Epidemiologically, there are numerous perplexing features, insufficiently appreciated, in the occurrences of degenerative diseases, and in the roles of their risk factors. This applies particularly to dental caries, the commonest of all diseases, and the risk factor, sugar intake. In some contexts, caries scores are much lower, or are much higher, than expected. Moreover, even in contexts where outwardly the same risk factors are widespread, ranges of scores are much wider than would be expected. In all contexts, among groups and more especially among individuals, the association of caries experience and dietary intakes, particularly that of sugar intake, is limited. Accordingly, caution must be exercised in the over-blaming of sugar and in the overclaiming of benefits to be derived from reducing intake.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Attwood D., Salapata J. & Blinkhorn A.S. (1990). Comparison of the dental health of 12-year-old school children living in Athens and GlasgowInternat Dent J.40, 117-121
2.
Beck D.J. (1967). Evaluation of dental care for children in New Zealand and AustraliaNew Zealand Dent J.63, 201-211
3.
Bille J. (1980). Dental caries in a group of 20-year-olds after previous participation in public child dental health services in Copenhagen, DenmarkCommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol8, 27-32
4.
Blicks C.S., Arvidsson S. & Holm A.K. (1985). Dental health, dental care and dietary habits in children in different parts of SwedenActa Odont Scand43, 59-67
5.
Bradnock G., Marchment M.D. & Anderson R.J. (1984). Social background, fluoridation and caries experience in a 5-year-old population in the West MidlandsBr Dent J.156, 127-131
6.
Bransby E.R. & Knowles E.M. (1949). A comparison of the effects of enemy occupation and post-war conditions on the incidence of dental caries in children in the Channel Islands in relation to diet and food suppliesBr Dent J. 87, 236-243
7.
Brown R.H. (1982). Evidence of decrease in the prevalence of dental caries in New ZealandJ Dent Res61, 1327-1330
8.
Burton V.J., Rob M.I. & Lawson J.S.( 1984). Changes in the caries experience of 12-year-old Sydney school-children between 1963 and 1982Med J. Aust140,405-407
9.
Coma Report (1990). Dietary Sugars and Human Disease, Conclusion, Department of Health, Report on Health and Social Subjects No 37 London, Her Majesty's Stationery Office
10.
Cutress T.W., Powell R.N. & Ball M.E. (1982). Differing profiles of periodontal disease in 2 similar South Pacific Island populations, Community Dent Oral Epidemiol10, 193-203
11.
Deitch R. (1985). Commentary from Westminster: Another ferocious but unavailing stand against fluoridationLanceti, 231
12.
Dummer P M H, Oliver S.J., Hicks R., Kinddon A., Addy M. & Shaw W.C. (1990). Factors influencing the initiation of carious lesions in specific tooth surfaces over a 4-year period in children between the ages of 11-12 years and 15-16 yearsJ Dent18, 190-197
13.
Frencken J E F M, Truin G.J., Konig K.G., Ruiken R M H M & Elvers H J W (1986). Prevalence of caries, plaque and gingivitis in an urban and rural Tanzanian child populationCommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol14,161-164
14.
Frencken J.E., Kalsbeek H. & Verrips G.H. (1990). Has the decline in dental caries been halted? Changes in caries prevalence amongst 6- and 12-year-old children in Friesland, 1973-1988Internat Dent J.40, 225-230
15.
French A.D., Carmichael C.L., Furness J.A. & Rugg-Gunn A.J. (1984). The relationship between social class and dental health in 5-year-old children in the North and South of EnglandBr Dent J.156, 83-86
16.
Garn S.M., Cole P.E., Solomon M.A., & Schaefer A.E. (1981). Relationships between sugar foods and the DMFT in 1968-1970Ecol Food Nutr9, 135-138
17.
Hargreaves J.A., Thompson G.W., Main P.A. et al (1980). Sugar intake and dental caries of Canadian childrenCaries Res14, 181
18.
Hargreaves J.A., Thompson G.W., & Wagg B.J. (1983). Changes in caries prevalence of Isle of Lewis children between 1971 and 1981Caries Res17, 554-559
19.
Heidmann J. & Poulsen S. (1986). Forecasting future caries prevalence from data in a national recording systemCaries Res20, 543-547
20.
Household Food Consumption And Expenditure ( 1985). Annual Report of the National Food Survey CommitteeLondon, Her Majesty's Stationery Office
21.
King J.D. (1940). Dental disease in the Island of Lewis Med Res Coun Spec Rep Ser No 241London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office
22.
Lachapelle-Harvey D. & Sevigny J. (1985). Multiple regression analysis of dental status and related food behaviour of French Canadian adolescentsCommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol13, 226-229
23.
LIVING BIBLE (1971a). Canticles4, 2
24.
LIVING BIBLE (1971b). Ecclesiastes12,4
25.
Mandel D. (1983). Caries through the ages: A worm's eye viewJ. Dent Res62, 926-929
26.
Marthaler T. (1983). Explanations for changing patterns o disease in the Western world Cariology Today: Int CongZurich P1 13-23, Basel: Karger
27.
Medcalf G.W. & O'Grady M J. (1983). The dental healtl of children eight and fifteen years of age living in Bunbury Western AustraliaAust Dent J.28, 162-165
28.
Mintz S W ed (1985). Sweetness and Power: The Place of Suga in Modern HistoryNew York : Viking Elizabeth Sifton Books p 67
29.
Naylor M.N. (1985) Possible factors underlying the decline in caries prevalence, J Roy Soc Med78, 23-24
30.
Powell R.N. (1983). Geographic effects on dental carie prevalence and tooth loss in Australia CommunityDent Ora Epidemiol 11, 242-245
31.
Roder D. M (1971). The dental health and habits of South Australian children from different socio-economic environmentAust Dent J. 16, 34-40
32.
Rugg-Gunn A.J., Hackett A.F., Appleton D.R.Jenkins G.N. & Eastoe J.E. (1984). Relationship betweet dietary habits and caries increment assessed over 2 years in 405 English adolescent school children , Arch Oral Biol29, 982-992
33.
Rugg-Gunn A.J. & Murray J.J. (1983). The role of suga in the aetiology of dental caries I. Sugar and the antiquity of carieJ Dent11, 190-199
34.
Sibbison J.B. (1990). USA: More about fluoride, Lancet336, 737Spencer A.J. (1986). Trends in dental caries: Australian adolescents , Aust Dent J.31, 262-267
35.
Steyn N.P. & Albertse E C. (1987). Sucrose consumption and dental caries in twelve year-old children residing in Cape Town, J Dent Ass S. Afr42, 43-49
36.
Sognnaes E.R. (1948). Analysis of war-time reduction o dental caries in European children, Am J Dis Child75, 792-822
37.
Sundin B., Birkhed D. & Granath L. (1983). Is there no a strong relationship nowadays between caries and consumption of sweets?Swed Dent J. 7, 103-108
38.
Takeuchi D D S (1961). Epidemiological study on relation between dental caries in Japanese children, before, during and after World War IIInternat Dent J.11, 443-457
39.
Toverud G. (1949). Dental caries in Norwegian children during and after the last world-war, A preliminary reportProc Roy Soc Med42, 249-259
40.
Walker A R P, Dison E., Duvenhage A. et al (1981) Dental caries in South African black and white school pupils in relation to sugar intake and snack habits, Community Dent Ora Epidemiol9, 37-43
41.
Walker A R P, Dison E., Walker B.F. & Segal A.H. (1982). Contrasting patterns of caries profile and dental treatmen in pupils of 16-18 years in South African ethnic groupsCommunity Dent Oral Epidemiol10, 69-7 3
42.
Walker A R P, Dison E., Walker B.F. et al (1983). Low denta caries in Jewish adolescent school pupils in South Africa, J Den Child May/June, 210-224
43.
Walker A R P (1984). Reply to letter by Hackett and Rugg GunnAm J Clin Nutr39, 493-494
44.
Walker A R P & Cleaton Jones P.E. (1989). Sugar intake and dental caries - where do we stand? J Dent Child Jan/Feb, 30-36
45.
Walker Arp, Disone, Walker BF et al (1991). Pattern of dental caries in rural elderly black pensioners, S Afr J Epidemio Infect in press
46.
Walker, A.R.P. & Walker B.F. (1991) Sugar intakes in rura and urban black adolescents , S Afr J Clin Nutr in press
47.
Winter G.B. (1990). Epidemiology of dental cariesArch Ora Biol35, 1S-7S
