Sage Journals: Discover world-class research

Abstract

The demise of Rocky Mountain News and printed Seattle Post-Intelligencer only weeks apart in 2009 met with an outpouring of mediated concern among the journalistic community. In the shadow of the two failed newspapers, journalists defended the medium while warning of the growth of online news forms. In analyzing this response, this essay reappraises literature on ‘paradigm repair’ in which public repudiations of supposedly individual deviance aim to protect journalistic values and practices from scrutiny. It argues for the need to extend paradigm repair to account for an interpretive shift from individualizing and ostracizing incidents to holding them to be generalizable indicators of widespread paradigmatic challenges. Dubbed ‘second-order paradigm repair’, this concept aims to improve understanding of journalism in a time of change.

Keywords

interpretive community journalism metajournalistic discourse newspapers paradigm repair

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Abbott

(1988) The System of Professions. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

Beebe

(2009) Are newspapers sinking? Salt Lake Tribune, 14 March.

Bennett

(1983) News: The Politics of Illusion. New York: Longman.

Bennett

(1990) Toward a theory of press-state relations in the United States. Journal of Communication 40: 103–125.

Bennett

Gressett

Haltom

(1985) Repairing the news: A case study of the news paradigm. Journal of Communication 35(1): 50–68.

Berger

(2010) A paradigm in process: What the scapegoating of Vusi Mona signaled about South African journalism. In: Berkowitz

(ed.) Cultural Meanings of News. Los Angeles, CA: SAGE, 225–240.

Berkowitz

(2000) Doing double duty: Paradigm repair and the Princess Diana what-a-story. Journalism 1(2): 125–143.

Bishop

(1999) From behind the walls: Boundary work by news organizations in their coverage of Princess Diana’s death. Journal of Communication Inquiry 23(1): 90–112.

Boston Globe (2009) What newspapers do. 16 April, A18.

10.

Buffalo News (2009) Keeping the media strong. 15 March, G4.

11.

BurrellesLuce (2009) Top Media Outlets: Newspapers, Blogs, Consumer Magazines and Social Networks. Available at: www.burrellesluce.com/top100/

12.

Carlson

(2007a) Making memories matter: Journalistic authority and the memorializing discourse around Mary McGrory and David Brinkley. Journalism 8(2): 165–183.

13.

Carlson

(2007b) Blogs and journalistic authority: The role of blogs in US election day 2004 coverage. Journalism Studies 8(2): 264–279.

14.

Carlson

(2009) The reality of a fake image: News norms, photojournalistic craft, and Brian Walski’s fabricated photo. Journalism Practice 3(2): 125–139.

15.

Carter

(2009) Who will pay for the news? The internet has walloped newspapers. Birmingham News, 8 March, F1.

16.

Cecil

(2002) Bad apples: Paradigm overhaul and the CNN/Time ‘tailwind’ story. Journal of Communication Inquiry 26(1): 46–58.

17.

(2009) It’s hard to be objective when newspapers die. Editor & Publisher, 24 March. Available at: www.editorandpublisher.com/eandp/search/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1003954722

18.

Columbia Journalism Review (2009) The grave dancer’s folly. July/August, p. 4.

19.

Colwell

(2009) No substitute for newspapers’ reporting. 8 March, D4.

20.

Cunningham

(2003) Re-thinking objectivity. Columbia Journalism Review July/August: 24–32.

21.

Dahlgren

(1992) Introduction. In: Dahlgren

Sparks

(eds) Journalism and Popular Culture. London: SAGE, 1–23.

22.

Denton Record-Chronicle (2009) The death of a newspaper. 28 February, A6.

23.

Deuze

(2005) What is journalism? Professional identity and ideology of journalists reconsidered. Journalism 6(4): 442–464.

24.

Eason

(1988) On journalistic authority: The Janet Cooke scandal. In: Carey

(ed.) Media, Myths, and Narratives: Television and the Press. Los Angeles, CA: SAGE, 205–227.

25.

Edgecliffe-Johnson

(2009) Colorado’s oldest newspaper shuts down. Financial Times, 2 February. Available at: www.ft.com/cms/s/0/e21652a2-0456–11de-845b-000077b07658.html

26.

English

(2009) Support your local newspapers – before it’s too late. Idaho Statesman, 29 March, p. 15.

27.

Esser

D’Angelo

(2006) Framing the press and publicity process in US, British, and German general election campaigns. Harvard International Journal of Press/Politics 11(3): 44–66.

28.

Frank

(2003) ‘These crowded circumstances’: When pack journalists bash pack journalism. Journalism 4(4): 441–458.

29.

Gieryn

(1999) Cultural Boundaries of Science. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

30.

Greenberg

(2009) The vanishing newspaper. Arkansas Democrat Gazette, 22 April, p. 16.

31.

Guy

(2009) Proud newspaper tradition more humble these days. Salt Lake Tribune, 7 March.

32.

Haas

(2006) Mainstream news media self-criticism: A proposal for future research. Critical Studies in Media Communication 23(4): 350–355.

33.

Hackett

(1984) Decline of a paradigm? Bias and objectivity in news media studies. Critical Studies in Mass Communication 1: 229–259.

34.

Hallin

(1986) The ‘Uncensored War’. New York: Oxford University Press.

35.

Hecox

(2009) Print isn’t dying, it only thinks it is. Laramie Boomerang, 24 March, A4.

36.

Hindman

(2003) The princess and the paparazzi: Blame, responsibility, and the media’s role in the death of Diana. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 80(3): 666–688.

37.

Hindman

(2005) Jayson Blair, the New York Times, and paradigm repair. Journal of Communication 55(2): 225–241.

38.

Kitch

(2002) Anniversary journalism: Collective memory and the cultural authority to tell the story of the American past. Journal of Popular Culture 36(1): 46–67.

39.

Kuhn

(1996[1962]) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions, 3rd edn. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

40.

Kurtz

(2009) Under weight of its mistakes, newspaper industry staggers. Washington Post, 1 March, A4.

41.

Lacy

(2009) Local advertising isn’t jumping online. BusinessWeek, 18 February. Available at: www.businessweek.com/technology/content/feb2009/tc20090213_028329.htm

42.

(2009) Endangered: Marketplace of ideas. Seattle Post-Intelligencer, 26 February, A13.

43.

McCoy

(2001) Dark alliance: News repair and institutional authority in the age of the internet. Journal of Communication 51(1): 164–193.

44.

Mulshine

(2009) No news is bad news for the internet. Star-Ledger, 24 March, p. 13.

45.

Newspaper Association of America (n.d.) Advertising Expenditures. Available at: www.naa.org/TrendsandNumbers/Advertising-Expenditures.aspx

46.

Omdahl

(2009) Democracy loses when newspapers decline. Grand Forks Herald, 30 March, A4.

47.

Outing

(2009) Can former newspaper employees invent a brave new news model? Editor & Publisher, 3 April. Available at: www.editorandpublisher.com/eandp/search/article_display.jsp?vnu_content_id=1003958801

48.

Overholser

(2004) The inadequacy of objectivity as a touchstone. Nieman Reports Winter: 53.

49.

Paper Cuts (2009) 14,783 + Jobs: 2009 Layoffs and Buyouts at US Newspapers. Available at: newspaperlayoffs.com/maps/2009-layoffs/

50.

Perez-Pena

(2009) Rocky Mountain News fails to find buyer and will close. New York Times, 27 February, B6.

51.

Pew Research Center (2008) Key News Audiences Now Blend Online and Traditional Sources. Available at: people-press.org/report/?pageid=1358

52.

Pew Research Center (2009) Many Would Shrug If Their Local Newspaper Closed. Available at: people-press.org/report/497/many-would-shrug-if-local-newspaper-closed

53.

Pew Research Center (2010) Americans Spending More Time Following the News. Available at: people-press.org/report/652/

54.

Philadelphia Inquirer (2009) The Rocky’s demise; All blogged up. 5 March, A14.

55.

Project for Excellence in Journalism (2009) State of the News Media (2009). Available at: www.stateofthemedia.org/2009/index.htm

56.

Reese

(1990) The news paradigm and the ideology of objectivity: A socialist at the Wall Street Journal. Critical Studies in Mass Communication 7(4): 390–409.

57.

Rocky Mountain News (2009) After the fall: Communities need newspaper-type coverage of local news. 27 February, p. 64.

58.

Ruggiero

(2004) Paradigm repair and changing journalistic perceptions of the internet as an objective news source. Convergence 10(4): 92–106.

59.

Saunders

(2009) Cutting off your news to spite your face. San Francisco Chronicle, 26 February, A13.

60.

Schudson

(1978) Discovering the News. New York: Basic Books.

61.

Schudson

(1995) The Power of News. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

62.

Shafer

(2009) Hello and goodbye to the P-I. Slate, 16 March. Available at: www.slate.com/id/2213883/

63.

Singer

(2003) Who are these guys? The online challenge to the notion of journalistic professionalism. Journalism 4(2): 139–163.

64.

Smolkin

(2009) Cities without newspapers. American Journalism Review June/July: 16–26.

65.

Stepp

(1999) State of the American newspaper: Then and now. American Journalism Review September: 60–76.

66.

Tatum

(2009) In Denver, residents lament the closing of a newspaper. New York Times, 2 March, B5.

67.

Taylor

(2009) Good journalism costs – and it’s worth it. Palm Beach Post, 12 April, A19.

68.

Temple

(2009) Why Denver can’t support two papers. Rocky Mountain News, 27 February, p. 47.

69.

Usher

(2010) Goodbye to the news: How out-of-work journalists assess enduring news values and the new media landscape. New Media & Society 12(6): 911–928.

70.

Winch

(1997) Mapping the Cultural Space of Journalism. Westport, CO: Praeger.

71.

Wright

(2001) The New York Times Almanac. New York: Penguin.

72.

Zelizer

(1992) Covering the Body. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

73.

Zelizer

(1993) Journalists as interpretive communities. Critical Studies in Mass Communication 10: 219–237.

‘Where once stood titans’: Second-order paradigm repair and the vanishing US newspaper

Abstract

Keywords

Get full access to this article

References