Contrary to the classical proposition, the works of Prebisch and Singer launched the
controversial hypothesis of long-term decline in the terms of trade of primary
products vis-à-vis manufactures and a corresponding decline in
the terms of trade of the South vis-à-vis the North. The present
study traces the origin and evolution of the hypothesis and reviews the related
statistical debate. It concludes that the empirical base of the Prebisch-Singer
hypothesis is much stronger than it appeared in earlier decades. Reviewing some of
the North-South models, the study also finds theoretical support for the
Prebisch-Singer hypothesis.
Ardeni, P. G.
and
Wright, B.1992:
The Prebisch-Singer hypothesis: a reappraisal independent of the
stationarity hypothesis
. Economic Journal102,
803-812
.
2.
Bairoch, P.1975: The economic development of the Third World since 1900.
London: Methuen
.
3.
Baldwin, R. E.1955:
Secular movements in the terms of trade
. American Economic Review45,
259-269
.
4.
Barros, A. R.
and
Amazonas, A.1993:
On the deterioration of the net barter terms of trade for primary commodities
. UNCTAD Review4,
99-116
.
5.
Bleaney, M.
and
Greenaway, D.1993:
Long-run trends in the relative price of primary commodities and in the
terms of trade of developing countries
. Oxford Economic Papers45,
349-363
.
6.
Bloch, H.
and
Sapsford, D.2000:
Whither the terms of trade? An elaboration of the Prebisch-Singer hypothesis
. Cambridge Journal of Economics24,
461-481
.
7.
Clark, C.1942: The economics of 1960.
London: Macmillan
.
8.
Cuddington, J.1992:
Long-run trends in 26 primary commodity prices: a disaggregated look at the
Prebisch-Singer hypothesis
. Journal of Developing Economies39,
207-227
.
9.
Cuddington, J.
and
Urzua, C. M.1989:
Trends and cycles in the net barter terms of trade: a new approach
. Economic Journal99,
426-442
.
10.
Darity, Jr., W.1990:
The fundamental determinants of the terms of trade reconsidered: long-run
and long-period equilibrium
. The American Economic Review80,
816-827
.
11.
Dutt, A. K.1988:
Monopoly power and uneven development: Baran revisited
. Journal of Development Studies24,
161-176
.
12.
Ellsworth, P. T.1956:
The terms of trade between primary producing and industrial countries
. Inter-American Affairs10,
47-65
.
Emmanuel, A.
1979:
The dynamics of unequal exchange/unequal development
. Paper presented to a conference on Dependence at the London
School of Economics.
15.
Evans, D.1987:
The long-term determinants of the North-South terms of trade and some
recent empirical evidence
. World Development15,
657-671
.
16.
Findlay, R.1980:
The terms of trade and equilibrium growth in the world economy
. The American Economic Review70,
291-299
.
17.
Findlay, R.1981: The fundamental determinants of the terms of
trade. In
Grassman, S.
and
Lundberg, E.
, editors, The world economic order.
London: Macmillan
, 425-457.
18.
Flanders, M.1964:
Prebisch on protectionism: an evaluation
. Economic Journal74,
305-326
.
19.
Frank, I.1976:
Towards a new framework for international commodity policy
. Finance and Development13,
17-20, 37-38
.
20.
Grilli, E. R.
and
Yang, M. C.1988:
Primary commodity prices, manufactured goods prices and the terms of trade
of developing countries: what the long-run shows
. The World Bank Economic Review2,
1-47
.
21.
Haberler, G.1961: Terms of trade and economic development. In
Ellis, H. S.
editor, Economic development for Latin America.
London: Macmillan
, 275-297.
22.
Helg, R.1990: A note on the stationarity of the primary commodities
relative price index. Queen Elizabeth House Development Studies
Working Papers (
Oxford University
), 31-31.
23.
Imlah, A. H.1950:
Terms of trade of the United Kingdom, 1798-1913
. Journal of Economic History10,
170-194
.
24.
Johnson, H. G.1967: Economic policies towards less developed countries.
London: Allen & Unwin
.
25.
Keynes, J. M.1912:
Official papers
. Economic Journal22,
630-631
.
26.
Kindleberger, C. P.1943:
Planning for foreign investment
. American Economic Review33,
347-354
.
27.
Kindleberger, C. P.1950: The dollar shortage.
New York: Willey
.
28.
Kindleberger, C. P.1955:
Comment
. American Economic Review45,
290-290
.
29.
Kindleberger, C. P.1956: The terms of trade: a European case study.
New York: Wiley
.
30.
Kindleberger, C. P.1958:
The terms of trade and economic development
. Review of Economics and Statistics40,
72-85
.
31.
Kuznets, S.1967:
Quantitative aspects of the economic growth of nations
. Economic Development and Cultural Change15,
1-140
.
32.
League of Nations1945: Industrialisation and foreign trade.
Geneva: League of Nations
.
33.
Lewis, W. A.1952:
World production, prices and trade, 1870-1950
. Manchester School of Economic and Social Studies20,
105-138
.
34.
Lewis, W. A.1964:
Economic development with unlimited supplies of labour
. Manchester School of Economic and Social Studies22,
139-191
.
35.
Lipsey, R. E.1963: Price and quantity trends in the foreign trade of United
States.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press for NBER
.
36.
Lutz, M. G.1999:
A general test of the Prebisch-Singer hypothesis
. Review of Development Economics3,
44-57
.
37.
Maizels, A.1994: Commodities in crisis. In
Sapsford, D.
and
Morgan, W.
editors, The economics of primary commodities.
Aldershot: Edward Elgar
, 9-29.
38.
Meier, G. M.1958:
International trade and international inequality
. Oxford Economic Papers10 (New Series),
277-289
.
39.
Mill, J. S.1848: Principles of political economy. Vol. II, Book IV.
New York: Colonial Press (reprint, 1900)
.
40.
Morgan, T.1957:
The long-run terms of trade between agriculture and manufacturing
. Econometrica25,
360-360
.
41.
Morgan, T.1963: Trends in terms of trade and their repercussions on primary
producers. In
Harrod, R.
and
Hague, D.
editors, International trade theory in a developing world.
London: Macmillan
, 52-95.
42.
Myrdal, G.1956: An international economy. Problems and prospects.
New York: Harper
.
43.
Powell, A.1991:
Commodity and developing country terms of trade: what does the long-run show?Economic Journal101,
1485-1496
.
44.
Prebisch, R.1950: The economic development of Latin America and its principal
problems.
New York: United Nations
.
45.
Prebisch, R.1959:
Commercial policy in the underdeveloped countries
. American Economic Review49,
251-273
.
46.
Prebisch, R.1964: Towards a new trade policy for development.
New York: United Nations for UNCTAD
.
47.
Robertson, D. H.1915: A study of industrial fluctuations.
London: King
.
48.
Rostow, R. R.1950:
The terms of trade in theory and practice
. Economic History Review3 (Second Series),
1-20
.
49.
Sapsford, D.1985:
Some further evidence in the statistical debate on the net barter terms of
trade between primary commodities and manufactures
. Economic Journal95,
781-788
.
50.
Sapsford, D.
,
Sarkar, P.
and
Singer, H. W.1992:
The Prebisch-Singer terms of trade controversy revisited
. Journal of International Development4,
315-332
.
51.
Sarkar, P. 1983: Terms of trade between primary products and manufactures.
M.Phil. Dissertation, Calcutta University.
52.
Sarkar, P.1986a:
Terms of trade experience of Britain since the nineteenth century
. Journal of Development Studies23,
20-39
.
53.
Sarkar, P.1986b:
The Singer-Prebisch hypothesis: a statistical evaluation’
. Cambridge Journal of Economics10,
355-371
.
54.
Sarkar, P.1986c:
Patterns of trade and movements of interregional terms of trade between the
developing and the developed market economies, 1950-1980
. Economic Bulletin for Asia and the Pacific37,
1-13
.
55.
Sarkar, P.1991:
Debt crisis of the less developed countries and the transfer debate once again
. Journal of Development Studies27,
84-101
.
56.
Sarkar, P.1992:
De-industrialisation through colonial trade
. Journal of Contemporary Asia22,
297-302
.
57.
Sarkar, P.1994:
Long-term behaviour of terms of trade of primary products vis à
vis manufactures: a critical review of recent dabate
. Economic and Political Weekly29,
1612-1614
.
58.
Sarkar, P.1997:
Growth and terms of trade: a North-South macroeconomic framework
. Journal of Macroeconomics19,
117-133
.
59.
Sarkar, P.2000:
North-South uneven development: what the data show
. Review23,
439-457
.
60.
Sarkar, P.
2001:
Export diversification, market shares and the issues of North-South terms
of trade
. Paper presented at the UNESCO Participation Programme on the
Teaching of Advanced Economics (1-3 December
1999), Centre for Studies in Social Sciences Calcutta (forthcoming).
61.
Sarkar, P.
and
Singer, H.1991:
Manufactured exports of developing countries and their terms of trade since 1965
. World Development19,
333-340
.
62.
Schloss, W. W.1977:
Declining terms of trade; myth or reality
. Economia Internazionale30,
466-469
.
63.
Schlote, W.1938: British overseas trade from 1700 to the 1930s.
Oxford: Basil Blackwell
(Eng. Trans. 1952).
64.
Singer, H.1950:
The distribution of gains between investing and borrowing countries
. American Economic Review, 40,
473-485
.
65.
Singer, H.1958:
Comment
. Review of Economics and Statistics40,
473-485
.
66.
Singer, H.1975: The strategy of international development.
London: Macmillan
.
67.
Singer, H.1984: Terms of trade controversy and the evolution of soft
financing: early years in the UN: 1947-1951. In
Meier, M.
and
Seers, D.
editors, Pioneers in development.
New York and Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
68.
Smith, A.1776: An inquiry into the nature and causes of the wealth of
nations.
London: George Routledge
(reprint, 1890.
69.
Spraos, J.1980:
The statistical debates on the net barter terms of trade between primary
commodities and manufactures
. Economic Journal90,
107-128
.
Streeten, P.1974: World trade in agricultural commodities and the terms of
trade with industrial goods. In
Islam, N.
editor, Agricultural policy in developing countries.
London: Macmillan
, 207-223.
72.
Thirlwall, A. P.
and
Bergevin, J.1985:
Trends, cycles and asymmetries in the terms of trade of primary commodities
from developed and less developed countries
. World Development13,
805-817
.
73.
Torrens, R.1821: An essay on the production of wealth.
New York: Kelley
(reprint 1965).
74.
United Nations1949a: Post-war price relations in trade between under-developed and
industrialized countries. Mimeograph.
75.
United Nations1949b: Relative prices of exports and imports of under-developed
countries.
New York: United Nations
.
76.
United Nations1982: Yearbook of international trade statistics, 1981.
United Nations: New York
.
77.
United Nations Conference Trade and Development (UNCTAD)1972: Handbook of international trade and development statistics,
1972.
New York: United Nations
78.
Viner, J.1953: International trade and economic development.
Oxford: Clarendon Press
.
