A preliminary assessment of two hospital food service systems using parameters of food safety and consumer opinion

Abstract

The goal of any hospital caterer should be to provide food that meets nutritional requirements, satisfies the patient, improves morale and is microbiologically safe. Food distribution to hospital wards plays a critical role. The aim of this study was to compare two hospital food service systems using parameters of food safety and consumer opinion.

An NHS hospital was selected where food delivery was due to change from a plated system to a cafeteria trolley system.

Samples (50g) of dishes (n=27) considered to be high-risk were collected for three consecutive days from breakfast, lunch and supper meals. The samples were taken from a pre-ordered tray (similar to that of a patient) in the plated system and from the trolley on the ward in the cafeteria system of meal delivery (approxi mately six months after its introduction). Consumer opinions cards (n=180) were distributed and interviews also conducted.

Microbiologically, the quality of food items delivered by both systems was satisfactory. However, concern was raised with the plated system, not for hot foods cooling down but for chilled foods warming up and being sustained in ambient conditions. Overall con sumer satisfaction and experience was enhanced with the trolley system. Food was hotter and generally per ceived to be of a better quality. Satisfaction with cold desserts was not dependent on the delivery system.

Keywords

Consumer opinion food safety hospital food service hostess cafeteria trolley delivery plated delivery

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Achcew (Association Of Community Health Councils For England And Wales) (1997). Hungry in Hospital. London: ACHCEW

Advisory Committee On The Microbiological Safety Of Food (2000). Advisory Committee on the Microbiological Safety of Food Annual Report 2000. London: Food Standards Agency

Allison S. (1999). Hospital Food as Treatment. Maidenhead: British Association for Parenteral and Enteral Nutrition

Aston G. (2000). Food hygiene in hospitals - are we training the right people? J Roy Soc Health; 120(4), 211

Barrie D. (1996). The provision of food and catering services in hospital. J Hospital Infect; 33, 13-33

Cardello A.V. and Maller O. (1982). Acceptability of water, selected beverages and foods as a function of serving temperature. J Food Sci; 47,1549-1552

Cardello A.V. , Maller O. and Kluter R. (1984). Multi-user assessment of a hospital cook-freeze food service system. J Food Serv Syst; 3, 153-169

Coleman P. and GRIFFITH C (2001). Welsh Caterers: An Exploratory Study of Attitudes Towards Safe Food Handling in the Hospitality Industry . In: Culinary Arts and Sciences. (Edited by Edwards J S A and Hewedi M M. ) Bournemouth: Worshipful Company of Cooks Centre for Culinary Research, Bournemouth University

Council Of Europe (2001). Food and Nutritional Care in Hospitals: How to Prevent Undernutrition. Draft Report 2001, in press

10.

Davis A.M. and Bristow A. (1999). Managing Nutrition in Hospital. London: The Nuffield Trust

11.

DHSS (DEPARTMENT OF HEALTH AND SOCIAL SERVICES) (1986). The Report of the Committee of Enquiry into an Outbreak of Food

12.

Poisoning at Stanley Road Hospital. London: HMSO

13.

Elia M. , Russell C. , Shaffer J. , Mick-Lewright A. , Wood S. , Wheatley C. , et al (1998). British Artificial Nutrition Society Annual Report 1998. London: BANS

14.

Food Safety Act (1990). Food Safety Act. London: HMSO

15.

Food Safety (Temperature Control) Regulations ( 1995). Statutory Instru

16.

ment Number 2200. London: The Stationery Office

17.

Food Standards Agency (2001 a). Food Standards Agency website: www.foodstandards.gov.uk (accessed July 2001)

18.

Food Standards Agency (2001b). Annual Consumer Report. London: Food Standards Agency

19.

Food Standards Agency (2001 c). Industry and Enforcement. Official Control of Foodstuffs Statistics for 2000 www.foodstandards.gov.uk/lalist/2000/authindex.htm (accessed November 2001)

20.

Food Standards Agency (2001d). Setting the Baseline for the Agency's Foodborne Disease Target: Measures of Foodborne Disease in the UK. London: Food Standards Agency

21.

Food Standards Agency (2001e). Food Standards Agency website: www.foodstandards.gov.uk (accessed February 2001)

22.

Gillespie I. , Little C. and Mitchell R. (2000). Microbiological examination of cold ready-to-eat sliced meats from catering establishments in the United Kingdom. J Appl Microbiol; 88, 467-474 Gregoire M. (1994). Quality of patient meal service in hospitals: delivery of meals by dietary employees vs delivery by nursing employees. J Am Diet Assoc ; 94(10), 1129-1134

23.

Hwang Li-Jen J. , Desombre T. , Eves A. and Kipps M. (1999). An analysis of catering options within NHS acute hospitals. Int J Health Care Quality Ass, 12(7), 293-308

24.

Kelly L. (1999). Audit of food wastage: differences between a plated and bulk system of meal provision. J Human Nutr Diet, 12(5), 415-424

25.

Kipps M. and Middleton T.C. (1990). Achieving quality and choice for the customer in hospital catering. Int J Hospitality Manage, 9(1), 69-83 Lomas D. (1988). Hospital food - a healthy choice? Which; September 1988, 430-432

26.

Nhs (National Health Service) (1994). Hospital Catering in England. Report by the

27.

Comptroller and Auditor General. London: HMSO

28.

O'Hara P.A. , Harper D.W. , Kangas M. , Dubeau J. , Borsutzky C. and Lemire N.

29.

( 1997). Taste, temperature and presentation predict satisfaction with food services in a Canadian continuing-care hospital. J Am Diet Assoc, 97(4), 401-405

30.

Phls (Public Health Laboratory Service) (2000 ). Advisory Committee for Food and Dairy products. Guidelines for the microbiological quality of some ready-to-eat foods sampled at the

31.

point of sale. Commun Dis Public Health; 3(3), 163-167

32.

Reilly J.R. , Hull S.F. , Albert N. , Waller A. and Bringarderner S. (1987). Economic impact of malnutrition: a model system for hospitalised patients. J Parenteral Enteral Nutri; 12, 372-376

33.

Rush F. and Moloney M. (1998). Patient Satisfaction, Nutrient Content and Actual Intake of Food Served in Two Dublin Teaching Hospitals. Proceedings of the Nutrition Society; 1998, 57(166A)

34.

Ryynanen S. , Tuorila H. and Hyvonen L. (2001). Perceived temperature effects on microwave heated meals and meal components. Food Service Technol; in press

35.

Tebbut G.M. (1984). A microbiological study of various food premises with an assessment of cleaning and disinfection practices. J Hygiene; 92, 365-375

36.

United Kingdom Central Council For Nursing, Midwifery And Health Visiting (1997). Registrar's Letter. London: UKCC

37.

Who (World Health Organization) (2001). World Health Organization, Surveillance Programme for Control of Foodborne Infections and Intoxications in Europe www.who.it/docs/fdsaf/fs_survprog.htm (accessed August 2001)

38.

Wilson A. , Evans S. and Frost G. (2000). A comparison of the amount of food served and

39.

consumed according to meal service system. J Human Nutr Diet ; 13, 271-275 Wilson M. , Murray A.E. , Black M.A. and Mcdowell D.A. (1997). The implementation of hazard analysis and critical control points in hospital catering. Managing Service Quality, 7(3), 150-156