Care workers,collectivisation and protest: a case for feminist and anti-capitalist resistance against the state

Abstract

Nation-wide organised protests by Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHAs), arguably the backbone of India's fragmented healthcare system, form a watershed moment in feminist protest in India by centring demands for the regularisation of their ‘voluntary’ and undercompensated work. This distinct subaltern group (the ASHAs) engages with the state through dynamic political protest. This article critically explores the protest strategies adopted by ASHAs to better understand feminist protest on the Indian political landscape. It adopts a reflexive method of inquiry by unpacking how ASHA policy perpetuates institutional patterns of gender-based occupational segregation and how ASHAs, in turn, navigate and respond to these challenges. Somewhere between victimhood and agency, ASHA workers have reclaimed a site of struggle and resistance. Indeed, in the face of gender-based discrimination, ASHA workers are agitating on their own terms. A postcolonial feminist lens allows us to explore the axes of resistance adopted by ASHAs, including their medium of protest, which offers a space for different performative strategies: the self-sustained and self-contained leadership and mobilisation in which ASHAs reject gender-based stereotypes, exclusion, disadvantage and discrimination; and the use of protest to build sites of resistance, solidarity and negotiation. This theoretical framework offers valuable insight by shifting focus away from judicial strategies and towards ASHA workers as ‘protesters’ and as authors of their own narrative.

Keywords

Anti-capitalism collectivisation gender healthcare workers postcolonial feminism protest resistance unions

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Ahmed

Farrah

(2020) ‘Arbitrariness, Subordination and Unequal Citizenship’. Indian Law Review, 4: 121–137. https://doi.org/10.1080/24730580.2020.1761142

Amnesty International (2024) ‘India: Citizenship Amendment Act Is a Blow to Indian Constitutional Values and International Standards’. Available at: https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2024/03/india-citizenship-amendment-act-is-a-blow-to-indian-constitutional-values-and-international-standards/ (accessed 2 August 2024).

Aruna Ramchandra Shanbaug v. Union of India A.I.R. 2011 S.C. 1290.

Assam Times (2017) ‘Asha Workers Stage Protest in Udalguri’. Available at: https://assamtimes.org/node/19753#:∼:text=Protesting%20against%20government%20failure%20to,30%20with%20day%20long%20programme (accessed 27 August 2023).

Atrey

Shreya

(2018) ‘Intersectional Case of Poverty in Discrimination Law’. Human Rights Law Review, 18(3): 411–440.

Bakshi

Garima

(2017) ‘The “Nirbhaya” Movement: an Indian Feminist Revolution’. Gnovis Journal, 17(2): 43–55.

Balakrishnan

Ghosh

(2020) Karnataka Asha Social Health Workers Demand Better Wages, To Stay Off Duties Indefinitely from Today’. Available at https://www.news18.com/news/india/karnataka-asha-social-health-workers-demand-better-wages-to-stay-off-duties-indefinitely-from-saturday-2444985.html (accessed 8 October, 2024).

Baud

Michiel

Rutten

Roseanne

(2004) Popular Intellectuals and Social Movements: Framing Protest in Asia, Africa, and Latin America. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Baxi

Upendra

(1985) ‘Taking Suffering Seriously: Social Action Litigation in the Supreme Court of India’. Third World Legal Studies, 4(6): 107.

10.

Bhagwati

P. N.

Dias

C. J.

(2012) ‘The Judiciary in India: a Hunger and Thirst for Justice’. NUJS Law Review, 5: 171.

11.

Bhowmick

Nilanjana

(2020) ‘How Women Have Changed India Through Political Protests’. Time, 15 January. Available at: https://time.com/5765702/india-protests-women/ (accessed 27 August 2023).

12.

Bhuwania

Anuj

(2017) Courting the People: Public Interest Litigation in Post-emergency India. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

13.

Biju

Rintu Mariam

(2020) ‘Karnataka HC Issues Notice in Plea Seeking Proper Implementation of SC/ST (Prevention of Atrocities) Act Provisions in State’. Available at: https://www.barandbench.com/news/litigation/karnataka-hc-issues-notice-in-plea-seeking-proper-implementation-of-scst-prevention-of-atrocities-act-provisions-in-state (accessed 25 February 2021).

14.

Butler

Judith

(2015) Notes Toward a Performative Theory of Assembly. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

15.

Cappelletti

Mauro

Gordley

James

Johnson

Earl

(1975) Toward Equal Justice: a Comparative Study of Legal Aid in Modern Societies (Texts and Materials). Milan: Dott. A. Giuffrè Editore.

16.

Carby

Hazel V.

(1997) ‘White Women Listen! Black Feminism and the Boundaries of Sisterhood’. In: Mirza

Heidi Safia

(ed.) Black British Feminism: a Reader. London and New York: Routledge, pp. 45–53.

17.

Chakrabarty

(2000) Provincializing Europe: Postcolonial Thought and Historical Difference (New Edition). Princeton: Princeton University Press.

18.

Chakraborty

Satarupa

(2021) ‘CJI’s Remarks on Women Farmers Are an Assault on Human Agency and Constitutional Rights’. Available at: https://thewire.in/women/cji-bobde-women-farmers-protest-remarks-rights (accessed 25 February 2021).

19.

Chowdhury

Sreya Dutta

(2020) ‘3 States Wage War Against India’s Corona. Available at: https://www.article-14.com/post/3-states-wage-war-against-india-s-female-corona-warriors (accessed 25 February 2021).

20.

Comaroff

Jean

Comaroff

John L.

(2006) Law and Disorder in the Postcolony. Chicago: University of Chicago Press.

21.

Comptroller and Auditor General of India (2009) Report No. 8 of 2009 – Performance Audit of National Rural Health Mission of Union Government, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare. New Delhi: Comptroller and Auditor General of India.

22.

Crain

Marion

(1991) ‘Feminizing Unions: Challenging the Gendered Structure of Wage Labor’. Michigan Law Review, 89(5): 1155–1221.

23.

Dasgupta

Velankar

Borah

Nath

G. H.

(2017) ’The safety of women health workers at the frontlines’ Indian’. J Med Ethics, 2(3): 209-213. doi: https://doi.org/10.20529/IJME.2017.043.

24.

Rohit

(2018) A People’s Constitution: the Everyday Life of Law in the Indian Republic. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

25.

Rohit

Ranganathan

Surabhi

(2019) ‘Opinion: We Are Witnessing a Rediscovery of India’s Republic’. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2019/12/27/opinion/india-constitution-protests.html (accessed 27 August 2023).

26.

Deccan Herald (2020) ‘Asha Workers Demand Minimum Wages’ Available at: https://www.deccanherald.com/india/karnataka/asha-workers-demand-minimum-wages-745544.html (accessed 8 October 2024).

27.

Dwary

Anurag

(2018) ‘Woman Protesting Near Shivraj Chouhan’s Home in Bhopal Falls 30 Feet from Tower’. Available at: https://www.ndtv.com/india-news/asha-worker-climbs-tower-during-protest-in-bhopal-falls-with-a-thud-1926285 (accessed 25 February 2021).

28.

Early Times (2012) ‘Asha Workers Hold Protest in Support of Demands’. Available at: https://www.earlytimes.in/newsdet.aspx?q=96128 (accessed 27 August 2023).

29.

Economic and Political Weekly (2021) ‘ASHA Workers’ Struggle for Recognition’. Economic and Political Weekly, 56(1): 7–8.

30.

Fraser

Nancy

(2013) Fortunes of Feminism: from State-managed Capitalism to Neoliberal Crisis. London: Verso Books.

31.

Gaurav Jain v. Union of India A.I.R. 1998 S.C. 2848.

32.

Government of India, Ministry of Health & Family Welfare (2011) ‘Asha Which Way Forward? Evaluation of the ASHA Programme’. Available at: https://nhm.gov.in/images/pdf/communitisation/asha/Studies/Evaluation_of_ASHA_Program_2010 (accessed 27 August 2023)

33.

Gupta

Hemangini

(2016) ‘Taking Action: the Desiring Subjects of Neoliberal Feminism in India’. Journal of International Women’s Studies, 17(1): 152–168.

34.

Harvey

David

(2006) ‘Space as a Keyword’. In: Castree

Noel

Gregory

Derek

(eds) David Harvey: a Critical Reader. Hoboken, New Jersey: Wiley Online Library.

35.

Hindu (2020) ‘ASHA Workers Stage Massive Protest’. Available at: https://www.thehindu.com/news/cities/Visakhapatnam/asha-workers-stage-massive-protest/article33006810.ece (accessed 27 August 2023).

36.

Hindustan Times (2020) ‘ASHA Workers Protest Against Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal’. Available at: https://www.gettyimages.ae/detail/news-photo/asha-workers-bang-plates-during-protest-at-the-residence-of-news-photo/1668658475 (accessed 2 August 2024).

37.

Hindustan Times (2024) ASHA Workers to Stage Demonstration from Feb 15 over Pay Hike. Available at https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/lucknow-news/asha-workers-to-stage-demonstration-from-feb-15-over-pay-hike-101707678544536.html (accessed 8 October 2024).

38.

Hindustan Times (2020) ‘FIR Against 100 Asha Workers for Jantar Mantar Protest’. Available at: https://www.hindustantimes.com/cities/fir-against-100-asha-workers-for-jantar-mantar-protest/story-q2obOCJAwddgNEt0QeM7lL.html (accessed 27 August 2023).

39.

hooks

bell

(1984) Black Women Shaping Feminist Theory. In: Marable, Manning and Leith Mullings (eds) (2000) Let Nobody Turn Us Around: Voices of Resistance, Reform, and Renewal: an African American Anthology. New York: Bowman and Littlefield, pp.544–550.

40.

Jain

Dipika

(2017) ‘Shifting Subjects of State Legibility: Gender Minorities and the Law in India’. Berkeley Journal of Gender Law & Justice, 32(1): 39–72.

41.

Jain

Pragya

(2020) ‘Asha Workers Sport Black Badges to Mark Protest’. Available at: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/nashik/asha-workers-sport-black-badges-to-mark-protest/articleshow/75683378.cms (accessed 27 August 2023).

42.

Jain

Kartik

(2020) ‘Unjust Citizenship: the Law That Isn’t’, 13 NUJS L. Rev. 159.

43.

Jain

Dipika

(n.d.) ASHA Workers Rights' Violations in the time of COVID-19: a Critical Reflection, COVID-19 and the Constitution. Available at https://covid-19-constitution.in/analyses/asha-workers-rights-violations-in-the-time-of-covid-19-a-critical-reflection (accessed 9 October 2024).

44.

Johnson

Gaye Theresa

(2013) ‘Space, Sound, and Shared Struggles’. In: Spaces of Conflict, Sounds of Solidarity. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

45.

Kalia

Saumya

(2024) ‘The Women of ASHA: Overworked, Underpaid and on the Edge of Breakdown’. Available at: https://www.thehindu.com/sci-tech/health/the-women-of-asha-overworked-underpaid-and-on-the-edge-of-breakdown/article67866061.ece (accessed 25 April 2024).

46.

Kapur

Ratna

(2005) Erotic Justice: Law and the New Politics of Postcolonialism. Glass House Press.

47.

Kelp-Stebbins

Katherine

Schifani

Allison M.

(2015) ‘The Medium Is the Masses: Embodied Amplification, Urban Occupation’. Media Fields Journal, 9: 1–14.

48.

Khare

Harish

(2020) ‘Hope, Belief and the Candles of Shaheen Bagh’. Available at: https://www.thehindu.com/opinion/lead/hope-belief-and-the-candles-of-shaheen-bagh/article30935340.ece (accessed 27 August 2023).

49.

Kim

Richard

(2011) ‘The Nation: We Are All Human Microphones’. Available at: https://www.npr.org/2011/10/06/141109428/the-nation-we-are-all-human-microphones (accessed 25 February 2021).

50.

Kinniburgh

Colin

(2019) ‘India Cracks Down on Free Expression as Protests Against Citizenship Law Grow’. Available at: https://www.france24.com/en/20191221-india-cracks-down-on-free-expression-as-protests-against-citizenship-law-spread (accessed 27 August 2023).

51.

Kohli

Jatinder

(2016) ‘190 Health Mission Workers in Jalandhar Working Without Pay for 1 Yr’. Hindustan Times. Available at: https://www.hindustantimes.com/punjab/190-health-mission-workers-in-jalandhar-working-without-pay-for-1-yr/story-agvi6sadKJAz1KgyQcAWeO.html (accessed 27 August 2023).

52.

Kumar

Shiva M. T.

(2015) ‘ASHA Workers Join Indefinite Agitation Launched by AIUTUC’. Available at: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/karnataka/asha-workers-join-indefinite-agitation-launched-by-aiutuc/article7729118.ece (accessed 27 August 2023).

53.

Kunreuther

Laura

(2017) ‘Democratic Soundscapes’. Avery Review.

54.

Kunreuther

Laura

(2018) ‘Sounds of Democracy: Performance, Protest, and Political Subjectivity’. Cultural Anthropology, 33: 1–31.

55.

Kurian

Alka

(2020) ‘Shaheen Bagh Protests Resonate with Fourth-wave Feminist Movements in Chile, Hong Kong, Lebanon’. Available at: https://scroll.in/article/954283/protests-across-indias-shaheen-baghs-are-part-of-a-global-fourth-wave-feminist-uprising (accessed 25 February 2021).

56.

Lieder

K. Francis

(2018) ‘Performing Loitering: Feminist Protest in the Indian City’. TDR/The Drama Review, 62: 145–161. https://doi.org/10.1162/dram_a_00776 .

57.

McEwan

Cheryl

(2001) ‘Postcolonialism, Feminism and Development: Intersections and Dilemmas’. Progress in Development Studies, 1: 93–111.

58.

Mehta

Uday Singh

(1999) Liberalism and Empire: India in British Liberal Thought. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

59.

Minh-ha

Trinh T.

(1989) Woman, Native, Other: Writing Postcoloniality and Feminism. Indiana University Press.

60.

Ministry of Health and Family Welfare (MoHFW) (2005) National Rural Health Mission: Meeting People’s Health Needs in Rural Areas, Framework for Implementation 2005-2012. New Delhi: Ministry of Health and Family Welfare.

61.

Mohanty

Chandra Talpade

Russo

Ann

Torres

Lourdes

(1991) Third World Women and the Politics of Feminism. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press.

62.

Mounika

Alithea Stephanie

(2020) ‘Why 15,000 Women Descended on the Streets of Bengaluru in a Sea of Pink’. Available at: https://www.thenewsminute.com/article/why-15000-women-descended-streets-bengaluru-sea-pink-115294 (accessed 27 August 2023).

63.

National Health Mission (2005a) ‘About Accredited Social Health Activist (ASHA)’. Available at: https://nhm.gov.in/index1.php?lang=1&level=1&sublinkid=150&lid=226#:∼:text=ASHA%20will%20provide%20information%20to,of%20health%20%26%20family%20welfare%20services (accessed 27 August 2023).

64.

National Health Mission (2005b) ‘Janani Suraksha Yojana’. Available at: https://nhm.gov.in/index1.php?lang=1&level=3&lid=309&sublinkid=841 (accessed 27 August 2023).

65.

National Health Mission (2005c) ‘National Rural Health Mission’. Available at: https://nhm.gov.in/index1.php?lang=1&level=1&lid=49&sublinkid=969 (accessed 27 August 2023).

66.

National Health Systems Resource Centre (2021) Annual ASHA Update 2020–21. New Delhi: Ministry of Health and Family Welfare and National Rural Health Mission.

67.

National Rural Health Mission (2005) National Rural Health Mission (2005–2012) Mission Document. New Delhi: National Rural Health Mission.

68.

National Rural Health Mission (2012) ‘Success Story: A Case Study on the Best ASHA of 2012 Selected Under Sonamura Health Sub-Division’. Available at: http://tripuranrhm.gov.in/Asha/Sucess3.pdf (accessed 25 August 2023).

69.

O’Keefe

Theresa

(2014) ‘My Body Is My Manifesto! SlutWalk, FEMEN and Femmenist Protest’. Feminist Review, 107: 1–19.

70.

Ong

Aihwa

(1988) ‘Colonialism and Modernity: Feminist Re-presentations of Women in non-Western Societies’. Inscriptions, 3(4): 79–93.

71.

Raman

Shreya

Gurjar

Abhijeet

(2024) ‘Their Roles Ambiguous, ASHA Workers Fight for the Right to Contest Elections’. Available at: https://behanbox.com/2024/01/05/their-roles-ambiguous-asha-workers-fight-for-the-right-to-contest-elections/ (accessed 27 August 2023).

72.

Ramani

Priya

(2020) ‘Adda and Lemon Tea at Shaheen Bagh’. Available at: https://lifestyle.livemint.com/news/opinion/adda-and-lemon-tea-at-shaheen-bagh-111641396511108.html (accessed 27 August 2023).

73.

Ramya S (2019) ‘Issues and Challenges of Women Pourakarmikas in Mysuru City Corporation: A Study’. International Research Journal of Management Sociology & Humanities, 10(11): 18–28.

74.

Rao

Anupama

(ed.) (2005) Issues in Contemporary Indian Feminism: Gender and Caste. New York: Zed Books.

75.

Rege

Sharmila

(1998) ‘Dalit Women Talk Differently: a Critique of “Difference” and Towards a Dalit Feminist Standpoint Position’. Economic and Political Weekly, 31 October – 6 November, p. WS39.

76.

Rosenberg

Gerald N.

(2008) The Hollow Hope: Can Courts Bring About Social Change? University of Chicago Press.

77.

Rottenberg

Catherine

(2014) ‘The Rise of Neoliberal Feminism’. Cultural Studies, 8.

78.

Sabrang India (2017) ‘Dignify Our Work, Recognise Us as Workers: ASHA Workers Tell Govt’. Available at: https://www.sabrangindia.in/article/dignify-our-work-recognise-us-workers-asha-workers-tell-govt (accessed 25 February 2021).

79.

Sarin

Enisha

Sooden

Ankur

Kole

Subir K.

, et al. (2016) ‘Identification of Challenges and Needs to Improve Community Health Workers Performance: Narratives of Accredited Social Health Activists (ASHA) from Two Indian Districts’. Journal of Public Health in Developing Countries, 2: 173–182.

80.

Scroll (2019) ‘Andhra Pradesh: ASHA Workers Hold Massive Protests in Vijayawada, Say CM Promised Salary Increase’. Available at: https://scroll.in/latest/935198/andhra-pradesh-asha-workers-hold-massive-protest-in-vijayawada-demanding-salary-revision (accessed 25 February 2021).

81.

Singh

Jyotsna

(2015) ‘ASHA Workers’ Strike in Delhi Continues’. Available at: https://www.downtoearth.org.in/news/health/asha-workers-strike-in-delhi-continues-50534 (accessed 25 February 2021).

82.

Singh

Harmeet Shah

(2019) ‘How CAA Is Consolidating Minorities, Civil Society Organically in India’. Available at: https://www.indiatoday.in/news-analysis/story/caa-diverse-group-of-protesters-1630364-2019-12-21 (accessed 25 August 2023).

83.

S. Jagannath v. Union of India A.I.R. 1997 S.C. 811.

84.

Smashboard (2020) ‘Dalit Voices’. Available at: https://smashboard.org/dalit-voices/ (accessed 20 July 2024).

85.

Statesman (2018) ‘HC Flays Govt on Implementation of RTE Act, Vacant Posts in Schools’. Available at: https://www.thestatesman.com/cities/hc-flays-govt-on-implementation-of-rte-act-vacant-posts-in-schools-1502684002.html (accessed 27 August 2023).

86.

Tellis

Ashley

(2012) ‘Disrupting the Dinner Table: Re-Thinking the “Queer Movement” in Contemporary India’. Jindal Global Law Review, 4: 15.

87.

Times of India (2013) ‘ASHAs Seek Salary on Time’. Available at: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/city/bhubaneswar/ASHAs-seek-salary-on-time/articleshow/27533203.cms (accessed 27 August 2023).

88.

Times of India (2017) ‘Asha Workers Protest for Better Salary, Allowances in Mussoorie’. Available at: https://timesofindia.indiatimes.com/videos/news/asha-workers-protest-for-better-salary-allowances-in-mussoorie/videoshow/61677503.cms (accessed 27 August 2023).

89.

Tribune (2019) ‘ASHA Workers Protest, Demand Pay Hike’. Available at: https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/archive/amritsar/asha-workers-protest-demand-pay-hike-836181 (accessed 27 August 2023).

90.

Tribune (2020a) ‘ASHA Workers Break Earthen Pots in Protest’. Available at: https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/ludhiana/asha-workers-break-earthen-pots-in-protest-139994 (accessed 27 August 2023).

91.

Tribune (2020b) ‘ASHA Workers Intensify Stir, Demand Better Pay’. Available at: https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/chandigarh/asha-workers-intensify-stir-demand-better-pay-131921 (accessed 27 August 2023).

92.

Ved

Scott

Gupta

, et al. (2019) ‘How Are Gender Inequalities Facing India’s One Million ASHAs Being Addressed? Policy Origins and Adaptations for the World’s Largest all-Female Community Health Worker Programme’. Human Resources for Health, 17: 3. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12960-018-0338-0 .

93.

Veerendra

P. M.

(2015) ‘ASHA Workers Demand Payment of Incentives’. Hindu, 7 October. Available at: https://www.thehindu.com/news/national/karnataka/asha-workers-demand-payment-of-incentives/article7733025.ece (accessed 27 August 2023).

94.

Vineet Narain v. Union of India A.I.R. 1998 S.C. 889.

95.

WHO (2020) ‘WHO Director-General announces Global Health Leaders Awards’. Available at https://www.who.int/news/item/22-05-2022-who-directorgeneral- announces-global-health-leaders-awards (accessed 8 October, 2024).

96.

Wichterich

(2020) ’Who Cares about Healthcare Workers? Care Extractivism and Care Struggles in Germany and India’. Social Change, 50(1): 121-140. Available at https://doi.org/10.1177/0049085719901087 (accessed 8 October 2024).

97.

Yadav

Shashi

(2020) ‘Tweet by Shashi Yadav @Shashi_Aipwa’. X, 7 August. Available at: https://twitter.com/Shashi_Aipwa/status/1291553438283599872 (accessed 27 August 2023).