Restricted accessResearch articleFirst published online 2024-9
Do (too many) elections depress participation? How the position,frequency and nature of domestic ballots affect turnout in European Parliament elections
In Europe, the multiplication of elections makes the election calendar a decisive issue given the decreasing participatory trend. Turnout is expected to be higher in simultaneous elections, while it lessens if several elections are held over a short period. The saliency of the preceding ballot may also affect participation in the next one. In this article, we argue that these temporal effects are crucial for European Parliament elections due to their second-order nature. We analyse how the position, frequency and nature of domestic ballots affect European Parliament elections turnout since 1979. Our results indicate that the participation level is less affected by the timing of elections than by their overall frequency. The type of preceding election also matters, although not the second-order nature per se.
AldrichJH (1993) Rational choice and turnout. American Journal of Political Science37(1): 246–278.
2.
AldrichJHMontgomeryJMWoodW (2011) Turnout as a habit. Political Behavior33(4): 535–563.
3.
AltmanD (2013) Does an active use of mechanisms of direct democracy impact electoral participation? Evidence from the U.S. States and the Swiss cantons. Local Government Studies39(6): 739–755.
4.
BhattiYHansenKM (2012) The effect of generation and age on turnout to the European parliament–how turnout will continue to decline in the future. Electoral Studies31(2): 262–272.
5.
BlondelJSinnottRSvenssonP (1997) Representation and voter participation. European Journal of Political Research32(2): 243–272.
6.
BraunDGrandeE (2021) Politicizing Europe in elections to the European parliament (1994–2019): The crucial role of mainstream parties. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies59(5): 1124–1141.
7.
CainBDaltonRScarrowS (2003) Democracy Transformed?: Expanding Political Opportunities in Advanced Industrial Democracies. Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press.
8.
ClarkN (2014) Explaining low turnout in European elections: The role of issue salience and institutional perceptions in elections to the European parliament. Journal of European Integration36(4): 339–356.
9.
DöringHHuberCManowP (2022) Parliaments and governments database (ParlGov): Information on parties, elections and cabinets in established democracies. Available at: https://www.parlgov.org (accessed 13 May 2024).
10.
DvořákTZouharJNovákJ (2017) The effect of direct democracy on turnout: Voter mobilization or participatory momentum?Political Research Quarterly70(2): 433–448.
11.
EhinPTalvingL (2021) Still second-order? European elections in the era of populism, extremism, and euroscepticism. Politics41(4): 467–485.
12.
EzrowLXezonakisG (2016) Satisfaction with democracy and voter turnout: A temporal perspective. Party Politics22(1): 3–14.
13.
Fauvelle-AymarCStegmaierM (2008) Economic and political effects on European parliamentary electoral turnout in post-communist Europe. Electoral Studies27(4): 661–672.
14.
FiorinoNPontarolloNRicciutiR (2019) Supranational, national and local dimensions of voter turnout in European parliament elections. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies57(4): 877–893.
15.
FlickingerRSStudlarDT (2007) One Europe, many electorates? Models of turnout in European parliament elections after 2004. Comparative Political Studies40(4): 383–404.
16.
FollesdalAHixS (2006) Why there is a democratic deficit in the EU: A response to Majone and Moravcsik. JCMS: Journal of Common Market Studies44(3): 533–562.
17.
FranklinMN (1999) Electoral engineering and cross-national turnout differences: What role for compulsory voting?British Journal of Political Science29(1): 205–216.
18.
FranklinMN (2001) How structural factors cause turnout variations at European parliament elections. European Union Politics2(3): 309–328.
19.
FranklinMN (2004) Voter Turnout and the Dynamics of Electoral Competition in Established Democracies since 1945. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
20.
FranklinMN (2007) Effects of space and time on turnout in European parliaments elections. In: Van Der BrugWVan Der EijkC (eds) European Elections and Domestic Politics: Lessons from the Past and Scenarios for the Future. Notre Dame: University of Notre Dame Press, 13–31.
21.
FreitagMStadelmann-SteffenI (2010) Stumbling block or stepping stone? The influence of direct democracy on individual participation in parliamentary elections. Electoral Studies29(3): 472–483.
22.
FrognierAP (2002) Identity and electoral participation: For a European approach to European elections. In: PerrineauPGrunbergGYsmalC (eds) Europe at the Polls: The European Elections of 1999. New York: Palgrave Macmillan, 43–58.
23.
GarmannS (2017) Election frequency, choice fatigue, and voter turnout. European Journal of Political Economy47(1): 19–35.
24.
GerberASGreenDPShacharR (2003) Voting may be habit-forming: Evidence from a randomized field experiment. American Journal of Political Science47(3): 540–550.
25.
GieblerHWüstAM (2011) Campaigning on an upper level? Individual campaigning in the 2009 European parliament elections in its determinants. Electoral Studies30(1): 53–66.
26.
GreenDPShacharR (2000) Habit formation and political behaviour: Evidence of consuetude in voter turnout. British Journal of Political Science30(4): 561–573.
27.
HixSHagemannS (2009) Could changing the electoral rules fix European parliament elections?Politique Européenne28(2): 37–52.
28.
HosliMOKantorowiczJNagtzaamMAM, et al. (2022) Turnout in European parliament elections 1979–2019. European Politics and Society25(1): 1–23.
29.
IrwinGJ (1995) Second-order or third-rate?: Issues in the campaign for the elections for the European parliament 1994. Electoral Studies14(2): 183–199.
30.
JackmanRWMillerRA (1995) Voter turnout in the industrial democracies during the 1980s. Comparative Political Studies27(4): 467–492.
31.
KarpJABanducciSA (2007) Party mobilization and political participation in new and old democracies. Party Politics13(2): 217–234.
32.
KostelkaF (2017) Does democratic consolidation lead to a decline in voter turnout? Global evidence since 1939. American Political Science Review111(4): 653–667.
33.
KostelkaFKrejcovaESaugerN, et al. (2023) Election frequency and voter turnout. Comparative Political Studies56(14): 2231–2268.
34.
KritzingerSPlesciaCRaubeK, et al. (2020) Assessing the 2019 European Parliament Elections. London: Routledge.
35.
LefevereJVan AelstP (2014) First-order, second-order or third-rate? A comparison of turnout in European, local and national elections in The Netherlands. Electoral Studies35: 159–170.
36.
LeiningerARudolphLZittlauS (2018) How to increase turnout in low-salience elections: Quasi-experimental evidence on the effect of concurrent second-order elections on political participation. Political Science Research and Methods6(3): 509–526.
37.
MarquartFGoldbergACDe VreeseCH (2020) This time I’m (not) voting’: A comprehensive overview of campaign factors influencing turnout at European parliament elections. European Union Politics21(4): 680–705.
38.
MarshMMikhaylovS (2010) European Parliament Elections and EU Governance. Living Reviews in European Governance5. https://doi.org/10.12942/lreg-2010-4. Accessed 4 April 2019.
39.
MattilaM (2003) Why bother? Determinants of turnout in the European elections. Electoral Studies22(3): 449–468.
40.
MuxelA (2005) Les abstentionnistes le premier parti européen. In: PerrineauP (eds) Le vote européen 2004-2005. De l'élargissement au référendum français. Paris: Presses de Sciences Po, 45–76.
41.
NonnemacherJ (2021) Disengaging elections? Political interest, number of elections, and turnout in elections to the European parliament. European Union Politics22(3): 545–565.
42.
NorrisP (2004) Electoral Engineering: Voting Rules and Political Behavior. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
43.
RallingsCThrasherMBorisyukG (2003) Seasonal factors, voter fatigue and the costs of voting. Electoral Studies22(1): 65–79.
44.
ReifK (1984) National electoral cycles and European elections 1979 and 1984. Electoral Studies3(3): 244–255.
45.
ReifKSchmittH (1980) Nine second-order national elections – a conceptual framework for the analysis of European election results. European Journal of Political Research8(1): 3–44.
46.
SchäferC (2021) Indifferent and Eurosceptic: The motivations of EU-only abstainers in the 2019 European parliament election. Politics41(4): 522–536.
47.
SchäferCDebusM (2018) No participation without representation. Journal of European Public Policy25(12): 1835–1854.
48.
SchakelAHDandoyR (2014) Electoral cycles and turnout in multilevel electoral systems. West European Politics37(3): 605–623.
49.
SchakelAHVerdoesA (2023) Tracing developments in regional electoral democracy: The impact of regional authority, regional identity, and regional electoral systems on the regional vote. In: Teles F (ed) Handbook on Local and Regional Governance. Cheltenham: Edward Elgar Publishing, 164–183.
50.
SchmittHSanzABraunD, et al. (2020) It all happens at once: Understanding electoral behaviour in second-order elections. Politics and Governance8(1): 6–18.
51.
SchmittHTeperoglouE (2017) The study of less important elections. In: ArzheimerKLewis-BeckMSEvansJ (eds) The Sage Handbook of Electoral Behaviour. London: Sage, 56–79.
52.
StockemerD (2017) Electoral participation: How to measure voter turnout?Social Indicators Research133(3): 943–962.
53.
StudlarDFlickingerRSBennettS (2003) Turnout in European parliament elections: Towards a European-centred model. British Elections & Parties Review13(1): 195–209.
54.
Van der EijkCFranklinMMarshM (1996) What voters teach US about Europe-wide elections: What Europe-wide elections teach us about voters. Electoral Studies15(2): 149–166.
55.
Van der EijkCFranklinMN (1996) Choosing Europe? The European electorate and national politics in the face of union. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
56.
WillocqSKelbelC (2018) Splitting votes, splitting Hairs? Rationale for split-ticket voting at the federal, regional, and European elections of May 2014 in Belgium. Publius: The Journal of Federalism48(4): 664–685.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
