What do news organizations treat as expertise when detailing their staff’s backgrounds and experiences? In this study, we apply the dual concepts of “connection-based reporting” and “political identity ownership” to examine New York Times “enhanced bios,” the paper’s initiative to publish more detailed information about newsroom staff highlighting what they describe as their “deep expertise,” unique perspectives, and personal backgrounds. Using a large corpus of bios (N = 1160) scraped from the paper’s website, we find that most bios stick to “safe” areas of identity disclosure including previous journalistic employment, awards won, books published, and academic credentials from often elite universities. In so doing, the initiative underscores the degree to which the paper’s reporting staff overrepresents those with elite backgrounds and geographic connections to cosmopolitan communities where wealth and power is concentrated. We theorize that the absence of disclosure emphasizing alternative personal characteristics or social identities suggests an adherence to constraining professional norms around what “counts” as expertise as well as a hesitance within the profession around foregrounding particular aspects of identity presumed to be politically salient. At the same time, we argue that these patterns may further alienate some audiences, especially those on the right in the US, who may view conventional, institutional signals of expertise as ideologically liberal.
AllenDS (2008) The trouble with transparency: the challenge of doing journalism ethics in a surveillance society. Journalism Studies9(3): 323–340.
2.
BakerDJRamirez-MendozaJMena ShookL, et al. (2023) (Pay)Walled Gardens: Status and Racialized Discourse Among Authors of Student Loan News Articles. (EdWorkingPaper: 23-856). Annenberg Institute at Brown University.
BeattyJEKirbySL (2006) Beyond the legal environment: how stigma influences invisible identity groups in the workplace. Employee Responsibilities and Rights Journal18(1): 29–44.
BossioDHoltonAE (2018) The identity dilemma: identity drivers and social media fatigue among journalists. Popular Communication16(4): 248–262.
7.
BurkhartFNSigelmanCK (1990) Byline bias? effects of gender on news article evaluations. Journalism Quarterly67(3): 492–500.
8.
CarvalhoJChungAKoliskaM (2021) Defying transparency: ghostwriting from the Jazz age to social media. Journalism22(3): 709–725.
9.
ChaSERobertsLM (2019) Leveraging minority identities at work: an individual-level framework of the identity mobilization process. Organization Science30(4): 735–760.
10.
CraftSHeimK (2008) Transparency in journalism: meanings, merits, and risks. In: The Handbook of Mass Media Ethics. Routledge: 231–242.
11.
CramerKJ (2016) The Politics of Resentment: Rural Consciousness in Wisconsin and the Rise Scott Walker. University of Chicago Press.
12.
CurryALStroudNJ (2021) The effects of journalistic transparency on credibility assessments and engagement intentions. Journalism22(4): 901–918.
13.
DeuzeM (2005) What is journalism? professional identity and ideology of journalists reconsidered. Journalism6(4): 442–464.
14.
DogruelLJoeckelSWilhelmC (2021) Are byline biases an issue of the past? the effect of author’s gender and emotion norm prescriptions on the evaluation of news articles on gender equality. Journalism24(3): 560–579.
15.
DolanK (2014) Gender stereotypes, candidate evaluations, and voting for women candidates: what really matters?Political Research Quarterly67(1): 96–107.
FisherC (2016) The trouble with ‘trust’ in news media. Communication Research and Practice2(4): 451–465.
19.
FletcherRAndıSBadrinathanS, et al. (2025) The link between changing news use and trust: longitudinal analysis of 46 countries. Journal of Communication75(1): 1–15.
GarbesL (2022) When the “blank slate” is a white one: white institutional isomorphism in the birth of national public radio. Sociology of Race and Ethnicity8(1): 79–94.
GrubenmannSMeckelM (2015) Journalists’ professional identity. Journalism Studies18(6): 732–748.
24.
GustafsonKLKenixLJ (2016) Visually framing press freedom and responsibility of a massacre: photographic and graphic images in Charlie Hebdo’s newspaper front pages around the world. Visual Communication Quarterly23(3): 147–160.
25.
HanitzschTÖrnebringH (2019) Professionalism, professional identity, and journalistic roles. In: The Handbook of Journalism Studies. 2nd edition. Routledge: 105–122.
26.
HanitzschTVosTP (2017) Journalistic roles and the struggle over institutional identity: the discursive constitution of journalism. Communication Theory27(2): 115–135.
27.
JenkinsJVolzY (2016) Players and contestation mechanisms in the journalism field. Journalism Studies19(7): 921–941.
28.
JohnsonKASt JohnBIII (2021) Transparency in the news: the impact of self-disclosure and process disclosure on the perceived credibility of the journalist, the story, and the organization. Journalism Studies22(7): 953–970.
29.
KaplanR (2009) The origins of objectivity in American journalism. In: The Routledge Companion to News and Journalism. Routledge: 25–37.
30.
KarlssonM (2010) Rituals of transparency: evaluating online news outlets’ uses of transparency rituals in the United States, United Kingdom and Sweden. Journalism Studies11(4): 535–545.
31.
KarlssonM (2020) Dispersing the opacity of transparency in journalism on the appeal of different forms of transparency to the general public. Journalism Studies21(13): 1795–1814.
32.
KoliskaM (2022) Trust and journalistic transparency online. Journalism Studies23(12): 1488–1509.
33.
KreissDLawrenceRGMcGregorSC (2020) Political identity ownership: symbolic contests to represent members of the public. Social Media + Society6(2): 2056305120926495.
34.
MasonL (2018) Uncivil Agreement: How Politics Became Our Identity. University of Chicago Press.
35.
MasulloGMWilhelmCLeeT, et al. (2022) Signaling news outlet trust in a google knowledge panel: a conjoint experiment in Brazil, Germany, and the United States. New Media & Society26: 5379–5402.
36.
McDermottML (1998) Race and gender cues in low-information elections. Political Research Quarterly51(4): 895–918.
37.
MeeksL (2020) Defining the enemy: how Donald Trump frames the news media. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly97(1): 211–234.
38.
MelladoCHermidaA (2021) The promoter, celebrity, and joker roles in journalists’ social media performance. Social Media + Society7(1): 2056305121990643.
39.
MillerKC (2023) The “price you pay” and the “badge of honor”: journalists, gender, and harassment. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly100(1): 193–213.
40.
MillerKCLewisSC (2020) Journalists, harassment, and emotional labor: the case of women in on-air roles at US local television stations. Journalism23(1): 79–97.
41.
MitchelsteinEBoczkowskiPJAndelsmanV, et al. (2019) Whose voices are heard? the byline gender gap on Argentine news sites. Journalism21(3): 307–332.
MottaM (2024) Anti-Scientific Americans: The Prevalence, Origins, and Political Consequences of Anti-Intellectualism in the US. Oxford University Press.
PowersE (2024) “Standard” appearance and “Accentless” speech: how performance neutrality limits diversity in broadcast news. Electronic News18(4): 196–212.
52.
ReichZ (2010) Constrained authors: bylines and authorship in news reporting. Journalism11(6): 707–725.
53.
ReichZBoudanaS (2013) The fickle forerunner: the rise of bylines and authorship in the French press. Journalism15(4): 407–426.
54.
RossKPadovaniC (2019) Getting to the top: women and decision-making in European news media industries. In: Journalism, Gender and Power. Routledge: 3–17.
55.
SanbonmatsuK (2002) Gender stereotypes and vote choice. American Journal of Political Science46: 20–34.
56.
SchmidtTR (2023) Challenging journalistic objectivity: how journalists of color call for a reckoning. Journalism25(3): 547–564.
VellosoC (2023) “‘I Have an Extra Level of Context that Some Reporters Don’t Have’: Journalistic Perspectives on the Role of Identity and Experience in the Production of More Equitable News Coverage.” (Publication No. 30573829). Doctoral Dissertation, ProQuest Dissertations & Theses Global. University of Maryland.
65.
VosTPCraftS (2017) The discursive construction of journalistic transparency. Journalism Studies18(12): 1505–1522.
66.
VosTFerrucciP (2018) Who am I? perceptions of digital journalists’ professional identity. In: The Routledge Handbook of Developments in Digital Journalism Studies. Routledge: 40–52.
67.
WaiJPerinaK (2018) Expertise in journalism: factors shaping a cognitive and culturally elite profession. Journal of Expertise1(1): 57–78. https://www.journalofexpertise.org/
68.
XiaYRobinsonSZahayM, et al. (2020) The evolving journalistic roles on social media: exploring “engagement” as relationship-building between journalists and citizens. Journalism Practice14(5): 556–573.
Supplementary Material
Please find the following supplemental material available below.
For Open Access articles published under a Creative Commons License, all supplemental material carries the same license as the article it is associated with.
For non-Open Access articles published, all supplemental material carries a non-exclusive license, and permission requests for re-use of supplemental material or any part of supplemental material shall be sent directly to the copyright owner as specified in the copyright notice associated with the article.
