A comparative study of generalised obesity and anatomical distribution of subcutaneous fat in adult White and Pakistani migrant males in Peterborough

Abstract

Obesity can be defined in two main ways - generalised obesity (measured as Body Mass Index (BMI)) and anatomical distribution of adiposity. A comparative study of generalised obesity (body mass index) and the anatomical distribution of subcutaneous fat in adult White and Pakistani migrant males was carried out in Peterborough. No signifi cant difference in the prevalence of obesity as measured by the BMI was observed between Whites and Pakistani migrants. The mean BMI values were similar in both ethnic groups. However, Pakistanis had significantly more truncal fat com pared with Whites whereas the latter group had more upper extremity fat compared with the former. No significant difference was observed in the amount of fat deposited on the lower extremities between the two ethnic groups. The Pakista nis also had significantly more total (sum of all skinfolds) subcutaneous fat compared with Whites.

These preliminary results clearly indicate that there is a tendency for accumulation of truncal adiposity in Asians of Pakistani origin compared with Whites irrespective of the level of generalised (BMI) obesity.

The health implications of body fat patterning on non-insulin-dependent diabetes mellitus (NIDDM) and coronary heart disease (CHD) are well known. It is possible that the pattern of fat distribution observed in migrant Pakistani males in this study exists in other migrant groups originating from the Indian subcontinent. This pronounced truncal distribu tion of body fat could be one of the risk factors predisposing migrant Asians in the UK to develop NIDDM and CHD irrespective of their BMI.

Future epidemiological studies should lay more emphasis on morphological fat patterning rather than BMI in Asian migrants in the UK.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bose K. ( 1992). Non-Insulin-Dependent (Type II). Diabetes Mellitus and Obesity in Asians in UK — Scope for Future Studies J Roy Soc Hlth; 112, 291-293

Cruickshank J.K. and Beevers D.G. (1989). Ethnic Factors in Health and Disease. London: Butterworth and Company

Dowse G.K. , Zimmet P.Z. , Gareeboo H. , Alberti K G M M , Tuomilehto J. , Finch C.F. , Chitson P. and Tulsidas H. (1991). Abdominal Obesity and Physical Inactivity as Risk Factors for NIDDM and Impaired Glucose Tolerance in Indians, Creole and Chinese Mauritians. Diabetes Care; 14, 271-282

Ducimetiere P. , Richard J. and Cambien F. (1986). The pattern of subcutaneous fat distribution in middle-aged men and the risk of coronary heart disease: The Paris Prospective Study Inter J of Obesity; 10, 229-240

Garrow J.S. (1988). Obesity and Related Diseases Edinburgh: Churchill Livingstone

Knight T. , Smith Z. , Lockton J.A. , Sahota P. , Bedford A. , Toop M. , Kernohan E. and Baker M.R. (1993). Ethnic differences in risk markers for heart disease in Bradford and implications for preventive strategies J of Epid and Comm Hlth; 47, 89-95

Lohman T.G. , Roche A.F. and Martorell R. (1988). Anthropometric Standardized Reference Manual. Champaign. Illinois: Human Kinetics Books

McKeigue P.M. , Shah B. and Marmot M.G. (1991). Relation of central obesity and insulin resistance with high diabetes prevalence and cardiovascular risk in South Asians The Lancet; 337, 382-386

Mueller W.H. , Joos S.K. , Hanis C.L. , Zavaleta A.N. , Eichner J. and Schull W. (1984). The Diabetes Alert Study: growth, fatness and fat patterning, Adolescence through adulthood in Mexican Americans Amer J of Phy Anthropology; 64, 389-399

10.

Mueller W.H. and Reid R.M. (1979). A multivariate analysis of fatness and relative fat patterning. Amer J of Phy Anthropology; 50, 199-208

11.

Newell-Morris L.L. , Treder R.P. , Shuman W.P. and Fujimoto W.Y. (1989). Fatness, fat distribution and glucose toler

12.

ance in second-generation Japanese-American (Nisei) men. Amer J of Clinical Nutr; 50, 9-18

13.

OFFICE of the POPULATION CENSUSES and SURVEYS, UK (1980). Classification of Occupations and Coding Index . London: HMSO

14.

Office of the Population and CENSUSES and SURVEYS, UK (1991). H Form for Private Households London: HMSO

15.

Ohlson L.O. , Larsson B. , Svardsudd K. , Welin L. , Eriksson H. , Wilhelmsem L. , Bjorntorp P. and Tibblin

16.

G. (1985). The influence of body fat distribution on the incidence of diabetes mellitus . Diabetes; 34, 1055-1058

17.

Simmons D. , Williams D R R and Powell M.J. (1989). Prevalence of diabetes in a predominantly Asian community - preliminary findings of the Coventry Diabetes Study. BMJ; 298, 18—21

18.

Szathmary E J E and Holt N. (1983). Hyperglycaemia in Dogrib Indians of the Northwest Territories. Canada: association with age and centripetal distribution of body fat. Human Biology; 55, 493-515

19.

Vague J. (1956). The degree of masculine differentiation of obesities: a factor determining predisposition to diabetes, atherosclerosis, gout and uric calculous disease Amer J of Clinical Nutr; 4, 20-34

20.

Van GAAL L. , Rillaerts E. , Creten W. and D I. (1988). Relationship of Body Fat Distribution Pattern to Atherogenic Risk Factors in NIDDM. Preliminary Results. Diabetes Care; 11, 103-106