Urinal or conduit? Institutional information flow between the UK intelligence services and the news media

Abstract

Since the 1990s, the Secret Intelligence Service (MI6) and the Security Service (MI5) have developed formal links with most major UK news organisations in an effort to improve the agencies’ media presentation. This article discusses the impact and inherent problems of these relationships, including whether the news media can have official, formal but non-attributable links with these agencies without compromising their role as the fourth estate.

Utilising epistemologies for crime reporting and news sources, this article proposes an initial framework to analyse these institutional relationships. It also takes as a case study the controversy over whether MI5 deliberately played down their prior knowledge of 7/7 suicide bomber Mohammed Sidique Khan. The author was one of the journalists briefed by MI5 on Khan and has here taken the Khan controversy as a case study to investigate the Security Service’s information flow and whether the agency misled, and indeed intended to mislead, the media and the public.

Keywords

Accredited journalists intelligence agencies MI5 MI6 news sources primary definers Secret Service Security Service transparency

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Aldrich

(2001) The Hidden Hand: Britain, America and Cold War Secret Intelligence. London: John Murray, 132–134.

Andrew

(2004) Intelligence, international relations and ‘under-theorisation’. Intelligence and National Security 19(2): 170–184.

Becker

(1972) Whose side are we on? In: Douglas

(ed.) The Relevance of Sociology. New York: Appleton-Century-Crofts.

Bloch

Fitzgerald

(1984) British Intelligence and Covert Action: Africa, Middle East and Europe since 1945. London: Brandon Press.

Bright

(2002) Terror, security and the media. The Observer, 21 July.

Carlyle

(1841) On Heroes and Hero Worship. London: privately published.

Chibnall

(1977) Law and Order News. London: Tavistock.

Chibnall

(1982) The crime reporter. In: Cohen

Young

(eds) The Manufacture of News, 2nd edn. London: Sage.

Cottle

(1998) Ulrich Beck, ‘risk society’ and the media, a catastrophic view? European Journal of Communication 13(1): 5–32.

10.

Cudlipp

(1976) Walking on Water. London: Bodley Head.

11.

Curtis

(1984) Ireland: The Propaganda War. London: Pluto Press.

12.

Dorril

Ramsay

(1992) Smear! Wilson and the Secret State. London: HarperCollins.

13.

Dover

Goodman

(eds) (2009) Spinning Intelligence: Why Intelligence Needs the Media, Why the Media Needs Intelligence. London: Hurst.

14.

Drogin

(2007) Curveball: Spies, Lies, and the Con Man Who Caused a War. New York: Random House.

15.

Evans

(2007) Intelligence, Counter-terrorism and Trust. Address to the Society of Editors, Manchester.

16.

Franklin

Carlson

(2011) Journalists, Sources and Credibility: New Perspectives. London: Routledge.

17.

Glees

Davies

(2004) Spinning the Spies: Intelligence, Open Government and the Hutton Inquiry. London: Social Affairs Unit.

18.

Hall

Critcher

Jefferson

Robert

Clarke

(1978) Policing the Crisis, Mugging, the State and Law and Order. London: Palgrave Macmillan.

19.

Intelligence and Security Committee (2005) Annual Report 2004–5. London: HMSO, 31–32.

20.

Intelligence and Security Committee (2006) Report into the London Terrorist Attacks on 7 July 2005. London: HMSO.

21.

Intelligence and Security Committee (2009) Could 7/7 Have Been Prevented? Review of the Intelligence on the London Terrorist Attacks on 7 July 2005. London: HMSO.

22.

Keeble

(2008) Uncovered: British reporters who are spooks. The-Latest.com, 2 July. Available at: http://www.the-latest.com/uncovered-british-journalists-who-are-spooks

23.

Knightley

(2006) First Casualty: The War Correspondent as Hero and Myth-maker from the Crimea to Kosovo. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

24.

Lashmar

Oliver

(1998) Britain’s Secret Propaganda War: A History of the Foreign Office’s Information Research Dept, 1948–77. Stroud: Sutton.

25.

Leigh

Lashmar

(1985) Revealed: How MI5 vets BBC staff. The Observer, 18 August, p. 1.

26.

Leigh

(1988) The Wilson Plot: How the Spycatchers and Their American Allies Tried to Overthrow the British Government. New York: Pantheon Books.

27.

Leigh

(2000) Britain’s security services and journalists: The secret story. British Journalism Review 11(2): 21–26.

28.

Miller

(1994) Don’t Mention the War. London: Pluto Press.

29.

Norton-Taylor

White

(2004) Blair misused intelligence, says ex-spy officer. The Guardian, 29 October.

30.

Rose

(2007) Spies and their lies. New Statesman, 27 September. Available at: http://www.newstatesman.com/politics/2007/09/mi6-mi5-intelligence-briefings

31.

Schlesinger

Tumber

(1994) Reporting Crime. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

32.

Today (2003) Interview: John Reid v John Humphrys, 4 June. Transcript available at: http://www.guardian.co.uk/politics/2003/jun/04/iraq.iraq

33.

Whitaker

Lashmar

McSmith

(2003) Revealed: How Blair used discredited WMD ‘evidence’: UK intelligence chiefs warned claim that Iraq could activate banned weapons in 45 minutes came from unreliable defector. Independent on Sunday, 1 June.

34.

Wright

(1987) Spycatcher. London: William Heinneman.