Despite research to the contrary, a recent British Home Office report by Kelly et al.
(2005) notes that in public consciousness a 'real rape' is perceived to occur in a
public place, is perpetrated by a stranger and involves aggravating violence.
Further, it notes that such skewed perceptions are implicated in the high attrition
rate that this offence attracts in the United Kingdom. This paper suggests that a
significant factor in the reinforcing of this skewed perception is the reporting of
violence against women in the print media. It is argued that murders of women are
regularly sexualized by journalists and conversely that sexual assaults of women are
framed within a discourse of murder. Through a discourse analysis of six case
studies of rape and/or murder of women by men between 2003 and 2004, this research
contends that the habitual linking of the concepts of sex and death in such
reporting, which in some contexts effectively produces a conflation of the offences
of rape and murder, contributes to the way in which rape is received by criminal
justice professionals, victims and the wider public.
Allison, R.
(2003)
''Model Daughter' Murdered After Night Out With Friends'
, Guardian, 17 March:
8
.
2.
Bevacqua, M.
(2000) Rape on the Public Agenda.
Boston, MA: Northeastern
University Press.
3.
Bird, S.
(2003a)
'Abducted Teenage Girl was Strangled'
, The Times, 18 March:
15
.
4.
Bird, S.
(2003b)
'Woman "Heard Murdered Girl Scream"'
, The Times, 21 March:
16
.
5.
Cameron, S.
(2003)
'SAS Doc Dumped Over Rifle Murder'
, Mirror, 13 May:
11
.
6.
Caputi, J.
(1987) The Age of Sex Crime.
London : The Women's
Press.
7.
Carter, C.
,
G. Branston
and
S. Allan
(1998) News, Gender and Power.
London :
Routledge.
8.
Carter, C.
and
C.K. Weaver
(2003) Violence and the Media.
Buckingham : Open University
Press.
9.
Chapman, J.
and
J. Twomey
(2003)
'Battered Girls Final Journey Caught on Film; Seconds to Live'
, Daily Express, 8 February:
5
.
10.
Chibnall, S.
(1977) Law And Order News.
Tavistock: British Press
.
11.
Cohen, S.
(eds) (1971) Images of Deviance.
Harmondsworth:
Penguin .
12.
Cohen, S.
and
J. Young
(eds) (1973) The Manufacture of News: Social Problems,
Deviance and Mass Media. London:
Constable.
13.
Crimewatch (2006) URL (consulted 23 December 2006
): http://www.bbc.co.uk/crime/crimewatch/anniversary/casessolved.shtml
.
14.
Daily Mail
(2003a) 'Was Strangled Girl Victim Of A Serial
Killer?', 18 March.
15.
Daily Mail
(2003b) 'Has Milly's Killer Struck Again?', 20
March.
16.
Daily Mail
(2004) 'Rolling Pin Horror of Love Cheat Navy Wife', 16
November: 25.
17.
Dawson, M.
(2003)
'The Cost of "Lost" Intimacy: The Effect of Relationship State on Criminal
Justice Decision Making'
, British Journal of Criminology43 (4):
689-709.
18.
Dobash, R.E.
and
R.P. Dobash
(1988) 'Research As Social Action: The Struggle for Battered
Women.' in
K. Yllö
and
M. Bograd
(eds), Feminist Perspectives on Wife Abuse, pp.
51-74.Los Angeles, CA.:
SAGE.
19.
Edley, N.
(2001) 'Analysing Masculinity: Interpretive Repertoires,
Ideological Dilemmas and Subject Positions' in
M. Wetherell
,
S. Taylor
, and
S. Yates
(eds) Discourse as Data, A Guide for Analysis.
London:
SAGE.
20.
Edwards, J.
(2003)
'Human Clamp Doc Saves Knifed Jogger; Police Link Attack to Murder of U.S.
Student. She Stems Bleeding'
, Mirror , 8 December:
11
.
21.
Ericson, R.
,
P.M. Baranek
and
J.B.L. Chan
(1991) Representing Order. Milton
Keynes : Open University
Press.
22.
Fagge, N.
(2003)
'Outrage Over Man Who Raped Wife, Jailed for Life…But Out in 28
Months?'
, Daily Express, 19 November:
22
.
23.
Fairclough, N.
(1992) Discourse and Social Change.
Cambridge: Polity
Press.
24.
Fairclough, N.
(1995) Critical Discourse Analysis: The Critical Study of
Language. London:
Longman.
25.
Fairclough, N.
and
L. Chouliaraki
(1995) Discourse in Late Modernity: Rethinking Critical
Discourse Analysis. Edinburgh:
Edinburgh University Press.
26.
Foucault, M.
(1970) The Order of Things: an Archaeology of the Human
Sciences. London: Tavistock
Press .
27.
Foucault, M.
(1972/2004) The Archaeology of Knowledge .
London:
Routledge.
28.
Foucault, M.
(1973) The Birth of the Clinic.
London : Tavistock
Press.
29.
Foucault, M.
(1978) The History of Sexuality.
Harmondsworth :
Penguin.
30.
Foucault, M.
(1979) Discipline and Punish.
Harmondsworth :
Penguin.
31.
Foucault, M.
(1980) Power/Knowledge: Selected Interviews and Other
Writings 1972-1977. Brighton:
Harvester Books.
32.
Fowler, R.
(1991) Language in the News.
London :
Routledge.
33.
Foster, J.
(2003)
'My Husband Beat and Raped Me Until One Day I Stabbed Him…But it
Makes Me So Sad My Kids Don't Have a Father'
, Mirror, 21 June:
28-29.
34.
Frayling, C.
(1986) 'The House That Jack Built', in
S. Tomaselli
and
R. Porter
(eds) Rape: An Historical and Cultural Enquiry, pp. 174
-215. London:
Blackwells.
35.
Gerberth, V.J.
(1998)
'Practical Homicide Investigation'
, Law and Order Magazine46(5). URL:
http://www.practicalhomicide.com/articles/lustmurder.htm
.
36.
Gerberth,V.J.
(2003) Sex-Related Homicide and Death Investigation.
Practical and Clinical Perspectives. Boca Raton,
FL: CRC Press.
37.
Gillespie, M.
and
E. McLaughlin
(2002)
'Media and the Making of Public Attitudes'
, Criminal Justice Matters49(Autumn): 8-9.
38.
Gillespie, M.
and
E. McLaughlin
, (2003) 'Rethink Briefings: Media and the Shaping of Public
Knowledge and Attitudes Towards Crime and Punishmen',
London: Rethinking Crime and
Punishment,
URL:http://www.rethinking.org.uk/publications/index.shtml.
39.
Gordon, M.T.
and
S. Riger
(1989) The Female Fear . New York,
NY: The Free Press.
40.
Greer, C.
(2003) Sex Crime and the Media.
Cullompton : Willan
Publishing.
41.
Hall, S.
(1997) 'The Work of Representation', in
S. Hall
(ed.), Representation: Cultural Representation and Signifying
Practices, p. 15. London:
SAGE.
42.
Hall, S.
,
C. Critcher
,
T. Jefferson
,
J. Clarke
and
B. Roberts
(1978) Policing the Crisis: Mugging, the State and Law and
Order. London:
Macmillan.
43.
Harris, J.
and
S. Grace
(1999) A Question of Evidence? Investigating and Prosecuting
Rape in the 1990s. Home Office Research Study 196.
London :
HMSO.
44.
Howe, A.
(1998) Sexed Crime in the News.
Sydney : Federation
Press.
45.
Hughes, S.
(2004)
'Motorists Ignored Pleas of Rape Girl'
, Sun, 29 January.
46.
Innes, M.
(2002)
'Police Homicide Investigations'
, British Journal of Criminology42 (4):
669-688.
47.
Karlberg, M.
and
R.A. Hackett
(1996)
'Cancelling Each Other Out? Interest Group Perceptions of the News
Media'
, Canadian Journal of Communication21(4). URL:
http://www.cjc-online.ca/viewarticle.php?id=383.
48.
Kelly, L.
,
J. Lovett
and
L. Regan
(2005) A Gap or a Chasm? Attrition in Reported Rape Cases.
Home Office Research Study 293. London:
HMSO.
49.
Kidd-Hewitt, D.
and
R. Osborne
(eds) (1995) Crime and the Media: the Post-Modern
Spectacle. London: Pluto
Press .
50.
Kitzinger, J.
(2004) Framing Abuse: Media Influence and Public
Understanding of Sexual Violence Against Children.
London: Pluto
Press.
51.
Knox, S.
(2004)
'A Gruesome Accounting: Mass, Serial and Spree Killing in the Mediated
Public Sphere'
, Journal for Crime, Conflict and the Media1 (2): 1-14. URL
(consulted 17 November 2006): http://www.jc12m.co.uk/Issue12/Knox.pdf
.
52.
Lees, S.
(1997) Ruling Passions. Sexual Violence, Reputation and the
Law. Milton Keynes: Open
University Press.
53.
Lockton, D.
and
R. Ward
(1997) Domestic Violence.
London:
Cavendish.
54.
MacDonald, E.
(1991) Shoot the Women First.
London : Fourth
Estate.
55.
Marriner, B.
(1992) A Century of Sex Killers.
London : True Crime
Library.
56.
Mason, G.
(2003a)
'"Stranger Murders" Give The Police Their Toughest Detection Problem,
Leaving Us Haunted By The Beasts Who Kill For The Thrill'
, Daily Express, 20 March:
13
.
57.
Mason, G.
(2003b)
'As a Jogger's Murder Highlights Our Rising Crime Rates…Is It
Safer To Live in America Than Britain?'
, Daily Express, 6 February:
13
.
58.
Mason, P.
(ed.) (2003) Criminal Visions: Media Representations of Crime
and Justice. Cullompton : Willan
Publishing.
59.
Mason, P.
(ed.) (2006) Captured By The Media: Prison Discourse in
Popular Culture. Cullompton :
Willan Publishing.
60.
Mooney, J.
(1993) The Hidden Figure: Domestic Violence in North
London . London: Islington
Council.
61.
Morris, S.
(2003)
'Jogger's Murder May Be Linked To Rape: Police Identify US Artist Killed In
Park From Mobile Phone'
, Guardian , 5 February:
5
.
62.
Myhill, A.
and
J. Allen
(2002) Rape and Sexual Assault of Women: The extent and
nature of the problem. Home Office Research Study 237.
London:
HMSO.
63.
Office for Criminal Justice Reform
(2006) Convicting Rapists and Protecting Victims - Justice
for Victims of Rape: London:
HMSO. URL:
http://www.cjsonline.gov.uk/downloads/application/pdf/Rape_consultation.pdf.
64.
Palmer, R.
(2003)
'In This Short Stroll Home, Brilliant Doctor-To-Be Hannah Was Snatched and
then Strangled; Her Final Walk'
, Daily Express, 18 March:
11
.
65.
Polk, K.
(1994) When Men Kill: Scenarios of Masculine Violence .
Cambridge: Cambridge University
Press.
66.
Pyatt, J.
(2003)
'Hannah Murdered on 5 Min Walk Home'
, Sun, 17 March.
67.
Reiner, R.
,
S. Livingstone
and
J. Allen
(2003) 'From Law and Order to Lynch Mobs: Crime News Since
the Second World War ', in
P. Mason
(ed.), Criminal Visions: Media Representations of Crime and
Justice , pp. 13-32.
Cullompton: Willan
Publishing.
68.
Riches, C.
(2003)
'Killed at Random'
, Sun, 18 March.
69.
Roberts, M.
(2001)
'Just Noise? Newspaper Reporting and Fear of Crime'
, Criminal Justice Matters43: 10-11.
70.
Schlesinger, L.
(2003) Sexual Murder: Catathymic and Compulsive
Homicides . Boca Raton, FL: CRC
Press.
71.
Schmid, D.
(2005) Natural Born Celebrities. Serial Killers in American
Culture. Chicago: University of
Chicago Press.
72.
Scott, H.
(2003)
'Stranger Danger: Explaining Women's Fear of Crime'
, Western Criminology Review4 (3). URL: http://wcr.sonoma.edu/v4n3/scott.html
.
73.
Shaw, A.
(2004)
'Outburst By Rape Suspect'
, Mirror , 26 February:
28
.
74.
Soothill, K.
and
S. Walby
(1991) Sex Crime in the News.
London :
Routledge.
75.
Smith, L.
and
Tendler, S.
(2004)
'Trophy Rapist Victims "Feared Murder"'
, The Times, 5 March:
4
.
76.
Stabile, C.
(2005)
'The Most Disgusting Objects of Both Sexes'
, Journalism6(4):
403-421.
77.
Stanko, B.
(1996)
'The Commercialism of Women's Fear of Crime'
, at International Victimology 8th International
Symposium , Australian Institute of Criminology,
78.
Storrar, K.
(2003)
'SAS Rifle Killer Fails in Death Appeal'
, Mirror, 20 March.
79.
Sullivan, M.
(2003)
'2 Men Sprinted From Jogger Murder Park'
, Sun, 6 February, np.
80.
Surette, R.
(1998) Media, Crime and Criminal Justice: Images and
Realities . Pacific Grove, CA:
Brooks/Cole .
81.
Tatar, M.
(1995) Lustmord. Sexual Murder in Weimar Germany.
Princeton, NJ: Princeton
University Press.
82.
Taylor, B.
(2004)
'Brush with a killer'
, Daily Mail , 4 February:
45
.
83.
Tendler, S.
and
R. McGreevy
(2003)
'Killer Struck as Teenager Made Short Walk Home'
, The Times, 17 March:
5
.
84.
Daily Express
(2003) 'Man Held Over Killing of Jogger', 19 March:
15.
Mirror
(2004a) 'Walsh In Killer Plea', 4 February:
17.
87.
Mirror
(2004b) 'Boy Held In "Park Ripper" Attacks; Jogger Murder
Quiz', 16 January.
88.
The Times
(2003) 'Doctor's Murder Conviction "Unsafe"', 8
February: 4.
89.
The Times
(2005) '"I'm Looking at Killer" Says Outback Victim',
19 October: 17.
90.
Tunstall, J.
(1996) Newspaper Power. The New National Press in
Britain . Oxford: Clarendon
Press.
91.
Wainwright, M.
(1999)
'Former SAS Doctor to Face Retrial'
, The Guardian, 29 May:
12
.
92.
Walby, S.
and
J. Allen
(2004) 'Domestic Violence, Sexual assault and Stalking:
Findings from the British Crime Survey', Home Office Research Study 276.
London: Home
Office.
93.
Walkowitz, J.R.
(1992) City of Dreadful Delight: Narratives of Sexual Danger
in Late-Victorian London. London:
Virago Press.
94.
Wodak, R.
and
M. Meyer
(eds) (2001) Methods of Critical Discourse Analysis.
London:
SAGE.
95.
Wright, S.
,
L. Clark
and
S. McIntyre
(2003)
'Kill-For-Kicks Knife Maniac Stabs Another Woman Jogger In The Park'
, Daily Mail, 8 December:
5
.
96.
Wykes, M.
(2001) News, Crime and Culture.
London : Pluto
Press.
97.
Young, J.
(1971) The Drug Takers.
London:
Paladin.
