Trans architecture and the prison as archive: “don’t be a queen and you won’t be arrested”

Abstract

Most incarceration settings around the world are governed by strong cisnormative policies, architectures, and social expectations that segregate according to a person's legal gender (i.e. male or female). This paper draws on the lived experiences of 24 formerly incarcerated trans women in Australia and the U.S. to elucidate the way in which the prison functions according to Lucas Crawford's theory of trans architecture, alongside Jacques Derrida's notion of archive fever. The paper displays how the cisnormative archive of the justice system and its architectural constructs impact trans women in men's incarceration settings, including how trans women entering the incarceration setting are able to embody gender in a way that is not reified by the insistences of those normative structures. In light of this, this paper advances a theoretical understanding of the prison as an archive and as an architectural construct, providing a new means of understanding how incarcerated trans persons may use and perform gender to survive carceral violence.

Keywords

trans women incarceration prison archive fever trans architecture

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Arvatu

(2011) Spectres of freud: The figure of the archive in derrida and foucault. Mosaic: An Interdisciplinary Critical Journal 44(4): 141–159.

Baker

JHA

(2016) Intuiting archive: notes for a post-trauma poetics. African American Review 49(1): 1–4.

Bartels

Lynch

(2017) Transgender prisoners in Australia: an examination of the issues, law and policy. Flinders law journal 19(2): 185–231.

Braun

Clarke

(2019) Reflecting on reflexive thematic analysis. Qualitative Research in Sport, Exercise and Health 11(4): 589–597.

Brömdal

Clark

Hughto

JMW

, et al. (2019a) Whole-incarceration-setting approaches to supporting and upholding the rights and health of incarcerated transgender people. International Journal of Transgenderism 20(4): 341–350.

Brömdal

Halliwell

Sanders

, et al. (2022) Navigating Intimate Trans Citizenship while Incarcerated in Australia and the US. Feminism & Psychology. Accepted.

Brömdal

Mullens

Phillips

, et al. (2019b) Experiences of transgender prisoners and their knowledge, attitudes, and practices regarding sexual behaviors and HIV/STIs: A systematic review. International Journal of Transgenderism 20(1): 4–20.

Clark

Brömdal

Phillips

, et al. (2022) Developing the “opression-to-incarceration cycle” of black American and first nationa Australian trans women. Journal of Correctional Health Care. In Press.

Clark

White Hughto

Pachankis

(2017) “What's the right thing to do?” correctional healthcare providers’ knowledge, attitudes and experiences caring for transgender inmates. Social Science & Medicine 193: 80–89.

10.

Coleman

Bockting

Botzer

, et al. (2012) Standards of care for the health of transsexual, transgender, and gender-nonconforming people, version 7. International Journal of Transgenderism 13(4): 165–232.

11.

Crawford

(2020) Transgender Architectonics: The Shape of Change in Modernist Space. London: Routledge.

12.

Crawford

(2010) Breaking ground on a theory of transgender architecture. Seattle Journal of Social Justice 8(2): 515–539.

13.

Derrida

Prenowitz

(1995) Archive fever: A freudian impression. Diacritics 25(2): 9–63.

14.

Federal Bureau of Prisons (2018) Transgender Offender Manual. Available at: https://www.bop.gov/policy/progstat/5200-04-cn-1.pdf (accessed 24 March 2019).

15.

Foucault

(2002) Archaeology of Knowledge. London; New York: Routledge.

16.

Halliwell

du Plessis

Hickey

, et al. (2022) A critical discourse analysis of an Australian incarcerated trans woman’s letters of complaint and self-advocacy. Ethos (Berkeley, Calif ). In Press.

17.

Hughto

JMW

Clark

Daken

, et al. (2022) Victimization within and beyond the prison walls: A latent profile analysis of transgender and gender diverse adults. Journal of Interpersonal Violence 0(0): 1–33.

18.

Jenness

Fenstermaker

(2014) Agnes goes to prison: gender authenticity, transgender inmates in prisons for Men, and pursuit of “The real deal”. Gender & Society 28(1): 5–31.

19.

Jenness

Gerlinger

(2020) The feminization of transgender women in prisons for Men: How prison as a total institution shapes gender. Journal of Contemporary Criminal Justice 36(2): 182–205.

20.

Jenness

Sexton

Sumner

(2019) Sexual victimization against transgender women in prison: consent and coercion in context. Criminology; An Interdisciplinary Journal 57(4): 603–631.

21.

Kleinman

(2001) Archiving/architecture. Archival Science 1: 321–332.

22.

Ledesma

Ford

(2020) Health implications of housing assignments for incarcerated transgender women. American Journal of Public Health 110(5): 650–654.

23.

Lydon

Carrington

Low

, et al. (2015) Coming out of Concrete Closets: A Report on Black & Pink’s National LGBTQ Prisoner Survey. Available at: http://www.blackandpink.org/wp-content/upLoads/Coming-Out-of-Concrete-Closets.-Black-and-Pink.-October-21-2015.pdf (accessed 27 March 2019).

24.

Lynch

Bartels

(2017) Transgender prisoners in Australia: An examination of the issues, Law and policy. Flinders Law Journal 19(2): 185–231.

25.

Malkin

DeJong

(2018) Protections for transgender inmates under PREA: A comparison of state correctional policies in the United States. Sexuality Research and Social Policy. DOI: 10.1007/s13178-018-0354-9. 1-15.

26.

Markshamer

Harper

(2014) Standing with LGBT Prisoners: An Advocate's Guide to Ending Abuse and Combating Imprisonment. Available at: https://transequality.org/sites/default/files/docs/resources/JailPrisons_Resource_FINAL.pdf (accessed 23 April 2019).

27.

Mogul

Richtie

Whitlock

(2011) Queer (in)Justice: The Criminalization of LGBT People in the United States. Boston: Beacon Press.

28.

Musto

(2019) Transing critical criminology: a critical unsettling and transformative anti-carceral feminist reframing. Critical Criminology 27(1): 37–54.

29.

National Center for Transgender Equality (2018) Ending abuse of transgender prisoners: A guide to winning policy change in jails and prisons. Available at: https://transequality.org/sites/default/files/docs/resources/EndingAbuseofTransgenderPrisoners.pdf (accessed 15 April 2019).

30.

Oparah

(2012) Feminism and the (trans)gender entrapment of gender nonconforming prisoners. UCLA Women's Law Journal 18(2): 239–271.

31.

Pemberton

(2013) Enforcing gender: The constitution of sex and gender in prison regimes. Signs: Journal of Women in Culture and Society 39(1): 151–175.

32.

Phillips

Brömdal

Mullens

, et al. (2020) "We don't recognise transexuals…and we're not going to treat you": cruel and unusual and the lived experiences of transgender women in US prisons. In: Harmes

Harmes

(eds) The Palgrave Handbook of Incarceration Across Popular Culture. London: Palgrave MacMillan, pp.331–360.

33.

Queensland Corrective Services (2021) Transgender Prisoners Custodial Operations Practice Directives (COPD), Version 05. Available at: https://www.publications.qld.gov.au/dataset/c85d0cd0-a020-4390-b2a3-5090e480d9e6/resource/c4782e0a-b06b-4877-96b0-fae43846dffc/download/copd-transgender.pdf (accessed 12 October 2021).

34.

Redcay

Luquet

Phillips

, et al. (2020) Legal battles: transgender Inmates’ rights. The Prison Journal 100(5): 662–682.

35.

Ricciardelli

Phoenix

Gaceck

(2020) ‘It's complicated’: Canadian correctional officer Recruits’ interpretations of issues relating to the presence of transgender prisoners. The Howard Journal of Crime and Justice 59(1): 86–104.

36.

Robinson

(2011) Masculinity as prison: sexual identity. Race, and incarceration. California Law Review 99(5): 1309–1408.

37.

Rodgers

Asquith

Dwyer

(2017) Cisnormativity, criminalisation, vulnerability: transgender people in prisons. Tasmanian Institute of Law Enforcement Studies Briefing Paper 12: 1–13.

38.

Roffee

(2018) Trans people and responding to need: improving carceral management. In: Church

II Springer

(eds) Serving the Stigmatized: Working Within the Incarcerated Environment. New York, NY: Oxford University Press, pp.217–257.

39.

Rosenberg

(2017) When temporal orbits collide: embodied trans temporalities in U.S. Prisons. Somatechnics 7(1): 74–94.

40.

Rosenberg

Oswin

(2015) Trans embodiment in carceral space: hypermasculinity and the us prison industrial complex. Gender, Place and Culture: A Journal of Feminist Geography 22(9): 1269–1286.

41.

Sexton

Jenness

(2016) “We’re like community”: collective identity and collective efficacy among transgender women in prisons for men. Punishment & Society 18(5): 544–577.

42.

Smith

(2014) Stories of Os: transgender women, monstrous bodies, and the Canadian prison system. Dalhousie Journal of Legal Studies 23: 149–171.

43.

Stanley

Smith

(2015) Captive Genders: Trans Embodiment and the Prison Industrial complex, 2nd ed. Oakland: CA AK Press.

44.

Stanley

Spade

and Queer (In)Justice (2012) Queering prison abolition, Now? American Quarterly 64(1): 115–127.

45.

Stryker

(2006) (De)subjugated knowledges: An introduction to transgender studies. In: Styker

Whittle

(eds) The Transgender Studies Reader. London: Routledge, pp.1–17.

46.

Sumner

Sexton

(2015) Lost in Translation: Looking for Transgender Identity in Women's Prisons and Locating Aggressors in Prisoner Culture. Critical Criminology 23(1): 1–20.

47.

Tadros

Ribera

Campbell

, et al. (2020) A call for mental health treatment in incarcerated settings with transgender individuals. The American Journal of Family Therapy 48(5): 495–508.

48.

Van Hout

Crowley

(2021) The “double punishment” of transgender prisoners: A human rights-based commentary on placement and conditions of detention. Interntational Journal of Prisoner Health 17(4): 439–451.

49.

Van Hout

Kewley

Hillis

(2020) Contemporary transgender health experience and health situation in prisons: A scoping review of extant published literature (2000–2019). International Journal of Transgender Health 21(3): 258–306.

50.

Vitulli

(2016) Carceral normativities: Sex, security, and the penal management of gender nonconformity . PhD Thesis, University of Minnesota.

51.

White Hughto

Clark

Altice

, et al. (2018) Creating, reinforcing, and resisting the gender binary: A qualitative study of transgender women’s healthcare experiences in Sex-segregated jails and prisons. International Journal of Prisoner Health 14(2): 69–88.

52.

Wilson

Simpson

Butler

, et al. (2017) ‘You’re a woman, a convenience, a cat, a poof, a thing, an idiot’: transgender women negotiating sexual experiences in men’s prisons in Australia. Sexualities 20(3): 380–402.

53.

Yarbrough

(2021) The carceral production of transgender poverty: How racialized gender policing deprives transgender women of housing and safety. Punishment & Society, 1-21.

54.

Zurn

(2019) Waste culture and isolation: prisons, toilets, and gender segregation. Hypatia 34(4): 668–689.