This exploratory study develops and tests a new approach to the study of expertise in journalism. It introduces a new method, News Sorting, which takes journalists out of their comfort zone by asking them to rank a sample of their recent publications and reflect on their challenges. This novel method is combined with two theoretical frameworks: Journalistic Content Knowledge, designed to study specialized beat journalists, and Naturalistic Decision Making, which examines the performance of experts in natural settings. These are tested on Israeli military journalists that are considered highly knowledgeable. Findings indicate that a minority of journalists develop not only intrinsic, beat-specific traits of expertise, but also extrinsic expertise that characterize experts in other occupations, such as pattern recognition and fine discrimination. The good news is that journalists can develop extrinsic traits. The bad news is that they only develop among a minority of highly experienced journalists, which might be too late in an era of shortening careers. Hence the need for measures to accelerate their expertise.
AlbaekE (2011) The interaction between experts and journalists in news journalism. Journalism12(3): 335–348.
2.
AlbaekEElmelund-PræstekærCHopmannDN, et al. (2017) Experts in election news coverage: process or substance?Nordicom Review32(1): 45–58.
3.
AndersonCW (2017) Knowledge, expertise, and professional practice in the sociology of Michael Schudson. Journalism Studies18(10): 1307–1317.
4.
AndersonCWBellEShirkyC (2015) Post-industrial journalism: aAdapting to the present. Geopolitics, History and International Relations7(2): 32.
5.
BarnhurstK (2014) The interpretive turn in news. In: ZimmermannCSchreiberM (eds) Journalism and Technological Change. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 111–141.
6.
BeaneM (2024) The Skill Code. HarperCollins.
7.
BerlinI (1953) The Hedgehog and the Fox. Weidenfeld and Nicolson.
8.
BoyceT (2006) Journalism and expertise. Journalism Studies7(6): 889–906.
9.
ChiMTH (2006) Two approaches to the study of experts’ characteristics. In: EricssonKACharnessNFeltovichPJ, et al. (eds) The Cambridge Handbook of Expertise and Expert Performance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 21–30.
10.
ChughR (2015) Do Australian universities encourage tacit knowledge transfer?Proceeding of the 7th International Joint Conference on Knowledge Discovery, Knowledge Engineering and Knowledge Management. Scitepress, 128–135.
11.
CoderreSMandinHHarasymPH, et al. (2003) Diagnostic reasoning strategies and diagnostic success. Medical Education37(8): 695–703.
12.
CollinsH (2010) Tacit and Explicit Knowledge. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
13.
CollinsH (2011) Language and practice. Social Studies of Science41(2): 271–300.
14.
CollinsHEvansR (2008) Rethinking Expertise. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
15.
DarntonR (1975) Writing news and telling stories. Daedalus104(2): 175–194.
16.
DauceF (2014) Military journalists and war correspondents from the USSR to Russia: subjectivity under fire. The Journal of Power Institutionsin Post-Soviet Societies 16. doi: 10.4000/pipss.4121.
17.
DonsbachW (2014) Journalism as the new knowledge profession and consequences for journalism education. Journalism15(6): 661–677.
18.
DreyfusHDreyfusSE (1986) Mind over Machine. New York, NY: Simon and Schuster.
19.
DunwoodyS (2014) Science journalism: prospects in the digital age. In: BucchiMTrenchB (eds) Routledge Handbook of Public Communication of Science and Technology. Milton Park, Abingdon: Routledge, 27–39.
20.
EricsonRVBaranekPChanJ (1989) Negotiating Control. Milton Keynes: Open University Press.
21.
EricssonAPoolR (2016) Peak. New York, NY: Houghton Mifflin Harcourt.
22.
EricssonKAHoffmanRRKozbeltA, et al. (eds) (2018) The Cambridge Handbook of Expertise and Expert Performance. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.
23.
EyalG (2013) For a sociology of expertise: the social origins of the autism epidemic. American Journal of Sociology118(4): 863–907.
24.
EyalG (2019) The Crisis of Expertise. Cambridge: Polity Press.
25.
FahmySJohnsonTJ (2005) “How we performed”: embedded journalists’ attitudes and perceptions towards covering the Iraq war. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly82(2): 301–317.
26.
FrenkelHNossekH (2013) Military censorship and self-censorship: coverage of the debate over the bar-Lev Line in the Israeli press 1973-1968. Kesher45: 83–94, [Hebrew].
27.
GabrielAViolatoC (2013) Problem-solving strategies in psychiatry: differences between experts and novices in diagnostic accuracy and reasoning. Advances in Medical Education and Practice4: 11–16.
GodlerYReichZMillerB (2019) Social epistemology as a new paradigm for journalism (and Journalism Studies). New Media and Society22(2): 213–229.
30.
HélieSSunR (2010) Incubation, insight, and creative problem solving: a unified theory and a connectionist model. Psychological Review117(3): 994.
31.
HellingerDJuddD (1991) The Democratic Façade. Pacific Grove, CA: Brooks Grove Publishing.
32.
HoffmanRRWardPFeltovichPJ, et al. (2014) Accelerated Expertise. NY: Psychology press.
33.
JackmanOReichZ (2023) The journalistic wishlist: exploring reporters’ desired skills using Delphi method. International Journal of Communication17: 4480–4503.
34.
JackmanOReichZ (2025) Reimagining the epistemology of news: the desired knowledge of military reporters. Journalism: 1–27. DOI: 10.1177/14648849251357799.
35.
KinesCM (2013) Aiding the enemy or promoting democracy? Defining the rights of journalists and whistleblowers to disclose national security information. West Virginia Law Review116: 735.
36.
KleinG (2008) Naturalistic decision making. Human Factors50(3): 456–460.
37.
KleinGA (2011) Streetlights and Shadows. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
38.
KleinGA (2017) Sources of Power. Cambridge, MA: MIT press.
39.
KleinGA (2022) Snapshots of the Mind. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
40.
KleinGAHoffmanRR (1992) Seeing the invisible: perceptual-cognitive aspects of expertise. In: RabinowitzM (ed) Cognitive Science Foundations of Instruction. Mahwah, NJ: Erlbaum, 203–226.
41.
KneeboneR (2020) Expert. UK: Penguin.
42.
LevyY (2010) Who Governs the Military?Magnes Press. [Hebrew].
43.
LewisJHuntJ (2011) Press coverage of the UK military budget: 1987 to 2009. Media, War & Conflict4(2): 162–184.
44.
LimorYNossekH (2006) The military and the media in the twenty-first century: towards a new model of relations. Israel Affairs12: 484–510.
45.
LippmannW (1922) Public Opinion. NY: Macmillan.
46.
LovedayTWigginsMFestaM, et al. (2013) Pattern recognition as an indicator of diagnostic expertisePattern Recognition-Applications and Methods: International Conference, ICPRAM 2012. Vilamoura, Algarve, Portugal, February 6-8, 2012 Revised Selected Papers. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 1–11.
47.
MaginMMaurerP (2019). In: NussbaumJF (ed) Beat Journalism and Reporting. Oxford research encyclopedia of communication.
NicholsT (2017) The Death of Expertise. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.
52.
NielsenRK (2017) Digital news as forms of knowledge: a new chapter in the sociology of knowledge. In: BoczkowskiPAndersonCW (eds) Remaking the News. Cambridge, Mass: MIT Press, 91–109.
53.
NossekHLimorY (2001) Fifty years. In A “marriage of convenience”: news media and military censorship in Israel. Communication Law and Policy6: 1–35.
54.
PattersonTE (2013) Informing the News. NY: Vintage.
55.
PerryY (2007) Cosmetic Changes or Substantial Changes? media-defense Relations in the Beginning of the 21 Century. Media Frames, 153–168. [Hebrew].
56.
PfauMHaighMGettleM, et al. (2004) Embedding journalists in military combat units: impact on newspaper story frames and tone. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly81(1): 74–88.
ReichZ (2010) Measuring the impact of PR on published news in increasingly fragmented news environments: a multifaceted approach. Journalism Studies11(6): 799–816.
59.
ReichZ (2012) Journalism as bipolar interactional expertise. Communication Theory22(4): 339–358.
60.
ReichZBarnoyA (2016) Reconstructing production process. In: AndersonCDomingoDHermidaA, et al. (eds) The Sage Handbook of Digital Journalism. London: Sage, 477–493.
61.
ReichZBarnoyA (2020) How news become “news” in increasingly complex ecosystems: summarizing almost two decades of newsmaking reconstructions. Journalism Studies21(7): 966–983.
62.
ReichZLahav (2021) What on earth do journalists know? A new model of knowledge brokers’ expertise. Communication Theory31(1): 62–81.
63.
ReichZJackmanOMishalyT, et al. (2021) The state of the news beat: expertise and division of labour in current newsrooms. Journalism Practice15(9): 1199–1202.
64.
ReichZLahavHBlumL (2025) It’s the authorship, stupid! Testing economic reporters’ expertise using news sorting interviews. In: Paper Presented at the Annual Conference of the Israel Communication Association. Haifa University.
65.
SchönDA (1983) The Reflective Practitioner. NY: Basic Books.
66.
SchudsonM (2006) The trouble with experts and why democracies need them. Theory and Society35(5/6): 491–506.
67.
SchudsonMAndersonCW (2009) Objectivity, professionalism, and truth seeking in journalism. In: Wahl-JorgensenKHanitzschT (eds) The Handbook of Journalism Studies. NY: Routledge, 88–101.
68.
SchultzI (2007) The journalistic gut feeling: Journalistic doxa, news habitus and orthodox news values. Journalism Practice1(2): 190–207.
69.
SennettR (2008) The Craftsman. Yale University Press.
70.
ShulmanLS (1986) Those who understand: knowledge growth in teaching. Educational Researcher15(2): 4–14.
71.
SilverDA (2008) National security and the press: the government's ability to prosecute journalists for the possession or publication of national security information. Communication Law and Policy13(4): 447–483.
72.
SmythD (2013) Avoiding bloodshed? US journalists and censorship in wartime. War & Society32(1): 64–94.
73.
StephensM (2014) Beyond News: The Future of Journalism. New York, NY: Columbia University Press.
74.
TuchmanG (1978) Making News. Free Press.
75.
TumberH (2004) Journalists, professionalism, and identification in times of war. In: AllanSZelizerB (eds) Reporting War. NY: Taylor & Francis, 190–205.
76.
WagnerMW (2015) Does specialization matter? How journalistic expertise explains differences in health-care coverage. In: Arnott-SmithCKeselmanA (eds) Meeting Health Information Needs Outside of Healthcare. Chandos, 321–340.
77.
WardSJ (2018) Epistemologies of journalism. Journalism19: 63–82.
78.
WardPSchraagenJMGoreJ, et al. (eds) (2019) The Oxford Handbook of Expertise. Oxford: Oxford University Press.
