Measuring National Delegate Positions at the Convention on the Future of Europe Using Computerized Word Scoring

Abstract

The Convention on the Future of Europe that led to the eventual drafting of an EU Constitution involved numerous political actors from many countries. Their negotiations over the constitution generated a huge volume of texts containing substantive information about their preferences for EU institutional and political outcomes. In this paper, we attempt to measure these preferences at the national party level by analysing the Convention texts using the computerized ‘word-scoring’ method for text analysis (Laver et al., 2003). For each national party whose delegates’ texts were recorded at the Convention, we estimate their positions on four political dimensions. We then test the validity of these estimates by comparing them with measures of national party positions on EU policy dimensions obtained through an extensive expert survey undertaken in 27 countries (the EU 25 plus Turkey and Romania). Our results show strong evidence that the word-scoring method is broadly successful in reconstructing the map of national party preferences for and against a more centralized and more powerful Europe as expressed through the Convention texts.

Keywords

comparative party policy computerized content analysis EU Constitution European Union Laeken Convention word scores

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Benoit, Kenneth and Michael Laver (2003) ‘Estimating Irish Party Policy Positions Using Computer Wordscoring: The 2002 Election’ , Irish Political Studies 18(1): 97-107 .

Benoit, Kenneth and Michael Laver (2005) Party Policy in Modern Democracies. London: Routledge (forthcoming).

Cavnar, William B. and John M. Trenkle (1994) ‘N-Gram-Based Text Categorization’ , in Proceedings of Third Annual Symposium on Document Analysis and Information Retrieval, Las Vegas, NV, UNLV Publications/Reprographics, pp. 161-175 , 11-13 April 1994.

Collignon, S. (2003) The European Republic: Reflections on the Economy of a Future Constitution. London: Federal Trust for Education and Research/Bertelsmann Foundation .

Dunning, Ted (1994) ‘Statistical Identification of Language’, CRL Technical Report MCCS, 94-273, New Mexico State University .

Gabel, Matthew and Simon Hix (2002) ‘Defining the EU Political Space’ , Comparative Political Studies 35(8): 934-964 .

Giannetti, Daniela and Michael Laver (forthcoming) ‘Policy Positions and Jobs in the Government’ , European Journal of Political Research.

Hooghe, Lisbet , Gary Marks and Carole J. Wilson (2002) ‘Does Left/Right Structure Party Positions on European Integration?’ , Comparative Political Studies 35(8): 965-989 .

Laeken Declaration on the Future of the European Union (2001) in Presidency Conclusions of the Laeken European Council (14 and 15 December 2001), Annex I , Bulletin of the European Union, No. 12, pp. 19-23 .

10.

Laver, Michael and Kenneth Benoit (2002) ‘Locating TDs in Policy Spaces Using Computer Word-Scoring’ , Irish Political Studies 17(1): 59-72 .

11.

Laver, Michael and Ben Hunt (1992) Party and Policy Competition. London: Routledge .

12.

Laver, Michael , Kenneth Benoit and John Garry (2003) ‘Extracting Policy Positions from Political Texts Using Words as Data’ , American Political Science Review 97(2): 311-331 .

13.

Marks, Gary and Carole J. Wilson (2000) ‘The Past in the Present: A Cleavage Theory of Party Response to European Integration’ , British Journal of Political Science 30: 433-459 .

14.

Pennings, Paul , Madeleine O. Hosli and Christine Arnold (2004) ‘The EU Constitution and Positions on Governance’ , Paper presented at the workshop ‘Domestic Structures and Institution Building in the European Union’, ECPR 13-18 April 2004.

15.

Pennings, Paul (2002) ‘The Dimensionality of the EU Policy Space: The European Elections of 1999’ , European Union Politics (1): 59-80 .

16.

Sibun, Penelope and Jeffrey Reynar (1996) ‘Language Identification: Examining the Issues’ , in Symposium on Document Analysis and Information Retrieval, pp. 125-135 , Las Vegas.

17.

Thomson, Robert , Jovanka Boerefijn and Frans Stokman (2004) ‘Actor Alignments in European Union Decision Making’ , European Journal of Political Research 43: 237-261 .

18.

Treaty of Nice amending the Treaty on European Union , the Treaties establishing the European Communities and certain related acts (2001) Official Journal of the European Communities, No. C 80, 10 March, p. 1 .