Personal exposure to benzene and the influence of attached and integral garages

Abstract

Benzene is an air pollutant that is a recognised human carcinogen. An air quality standard has been established for ambient air in the UK to reduce the popula tion's exposure. It has been estimated that about 70% of benzene emissions to air in the UK come from petrol vehicles.

A number of studies, including the Avon Longitudinal Study of Pregnancy and Childhood in the UK, have found that benzene concentrations in homes with attached or integral garages tend to be higher than in those without such garages. The present paper reviews these studies and reports a detailed investigation of five homes with either an attached or an integral garage.

Indoor and outdoor locations were monitored using diffusive sampling to determine the average benzene concentration over approximately 28 days each month for 18 consecutive months (June 1998-November 1999). For one of these homes, ten years of data had shown the indoor benzene concentration to be con sistently higher than outdoors. Personal exposure monitoring of one adult in this home showed that the benzene concentration in the main bedroom was a better predictor of personal exposure than the concentration outdoors.

In the homes where a car was regularly parked in the garage, 18-month aver age benzene concentrations of up to 101.3 μgm ³ were measured in the garage, which is more than six times the ambient air quality standard for benzene (16.25 μgm³ running annual average). Mean benzene values in all cars and most of the garages studied exceeded the benzene standard.

Mean benzene concentrations in the room above the garage ranged from 3.7 μgm³ in one home, where the car was rarely parked in the garage, to 39.9 μgm³ in another home where a car with high benzene emissions was parked in the garage for six of the 18 months monitored. The mean benzene concentration in the room above the garage in this latter home was nearly 2.5 times the ambient air standard.

The study demonstrates that there is a potential for people to have a higher exposure to benzene as a result of living in a home with an attached or integral garage. An understanding of routes of personal exposure is important to devel op effective policies to reduce risks to health.

Keywords

Attached garages benzene car health home personal exposure petrol

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Berry R.W. , Brown V.M. , Coward S K D , Crump D.R. , Gavin M. , Grimes C.P. , et al (1996). Indoor Air Quality in Homes. The Building Research Establishment Indoor Environment Study (BRE Reports BR 299 and BR 300) London: CRC Ltd

Brown V.M. and Crump D.R. (1998a). The use of diffusive samplers for the measurement of volatile organic compounds in the indoor air of 44 homes in Southampton . Indoor Built Environ; 7, 245-253

Brown V.M. and Crump D.R. (1998b). Diffusive Sampling of Volatile Organic Compounds in Air. Environmental Monitoring and Assessment. Volume 52, pp. 43-55. The Netherlands: Kluwer Academic Publishers

Cocheo V. (2000). Urban benzene and population exposure. Nature; 404, 141

Concawe (2000). In: CONCAWE Review . Volume 9, Number 1

Crump D.R. (1997). Indoor Air Pollution. In: Air Pollution in the UK, pp. 1-21. (Edited by G Davison and C N Hewitt ). London: Royal Society of Chemistry

Crump D.R. , Mann H.S. , Brown V.M. and Ross D.I. (1999). Personal exposures to air pollutants in Hertfordshire , England. Indoor Air 1999; 5, 288-293

De Bortoli M. , Knöppel H. , Pecchio E. , Peil A. , Rogora L. , Schauenburg H. , et al (1984). Integrating 'real life' measurements of organic pollution in indoor and outdoor homes in northern Italy. Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate. Indoor Air 1984; 4, 21-26

Detr (Department OF THE ENVIRONMENT, TRANSPORT AND THE REGIONS) (2000). The Air Quality Strategy for England, Scotland Wales and Northern Ireland: Working Together for Clean Air (Cm 4548). Norwich: HMSO

10.

Duarte-Davison R. , Courage C. , Rush-Ton L. and Levy L.S. (1999). General population exposure to environmental levels of benzene in the UK. Indoor Air 1999; 5, 333-334

11.

Ebs (Exxon Biomedical Sciences) (1996). Benzene Risk Characterisation. Eastmillstone, New Jersey : Exxon Biomedical Sciences

12.

Fellin P. and Otson R. (1993). Seasonal Trends of Volatile Organic Compounds (VOCs) in Canadian Homes In: Indoor Air 1993: Proceedings of the 6th International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate, Vol1, pp. 339-343. (Edited by J J K Jaakkola, R Ilmarinen and O Seppänen O). Espoo, Finland: Helsinki University of Technology

13.

Gammage R.B. and White D.A. (1984). Residential measurements of high volatility organics and their sources. Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate. IndoorAir 1984 ; 4, 157-162

14.

Goldstein B.D. , Tardiff R.G. , Baker S.R. , Hoffnagle G.F. , Murray D.R. , Catizone P.A. , et al (1992). Valdez Air Health Study. Anchorage Alabama: Alyseka Pipeline Service Co

15.

Hricko A. (1994). Rings of controversy around benzene. Environ Health Persp; 102(3), 276-281

16.

Ieh (Institute For Environmental Health) ( 1999). IEH Report on Benzene in the Environment (Report R12) . Leicester: MRC Institute for Environment and Health

17.

Jones N.C. , Thornton C.A. , Mark D. and Harrison R.M. (1999). Indoor/outdoor relationships of benzene and particulate matter. Indoor Air 1999; 4,1096-1097

18.

Kingham S. , Meaton J. , Sheard A. and Lawrenson O. (1998). Assessment of exposure to traffic-related fumes during the journey to work. Transp Res D; 3(4), 271-274

19.

Leung P. and Harrison P. (1998). Evaluation of personal exposure to monoaromatic hydrocarbons. Occup Environ Med; 55, 249-257

20.

Levson K. (1996). Exposure to Benzene and Other Aromatic Hydrocarbons: Indoor and Outdoor Sources. Proceedings of Indoor Air 1996; 6, 1061-1066

21.

Levson K. , Eiglen E. , Angerer J. , Schneider P. and Heinrich J. (1999). Humans' exposure to benzene and other aromatic hydrocarbons: indoor and outdoor sources. Indoor Air 1999; 5, 312-316

22.

Mann H.S. , Crump D.R. and Brown V.M. (1997). The Use of Diffusive Samplers to Measure Personal Exposure and Area Concentrations of VOCs Including Formaldehyde. Proceedings from Healthy Buildings/Indoor Air Quality 1997. Washington DC, USA

23.

Pierson W. , Schorran D.E. , Fujita E.M. , Sagebiel J.C. , Lawson D.R. and Tanner R.L. (1999). Assessment of non-tailpipe hydrocarbon emissions from motor vehicles. Air Waste Manag Assoc; 49, 498-519

24.

Ross I. ( 1999). The Introduction of Cleaner Fuels - Case Study of Finland and Sweden. Proceedings from the 1 st International Conference on Health Effects of Vehicle Emissions, pp. 1 (5)-5(5). London: Royal Society of Medicine

25.

Salway A.G. , Eggleston H.S. , Goodwin J W L and Murrells T.P. (1997). UK Emissions of Air Pollutants 1970-1995. AEAT-1746/Issue 1. Abingdon: AEA Technology

26.

Sawyer R.F. (1993). Trends in auto emissions and gasoline composition . Environ Health Perspect; 101(S6), 5-12

27.

Sheldon L.S. , Clayton A. , Jones B. , Keever J. , Perritt R. , Smith D. , et al (1991). Indoor Pollutant Concentrations and Exposures. Final Report Sacramento: California Air Resources Board

28.

Thomas K.W. , Pellizzari E.D. , Clayton C.A. , Perritt R.L. , Dietz R.N. , Goodeich R.W. , et al (1993). Temporal variability of benzene exposures for residents in several New Jersey homes with attached garages or tobacco smoke. J Exp Anal Environ Epidemiol; 3(1), 49-73

29.

Wallace L.A. , Pellizzari E. , Hartwell T. , Zelon H. , Sparacino C. and Whitmore R. (1984). Analyses of exhaled breath of 355 urban residents for volatile organic compounds. Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Indoor Air Quality and Climate. Indoor Air 1984; 4,15-20

30.

Wallace L.A. , Pellizzari E.D. , Hartwell T. , Sparacino C. , Sheldon L. and Zelon H. (1985). Personal exposure, indooroutdoor relationships and breath levels of toxic air pollutants measured for 355 persons in New Jersey. Atmos Environ; 19, 1651-1661

31.

Wallace L.A. (1987). The TEAM Study: Summary and Analysis. Volume 1 (EPA 600/6-87/002a.NTIS PB 88-100060). Washington: Environment Protection Agency

32.

Who (World Health Organisation) (1987). Air Quality Guidelines for Europe. European Series, Number 23. Copenhagen: WHO