Effect of layer orientation on the single tooth bending fatigue strength of polymer gears manufactured by selective laser sintering

Abstract

This study investigates the influence of tooth layer orientation on the bending fatigue behaviour of Nylon 12 spur gears manufactured by a selective laser sintering process in an ‘on-edge’ configuration. The test gears were submitted to single tooth bending fatigue tests, and the thermal response of gears was recorded using Infrared thermography. The surface morphology of failed teeth was examined using microscopy. The effect of tooth layer orientation on the fatigue strength of selective laser sintering gears was evaluated by testing each tooth configuration. The tooth configurations with the highest and lowest strength were 40° and 160°, respectively. The performance of selective laser sintering gears was compared with that of injection moulded Nylon 66 gears. The injection moulded, selective laser sintering 40°, and selective laser sintering 160° gear teeth were tested at multiple loads to investigate the high cycle fatigue and low cycle fatigue behaviour. The bending fatigue life was highest for the injection moulded gears in both low cycle fatigue and high cycle fatigue regimes. The surface temperature was higher in selective laser sintering gears, with 160° configuration exhibiting the highest temperature. The difference between the temperatures of selective laser sintering 40° configuration and injection moulded gear magnified as the applied load increased. Consequently, the strength of the selective laser sintering 40° configuration with respect to injection moulded gear deteriorated in the low cycle fatigue region. Fractography indicated that crack propagation in selective laser sintering 40° and selective laser sintering 160° configurations were cross-laminar and inter-laminar, respectively. In the cross-laminar mode of propagation, the crack propagation was impeded by the layer structure. However, the crack propagation was expedited in the inter-laminar mode, as the crack path was along the interlayer region, which presents a path of least resistance.

Keywords

Polymer gear selective laser sintering bending fatigue strength layer orientation injection moulding

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Munguia

Dalgarno

. Fatigue behaviour of laser-sintered PA12 specimens under four-point rotating bending. Rapid Prototyp J 2014; 20: 291–300.

ASTM F3091M-14. Standard specification for powder bed fusion of plastic materials. West Conshohocken, Pennsylvania: ASTM International, 2021.

Caulfield

McHugh

Lohfeld

. Dependence of mechanical properties of polyamide components on build parameters in the SLS process. J Mater Process Technol 2007; 182: 477–488.

Ajoku

Saleh

Hopkinson

, et al. Investigating mechanical anisotropy and end-of-vector effect in laser-sintered nylon parts. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part B J Eng Manuf 2006; 220: 1077–1086.

Brugo

Palazzetti

Ciric-Kostic

, et al. Fracture mechanics of laser sintered cracked polyamide for a new method to induce cracks by additive manufacturing. Polym Test 2016; 50: 301–308.

Munguia

Dalgarno

. Fatigue behaviour of laser sintered nylon 12 in rotating and reversed bending tests. Mater Sci Technol 2015; 31: 904–911.

Van Hooreweder

Moens

Boonen

, et al. On the difference in material structure and fatigue properties of nylon specimens produced by injection molding and selective laser sintering. Polym Test 2013; 32: 972–981.

Sobolak

Budzik

. Experimental method of tooth contact analysis (TCA) with rapid prototyping (RP) use. Rapid Prototyp J 2008; 14: 197–201.

Berger

Mäule

. Rapid manufacturing of high reduction polymer gears by use of stereolithography. IEEE/ASME Int Conf Adv Intell Mechatronics, AIM 2009; 613–617.

10.

Sobolak

Jagiełowicz

. Rapid prototyping techniques for prototyping and research of polymer gear transmissions. Acta Mech Slovaca 2012; 16: 68–73.

11.

Berger

. Aspects of accuracy and precision in the additive manufacturing of plastic gears. Virtual Phys Prototyp 2015; 10: 49–57.

12.

Lieh

Wang

Badiru

. The accuracy and surface roughness of spur gears processed by fused deposition modeling additive manufacturing. In: Additive Manufacturing Handbook. CRC Press, 2017, pp. 519–530.

13.

Mašović

Jagarčec

Miler

, et al. Analysis of printing direction impact on dimensional accuracy of spur gears. In: IFToMM World Congress on Mechanism and Machine Science. Springer, 2019, pp. 1111–1120.

14.

Durakbasa

Demircioglu

Bauer

, et al. Additive miniaturized-manufactured gear parts validated by various measuring methods. In: International Conference on Measurement and Quality Control-Cyber Physical Issue. Springer, 2019, pp. 276–290.

15.

Zhang

Mao

Leigh

, et al. A parametric study of 3D printed polymer gears. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2020; 107: 4481–4492.

16.

Zhang

Purssell

Mao

, et al. A physical investigation of wear and thermal characteristics of 3D printed nylon spur gears. Tribol Int 2020; 141: 105953.

17.

Sobolak

Połowniak

Cieplak

, et al. Application of polymeric materials for obtaining gears with involute and sinusoidal profile. Polimery 2020; 65: 563–567.

18.

Gbadeyan

Mohan

Kanny

. Processing and characterization of 3D-printed nanoclay/acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (abs) nanocomposite gear. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2020; 109: 619–627.

19.

Pisula

Budzik

Turek

, et al. An analysis of polymer gear wear in a spur gear train made using FDM and FFF methods based on tooth surface topography assessment. Polymers (Basel) 2021; 13: 1–20.

20.

Karthik Pandian

Gautam

Senthilvelan

. Comparison of the bending fatigue performances of selective laser sintered and injection moulded nylon spur gears. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part L J Mater Des Appl 2021: 14644207211047376.

21.

Lewicki

Ballarini

. Effect of rim thickness on gear crack propagation path. J Mech Des Trans ASME 1997; 119: 88–95.

22.

SAE J1619:2017-12. Single tooth gear bending fatigue test. Warrendale, Pennsylvania: SAE, 2017.

23.

Kodeeswaran

Verma

Suresh

, et al. Bi-directional and uni-directional bending fatigue performance of unreinforced and carbon fiber reinforced polyamide 66 spur gears. Int J Precis Eng Manuf 2016; 17: 1025–1033.

24.

Kodeeswaran

Verma

Suresh

, et al. Effects of frequency on hysteretic heating and fatigue life of unreinforced injection molded polyamide 66 spur gears. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part L J Mater Des Appl 2019; 233: 781–789.

25.

Karthik Pandian

Gautam

Senthilvelan

. Experimental and numerical investigation of the bending fatigue performance of symmetric and asymmetric polymer gears. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part L J Mater Des Appl 2020; 234: 819–834.

26.

Karthik Pandian

Gautam

Senthilvelan

. Effect of metal and polymer mating gears on the bending fatigue performance of asymmetric polymer gears. Proc Inst Mech Eng Part L J Mater Des Appl 2021; 235: 2324–2339.

27.

Blais

Toubal

. Single-gear-tooth bending fatigue of HDPE reinforced with short natural fiber. Int J Fatigue 2020; 141: 105857.

28.

Goodridge

Tuck

Hague

RJM

. Laser sintering of polyamides and other polymers. Prog Mater Sci 2012; 57: 229–267.

29.

Senthilvelan

Gnanamoorthy

. Effect of gear tooth fillet radius on the performance of injection molded nylon 6 / 6 gears. Mater Des 2006; 27: 632–639.

30.

Dearn

Hoskins

Petrov

, et al. Applications of dry film lubricants for polymer gears. Wear 2013; 298-299: 99–108.

31.

Zorko

. Investigation on the high-cycle tooth bending fatigue and thermo-mechanical behavior of polymer gears with a progressive curved path of contact. Int J Fatigue 2021; 151: 106394.

32.

ISO/ASTM 52921. Standard terminology for additive manufacturing-coordinate systems and test methodologies. West Conshohocken, Pennsylvania: ASTM International, 2019.

33.

ISO 6336-3:2019. Calculation of load capacity of spur and helical gears – part 3: calculation of tooth bending strength. Geneva: ISO, 2019.

34.

Jain

Pandey

Rao

PVM

. Effect of delay time on part strength in selective laser sintering. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2009; 43: 117–126.

35.

Castillo

Fernández-Canteli

. A unified statistical methodology for modeling fatigue damage. Dordrecht: Springer Science & Business Media, 2009.

36.

Khudiakova

Berer

Niedermair

, et al. Systematic analysis of the mechanical anisotropy of fibre-reinforced polymer specimens produced by laser sintering. Addit Manuf 2020; 36: 101671.

37.

ASTM E178-21. Standard practice for dealing with outlying observations. West Conshohocken, Pennsylvania: ASTM International, 2021.

38.

Mao

. The performance of dry running non-metallic gears. Birmingham: University of Birmingham, 1993.

39.

Amel

Rongong

Moztarzadeh

, et al. Effect of section thickness on fatigue performance of laser sintered nylon 12. Polym Test 2016; 53: 204–210.

40.

Van Hooreweder

De Coninck

Moens

, et al. Microstructural characterization of SLS-PA12 specimens under dynamic tension/compression excitation. Polym Test 2010; 29: 319–326.

41.

Terekhina

Tarasova

Egorov

, et al. On the difference in material structure and fatigue properties of polyamide specimens produced by fused filament fabrication and selective laser sintering. Int J Adv Manuf Technol 2020; 111: 93–107.

42.

Pandian

Gautam

Senthilvelan

. Numerical prediction of the bending fatigue crack propagation behaviour in asymmetric spur gears. Int J Veh Struct Syst 2020; 12: 507–512.

43.

Hart

Wetzel

. Fracture behavior of additively manufactured acrylonitrile butadiene styrene (ABS) materials. Eng Fract Mech 2017; 177: 1–13.

44.

Zhu

Yan

Shi

, et al. Investigation into mechanical and microstructural properties of polypropylene manufactured by selective laser sintering in comparison with injection molding counterparts. Mater Des 2015; 82: 37–45.