Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

On 12 September 2001, as Hans-Peter Feldmann documented in his 2002 installation 9/12 Front Page, the front pages of newspapers from 151 countries showed similar photographs of a plane crashing into the World Trade Center. Despite this cross-cultural agreement on the most salient image at the time, in the decade since, distinct visual narratives of 9/11 have emerged in newspaper anniversary journalism.

This paper examines how The New York Times (US) and Le Monde (France) have used photographs, advertisements, and editorial cartoons in 9/11 anniversary journalism. Using theories of collective memory and photography, along with demographic data of 9/11 victims, I examine how photographic representations of the victims have changed, offering a less complex story of events. I document the images that have been recirculated and discuss why the emergence of visual icons matters to our collective memory of 9/11. And I explore how the papers’ proximity to the events influenced their visual anniversary journalism.

Keywords

Collective memory 9/11 newspapers anniversary journalism photography

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Adoni

Mane

(1984) Media and the social construction of reality: Toward an integration of theory and research. Communication Research 11(3): 323–340.

Anon (2011) The New York Times announces robust circulation including increase in Sunday Home Delivery. Entertainment Newsweekly, 18 November, 199.

Chanel (2006) Untitled [Advertisement]. The New York Times, 11 September, A2.

Colwell-Chanthaphonh

(2011) The disappeared: Power over the dead in the aftermath of 9/11. Anthropology Today 27(3): 5–11.

Crumley

(2007) A French debate over Guy Moquet. Time, 23 October. Available at: http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1674710,00.html (accessed 7 December 2012).

Drechsel

(2010) The Berlin Wall from a visual perspective: Comments on the construction of a political media icon. Visual Communication 9(1): 3–24.

Engel

(2009) Seeing ghosts: 9/11 and the visual imagination. Montreal: McGill-Queen’s University Press.

Edy

(2006) Troubled Pasts: News and the Collective Memory of Social Unrest. Philadelphia: Temple University Press.

Fahmy

Kim

(2008) Picturing the Iraq War: Constructing the image of war in the British and U.S. Press. International Communication Gazette 70(6): 443–462.

10.

Feinberg

Biros

Feldman

. (2004) Final report of the special master for the September 11th victim compensation fund of 2001 (Vol. 1). Available at: (accessed 25 November 2012).

11.

Gavriely-Nuri

Lachover

(2012) Reframing the past as a cosmopolitan memory: Obituaries in the Israeli Daily Haaretz Communication Theory 22(1): 48–65.

12.

Giuliani

(2004) Remarks by former mayor Rudolph Giuliani. The New York Times, 30 August. Available at: http://www.nytimes.com/2004/08/30/politics/campaign/TEXT-GIULIANI.html (accessed 8 December 2012).

13.

Gucci (2006) Untitled [Advertisement]. The New York Times, 11 September, A2.

14.

Hariman

Lucaites

(2003) Public identity and collective memory in U.S. iconic photography: The image of “accidental napalm”. Critical Studies in Media Communication 20(1): 35–66.

15.

Harris

Jr (2011) “Portraits of Grief” 10 years later: Lessons from the original New York Times 9/11 coverage. Poynter, 31 August. Available at: http://www.poynter.org/latest-news/top-stories/144274/portraits-of-grief-10-years-later-lessons-from-the-original-new-york-times-911-coverage/ (accessed 14 August 2013).

16.

Jamieson

(2008) One more portrait from a time of grief. The New York Times, 16 June. Available at: http://cityroom.blogs.nytimes.com/2008/06/16/one-more-portrait-from-a-time-of-grief/ (accessed 6 December 2012).

17.

JP Morgan (2001) Untitled [Advertisement]. The New York Times, 18 September, A13.

18.

Keith

(2010) Collective memory and the end of occupation: Remembering (and forgetting) the liberation of Paris in images. Visual Communication Quarterly 17(3): 134–146.

19.

Kitch

(2003) “Mourning in America”: Ritual, redemption, and recovery in news narrative after September 11. Journalism Studies 4(2): 213–224.

20.

Kitch

Hume

(2008) Journalism in a Culture of Grief. New York: Routledge.

21.

Knights of Columbus (2006) Untitled Advertisement. The New York Times, 11 September, NY12.

22.

Le Monde (2001a) Photograph. 14 September, 3.

23.

Le Monde (2001b) Photograph. 15 September, 7.

24.

Le Monde (2002) 11 Septembre 2001 [Caption]. 11 September, 3.

25.

Le Monde (2011) 11-Septembre: Le debut du declin Americain? 10 September, 15–22.

26.

Lockheed Martin (2011) Untitled [Advertisement]. The New York Times, 11 September, NY16.

27.

Lucaites

(1997) Visualizing “the people”: Individualism and collectivism in Let Us Now Praise Famous Men. Quarterly Journal of Speech 83: 269–288.

28.

McElya

(2011) Remebering 9/11’s Pentagon victims and reframing history in Arlington National Cemetery. Radical History Review 111: 51-63.

29.

McMellon

Long

(2006) Sympathy, patriotism, and cynicism: How advertisers and consumers reacted after 9/11/01. Journal of Current Issues and Research in Advertising 28(2): 1–18.

30.

Meyers

(2002) Still photographs, dynamic memories: A study of the visual presentation of Israel’s past in commemorative newspaper supplements. The Communication Review 5: 179–205.

31.

Mills

(2006) Untitled [Photograph]. The New York Times, 11 September, A13.

32.

New Country Motor Cars of Greenwich (2001) Untitled advertisement. The New York Times, 16 September, AU MB 14.

33.

New York Times (2006) Getting past the pain of 9/11, with steps both big and small. 11 September, A14–A15.

34.

New York Times (2011a) The decade [caption]. 11 September, NY 2.

35.

New York Times (2011b) Witness to apocalypse [22 photographs]. 11 September, NY 4–5.

36.

New York Times (2001) Untitled [Advertisement]. 17 September, B5.

37.

Nucor (2011) Untitled [Advertisement]. The New York Times, 11 September, NY 12.

38.

Nucor (n.d.) A nation that makes and builds things [Advertisement]. Available at: www.americanbuildings.com/upload/A%20Nation%20That%20Makes%20and%20Builds%20Things.pdf (accessed 7 December 2012).

39.

Plantu (2003) Untitled [Cartoon]. Le Monde, 11 September, 1.

40.

Plantu (2007) Untitled [Cartoon]. Le Monde, 12 September, 1.

41.

Schudson

(2001) The objectivity norm in American journalism. Journalism 2(2): 149–170.

42.

Schwartz

Berenson

. (2002) Deaths in World Trade Center terrorist attack. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 11 September. Center for Disease Control and Prevention 51: 16–18. Available at: http://www.cdc.gov/mmwr/preview/mmwrhtml/mm51spa6.htm#tab2

43.

Shoemaker

Reese

(1996) Mediating the message: Theories of influence on mass media content (2nd edn). White Plains: Longman.

44.

Sontag

(2006) The hole in the City’s heart. The New York Times, 11 September, NY 1–12.

45.

Spratt

(2008) When police dogs attacked: Iconic news photographs and construction of history, mythology, and political discourse. American Journalism 25(2): 85–105.

46.

Spratt

Peterson

Lagos

(2005) Of photographs and flags: Uses and perceptions of an iconic image before and after September 11, 2001. Popular Communication 3(2): 117–136.

47.

Stanley

(2012) Women’s absence from news photos: The role of tabloid strategies at elite and non-elite newspapers. Media, Culture and Society 34(8): 979–998.

48.

Sturken

(2007) Tourists of History: Memory, Kitsch, and Consumerism from Oklahoma City to Ground Zero. Durham: Duke University Press.

49.

Sutton

(2009) Photography, Cinema, Memory: The Crystal Image of Time. Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press.

50.

Teer-Tomaselli

(2006) Memory and markers: Collective memory and newsworthiness. In: Volkmer

(ed.) News and public memory: An International Study of Media Memories Across Generations. New York: Peter Lang, pp.225-249.

51.

Tourneau (2011) Untitled [Advertisement]. The New York Times, 11 September, A2.

52.

Tuchman

(1980) Making News: A Study in the Construction of Reality. New York: Free Press.

53.

US Census Bureau (2013) State and county QuickFacts. Available at: http://quickfactscensus.gov/qfd/states/36/3651000.html (accessed 10 September 2013).

54.

Veltri

(2012) Information flows and centrality among elite European newspapers. European Journal of Communication 27(4): 354–375.

55.

Vestberg

(2005) Photography as cultural memory: Imag(in)ing France in the 1950s. Journal of Romance Studies 5(2): 75–90.

56.

Weisberger

(2001) Untitled photograph of the World Trade Center [Photograph]. The New York Times, 11 September 2011, NY 2–3.

57.

Zelizer

(1995) Reading the past against the grain: The shape of memory studies. Critical Studies in Mass Communication 12(2): 214–239.

58.

Zelizer

(1998) Remembering to Forget: Holocaust Memory Through the Camera’s Eye. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

59.

Zelizer

(2008) Why memory’s work on journalism does not reflect journalism’s work on memory. Memory Studies 1(1): 79–87.

60.

Zelizer

(2011) Photography, journalism, and trauma. In: Zelizer

Allan

(eds) Journalism After September 11 (2nd edn). New York: Routledge, pp.48–68.

Newspapers commemorate 11 September: A cross-cultural investigation

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References