By compiling data on 12 politico-institutional variables for 25 member states of the European Union over the years 1997—2006, we were able to investigate the emerging patterns of democracy in the European Union. The study addresses the questions of how direct democracy can be incorporated into Lijphart’s (1999) typology of consensus and majoritarian democracy and how empirical democratic patterns are affected by this extension. For the western democracies, three dimensions of democracy were extracted using principal component analysis, with two resembling those found by Lijphart (1999) and a third one being shaped by the interplay between direct democracy and cabinet type. East European democracies tend to have a lower degree of interest group corporatism, weaker central banks, stronger judicial review and stronger direct democracy.
Anderson, Jeffrey J. ( 2002) ‘Europeanization and the Transformation of the Democratic Polity, 1945-2000’, Journal of Common Market Studies40(5): 793-822.
2.
Armingeon, Klaus ( 2004) ‘Institutional Change in OECD Democracies, 1970-2000’, Comparative European Politics2(2): 212-38.
3.
Armingeon, Klaus and Romana Careja ( 2004) ‘Comparative Data Set for 28 PostCommunist Countries, 1989-2004’, Institute of Political Science, University of Berne.
4.
Armingeon, Klaus and Romana Careja ( 2008) ‘Institutional Change and Stability in Post-Communist Countries, 1990-2002’, European Journal of Political Research47(4): 436-66.
5.
Armingeon, Klaus, Philipp Leimgruber, Michele Beyeler and Sarah Menegale ( 2006) ‘Comparative Political Data Set 1960-2004’ (updated), Institute of Political Science, University of Berne.
6.
Auer, Andreas and Michael Bützer (eds) (2001) Direct Democracy: The Eastern and Central European Experience. Aldershot : Ashgate.
7.
Bogaards, Matthijs ( 2000) ‘The Uneasy Relationship between Empirical and Normative Types in Consociational Theory’, Journal of Theoretical Politics12(4): 395-423.
8.
Budge, Ian ( 1996) The New Challenge of Direct Democracy. Cambridge: Polity Press.
9.
Castles, Francis G. ( 1999) ‘Decentralization and the Post-War Political Economy’ , European Journal of Political Research36(1): 27-53.
10.
Cukierman, Alex ( 1992) Central Bank Strategy, Credibility and Independence - Theory and Evidence. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
11.
Cukierman, Alex, Geoffrey P. Miller and Bilin Neyapti ( 2002) ‘Bank Reform, Liberalization and Inflation in Transition Economies - An International Perspective’, Journal of Monetary Economics49(2): 237-64.
12.
De Winter, Lieven ( 2005) ‘Theoretical, Conceptual and Methodological Problems in Applying Lijphart’s Patterns of Democracy to Autonomous Regions in Europe’, paper presented at the ECPR Joint Sessions, 14-19 April 2005, Granada.
13.
Döring, Herbert ( 2001) ‘Parliamentary Agenda Control and Legislative Outcomes in Western Europe’, Legislative Studies Quarterly26(1): 145-65.
14.
Driffill, John ( 2006) ‘The Centralization of Wage Bargaining Revisited: What Have We Learnt?’, Journal of Common Market Studies44(4): 731-56.
15.
Eder, Christina and Raphael Magin ( 2008) ‘Direkte Demokratie’, in Markus Freitag and Adrian Vatter (eds) Die Demokratien der deutschen Bundesländer. Eine vergleichende Analyse ihrer politischen Institutionen, pp. 257-308. Opladen : Barbara Budrich (UTB).
16.
Flinders, Matthew ( 2005) ‘Majoritarian Democracy in Britain: New Labour and the Constitution’, West European Politics28(1): 61-93.
17.
Fortin, Jessica ( 2005) ‘Patterns of Democracy? Counter-Evidence from Nineteen Post-Communist Countries’, paper presented at the ECPR Joint Sessions, 14-19 April 2005, Granada.
18.
Freitag, Markus and Adrian Vatter (eds) (2008) Die Demokratien der deutschen Bundesländer. Eine vergleichende Analyse ihrer politischen Institutionen . Opladen: Barbara Budrich (UTB) .
19.
Gallagher, Michael ( 1991) ‘Proportionality, Disproportionality and Electoral Systems’, Electoral Studies10(1): 33-51.
20.
Gallagher, Michael and Pier Vincenzo Uleri ( 1996) The Referendum Experience in Europe. London/New York: Routledge.
21.
Ganghof, Steffen ( 2005) ‘Normative Modelle, institutionelle Typen und beobachtbare Verhaltensmuster: Ein Vorschlag zum Vergleich parlamentarischer Demokratien’ , Politische Vierteljahresschrift46(3): 406-31.
22.
Garry, John, Michael Marsh and Richard Sinnott ( 2005) ‘"Second-order" versus "Issue-voting" Effects in EU Referendums: Evidence from the Irish Nice Treaty Referendums’, European Union Politics6(2): 201-21.
23.
Grofman, Bernard ( 2000) ‘Arend Lijphart and the New Institutionalism’ , in Markus Crepaz, Thomas Koelble and David Wilsford (eds) Democracy and Institutions. The Life Work of Arend Lijphart, pp. 43-73. Ann Arbor: University of Michigan Press.
24.
Huber, Evelyne, Charles Ragin and John D. Stephens ( 1993) ‘Social Democracy, Christian Democracy, Constitutional Structure, and the Welfare State’, American Journal of Sociology99(3): 711-49.
25.
Hug, Simon ( 2004) ‘Occurrence and Policy Consequences of Referendums. A Theoretical Model and Empirical Evidence’, Journal of Theoretical Politics16(3): 321-56.
26.
Hug, Simon and George Tsebelis ( 2002) ‘Veto Players and Referendums around the World’ , Journal of Theoretical Politics14(4): 465-516.
27.
Ishiyama Smithey, Shannon and John Ishiyama ( 2000) ‘Judicious Choices: Designing Courts in Post-Communist Politics’, Communist and Post-Communist Studies33(2): 163-82.
28.
Ismayr, Wolfgang (ed.) (2004) Die politischen Systeme Osteuropas. Opladen: Leske und Budrich.
29.
Jung, Sabine ( 1996) ‘Lijpharts Demokratietypen und die direkte Demokratie’ , Zeitschrift für Politikwissenschaft6(3): 623-47.
30.
Jung, Sabine ( 2001) Die Logik der direkten Demokratie. Wiesbaden: Westdeutscher Verlag.
31.
Kaiser, André ( 1997) ‘Types of Democracy. From Classical to New Institutionalism’ , Journal of Theoretical Politics9(4): 419-44.
32.
Kaiser, André, Matthias Lehnert, Bernhard Miller and Ulrich Sieberer ( 2002) ‘The Democratic Quality of Institutional Regimes: A Conceptual Framework’, Political Studies50(2): 313-31.
33.
Keman, Hans ( 2000) ‘Federalism and Policy Performance’, in Ute Wachendorfer-Schmidt (ed.) Federalism and Political Performance, pp. 196-227. London/ New York: Routledge.
34.
Kenworthy, Lane ( 2003) ‘Quantitative Indicators of Corporatism’, International Journal of Sociology33(3): 10-44.
35.
Kraatz, Susanne and Silvia von Steinsdorff (eds) (2002) Parlamente und System-transformation im postsozialistischen Europa. Opladen : Leske und Budrich.
36.
Kurian, George T. (ed.) (1997) World Encyclopedia of Parliaments and Legislatures. New York: Congressional Quarterly Press.
37.
Laakso, Markku and Rein Taagepera ( 1979) ‘’’Effective’’ Number of Parties: A Measure with Application to West Europe’, Comparative Political Studies12(1): 3-27.
38.
LeDuc, Lawrence ( 2003) The Politics of Direct Democracy: Referendums in Global Perspective. Peterborough: Broadview Press.
39.
Lehmbruch, Gerhard ( 1967) Proporzdemokratie: Politisches System und politische Kultur in der Schweiz und in Österreich. Tübingen: Mohr Siebeck.
40.
Lijphart, Arend ( 1968) The Politics of Accommodation: Pluralism and Democracy in the Netherlands. Berkeley: University of California Press.
41.
Lijphart, Arend ( 1977) Democracy in Plural Societies. London : Yale University Press.
42.
Lijphart, Arend ( 1984) Democracies. New Haven/ London: Yale University Press.
43.
Lijphart, Arend ( 1999) Patterns of Democracy. New Haven/ London: Yale University Press.
44.
Lijphart, Arend ( 2003) ‘Measurement Validity and Institutional Engineering. Reflections on Rein Taagepera’s Meta-Study’, Political Studies51(1): 20-5.
45.
Lubbers, Marcel ( 2008) ‘Regarding the Dutch "Nee" to the European Constitution: A Test of the Identity, Utilitarian and Political Approaches to Voting "No"’ , European Union Politics9(1): 59-86.
46.
Lundell, Krister and Lauri Karvonen ( 2003) ‘A Comparative Data Set on Political Institutions’, Abo Akademi, Department of Political Science, Finland.
47.
Mainwaring, Scott ( 2001) ‘Two Models of Democracy’, Journal of Democracy12(3): 170-5.
48.
Neidhart, Leonhard ( 1970) Plebiszit und pluralitäre Demokratie. Eine Analyse der Funktion des schweizerischen Gesetzesreferendums. Bern: Francke.
49.
Norton, Philip and David M. Olson (eds) (2007) Post-Communist and Post-Soviet Legislatures: Beyond Transition. Special Issue of the Journal of Legislative Studies13(1).
50.
OECD (2004) Employment Outlook . Paris: Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development.
51.
Ost, David ( 2000) ‘Illusory Corporatism in Eastern Europe: Neoliberal Tripartism and Postcommunist Class Identities’, Politics and Society28(4): 503-30.
52.
Papadopoulos, Yannis ( 2001) ‘How Does Direct Democracy Matter? The Impact of Referendum Votes on Politics and Policy-Making’, West European Politics24(2): 35-57.
53.
Powell Jr., Bingham G. ( 1982) Contemporary Democracies: Participation, Stability, and Violence. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.
54.
Prochazka, Radoslav ( 2002) Mission Accomplished: On Founding Constitutional Adjudication in Central Europe. Budapest: Central European University Press.
55.
Qvortrup, Mads ( 2002) A Comparative Study of Referendums. Manchester: Manchester University Press.
56.
Roberts, Andrew ( 2006) ‘What Kind of Democracy Is Emerging in Eastern Europe?’ , Post Soviet Affairs22(1): 37-64.
57.
Rodden, Jonathan ( 2004) ‘Comparative Federalism and Decentralization. On Meaning and Measurement’, Comparative Politics36(4): 481-500.
58.
Sadeh, Tal ( 2005) ‘Who Can Adjust to the Euro?’, The World Economy28(11): 1651-78.
59.
Sadeh, Tal ( 2006) Sustaining European Monetary Union - Confronting the Cost of Diversity. Boulder, CO: Lynne Rienner.
60.
Sadurski, Wojciech (ed.) (2003) Constitutional Justice, East and West: Democratic Legitimacy and Constitutional Courts in Post-Communist Europe in a Comparative Perspective. London: Kluwer Law International.
61.
Schmidt, Manfred G. ( 2000) Demokratietheorien. Opladen: Leske und Budrich.
62.
Schnapp, Kai-Uwe and Philipp Harfst ( 2005) ‘Parlamentarische Informationsund Kontrollressourcen in 22 westlichen Demokratien’, Zeitschrift für Parlamentsfragen36(2): 348-72.
63.
Schroeder, Wolfgang ( 2003) ‘Arbeitsbeziehungen in Mittelosteuropa - die Bedeutung der Tarifpolitik’, WSI-Mitteilungen56(1): 51-9.
64.
Schwartz, Herman ( 2000) The Struggle for Constitutional Justice in Post-Communist Europe. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
65.
Setälä, Maija ( 2006) ‘On the Problems of Responsibility and Accountability in Referendums’, European Journal of Political Research45(4): 699-721.
66.
Shikano, Susumu ( 2006) ‘Bootstrap und Jackknife’, in Joachim Behnke, Thomas Gschwend , Delia Schindler and Kai-Uwe Schnapp (eds) Methoden der Politikwissenschaft. Neuere qualitative und quantitative Analyseverfahren, pp. 69-79. Baden-Baden : Nomos.
67.
Siaroff, Alan ( 1999) ‘Corporatism in 24 Industrial Democracies: Meaning and Measurement’, European Journal of Political Research36(2): 175-205.
68.
Siaroff, Alan ( 2003) ‘Varieties of Parliamentarianism in the Advanced Industrial Democracies’, International Political Science Review24(4): 445-64.
69.
Smith, Gordon ( 1976) ‘The Functional Properties of the Referendum’ , European Journal of Political Research4(1): 1-23.
70.
Steenbergen, Marco R., Erica E. Edwards and Catherine E. de Vries ( 2007) ‘Who’s Cueing Whom? Mass-Elite Linkages and the Future of European Integration’, European Union Politics8(1): 13-35.
71.
Suksi, Markku ( 1993) Bringing in the People. Dordrecht: Martinus Nijhof.
72.
Taagepera, Rein ( 2003) ‘Arend Lijphart’s Dimensions of Democracy: Logical Connections and Institutional Design’, Political Studies51(1): 1-19.
73.
Tsebelis, George ( 2002) Veto Players: How Political Institutions Work. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.
74.
Uleri, Pier Vincenzo ( 1996) ‘Introduction’, in Michael Gallagher and Pier Vincenzo Uleri (eds) The Referendum Experience in Europe, pp.1-19. London /New York: Macmillan.
75.
Vatter, Adrian ( 2000) ‘Consensus and Direct Democracy: Conceptual and Empirical Linkages’, European Journal of Political Research38(1): 171-92.
76.
Vatter, Adrian ( 2005) ‘Bicameralism and Policy Performance: The Effects of Cameral Structure in Comparative Perspective’, Journal of Legislative Studies11(2): 194-205.
77.
Vatter, Adrian ( 2007) ‘Lijphart Goes Regional: Different Patterns of Consensus in Swiss Democracies’, West European Politics30(1): 148-71.
78.
Zielonka, Jan (ed.) (2001) Democratic Consolidation in Eastern Europe. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
