This article analyzes the effect of Franco-German cooperation on Economic and Monetary Union reforms, negotiated between 2010 and 2015. We identify three causal mechanisms theorizing how Franco-German cooperation affected the outcomes of EMU negotiations, namely through (a) the elimination of issues from the negotiation agenda; (b) the identification of compromise solutions or the provision of compensations; and (c) the power-based imposition of joint agreements on other member states. We use process tracing to analyze almost the full sample of contested issues included in the ‘EMU Positions’ dataset. Our findings underline that France and Germany indeed eliminated issues to which they were jointly opposed, but they also positively shaped the agenda by proposing compromises and offering compensation. No evidence supports the power-focused perspective of a Franco-German directoire.
CaporasoJAKimM-H (2012)
The Maastricht Treaty at twenty: A Greco-European tragedy?Journal of European Integration34(7): 769–789.
7.
ChangM (2013)
Fiscal policy coordination and the future of the community method.Journal of European Integration35(3): 255–269.
8.
CliftBRynerM (2014)
Joined at the hip, but pulling apart? Franco-German relations, the Eurozone crisis and the politics of austerity.French Politics12(2): 136–163.
9.
Cole A (2010) Franco-German Europe. In Dyson K and Sepos A (eds) Which Europe? The Politics of Differentiated Integration. Houndmills: Palgrave Macmillan, pp. 156--169.
10.
CostelloRThomsonR (2013)
The distribution of power among EU institutions: Who wins under codecision and why?Journal of European Public Policy20(7): 1025–1039.
11.
CrespyASchmidtVA (2014)
The clash of Titans: France, Germany, and the discursive double game of EMU reform.Journal of European Public Policy21(8): 1085–1101.
12.
DegnerH (2016) European integration in response to the 'Euro Crisis' 2010–2013. In: SauruggerSTerpanF (eds) Crisis and Institutional Change in Regional Integration.
London:
Routledge, pp.23–40.
DinanDNugentNPatersonWE (2017) Conclusions: Crisis without end? In: DinanDNugentNPatersonWE (eds) The European Union in Crisis.
Houndmills:
Palgrave Macmillan, pp.360–375.
18.
DysonK (2017) Playing for high stakes: The Eurozone crisis. In: DinanDNugentN and PatersonWE (eds) The European Union in Crisis.
Houndmills:
Palgrave Macmillan, pp.54–76.
19.
EpsteinRARhodesM (2016)
The political dynamics behind Europe’s new banking union.West European Politics39(3): 415–437.
FriedenJAWalterS (2017)
Understanding the political economy of the Eurozone Crisis.Annual Review of Political Science20(1): 371–390.
25.
GocajLMeunierS (2013)
Time will tell: The EFSF, the ESM, and the Euro Crisis.Journal of European Integration35(3): 239–253.
26.
HallPA (2012)
The economics and politics of the Euro Crisis.German Politics21(4): 355–371.
27.
HodsonD (2015)
Eurozone governance: Deflation, Grexit 2.0 and the second coming of Jean-Claude Juncker.Journal of Common Market Studies53(Annual Review): 144–161.
28.
HowarthDJQuagliaL (2013)
Banking Union as Holy Grail: Rebuilding the single market in financial services, stabilizing Europe’s banks and ‘Completing’ economic and monetary union.Journal of Common Market Studies51(Annual Review): 103–123.
29.
KernA (2014)
The ECB and banking supervision: Building effective prudential supervision?Yearbook of European Law33(1): 417–432.
30.
KoopmannM (2004) A Driving Force Despite Everything. Franco-German Relations and the Enlarged European Union.
Brussels:
Notre Europe.
31.
KrollDALeuffenD (2014)
Enhanced cooperation in practice. An analysis of differentiated integration in EU secondary law.Journal of European Public Policy22(3): 353–373.
32.
KrotzUSchildJ (2013) Shaping Europe: France, Germany, and Embedded Bilateralism from the Elysée Treaty to Twenty-First Century Politics.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
33.
LehnerTWasserfallenF (2019)
Political conflict in the reform of the Eurozone. European Union Politics20(1): 45–64.
34.
LeuffenDDegnerHRadtkeK (2012)
Which mechanics drive the 'Franco-German Engine'? An analysis of how and why France and Germany have managed to shape much of Today's EU. L'Europe en Formation. Journal of Studies on European Integration and Federalism53(4): 47–83.
35.
LorentzenPFravelMTPaineJ (2017)
Qualitative investigation of theoretical models: The value of process tracing.The Journal of Theoretical Politics29(3): 467–491.
36.
LundgrenMBailerSDellmuthLMet al. (2019)
Bargaining success in the reform of the Eurozone. European Union Politics20(1): 65–88.
37.
MazzucelliC (1997) France and Germany at Maastricht.
London:
Garland.
38.
MenzGSmithMP (2013)
Kicking the can down the road to more Europe? Salvaging the Euro and the future of European economic governance.Journal of European Integration35(3): 195–206.
39.
Ministry for the Economy, Industry and Employment (2010) Franco-German Proposals for European Economic Governance – Communiqué Issued by the Ministry for the Economy, Industry and Employment. Paris: Author. Available at: https://uk.ambafrance.org/Franco-German-proposals-on (accessed 1 October 2018).
40.
NaurinDLindahlR (2008) East-North-South: Coalition-building in the council before and after enlargement. In: NaurinDWallaceH (eds) Unveiling the Council of the European Union. Games Governments Play in Brussels.
Basingstoke:
Palgrave Macmillan, pp.64–78.
41.
NielsenBSmeetsS (2017)
The role of EU institutions in establishing the banking union. Collaborative leadership in the EMU reform process. Journal of European Public Policy24: 1–24.
42.
PatersonWE (2009) Did France and Germany lead Europe? A retrospect. In: HaywardJ (ed.) Leaderless Europe.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press, pp.89–110.
43.
PuetterU (2014) The European Council and the Council. New Intergovernmentalism and Institutional Change.
Oxford:
Oxford University Press.
ScharpfFW (1997) Games Real Actors Play. Actor-Centered Institutionalism in Policy Research.
Boulder:
Westview.
48.
SchildJ (2010)
Mission impossible? The potential for Franco-German leadership in the enlarged EU.Journal of Common Market Studies48(5): 1367–1390.
49.
SchildJ (2013a)
Leadership in hard times. Germany, France, and the management of the Eurozone Crisis. German Politics and Society31(1): 24–47.
50.
SchildJ (2013b)
Politischer Fu¨hrungsanspruch auf schwindender Machtbasis: Frankreichs Europapolitik unter François Hollande.Integration 22(1): 1–14.
51.
SchildJ (2017)
Germany and France at cross purposes: The case of Banking Union. Journal of Economic Policy Reform 20:
1–16.
52.
SchimmelfennigF (2015)
Liberal intergovernmentalism and the Euro area crisis.Journal of European Public Policy22(2): 177–195.
53.
SchneiderCJSlantchevBL (2018)
The Domestic politics of international cooperation: Germany and the European Debt crisis.Internationale Organization72(1): 1–31.
54.
TallbergJ (2008)
Bargaining power in the European Council.Journal of Common Market Studies46(3): 685–708.
55.
TarleaSBailerSDegnerHet al. (2019)
Explaining governmental preferences on economic and monetary union reform. European Union Politics20(1): 24–44.
ThompsonH (2015)
Germany and the Euro-Zone Crisis: The European reformation of the German Banking Crisis and the future of the Euro.New Political Economy20(6): 851–870.
61.
ThomsonRArreguiJLeuffenDet al. (2012)
A new dataset on decision-making in the European Union before and after the 2004 and 2007 enlargements (DEUII).Journal of European Public Policy19(4): 604–622.
62.
ThurnerPWPappiFUStoiberM (2002) EU Intergovernmental Conferences. A Quantitative Analytical Reconstruction and Data-Handbook of Domestic Preference Formation, Transnational Networks and Dynamics of Compromise during the Amsterdam Treaty Negotiations.
Mannheim:
Mannheimer Zentrum für Europäische Sozialforschung.
63.
TsebelisG (2002) Veto Players.
Princeton:
Princeton University Press.
64.
TsebelisGHahmH (2014)
Suspending vetoes: How the euro countries achieved unanimity in the fiscal compact.Journal of European Public Policy21(10): 1388–1411.
65.
WasserfallenFLeuffenDKudrnaZet al. (2019)
Analysing European Union decision-making during the Eurozone Crisis with new data. European Union Politics20(1): 3–23.
66.
WebberD (1999a) Introduction. In: WebberD (ed.) The Franco-German Relationship in the European Union.
London:
Routledge, pp.1–20.
67.
WebberD (ed.) (1999b) The Franco-German Relationship in the European Union. London and New York: Routledge.
68.
WoodPC (1995) The Franco-German Relationship in the Post-Maastricht Era. In: RhodesCMazeyS (eds) The State of the European Union. Vol. 3: Building a European Polity?
Boulder, CO:
Lynne Rienner, pp.221–243.
