We introduce a computational method for identifying delegating and constraining provisions in European Union (EU) laws. Leveraging the syntactic structures employed by legislators, we developed a set of extraction rules applied through a custom-built computational linguistics pipeline. We run through the pipeline more than 600,000 legal sentences that we extracted from 9319 laws adopted between 1958 and 2019. The application performs very well vis-á-vis human annotation and outperforms transformer models. The produced patterns of authority delegation and constraint resonate with our knowledge of the policymaking and history of the EU. Our approach provides valuable insights for designing transparent and adaptable rule-based computational linguistic methods of legal text analysis. We also release the comprehensively annotated dataset and the fine-tuned transformer models developed for this task.
AnastasopoulosLJBertelliAM (2020) Understanding delegation through machine learning: A method and application to the European Union. American Political Science Review114(1): 291–301.
2.
BorrettCLaurerM (2020) The CEPS EurLex dataset: 142.036 EU laws from 1952-2019 with full text and 22 variables. Harvard Dataverse, V2. DOI: 10.7910/DVN/0EGYWY.
3.
ChalkidisIFergadiotisMMalakasiotisP, et al. (2020) LEGAL-BERT: The muppets straight out of law school. arXiv preprint arXiv:2010.02559.
4.
ChitiE (2000) The emergence of a community administration: The case of European agencies. Common Market Law Review37(2): 309–343.
5.
DevlinJChangMWLeeK, et al. (2018) BERT: Pre-training of deep bidirectional transformers for language understanding. arXiv preprint arXiv:1810.04805.
6.
EpsteinDO’HalloranS (1999) Delegating Powers: A Transaction Cost Politics Approach to Policy Making Under Separate Powers. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
7.
EpsteinRARhodesM (2016) The political dynamics behind Europe’s new banking union. West European Politics39(3): 415–437.
8.
ErshovaA (2019) The watchdog or the mandarin? Assessing the impact of the Directorates General on the EU legislative process. Journal of European Public Policy26(3): 407–427.
9.
FranchinoF (2007) The Powers of the Union: Delegation in the EU. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
10.
FranchinoFMiglioratiMPaganoG, et al. (2024) Concepts and measures of bureaucratic constraints in European Union laws from hand-coding to machine-learning. Regulation & Governance18(3): 688–703.
11.
FreudlspergerCMaricut-AkbikAMiglioratiM (2022) Opening Pandora’s box? Joint sovereignty and the rise of EU Agencies with operational tasks. Comparative Political Studies55(12): 1983–2014.
12.
GastingerMDürA (2021) Joint bodies in the European Union’s international agreements: Delegating powers to the European Commission in EU external relations. European Union Politics22(4): 611–630.
13.
GilardiF (2005) the institutional foundations of regulatory capitalism: The diffusion of independent regulatory agencies in Western Europe. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science598(1): 84–101.
14.
HumphreysLBoellaGvan der TorreL, et al. (2021) Populating legal ontologies using semantic role labeling. Artificial Intelligence and Law29: 171–211.
15.
LiuYOttMGoyalN, et al. (2019) RoBERTa: A robustly optimized BERT pretraining approach. arXiv preprint arXiv:1907.11692.
16.
MajoneG (1996) Regulating Europe. London: Routledge.
17.
MiglioratiM (2020a) The post-agencification stage between reforms and crises. A comparative assessment of EU agencies’ budgetary development. Journal of Common Market Studies58(6): 1393–1412.
18.
MiglioratiM (2020b) Relying on agencies in major European Union legislative measures. West European Politics43(1): 159–180.
19.
MiglioratiM (2021) Where does implementation lie? Assessing the determinants of delegation and discretion in post-Maastricht European Union. Journal of Public Policy41(3): 489–514.
20.
SanhVDebutLChaumondJ, et al. (2019) DistilBERT, a distilled version of BERT: Smaller, faster, cheaper and lighter. arXiv preprint arXiv:1910.01108.
21.
SchützeR (2018) European Constitutional Law. Second edition. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
22.
ThatcherM (2011) The creation of European regulatory agencies and its limits: A comparative analysis of European delegation. Journal of European Public Policy18(6): 790–809.
23.
ThomsonRTorenvliedR (2011) Information, commitment and consensus: A comparison of three perspectives on delegation in the European Union. British Journal of Political Science41(1): 139–159.
24.
VannoniMAshEMorelliM (2021) Measuring discretion and delegation in legislative texts: Methods and application to US states. Political Analysis29(1): 43–57.
