Legal reality or legal mirage? Examining the relationship between police violence,legal consciousness,and the promise of civil legal justice

Abstract

Race-and-class-subjugated communities continue to experience disproportionate police violence despite increased attention to this longstanding problem. This study examines how residents make sense of the legal issues that arise from these encounters and turn to civil law for assistance. I do so by unifying scholarship on police encounters, legal consciousness, and access to justice to consider the obstacles everyday people encounter when they consider filing a civil legal claim in the aftermath of police violence. Drawing on ethnographic fieldwork and interviews with 24 residents and two attorneys specializing in police brutality, I find that all residents, but especially those who sought civil legal justice, experienced what this study calls a legal mirage—which occurs when a knowable legal process exists to pursue one’s rights, but a variety of barriers (e.g., structural, human, financial) make that process unreachable. Three obstacles reinforced this mirage: difficulties obtaining competent representation, unresponsiveness when securing evidence, and frustration navigating municipal indemnification. I conclude by outlining the practical implications of this research for advocates looking to increase access to civil legal services and reduce police violence. Without these interventions, civil legal justice may remain elusive and beyond the reach of everyday people.

Keywords

policing police misconduct access to justice legal estrangment race social inequality civil legal system

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Baude

(2018) Is qualified immunity unlawful. California Law Review 106: 45–90.

Bell

(2016) Situational trust: How disadvantaged mothers reconceive legal cynicism. Law & Society Review 50(2): 314–347.

Bell

(2019) The community in criminal justice: Subordination, consumption, resistance, and transformation. Du Bois Review 16(1): 197–220.

Bersani

Condon

(2016) Fundamentals of Section 1983 Litigation: Common Claims, Defenses and Immunities. Available at https://www.hcbattorneys.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/02/Fundamentals-of-Section-1983-Litigation-11.22.16.pdf (accessed 4 October 2023).

Brayne

(2014) Surveillance and system avoidance: Criminal justice contact and institutional attachment. American Sociological Review 79(3): 367–391.

Bright

(2010) Legal representation for the poor: Can society afford this much injustice? Missouri Law Review 75: 683–714.

Brunson

(2007) Police don’t like black people: African-American young men’s accumulated police experiences. Criminology & Public Policy 6: 71–101.

Brunson

Weitzer

(2009) Police relations with black and white youths in different urban neighborhoods. Urban Affairs Review 44(6): 858–885.

Cheh

(1996) Are lawsuits the answer to police brutality. In Geller

Toch

(eds.), Police Violence: Understanding and Controlling Police Abuse of Force. New Haven, CT: Yale University Press, 247–272.

10.

Ewick

Silbey

(1998) The Common Place of Law. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

11.

Ewick

Silbey

(2003) Narrating social structure: Stories of resistance to legal authority. American Journal of Sociology 108(6): 1328–1372.

12.

Feldman

Gruskin

Coull

, et al. (2019) Police-related deaths and neighborhood economic and racial/ethnic polarization, United States, 2015–2016. American Journal of Public Health 190(3): 458–464.

13.

Garland

(2012) The Culture of Control: Crime and Social Order in Contemporary Society. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

14.

Goldsmith

(2004) Reforming the civil rights act of 1871: The problem of police perjury. Notre Dame Law Review 80: 1259–1286.

15.

Greene

(2016) Race, class, and access to civil justice. Iowa Law Review 101(4): 1263–1321.

16.

Hagan

Shedd

Payne

(2005) Race, ethnicity, and youth perceptions of criminal injustice. American Sociological Review 70(3): 381–407.

17.

Harrell

Davis

(2023) Contacts Between Police and the Public, 2018 statistical tables. U.S. Department of Justice , Office of Justice Programs, Bureau of Justice Statistics . Available at: https://bjs.ojp.gov/content/pub/pdf/cbpp18st.pdf.

18.

Headley

D’Alessio

Stolzenberg

(2020) The effect of a complainant’s race and ethnicity on dispositional outcome in police misconduct cases in Chicago. Race and Justice 19(1): 43–61.

19.

Hess

(1993) Good cop-bad cop: Reassessing the legal remedies for police misconduct. Utah Law Review 1: 149–204.

20.

Jones

(1981) For one and all: Section 1983 of the 1871 civil rights act confers court jurisdiction for violations of federal statutory rights by state and local government officials. Southern University Law Review 8: 45.

21.

Kagehiro

(1988) Perceived voluntariness of consent to warrantless police searches. Journal of Applied Social Psychology 18: 38–49.

22.

Kessler

(2008) Free to leave – an empirical look at the fourth amendment’s seizure standard. Journal of Criminal Law and Criminology 99: 51–88.

23.

Kirk

Papachristos

(2011) Cultural mechanisms and the persistence of neighborhood violence. American Journal of Sociology 116(4): 1190–1233.

24.

Kramer

Remster

(2018) Stop, frisk, and assault? Racial disparities in police use of force during investigatory stops. Law and Society Review 52(4): 960–993.

25.

Kramer

Remster

(2022) The slow violence of contemporary policing. Annual Review of Criminology 5: 43–66.

26.

Kupchick

(2010) Homeroom Security: School Discipline in an Age of Fear. New York: NYU Press.

27.

Langton

Durose

(2013) Police Behavior During Traffic And Street Stops, 2011. US Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Bureau of Justice Statistics. Available at: https://bjs.ojp.gov/content/pub/pdf/pbtss11.pdf.

28.

Lara-Millán

(2014) Public emergency room overcrowding in the era of mass imprisonment. American Sociological Review 79(5): 866–887.

29.

Legewie

(2016) Racial profiling and use of force in police stops: How local events trigger periods of increased discrimination. American Journal of Sociology 122(2): 379–424.

30.

Legewie

Fagan

(2019) Aggressive policing and the educational performance of minority youth. American Sociological Review 84(2): 220–247.

31.

Levine

Mellema (2001) Strategizing the street: How law matters in the lives of women in the street-level drug economy. Law & Social Inquiry 26(1): 169–208.

32.

McCarthy

Hagan

Herda

(2020) Neighborhood climates of legal cynicism and complaints about the abuse of police power. Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal 58(3): 510–536.

33.

McClellan

(2017) Dismantling the trap: Untangling the chain of events in excessive force claims. Columbia Journal of Race & Law 8: 1–32.

34.

Memphis Community School District v . Stachura, 477 U.S. 299 (1986).

35.

Merry

(1990) Getting Justice and Getting Even: Legal Consciousness among Working-Class Americans. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.

36.

Miller

Stuart

(2017) Carceral citizenship: race, rights and responsibilities in the age of mass supervision. Theoretical Criminology 21(4): 532–548.

37.

Monroe v . Pape, 365 U.S. 167 (1961).

38.

Nadler

Trout

(2012) The language of consent in police encounters. In: Solan

Tiersma

(eds) Oxford Handbook on Linguistics and Law. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 326–339.

39.

Nielsen

(2000) Situating legal consciousness: Experiences and attitudes of ordinary citizens about law and street harassment. Law & Society Review 24: 201–236.

40.

Purser

(2016) The circle of dispossession: Evicting the urban poor in Baltimore. Critical Sociology 42(3): 393–415.

41.

Reinert

(2010) Does qualified immunity matter. University of St. Thomas Law Journal 8: 477.

42.

Rios

(2011) Punished: Policing the Lives of Black and Latino Boys. New York: NYU Press.

43.

Rocha Beardall

(2019) Transactional Policing: Reframing Local Police-Community Relations Through The Lens Of Police Employment. PhD thesis, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY.

44.

Rocha Beardall

(2020) Abolition, defund, and the prospects of citizen oversight in the era of George Floyd. Exertions: Society for the Anthropology of Work.

45.

Rocha Beardall

(2022) Police legitimacy regimes and the suppression of citizen oversight in response to police violence. Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal 60(4): 740–765.

46.

Ross

(2018) Civil Liability in Criminal Justice. New York: Routledge.

47.

Sampson

Bartusch

(1998) Legal cynicism and (subcultural?) tolerance of deviance: The neighborhood context of racial differences. Law and Society Review 32: 777–804.

48.

Sandefur

(2007) The importance of doing nothing: Everyday problems and responses of inaction. In: Pleasence

Buck

Balmer

(eds) Transforming Lives: Law and Social Processes. London: Stationary Office Books, 116–136.

49.

Sandefur

(2014) Accessing Justice in the Contemporary USA: Findings From the Community Needs and Services Study. Report for the American Bar Foundation. SSRN 2478040.

50.

Sandefur

(2015) What we know and need to know about the legal needs of the public. South Carolina Law Review 67: 443–459.

51.

Schwartz

(2014) What police learn from lawsuits. Cardozo Law Review 33: 841–894.

52.

Schwartz

(2016) How governments pay: Lawsuits, budgets, and police reform. UCLA Law Review 63: 1144–1299.

53.

Schwartz

(2017) How qualified immunity fails. The Yale Law Journal 1: 2–76.

54.

Seidenberg

(2012) Unequal justice. American Bar Association Journal 58: 56–64.

55.

Shedd

(2015) Unequal City: Race, Schools, and Perceptions of Injustice. New York: Russell Sage Foundation.

56.

Skogan

(2006) Police and Community in Chicago: A Tale of Three Cities. New York: Oxford University Press.

57.

Smith

Jr (2020) Beyond qualified immunity. Michigan Law Review Online 119: 121–136.

58.

Soss

Weaver

(2017) Police are our government: Politics, political science, and the policing of race-class subjugated communities. Annual Review of Political Science 20: 565–591.

59.

Steinberg

(2014) Demand side reform in the poor people’s court. Connecticut Law Review 47: 741–805.

60.

Stuart

(2016) Becoming ‘copwise’: Policing, culture, and the collateral consequences of street-level criminalization. Law and Society Review 50: 279–313.

61.

Sudeall

Richardson

(2018) Unfamiliar justice: Indigent criminal defendants’ experiences with civil legal needs. U.C. Davis Law Review 52: 2105–2164.

62.

Sugie

Turney

(2017) Beyond incarceration: Criminal justice contact and mental health. American Sociological Review 82(4): 719–743.

63.

The Official Mapping Police Violence Database (2023) Mapping police violence interactive database. Available at: https://mappingpoliceviolence.squarespace.com/ (accessed 4 October 2023).

64.

Ward

(2015) The slow violence of state organized race crime. Theoretical Criminology 19(3): 299–314.

65.

Young

(2014) Everyone knows the game: Legal consciousness in the Hawaiian cockfight. Law & Society Review 48(3): 499–530.

66.

Young

Billings

(2020) Legal consciousness and cultural capital. Law & Society Review 54(1): 33–65.