The Millennium Village Project (MVP) has come to embody hope for a new development path that might succeed where previous efforts have failed. A closer consideration of this project, however, suggests that this hope might be misplaced. Because of a general dearth of critical thought in key areas of project conceptualization, the MVP risks reproducing the problems of previous top-down, expert-driven development efforts. This article examines the conceptual issues raised by this absence of critical thought, and the reasons why project supporters have generally overlooked these issues. It then presents a critical grassroots framework which, if incorporated into existing MVP practices, might allow for the creation of a realistic, sustainable development path in Africa.
Akinyele, I.O.1997:
Household food security in Africa
. Development2,
71–74
.
2.
Ali, R.
and
Pitkin, B.1991:
Searching for household food security in Africa
. Finance and Development28,
3–6
.
3.
Aryeetey, E.2004:
Household asset choice among the rural poor. ISSER-University of Ghana-Cornell University International Conference
on ‘Ghana at the Half Century’, Accra.
4.
Barrett, C.B.
,
Reardon, T.
and
Webb, P.2001:
Non-farm income diversification and household livelihood strategies in rural Africa: concepts, dynamics and policy implications
. Food Policy26,
315–31
.
5.
Barrientos, S.
,
Kritzinger, A.
,
Opondo, M.
and
Smith, S.2005:
Gender, work and vulnerability in African horticulture
. IDS Bulletin-Institute of Development Studies36,
74–79
.
6.
Barry, H.
and
Yoder, B.L.2002:
Multiple predictors of contribution by women to agriculture
. Cross-Cultural Research36,
286–97
.
7.
Bassett, T.2002:
Women's cotton and the spaces of gender politics in Northern Cote d'Ivoire
. Gender, Place and Culture9,
351–70
.
8.
Bhuyan, B.
and
Tripathy, S.K.1988:
Role of women in agriculture – a study in Ganjam-District of Orissa
. Journal of Rural Development7,
445–52
.
9.
Boserup, E.1970: Women's role in economic development.
George Allen and Unwin
.
10.
Broad, R.
and
Cavanaugh, J.2006:
The hijacking of the development debate: how Friedman and Sachs got it wrong
. World Policy Journal23(2),
21–30
.
11.
Bryceson, D.F.
, editor. 1995: Women wielding the hoe.
Berg Publishers
.
12.
Cabral, L.
,
Farrington, J.
and
Ludi, E.2006: The millennium villages project – a new approach to ending poverty in Africa?Natural Resource Perspectives 101,
Overseas Development Institute, London
.
13.
Carney, J.A.1996: Converting the wetlands, engendering the environment: the intersection of gender with agrarian change in the Gambia. In
Peet, R.
and
Watts, M.
, editors, Liberation ecologies: environment, development, social movements.
Routledge
.
14.
Carr, E.R.2005:
Development and the household: missing the point?Geojournal62,
71–83
.
15.
Chant, S.2005:
Household decisions, gender and development: a synthesis of recent research
. American Anthropologist107,
738–39
.
16.
Chikwendu, D.O.
and
Arokoyo, J.O.1997:
Women and sustainable agricultural development in Nigeria
. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture11,
53–69
.
17.
Clemens, M.A.
,
Kenny, C.J.
and
Moss, T.J.2004: The trouble with the MDGs: confronting expectations of aid and development success. Working Paper 40,
Center for Global Development, New York
.
18.
Clemens, M.A.
and
Radelet, S.2003: The millennium challenge account: how much is too much, how long is long enough?Working Paper 23,
Center for Global Development, New York
.
19.
Creevey, L.E.1986: The role of women in malian agriculture. In
Creevey, L.E.
, editor, Women farmers in Africa: rural development in Mali and the Sahel,
Syracuse University Press
, pp. 51–66.
20.
de Renzio, P.2005: Scaling up versus absorptive capacity: challenges and opportunities for reaching the MDGs in Africa. ODI Briefing Paper,
ODI, London
.
21.
Dixon, R.B.1982:
Women in agriculture – counting the labor-force in developing-countries
. Population and Development Review8,
539–66
.
22.
Doss, C.R.1996:
Intrahousehold resource allocation in an uncertain environment
. American Journal of Agricultural Economics78,
1335–39
.
23.
Easterly, W.2005: Reliving the ’50s: the big push, poverty traps, and takeoffs in economic development. Working Paper 65,
Center for Global Development, New York
.
24.
Egharevba, R.K.
and
Iweze, F.A.2004:
Sustainable agriculture and rural women: crop production and accompanied health hazards on women farmers in six rural communities in Edo State Nigeria
. Journal of Sustainable Agriculture24,
39–51
.
25.
Egyir, I.1998: Intra-household access to land and sources of inefficiency: a case study of Ghana. Working Paper,
Department of Agricultural Economics, University of Ghana, Legon, Accra
.
26.
Ellis, F.1998:
Household strategies in rural livelihood diversification
. The Journal of Development Studies35,
1–38
.
27.
Fapohunda, E.R.1988: The Nonpooling household. In
Dwyer, D.
and
Bruce, J.
, editors, A Home Divided: Women and Income in the Third World.
Stanford University Press
.
28.
Feldman, S.
and
Welsh, R.1995:
Feminist knowledge claims, local knowledge, and gender divisions of agricultural labor – constructing a successor science
. Rural Sociology60,
23–43
.
29.
Ferguson, A.E.1994:
Gendered science – a critique of agricultural-development
. American Anthropologist96,
540–52
.
30.
Gairola, J.
and
Todaria, N.P.1997:
The status of women in subsistence agriculture in the Garhwal Himalaya, India
. Mountain Research and Development, 17,
169–70
.
31.
García, V.V.2001:
Coffee production and house-hold dynamics: the popolucas of Ocotal Grande, Veracruz
. Agriculture and Human Values18,
57–70
.
32.
Geisler, G.1993:
Silences speak louder than claims: gender, household and agricultural development in Southern Africa
. World Development21,
1965–80
.
33.
Goebel, A.2002:
Gender, environment and development in Southern Africa
. Canadian Journal of Development Studies-Revue Canadienne D Etudes Du Developpement23,
293–316
.
34.
Goheen, M.1988: Land and the household economy: woman farmers of the grassfields today. In
Davison, J.
, editor, Agriculture, women and land: the African experience.
Westview Press
.
35.
Grier, B.1992:
Pawns, porters, and petty traders – women in the transition to cash crop agriculture in colonial Ghana
. Signs17,
304–28
.
36.
Guyer, J.I.1986: Intra-household processes and farming systems research: perspectives from anthropology. In
Mook, J.L.
, editor, Understanding Africa's rural households and farming systems.
Westview Press
, pp. 92–104.
37.
Haddad, L.
and
Hoddinott, J.1994:
Women's income and boy-girl anthropometric status in the C�te d'Ivoire
. World Development22,
543–53
.
38.
Haddad, L.
,
Hoddinott, J.
and
Alderman, H.1997: Intrahousehold resource allocation in developing countries: methods, models, and policy.
Johns Hopkins University Press
.
39.
Haddad, L.
and
Kanbur, R.1990:
How serious is the neglect of intra-household inequality?The Economic Journal100,
866–81
.
40.
Haller, H.2000:
Household decisions and equilibrium efficiency
. International Economic Review41,
723–44
.
41.
Hanlon, J.2004:
It is possible to just give money to the poor
. Development and Change35,
375–83
.
42.
Harrison, M.2001:
Women, land and agriculture
. Geography86,
267–68
.
43.
Harriss-White, B.1998: Female and male grain marketing systems: analytical and policy issues for West Africa and India. In
Jackson, C.
and
Pearson, R.
, editors: Feminist visions of development: gender analysis and policy.
Routledge
, pp. 189–213.
44.
Jackson, C.1993:
Doing what comes naturally? Women and environment in development
. World Development21,
1947–63
.
45.
Jackson, C.1998: Rescuing gender from the poverty trap. In
Jackson, C.
and
Pearson, R.
, editors, Feminist visions of development: gender analysis and policy.
Routledge
, pp. 39–64.
46.
Jha, N.2004:
Gender and decision making in Balinese agriculture
. American Ethnologist31,
552–72
.
47.
Kanbur, R.
and
Haddad, L.1994:
Are better off house-holds more equal or less equal?Oxford Economic Papers46
.
48.
Kennedy, E.
and
Peters, P.1992:
Household food security and child nutrition: the interaction of income and gender of household head
. World Development20,
1077–85
.
49.
Leach, M.
and
Fairhead, J.1995:
Ruined settlements and new gardens – gender and soil-ripening among Kuranko farmers in the forest Savanna Transition Zone
. IDS Bulletin-Institute of Development Studies26,
24–33
.
50.
Lewis, A.1954:
Economic development with unlimited supplies of labor
. The Manchester School of Economics and Social Studies22,
139–91
.
51.
Luckert, M.K.
,
Wilson, J.
,
Adamowicz, V.
and
Cunningham, A.B.2000:
Household resource allocations in response to risks and returns in a communal area of western Zimbabwe
. Ecological Economics33,
383–94
.
52.
Mama, A.2005:
Demythologising gender in development: feminist studies in African Contexts
. IDS Bulletin35,
121–24
.
53.
Maxwell, S.
and
Frankenberger, T.1992: Household food security: concepts, indicators, measurements.
United Nations Children's Fund – International Fund for Agricultural Development
.
54.
Mbata, J.N.
and
Amadi, C.J.1993:
The role of women in traditional agriculture – a case-study of women in food crops production in rivers state, Nigeria
. Discovery and Innovation5,
81–87
.
55.
Millennium Promise (ND) Millennium Villages Prospectus http://www.millenniumpromise.org/site/DocServer/MV_Prospectus_Sept12.pdf?docID=141, 5 December 2006.
56.
Millennium Promise Website (ND) http:/www.millenniumpromise.org/site/PageServer?pagename=mv_building, 5 February 2007.
57.
Millennium Villages Project. 2005: Annual Report, Millennium Research Villages: 2004–2005.
The Earth Institute, Columbia University
.
58.
Millennium Villages Project (ND). http://www.earthinstitute.columbia.edu/mvp/about/index, 5 December 2006.
59.
Moser, C.O.N.1993: Gender planning and development: theory, practice and training.
Routledge
.
60.
Peters, P.E.1995: Uses and abuses of the concept of ‘female-headed households’ in research on agrarian transformation and policy. In
Bryceson, D.F.
, editor, Women wielding the hoe: lessons from rural Africa for feminist theory and development practice.
Berg Publishers
, pp. 93–108.
61.
Phillips, T.P.
and
Taylor, D.S.1998:
Household food security: an assessment model
. Canadian Journal of Development Studies19,
257–75
.
62.
Riley, P.J.
and
Krogman, N.T.1993:
Gender-related factors influencing the viability of irrigation projects in Lesotho
. Journal of Asian and African Studies28,
162–79
.
63.
Rocheleau, D.
,
Thomas-Slayter, B.
and
Wangari, E.
, editors. 1996: Feminist political ecology: global issues and local experiences.
Routledge
.
64.
Rostow, W.W.1959:
The stages of economic growth
. Economic History Review12,
1–16
.
65.
Sachs, J.D.2005: The end of poverty: economic possibilities for our time,
Penguin Press
.
66.
Sachs, J.D.
and
McArthur, J.W.2005:
The millennium project: a plan for meeting the millennium development goals
. The Lancet365
.
67.
Sachs, J.D.
,
McArthur, J.W.
,
Schmidt-Traub, G.
,
Kruk, M.
,
Bahadur, C.
,
Faye, M.
and
McCord, G.2004: Ending Africa's poverty trap. Brookings Papers on Economic Activity.
68.
Thomas, D.1990:
Intrahousehold resource allocation: An inferential approach
. Journal of Human Resources25,
635–64
.
69.
Udry, C.1996:
Gender, agricultural production, and the theory of the household
. Journal of Political Economy104,
1010–46
.
