Effects of creative and social activity on the health and well-being of socially isolated older people: outcomes from a multi-method observational study

Abstract

Depression and social isolation affect one in seven people over 65 and there is increasing recognition that social isolation adversely affects long-term health. Research indicates that interventions, which promote active social contact, which encourage creativity, and which use mentoring, are more likely to positively affect health and well-being. The purpose of this study was to evaluate a complex intervention for addressing social isolation in older people, embodying these principles: The Upstream Healthy Living Centre. Mentors delivered a series of individually-tailored activities, with support tailing off over time. Two hundred and twentynine participants were offered the Geriatric Depression Scale, SF12 Health Quality of Life, and Medical Outcomes Social Support scale at baseline, then 6 months and 12 months post intervention. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 26 participants, five carers and four referring health professionals to provide a deeper understanding of outcomes. Data were available for 172 (75%) participants at baseline, 72 (53% of those eligible) at 6 months and 51 (55%) at 12 months. Baseline scores indicated social isolation and high morbidity for mental and physical health. The intervention was successful in engaging this population (80% of referrals were engaged in some form of activity). At 6 months, there were significant improvements in SF12 mental component, and depression scores, but not in perceived physical health or social support. At 12 months, there were significant improvements in depression and social support and a marginally significant improvement in SF12 physical component (p= 0.06), but the SF12 mental component change was not maintained. The qualitative data showed that the intervention was well-received by participants. The data indicated a wide range of responses (both physical and emotional), including increased alertness, social activity, self-worth, optimism about life, and positive changes in health behaviour. Stronger, ‘transformational’ changes were reported by some participants. Individual tailoring seemed to be a key mediator of outcomes, as was overcoming barriers relating to transport and venues. Key processes underlying outcomes were the development of a positive group identity, and building of confidence/self-efficacy. The Upstream model provides a practical way of engaging socially isolated elderly people and generating social networks. The data suggest a range of psychosocial and physical health benefits. Although there are limitations in attributing causality in uncontrolled studies, the data seem to indicate a reversal of the expected downward trends in some aspects of participants’ health, and suggest that this approach is worth further investigation.

Keywords

Creative activity mentoring older people social isolation social networking

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Department of Health . National Service Framework for Older People. London: HMSO , 2001

Dean M . Growing Older in the 21st Century. Swindon: Economic and Social Research Council , 2005

Department of Health . Modernising Social Services. London: HMSO , 1998

World Health Organisation . Active ageing: A Policy framework. Geneva: WHO , 2002

Owen T . The high cost of isolation . Working with Older People 2001;5: 21–23

Prince MJ , Harwood RH , Blizard RA , Thomas A , Mann AH . Social support deficits, loneliness and life events as risk factors for depression in old age. The Gospel Oak Project VI . Psychol Med 1997;27: 323–332

Bowling A , Gabriel Z , Banister D , Sutton S . Adding Quality to Quantity: Older People's Views on their Quality of Life and its Enhancement. Swindon: Economic and Social Research Council , 2003

House JS , Landis KR , Umberson D . Social relationships and health . Science 1998;241: 540–545

Berkman LF . The role of social relations in health promotion . Psychosomatic Medicine 1995;57: 245–254

10.

Philip I . Ageing and health . Community Practitioner 2005;78: 9–11

11.

Clark M , Clark SJ , Jagger C . Social intervention and the elderly: a randomised controlled trial . Am J Epidemiol 1992;136: 1517–1523

12.

Howse K , Prophet H . Improving the Health of Older Londoners. London: Centre for Policy on Ageing , 2000

13.

Findlay RA . Interventions to reduce social isolation amongst older people: where is the evidence? Ageing and Society 2003;23: 647–658

14.

Andersson L . Intervention against loneliness in a group of elderly women: an impact evaluation . Soc Sci Med 1985;20: 355–364

15.

Tennstedt S , Howland J , Lachman M , Peterson E , Kasten L , Jette A . A randomized controlled trial of a group intervention to reduce fear of falling and associated activity restriction in older adults . J Gerontol B Psychol Sci Soc Sci 1998;53: 384–392

16.

Ciechanowski P , Wagner E , Schmaling K , Schwartz S , Williams B , Diehr P et al. Community-integrated home-based depression treatment in adults. A randomized controlled trial . JAMA 2004;291: 1569–1577

17.

McAuley E , Blissmer B , Marquez DX , Jerome GJ , Kramer AF , Katula J . Social relations, physical activity, and well-being in older adults . Prev Med 2000;31: 608–617

18.

Smith GJ , Andersson G . Creativity as a key factor in adaptation to old age . Psychol Res Bull 1989;29: 24–28

19.

Angus J . A Review of Evaluation in Community-based Art for Health Activity in the UK. London: Health Development Agency , 2002

20.

Shaw ME . A history of guided autobiography. In Kenyon GM , editor. Narrative Gerontology: Theory, Research and Practice. New York: Springer , 2001

21.

Houston D . Attributional style, efficacy, and the enhancement of well-being among housebound older people . Basic Appl Soc Psychol 2000;22: 309–317

22.

Wikstrom-Britt M . Social interaction associated with visual art discussions: A controlled intervention study . Aging & Mental Health 2002;6(1): 82–87

23.

Runco MA , Richards R . Eminent Creativity, Everyday Creativity, and Health. Greenwich, CN: Ablex , 1997

24.

Matarasso F . Use or Ornament? The Social Implication of Participation in the Arts. Stroud: Comedia Publications , 1997

25.

Everitt A , Hamilton R . Art, Health and Community, A Study of Five Community Arts in Health Projects. Durham: Centre for Arts and Humanities in Health and Medicine , 2003

26.

Bygren LO , Konlaan BB , Johansson SE . Attendance at cultural events, reading books or periodicals, and making music or singing in a choir as determinants for survival: Swedish interview survey of living conditions . BMJ 1996;313: 1577–1580

27.

Bennetts C . The traditional mentor relationship and the wellbeing of creative individuals in school and work . J Int Health Prom Health Educ 2000;38(1): 22–27

28.

Pleiss M , Feldhusen JF . Mentors, heroes and role models in the lives of gifted children . Educational Psychologist 1995;30(3): 159–169

29.

Schwartz RA , Williams K . Metaphors We Teach By: the Mentor Teacher and the Hero Student . J Aesthetic Education 1995;29(2): 103–110

30.

Coull AJ , Taylor VH , Elton R , Murdoch PS , Hargreaves AD. A randomised controlled trial of senior lay health mentoring in older people with ischaemic heart disease: The braveheart project . Age Ageing 2004;33(4): 348–354

31.

Marshall MN . The key informant technique . Fam Pract 1996;13: 92–97

32.

Ware JE , Kosinski M , Keller SD . A 12-item short-form health survey: Construction of scales and preliminary test of reliability and validity . Med Care 1996;34: 220–233

33.

Ware J , Kosinski M , Kellet S . SF-12: How to Score the SF-12 Physical and Mental Health Summary Scales. Lincoln RI: Quality Metric Incorporated , 1998

34.

Brazier JE , Roberts J . Estimating a preferencebased index from the SF-12. Medical Care 2006:in press

35.

Sheikh JI , Yesavage JA . Geriatric Depression Scale (GDS): Recent Evidence and Development of a Shorter Version. Clinical Gerontology: A Guide to Assessment and Intervention. New York: Hawarth Press , 1986

36.

Brink TL , Yesavage JA , Lum O , Heersema P , Adey MB , Rose TL . Screening tests for geriatric depression . Clinical Gerontologist 1982;1: 37–44

37.

Sherbourne CD , Stewart AL . The MOS social support survey . Soc Sci Med 1991;32: 705–714

38.

Michalak EE , Tam EM , Manjunath CV , Yatham LN , Levitt AJ , Levitan RD et al. Hard times and good friends: negative life events and social support in patients with seasonal and nonseasonal depression . Can J Psychiatry 2004;49: 408–411

39.

Marshall MN . Sampling for qualitative research . Fam Pract 1996;13: 522–525

40.

Bryman J . Social Research Methods. Oxford: Open University Press , 2001

41.

Mostyn B . The content analysis of qualitative research data: a dynamic approach. In Bremner M , Brown J , Carter D , editors. The Research Interview: Uses and Approaches. New York: Academic Press , 1985

42.

Guba EG , Lincoln YS . Fourth Generation Evaluation. Newbury Park, CA: SAGE , 1989

43.

Strauss AL , Corbin J . Basics of Qualitative Research: Grounded Theory Procedures and Techniques. London: SAGE , 1990

44.

Firestone W . Alternative arguments for generalizing from data as applied to qualitative research . Educational Researcher 1993;22: 16–13

45.

Gandek B , Ware JE , Aaronson NK , Apolone G , Bjorner JB , Brazier JE et al. Cross-Validation of Item Selection and Scoring for the SF-12 Health Survey in Nine Countries: Results from the IQOLA Project . J Clin Epidemiol 1998;51: 1171–1178

46.

Scoring and Interpreting SF Data. Available online at: http://www.sf-36.org/cgi-bin/discuss/subject.cgi?sid=3 (accessed 30 October 2005)

47.

Adasi-Lari M , Packham C , Gray D . Is quality of life measurement likely to be a proxy for health needs assessment in patients with coronary artery disease? Health Qual Life Outcomes 2003;1: 50–57

48.

Ware J , Kosinski M , Kellet S . SF-12: How to Score the SF-12 Physical and Mental Health Summary Scales. Lincoln, RI: Quality Metric Incorporated , 1998

49.

Brown P , McCann S , Shaw M , Verne J . Second Blooming : Towards achieving a healthy and active mature population in the South West. Bulletin 1: Demographics and inequalities. Bristol: SW Public Health Observatory , 2005

50.

Parker CJ , Morgan K , Dewey ME , Analysis Group of the MRC CFA Study. Physical illness and disability among elderly people in England and Wales: the Medical Research Council cognitive function and ageing study . J Epidemiol Community Health 1997;51(5): 494–501

51.

MRC CFA Study Group . Health and ill-health in the older population in England and Wales . Age Ageing 2001;30: 53–62

52.

Marmot M , Banks J , Blundell R , Lessof C , Nazroo J . Health, Wealth and Lifestyles of the Older Population in England: The 2002 English Longitudinal Study Of Ageing. London: Institute for Fiscal Studies , 2003

53.

Kunik ME , Braun U , Stanley MA , Wristers K , Molinari V , Stoebner D et al. One session cognitive behavioural therapy for elderly patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease . Psychol Med 2001;31: 717–723

54.

Baldwin R , Pratt H , Goring H , Marriott A , Roberts C . Does a nurse-led mental health liaison service for older people reduce psychiatric morbidity in acute general medical wards? A randomised controlled trial . Age Ageing 2004;33(5): 472–478

55.

Llewellyn-Jones RH , Baikie KA , Smithers H , Cohen J , Snowdon J , Tennant CC . Multifaceted shared care intervention for late life depression in residential care: randomised controlled trial . BMJ 1999;319: 676–682

56.

Heyn-Billipp S . The psychosocial impact of interactive computer use within a vulnerable elderly population: a report on a randomized prospective trial in a home health care setting . Public Health Nurs 2001;18: 138–145

57.

Chin A , Paw MJM , Van Poppel MNM , Twisk JWR , Van Mechelen W . Effects of resistance and all-round, functional training on quality of life, vitality and depression of older adults living in long-term care facilities: a ‘randomized’ controlled trial . BMC Geriatrics 2004;4(5): 1471–1479

58.

McCusker J , Verdon J , Tousignant P , de Courval LP , Dendukuri N , Belzile E . Rapid emergency department intervention for older people reduces risk of functional decline: results of a multicenter randomized trial . J Am Geriatr Soc 2001;49: 1272–1281

59.

Bassey EJ . The benefits of exercise for the health of older people . Rev Clin Gerontol 2000;10: 17–31

60.

Tuomilehto J , Lindstrom J , Eriksson JG , Valle TT , Hamalainen H , Ilanne-Parikka P et al. Prevention of type 2 diabetes mellitus by changes in lifestyle among subjects with impaired glucose tolerance . N Engl J Med 2001;344: 1343–1350

61.

Weuve J , Kang JH , Manson JE , Breteler MMB , Ware JH , Grodstein F . Physical Activity, Including Walking and Cognitive Function in Older Women . JAMA 2004;292: 1454–1461

62.

Harter S . The Construction of the Self. New York: Guildford , 1999

63.

Levine RM . Identity and illness: The effects of identity salience and frame of reference on evaluation of illness and injury . Br J Health Psychol 1999;4: 63–80

64.

White M , Angus J . Arts and Adult Mental Health Literature Review. Addressing the Evidence Base from Participation in Arts and Cultural Activities. Durham: Centre for Arts and Humanities in Health and Medicine , 2003

65.

Glenny AM , Altman DG , Song F , Sakarovitch C , Deeks JJ , D’Amico R et al. Indirect comparisons of competing interventions . Health Technol Assess 2005;9(26)