This article takes a Talmudic parable as the starting point to consider the ethical as immanent and imminent in an ethnographic case study of contemporary Jewish prayer. I consider the role of blessings and curses at the Western Wall in Jerusalem, as speech acts in protests over Jewish legal interpretation and state-sanctioned laws. I demonstrate how women’s prayer performances, directed to the divine, also reflect judgments about felicitous gendered worship, and, at the same time, passionately solicit ongoing engagement in argumentation and debate with those who have seemingly incommensurable interpretations. Drawing on Das and Lambek’s notions of ordinary ethics, together with Jewish thinkers, I suggest a reading of what happens at the Western Wall that locates ethics not in transcendent, rationally formalized religious rules that frame women’s visits to this sacred site; rather, ethics is immanent and imminent in their practices of interpretation, judgment, and encounter with those statutes.
AbowdT (2014) Colonial Jerusalem: The Spatial Construction of Identity and Difference in a City of Myth, 1948–2012.
Syracuse, NY:
Syracuse University Press.
Abu El-HajN (2001) Facts on the Ground: Archeological Practice and Territorial Self-fashioning in Israeli Society.
Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press.
4.
AlexanderES (2013) Gender and Timebound Commandments in Judaism.
Cambridge, UK:
Cambridge University Press.
5.
AustinJL (1965) How to Do Things with Words.
New York, NY:
Oxford University Press.
6.
AvishaiO (2008)
Halakhic niddah consultants and the orthodox women’s movement in Israel.Journal of Modern Jewish Studies7(2): 195–216.
7.
BandakA (2017)
The social life of prayers–introduction.Religion47(1): 1–18.
8.
BialeD (2011) Not in the Heavens: The Tradition of Jewish Secular Thought.
Princeton, NJ:
Princeton University Press.
9.
BlochM (1974)
Symbols, song, dance and features of articulation: Is religion an extreme form of traditional authority?European Journal of Sociology15(1): 55–81.
10.
BoyarinD (1995) Take the bible for example: midrash as literary theory. In: GelleyA (ed.) Unruly Examples: On the Rhetoric of Exemplarity.
Stanford, CA:
Stanford University Press, pp.27–47.
11.
CavellS (2005) Philosophy the Day After Tomorrow.
Cambridge, UK:
Belknap Press of Harvard University.
12.
CharméS (2005)
The political transformation of gender traditions at the Western Wall in Jerusalem.Journal of Feminist Studies in Religion21(1): 5–34.
13.
CheslerPHautR (2003) Women of the Wall: Claiming Sacred Ground at Judaism’s Holy Site.
Woodstock, VT:
Jewish Lights.
14.
Cohler-EssesD (2008) Contemporary reflection. In Cohn EskenaziTWeissAL (eds) The Torah: A Women’s Commentary.
New York, NY:
URJ Press, pp.1229–1231.
15.
ColemanS (2014).
Pilgrimage as trope for an anthropology of Christianity.Current Anthropology55(10): S281–S291.
16.
DasV (2012) Ordinary ethics. In: FassinD (ed.) A Companion to Moral Anthropology.
Chichester, UK:
Wiley-Blackwell, pp.133–149.
17.
DasV (2015) What does ordinary ethics look like? In: LambekMDasVFassinDKeaneW (eds) Four Lectures on Ethics: Anthropological Perspectives.
Chicago, IL:
Hau Books, pp. 53–126.
18.
DaveN (2012) Queer Activism in India: A Story in the Anthropology of Ethics.
Durham, NC:
Duke University Press.
19.
DavidsonA (2013)
Ethics between cognition and volition.The Journal of Religion93(4): 452–460.
20.
El-OrT (1994) Educated and Ignorant: Ultraorthodox Jewish Women and their World. Watzman H (trans).
Boulder, CO:
Lynne Rienner Publishers.
21.
El-OrT (2002) Next Year I Will Know More: Literacy and Identity among Young Orthodox Women in Israel. Watzman H (trans).
Detroit, US:
Wayne State University Press.
22.
EliorR (2004) Men and Women: Gender, Judaism and Democracy.
Jerusalem, JRS:
Van Leer Jerusalem Institute; New York, NY: Urim Publications.
23.
ElishaO (2013)
The time and place for prayer: Evangelical urbanism and citywide prayer movements.Religion43(3): 312–330.
HabermasJ (1989) The Structural Transformation of the Public Sphere: An Inquiry into a Category of Bourgeois Society.
Cambridge, UK:
MIT Press.
29.
HammoudiA (2009) Textualism and anthropology: On the ethnographic encounter, or an experience in the hajj. In: BornemanJHammoudiA (eds) Being There: The Fieldwork Encounter and the Making of Truth.
Berkeley, CA:
University Press, pp.25–52.
30.
Israel-CohenY (2012)
Jewish Modern Orthodox women, active resistance and synagogue ritual.Contemporary Jewry32(1): 3–25.
31.
JobaniYPerezN (2017) Women of the Wall: Navigating Religion in Sacred Sites.
New York, NY:
Oxford University Press.
32.
KeaneW (1997)
From fetishism to sincerity: On agency, the speaking subject, and their historicity in the context of religious conversion.Society for Comparative Studies in Society and History39(4): 674–693.
LahavP (2013)
Israel’s Rosie the Riveter: between secular law and Jewish law. Boston University Law Review93(3): 1063–1083.
35.
LahavP (2015)
The Women of the Wall: A metaphor for national and religious identity. Israel Studies Review30(2): 50–70.
36.
LambekM (2010) Towards an ethics of the act. In: LambekM (ed.) Ordinary Ethics: Anthropology, Language, and Action.
New York, NY:
Fordham University Press, pp. 39–63.
37.
LambekM (2015a) The Ethical Condition: Essays on Action, Person, and Value.
Chicago, IL:
University of Chicago Press.
38.
LambekM (2015b)
The hermeneutics of ethical encounters: Between traditions and practice.HAU: Journal of Ethnographic Theory5(2): 227–250.
39.
LeibowitzY (1992) Judaism, Human Values, and the Jewish State. Goldman E (ed.), Goldman E, Navon Y, Jacobson Z, Levi G and Levy R (trans). Cambridge, UK: Harvard University Press.
40.
LevinasE (1999) Alterity and Transcendence. Smith M B (trans).
London, UK:
Athlone Press.
41.
LichtensteinA (1975) Does Jewish tradition recognize an ethic independent of halakha? In: FoxM (ed.) Modern Jewish Ethics, Theory and Practice.
Columbus, OH:
Ohio State University Press, pp. 62–88.
42.
LichtensteinA (2003) By His Light: Character and Values in the Service of God. Ziegler R (ed.) Jersey City: KTAV; Alon Shevut: Yeshivat Har Etzion.
43.
LuehrmannS (2017) Introduction: The senses of prayer in Eastern Orthodox Christianity. In: LuehrmannS (ed.) Praying with the Senses: Contemporary Orthodox Christian Spirituality in Practice.
Bloomington, IL:
Indiana University Press.
44.
MattinglyC (2013)
Moral selves and moral scenes: Narrative experiments in everyday life.Ethnos78(3): 301–327.
45.
MittermaierA (2011) Dreams that Matter: Egyptian Landscapes of the Imagination.
Berkeley, CA:
University of California Press.
OchsV (1990) Words on Fire: One Woman’s Journey into the Sacred.
San Diego, CA:
Harcourt Brace Jovanovich.
48.
OchsV (2003) Women and ritual artifacts. In: ChesslerPHautR (eds) Women of the Wall: Claiming Sacred Ground at Judaism’s Holy Site.
Woodstock, VT:
Jewish Lights.
PrellR (1989) Prayer and Community: The Havurah in American Judaism.
Detroit, MI:
Wayne State University Press.
51.
RadayF (2005)
Women’s human rights: Dichotomy between religion and secularism in Israel.Israel Affairs11(1): 78–94.
52.
RinaldoR (2013) Mobilizing Piety: Islam and Feminism in Indonesia.
Oxford, UK:
Oxford University Press.
53.
RobbinsJ (2016)
What is the matter with transcendence? On the place of religion in the new anthropology of ethics.Journal of the Royal Anthropological Institute22: 767–808.
54.
RossT (2004) Expanding the Palace of Torah: Orthodoxy and Feminism.
Hanover, DE:
Brandeis University Press, published by University Press of New England.
