Review: The impact of art,design and environment in mental healthcare: a systematic review of the literature

Abstract

Aims: There has been a burgeoning interest in arts and the environment in healthcare. While research has been undertaken on the clinical impact of disciplines, relatively little research has studied the impact of broader arts for health interventions. This paper reports findings from a systematic review of the arts for health literature, encompassing research on the impact of visual art, design and the environment on the well-being of patients and staff in mental healthcare settings.

Methods: A systematic review of over 600 papers published between 1985 and 2005 on the impact of arts, design and environments in mental healthcare was undertaken. The review includes a discussion of contextual and policy literature, as well as 19 reports of quantitative and qualitative studies that met our inclusion criteria.

Results: The largest number of studies focused on the aspects of art, design and environment that were relevant to mental healthcare. These studies suggest that this can affect health, including physiological, psychological, clinical and behavioural effects. Exposure to stressful visual and aural environments may reduce levels of stress and enhance recovery. Architectural design consideration is important in mental health settings, especially for patients with conditions such as dementia that can make wayfinding difficult. Exposure to art in healthcare environments has been found to reduce anxiety and depression. Environment features have also been found to affect staff, and improvements in visual and acoustic conditions may reduce risks of errors in some care settings. Qualitative studies provide insights into factors affecting the impact of arts, including issues of power and control, perceptions and influence of key stakeholders, and user participation. A key issue to emerge from this study is that arts interventions do not necessarily address the lack of control exercised by patients in healthcare environments.

Conclusions: While there is extensive literature on the impact of design, environment and the arts on health, there is still a need for further research that addresses methodological challenges of evaluating complex interventions. Our review found evidence that environmental enhancements can have a positive impact on health and well-being of staff and patients in mental healthcare. Arts, when considered within this framework of evidence-based design, can also contribute to well-being, offering reassurance and creating identity in healthcare settings. Further research is needed in this area, as well as research that explores the contribution of other models of art that do not fit within the framework of `evidence-based design'. Finally, responses to the arts are contingent on a number of complex social and political factors; further understanding of these is needed in order to inform future research and evaluation of the arts in healthcare.

Keywords

arts design environment mental health systematic review

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ruddy R. , Milnes D. Art therapy for schizophrenia or schizophrenia-like illnesses. The Cochrane Library. Oxford, 2005 (4)

Staricoff RL Arts in health: a review of the medical literature, 2004

Hogan S. Healing arts: the history of art therapy. London; Philadelphia: Jessica Kingsley Publishers Ltd, 2001

Gorman JM The new psychiatry: The essential guide to state-of-the-art therapy, medication, and emotional health, 1996

MacLennan BW , Saul S , Weiner MB , editors. Group psychotherapies for the elderly, 1988

Wallace J. , Yorgin PD , Carolan J. , Moore H. , Sanchez J. , Belson A. , et al. The use of art therapy to detect depression and post-traumatic stress disorder in pediatric and young adult renal transplant recipients. Pediatric Transplantation 2004; 8(1): 52—59

Heine D. , Steiner M. Standardised paintings as a proposed adjunct instrument for longitudinal monitoring of mood states: A preliminary note. Occupational Therapy in Mental Health 1986; 6(3): 31—37

Francis D. , Kaiser D. , Deaver SP Representations of attachment security in the bird's nest drawings of clients with substance abuse disorders. Art Therapy 2003; 20(3): 125—137

Dickman SB , Dunn JE , Wolf AW The use of art therapy as a predictor of relapse in chemical dependency treatment . Art Therapy 1996; 13(4): 232—237

10.

Coultier AC What is the effect of the hospital environment on perceptions of the organisation? A case study of two acute NHS trusts. Unpublished MSc dissertation, University of Bristol, Department of Management 2005

11.

Day K. , Carreon D. , Stump C. The therapeutic design of environments for people with dementia: A review of the empirical research. Gerontologist 2000 ; 40(4): 397—416

12.

Dettenkofer M. , Seegers S. , Antes G. , Motschall E. , Schumacher M. , Daschner FD Does the architecture of hospital facilities influence nosocomial infection rates? A systematic review. Infection Control and Hospital Epidemiology 2004; 25(1): 21—25

13.

Devlin A. , Arneill AB Healthcare environments and patient outcomes — A review of the literature . Environment and Behaviour 2003; 35(5): 665—694

14.

Ulrich R. How design impacts wellness. Healthcare Forum Journal 1992; 35: 20—25

15.

Ulrich R. , Quan X. , Zimring C. , Joseph A. , Choudhary R. The role of the physical environment in the hospital of the 21st century: a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity Report to the Center for Health Design for Designing the 21st Century Hospital Programme. Concord , Ca: Center for Health Design, 2004.

16.

Ulrich RS , Gilpin L. Healing Arts: Nutrition for the soul. In: Frampton SB , Glipin L , Charmel P , editors. Putting patients first: Designing and practising patient-centred care. San Fransisco : Jossey-Bass, 2003

17.

Department of Health. Modernising Mental Health Services: Safe, sound and supportive, 1998.

18.

Social Exclusion Unit (1998 ) Bringing Britain together: a national strategy for neighbourhood renewal. (cm 4045). London: The Stationery office.

19.

Office of the Deputy Prime Minister. Mental Health and Social Exclusion: Social Exclusion Unit Report, 2004

20.

Department of Health. From segregation to inclusion: Commissioning guidance on day services for people with mental health problems, 2006

21.

NHS Estates. Advice to trusts on the main components of the design brief for healthcare buildings , 2002a

22.

NHS Estates. Better Health Buildings: good design is a commitment to a better quality of life for all . London: Department of Health, 2002b

23.

NHS Estates. Improving the patient experience — Friendly healthcare environments for children and young people, 2003a

24.

NHS Estates. Improving the Patient Experience — Welcoming entrances and reception areas, 2003b

25.

Carpman J. , Grant M. Design that cares: Planning health facilities for patients and visitors (2nd ed). Chicago: American Hospital Publishing, 1993

26.

Scher P. Art House. The Journal for Healthcare Design & Development 1996; 27(7)

27.

Scher P. Chalet Style. Hospital Development. London: Jan 2000; pp13—19

28.

Miles M. Art in hospital: does it work? A survey of evaluation of arts projects in the NHS. Journal of the Royal Society of Medicine 1994; 87(3): 161—163

29.

White M. , Angus J.

Arts and Adult Mental Health

Literature Review, 2003

30.

Angus J. A review of evaluation in community-based art for health activity in the UK. CAHHM for the Health Development Agency, 2002

31.

Smith T.

An evaluation of sorts: Learning from

Common Knowledge, 2003

32.

Daykin N. Disruption, dissonance and embodiment: creativity, health and risk in music narratives. Health: An Interdisciplinary Journal for the Social Study of Health, Illness and Medicine 2005; 9(1): 67—87

33.

In this full report, a small number of papers on patient participatory arts were included. These have been excluded from this discussion to reflect the study's focus on arts and the environment. Details of the report are as follows: Daykin N. , Byrne E. The impact of arts in mental healthcare: A systematic review of the literature . UWE Bristol, 2007

34.

Daykin N. ; Bryne E. The impact of visual arts and design on the health and wellbeing of patients and staff in mental health care: a systematic review of the literature. University of the West of England, Bristol, UK, 2006

35.

Ulrich RS , Simons RF , Miles MA Effects of environmental simulations and television on blood donor stress . Journal of Architectural and Planning Research 2003; 20(1): 38—47

36.

Ulrich RS , Simons RF , Losito BD , Fiorito E. Stress recovery during exposure to natural and urban environments. Journal of Environmental Psychology 1991; 11(3): 201—230

37.

Staricoff R. , Loppert S. Integrating the arts into healthcare: can we affect clinical outcomes? 2003, p.63—79

38.

Blomkvist V. , Eriksen CA , Theorell T. , Ulrich R. , Rasmanis G. Acoustics and psychosocial environment in intensive coronary care. Occupational and Environmental Medicine 2005; 62

39.

Schofield P. A pilot study into the use of a multi-sensory environment (Snoezelen) within a palliative day-care setting. International Journal of Palliative Nursing 2003; 9(3): 124—130

40.

Passini R. , Rainville C, Marchand N, Joanette Y. Wayfinding and dementia: Some research findings and a new look at design. Journal of Architectural and Planning Research 1998; 15(2): 133—151

41.

Baldwin S. Effects of furniture rearrangement on the atmosphere of wards in a maximum-security hospital. Hospital and Community Psychiatry, Washington 1985; 36(5): 525—528

42.

Donald IP , Pitt K. , Armstrong E. , Shuttleworth H. Preventing falls on an elderly care rehabilitation ward. Clinical Rehabilitation 2000; 14(2): 178—185

43.

Kincaid C. , Peacock JR The effect of a wall mural on decreasing four types of door-testing behaviours . Journal of Applied Gerontology 2003; 22(1): 76—88

44.

Timko C. Physical characteristics of residential psychiatric and substance abuse programs: Organizational determinants and patient outcomes. American Journal of Community Psychology 1996; 24(1): 173—192

45.

Benjamin LC , Spector J. Environments for the dementing. International Journal of Geriatric Psychiatry 1990; 5(1): 15—24

46.

Francis S. , Willis J. , Garvey A. , King's Fund. NHS Estates. Department of Health. Evaluation of the King's Fund's enhancing the healing environment programme. London: The Stationery Office, 2003

47.

Scher P. , Senior P. Research and evaluation of the Exeter Health Care Arts Project. Medical Humanities . Journal of Medical Ethics 2000; 26(2): 71—78

48.

Duncan J. The effect of colour and design in hydrotherapy: designing for care. In: Kirklin D, Richardson R, editors. The Healing Environment : Royal College of Physicians, 2003. p.81—100

49.

Douglas CH , Douglas MR Patient-centred improvements in healthcare built environments: Perspectives and design indicators. Health Expectations: An International Journal of Public Participation in Health Care & Health Policy 2005; 8(3): 264—276

50.

Lawson B. , Phiri M. , Wells-Thorpe J. , Department of Health. NHS Estates. The architectural healthcare environment and its effects on patient health outcomes: a report on an NHS Estates-funded research project by Bryan Lawson and Michael Phiri, in collaboration with John Wells-Thorpe . London: The Stationery Office , 2003

51.

Chen TS , Sanoff H. The patients' view of their domain. Des Stud 1988; 9(1): 40—55

Supplementary Material

Please find the following supplemental material available below.

For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.

For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.

0.00 MB

0.11 MB