This article examines whether there is a political budget cycle (PBC) in countries in
the euro area. Using a multivari ate model for 1999–2004 and various
election indicators we find strong evidence that, since the start of the Stability
and Growth Pact, fiscal policy-makers in the euro area have pursued expansionary
policies before elections. In an elec tion year – but not in the year
prior to the election – the budget deficit increases. This result is in
line with third-generation PBC models, which are based on moral hazard. We also find
a significant but small partisan effect on fiscal policy outcomes.
Alesina, Alberto
,
Nouriel Roubini
and
Gerald Cohen
(1997) Political Cycles and the Macroeconomy.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
2.
Alt, James E.
and
David Dreyer Lassen
(2006) ‘
Transparency, Political Polarization, and Political Budget Cycles in OECD Countries
’, American Journal of Political Science, forthcoming.
3.
Amtenbrink, Fabian
and
Jakob De Haan
(2003) ‘
Economic Governance in the European Union – Fiscal Policy
Discipline versus Flexibility
’, Common Market Law Review40:
1075–1106
.
4.
Andrikopoulos, Andreas
,
Ioannis Loizides
and
Kyprianos Prodromidis
(2004) ‘
Fiscal Policy and Political Business Cycles in the EU
’, European Journal of Political Economy20:
125–152
.
5.
Benoit, Kenneth
and
Michael Laver
(2006) Party Policy in Modern Democracies.
London: Routledge
, forthcoming.
6.
Block, Steven A.
(2002) ‘
Political Business Cycles, Democratization, and Economic Reform: The Case
of Africa
’, Journal of Development Economics67:
205–228
.
7.
Brender, Adi
(2003) ‘
The Effect of Fiscal Performance on Local Government Election Results in
Israel: 1989–1998
’, Journal of Public Economics87(9–10):
2187–2205
.
8.
Brender, Adi
and
Allan Drazen
(2005) ‘
Where Does the Political Business Cycle Really Come From?
’, Journal of Monetary Economics,
52(7):
1271–1295
.
9.
Buti, Mario
and
Paul van den Noord
(2003) ‘Discretionary Fiscal Policy and Elections:
The Experience of the Early Years of EMU’, OECD Economics
Department Working Paper, No. 351.
10.
De Haan, Jakob
and
Jan-Egbert Sturm
(1994) ‘
Political and Institutional Determinants of Fiscal Policy in the European Community
’, Public Choice80:
157–172
.
11.
De Haan, Jakob
and
Jan-Egbert Sturm
(1997) ‘
Political and Economic Determinants of OECD Budget Deficits and Government
Expenditures: A Reinvestigation
’, European Journal of Political Economy13:
739–750
.
12.
De Haan, Jakob
,
Helge Berger
and
David-Jan Jansen
(2003) ‘The End of the Stability and Growth
Pact?’, CESifo Working Paper No. 1093.
13.
De Haan, Jakob
,
Helge Berger
and
David-Jan Jansen
(2004) ‘
Why Did the Stability and Growth Pact Fail?
’, International Finance7(2):
235–260
.
14.
Drazen, Allan
(2001) ‘The Political Business Cycle after 25
Years’, in
Ben S. Bernanke
and
Kenneth S. Rogoff
(eds) NBER Macroeconomic Annual, pp.
75–117.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
15.
Drazen, Allan
and
Marcella Eslava
(2003) ‘Reconciling Fiscal Conservatism and
Political Fiscal Cycles’,
mimeo, University of Maryland
.
16.
Franzese, Robert J.
(2000) ‘Electoral and Partisan Manipulation of
Public Debt in Developed Democracies, 1956–1990’,
in
Rolph Strauch
and
Jürgen von Hagen
(eds) Institutions, Politics and Fiscal Policy, pp.
61–83.
Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Press
.
17.
Franzese, Robert J.
(2002) ‘
Electoral and Partisan Cycles in Economic Policies and Outcomes
’, Annual Review of Political Science5:
369–421
.
18.
Hallerberg, Mark
(2004) Domestic Budgets in a United Europe: Fiscal Governance
from the End of Bretton Woods to EMU.
Cornell: Cornell University Press
.
19.
Hallerberg, Mark
,
Lucio Vinhas da Souza
and
William Roberts Clark
(2002) ‘
Political Business Cycles in EU Accession Countries
’, European Union Politics3(2):
231–250
.
20.
Hibbs, Douglas
(1977) ‘
Political Parties and Macroeconomic Policy
’, American Political Science Review71(4):
1467–1487
.
21.
Katz, Richard S.
and
Ruud Koole
(1999) ‘
Political Data Yearbook 1999
’, European Journal of Political Research36:
317–547
.
22.
Katz, Richard S.
and
Ruud Koole
(2000) ‘
Political Data Yearbook 2000
’, European Journal of Political Research38:
303–556
.
23.
Katz, Richard S.
and
Ruud Koole
(2001) ‘
Political Data Yearbook 2001
’, European Journal of Political Research40:
223–457
.
24.
Katz, Richard S.
and
Ruud Koole
(2002) ‘
Political Data Yearbook 2002
’, European Journal of Political Research41:
885–1118
.
25.
Katz, Richard S.
and
Ruud Koole
(2003), ‘
Political Data Yearbook 2003
’, European Journal of Political Research42:
873–1123
.
26.
Lohmann, Susanne
(1998) ‘
Rationalizing the Political Business Cycle: A Workhorse Model
’, Economics and Politics10(1):
1–17
.
27.
Mayes, David
and
Matti Viren
(2000) ‘Pressures on the Stability and Growth Pact
from Asymmetry in Policy’, Bank of Finland Discussion Paper No. 11.
28.
Melitz, Jacques
(2000) ‘
Some Cross-Country Evidence about Fiscal Policy Behaviour and Consequences
for EMU
’, European Economy2:
3–21
.
29.
Nordhaus, William
(1975) ‘
The Political Business Cycle
’, Review of Economic Studies42:
169–190
.
30.
Perotti, Roberto
and
Yianos Kontopoulos
(2002) ‘
Fragmented Fiscal Policy
’, Journal of Public Economics86(2):
191–222
.
31.
Persson, Torsten
and
Guido Tabellini
(2000) Political Economics: Explaining Economic Policy.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press
.
32.
Persson, Torsten
and
Guido Tabellini
(2002) ‘Do Electoral Cycles Differ across Political
Systems?’, working paper.
33.
Rogoff, Kenneth S.
(1990) ‘
Equilibrium Political Budget Cycles
’, American Economic Review80:
21–36
.
34.
Rogoff, Kenneth S.
and
Anne Sibert
(1988) ‘
Elections and Macroeconomic Policy Cycles
’, Review of Economic Studies55:
1–16
.
35.
Roubini, Nouriel
and
Jeffrey Sachs
(1989) ‘
Government Spending and Budget Deficits in the Industrialized Countries
’, Economic Policy, No. 8:
99–132
.
36.
Schuknecht, Ludger S.
(1996), ‘
Political Business Cycles in Developing Countries
’, Kyklos49:
155–170
.
37.
Schuknecht, Ludger S.
(2000) ‘
Fiscal Policy Cycles and Public Expenditures in Developing Countries
’, Public Choice102:
115–130
.
38.
Schuknecht, Ludger S.
(2004) ‘EU Fiscal Rules: Issues and Lessons from
Political Economy’, ECB Working Paper No. 421.
39.
Shi, Min
and
Jakob Svensson
(2002) ‘Conditional Political Budget
Cycles’, CEPR Discussion Paper No. 3352.
40.
Shi, Min
and
Jakob Svensson
(2004) ‘Political Budget Cycles: A Review of Recent
Developments’, mimeo.
41.
Tujula, Mika
and
Guido Wolswijk
(2004) ‘What Determines Fiscal Balances? An
Empirical Investigation in Determinants of Changes in OECD Budget
Balances’, ECB Working Paper No. 422.
42.
Van Biezen, Ingrid
and
Richard S. Katz
(2004) ‘
Political Data Yearbook 2004
’, European Journal of Political Research43:
919–1175
.
43.
Volkerink, Bjørn
and
Jakob De Haan
(2001) ‘
Fragmented Government Effects on Fiscal Policy: New Evidence
’, Public Choice109:
221–242
.
44.
Von Hagen, Jürgen
(2003) ‘Fiscal Discipline and Growth in Euroland.
Experiences with the Stability and Growth Pact’, ZEI Working
Paper No. B062003.
