
.
71.
Schuster, L.
(2000)
‘A Comparison of Asylum Policy in Seven European States’
, Journal of Refugee Studies13(1):
118-132
.
72.
Schuster, L.
(2002)
‘Asylum and the Lessons of History: An Historical Perspective’
, Race & Class44(2):
40-56
.
73.
Schuster, L.
(2003a) The Use and Abuse of Political Asylum in Britain and
Germany.
London: Frank Cass
.
74.
Schuster, L.
(2003b)
‘Asylum Seekers: Sangatte and the Channel Tunnel’
, Parliamentary Affairs56(3):
506-522
.
75.
Schuster, L.
(2003c)
‘Sangatte: Smoke and Mirrors’
, Global Dialogue4(4):
57-68
.
76.
Simon, J.
(1998)
‘Refugees in a Carceral Age: The Rebirth of Immigration Prisons
in the United States’
, Public Culture10(3):
577-607
.
77.
Smith, D.
(2004)
‘Editorial: Criminology and the Wider Europe’
, European Journal of Criminology1(1):
5-15
.
78.
Sparks, R.
,
A. Bottoms
and
W. Hay
(1996) Prisons and the Problem of Order.
Oxford: Clarendon Press
.
79.
Stenson, K.
and
R. Sullivan
(2000) Crime, Risk, and Justice: The Politics of Crime
Control in Liberal Democracies.
Devon: Willan
.
80.
Tournier, P.V.
(2000)
‘The Prisons of Europe, Prison Population Inflation and Prison Overcrowding’
, Penal Issues12(2):
6-9
.
81.
Tonry, M.
(2004) Thinking about Crime: Sense and Sensibility in
American Culture.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
82.
Travis, A.
(2003)
‘Asylum seeker dispersal is “a waste of
money”: Policy driven by moral panic and ineffective, says study,
arguing that a considered approach would calm fears and build communities’
. Guardian, 30 July:
7
.
83.
Tulsky, F.
(2000)
‘Asylum seekers face tougher U.S. laws, attitudes’
. San Jose Mercury News, 10 December:
EV-1-EV-9
.
84.
United Nations
(2002) Bail for Immigration Detainees. Submission to
the United Nations Working Group on Arbitrary Detention Immigration Detention in the
United Kingdom, September.
85.
Useem, B.
,
R. Liedka
and
A. Piehl
(2003)
‘Popular Support for the Prison Build-up’
, Punishment & Society5(1):
5-32
.
86.
Wacquant, L.
(1999)
‘Suitable Enemies, Foreigners and Immigrants in the Prisons of Europe’
, Punishment & Society1(2):
215-222
.
87.
Wacquant, L.
(2001)
‘The Penalization of Poverty and the Rise of Neo-Liberalism’
, European Journal on Criminal Policy and Research9(4):
401-412
.
88.
Weber, L.
(2002)
‘The Detention of Asylum Seekers: 20 Reasons Why Criminologists
Should Care’
, Current Issues in Criminal Justice14(1):
9-30
.
89.
Welch, M.
(2002) Detained: Immigration Laws and the Expanding I.N.S.
Jail Complex.
Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press
.
90.
Welch, M.
(2003)
‘Ironies of Social Control and the Criminalization of Immigrants’
, Crime, Law & Social Change: An International Journal39:
319-337
.
91.
Welch, M.
(2004)
‘Quiet Constructions in the War on Terror: Subjecting Asylum
Seekers to Unnecessary Detention’
, Social Justice: A Journal of Crime, Conflict & World Order31(1-2):
113-129
.
92.
Welch, M.
(2005a) ‘Immigration Lockdown Before and After
9/11: Ethnic Constructions and Their Consequences’, in
M. Bosworth
and
J. Flavin
(eds) From Slavery to Globalization: How Race and Gender Shape
Punishment in America.
New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press
.
93.
Welch, M.
(2005b) Ironies of Imprisonment.
Thousand Oaks, CA and London: Sage Publications
.
94.
Welch, M.
(2006) Scapegoats of September 11th: Hate Crimes and State
Crimes in the War on Terror.
New Brunswick, NJ: Rutgers University Press
.
95.
Welch, M.
and
L. Schuster
(2005, forthcoming)
‘Detention of Asylum Seekers in the UK and US: Deciphering Noisy
and Quiet Constructions’
, Punishment & Society7(4):
397-417
.
96.
Windlesham, L.
(1996) Responses to Crime, Vol. 3: Legislating with the
Tide.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
97.
Young, J.
(1999) The Exclusive Society.
London: Sage Publications
.
98.
Young, J.
(2003a)
‘To These Wet and Windy Shores: Recent Immigration Policy in the UK’
, Punishment & Society5(4):
449-462
.
99.
Young, J.
(2003b)
‘In Praise of Dangerous Thoughts’
, Punishment & Society5(1):
97-108
.
