Antiseptics: a forgotten weapon in the control of antibiotic resistant bacteria in hospital and community settings?

Abstract

The aim of this study was to ascertain the activity of a selection of widely-used antiseptic/disinfectant agents against antibiotic resistant bacteria and strains isolated from patients infected with clinically significant species. Four antiseptic agents (Dettol, Dettol Hospital Concentrate, Savlon and Betadine) were tested against Staphylococcus aureus, Methicillin Resistant S. aureus (MRSA), Enterococcus hirae, Vancomicin Resistant Enterococcus sp (VRE), Escherichia coli and E. coli 0157. The antiseptics were applied at recommended use dilutions and at a half and a quarter of those concentrations in a standard suspension test (EST). Organic material was added to mimic the presence of blood, protein and other such contaminants to be found in the clinical situation. All antiseptics tested were effective against both the antibiotic sensitive and antibiotic resistant strains of S. aureus and E. hirae as well as normal and clinical strains of E. coli at recommended concentrations. All but Betadine were also effective against the antibiotic resistant bacteria at a half and a quarter of normal concentration. The iodine containing antiseptic, however, failed the test against MRSA at a half normal concentration and showed virtually no activity against MRSA at a quarter normal concentration.

Keywords

Antibiotic resistance antiseptic activity community hospital acquired infections infection control.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Anon (1994). Chemical disinfection and antisepsis — quantitative suspension test for the evaluation of bacterial activity of chemical disinfectants and antiseptics use in food, industrial and institutional areas — test method and requirements. prEN 1276 London, British Standards Institute

Anon (1996). The state of world health. In: The World Health Report 1996, pp 1-62 Geneva: World Health Organization

Anon (1997). http://www.open.gov.uk/cdsc/site_fr6.htm

Emmerson A.M. (1997). Infection control in the hospital and community settings. Res Clin Forums; 19, 19-25

Fraise A.P. (1997). Antibiotic resistance and inappropriate antibiotic use. Res Clin Forums ; 19, 27-33

Gibson S A W (1997). The role of antiseptics. Res Clin Forums; 19, 49-55

Goldenheim P.D. (1993). In vitro efficacy of povidone-iodine solution and cream against methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus. Postgraduate Med J; 69, S62-5

Irizarry I. , Merlin T. , Rupp J. and Griffith J. (1996). Reduced susceptibility of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus to cetylpyridinium chloride and chlorhexidine. Chemotherapy; 42, 248-52

Jones S.G. and Fraise A.P. (1997). Coping with nosocomial infection: a non-antibiotic approach. Br J Hospital Med; 58, 217-20

10.

Koyono M. , Omura T. , Fugimori H. and Pan Hou H. (1995). Organomercurial resistance determinants in Pseudomonas K-62 are present on two plasmids. Arch Microbiol; 163, 242-7

11.

O'Connor D.O. and Rubino J.R. (1991). Phenolic compounds. In: Disinfection, sterilisation and Preservation, pp 204-224 ( SS Block , ed). London: Lea and Febiger

12.

Stickler D.J. and King J.B. (1992). Bacterial sensitivity and resistance. In: Principles and Practice of Disinfection, Preservation and Sterilisation, pp 211-214 ( AD Russell , WG Hugo and GAJ Ayliffe , eds). Oxford: Black-well Scientific Publications

13.

Yamamoto T. , Tamura Y. and Yokota T. (1988). Antiseptic and antibiotic resistance plasmid in Staphylococcus aureus that possesses the ability to confer chlorhexidine and acrinol resistance. Antimicrobial Agents and Chemotherapy ; 32, 932-5