Public support for the death penalty in a red state: The distrustful,the angry,and the unsure

Abstract

Set against the backdrop of Nebraska’s 2015 legislative repeal of the death penalty and the 2016 electoral reinstatement, we examined public support for capital punishment. Using two years of statewide survey data, we compared respondents who preferred the death penalty for murder, those who preferred other penalties, and those who were unsure, a respondent group often excluded from research. To understand what distinguishes among these groups, we examined media consumption, instrumental and expressive feelings about crime, and confidence and trust in the government regarding criminal justice. Results revealed that those who preferred the death penalty expressed more anger about crime and greater distrust, but perceived the death penalty as applied more fairly, relative to the other groups. The unsures, compared to those who preferred other penalties, were less trusting and viewed the death penalty as applied more fairly. The persistence of public support for capital punishment may best be understood for its symbolic, expressive qualities.

Keywords

capital punishment death penalty punitiveness

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Altheide

Michalowski

(1999) Fear in the news: A discourse in control. Sociological Quarterly 40(3): 475–503.

Anderson

Lytle

Schwadel

(2017) Age, period, and cohort effects on death penalty attitudes in the United States, 1974–2014. Criminology 55(4): 833–868.

Bader

Desmond

Mencken

, et al. (2010) Divine justice: The relationship between images of god and attitudes toward criminal punishment. Criminal Justice Review 35(1): 90–106.

Baumgartner

De Boef

Boydstun

(2008) The Decline of the Death Penalty and the Discovery of Innocence. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Barkan

Cohn

(2005) Why whites favor spending more money to fight crime: The role of racial prejudice. Social Problems 52(2): 300–314.

BBC (2015) Nebraska abolishes death penalty after veto-override. Available at: http://www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-32910693 (accessed 28 May 2015).

Beale

(2014) Public opinion and the abolition or retention of the death penalty: Why is the United States different? Paper presented at the International Society for Reform of Criminal Law conference, Vancouver, British Columbia. Available at: http://dx.doi.org/10.2139/ssrn.2488175

Bearman

(2015a) Nebraska lawmakers abolish the death penalty, narrowly overriding governor’s veto. Washington Post, 27 May. Available at: https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/post-nation/wp/2015/05/27/nebraska-lawmakers-officially-abolish-the-death-penalty/

Bearman

(2015b) How Nebraska abolished the death penalty. The Atlantic, 27 May. https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2015/05/how-nebraska-banned-the-death-penalty/394271/

10.

Beckett

(1997) Making Crime Pay. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

11.

Beckett

Reosti

Knaphus

(2016) The end of an era? Understanding the contradictions of criminal justice reform. The ANNALS of the American Academy of Political and Social Science 664(1): 238–259.

12.

Bosman

(2015) Nebraska bans death penalty, defying a veto. The New York Times, 28 May. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2015/05/28/us/nebraska-abolishes-death-penalty.html

13.

Britto

Noga-Styron

(2014) Media consumption and support for capital punishment. Criminal Justice Review 39(1): 81–100.

14.

Brown

Socia

(2017) Twenty-first century punitiveness: Social sources of punitive American views reconsidered. Journal of Quantitative Criminology 33(4): 935–959.

15.

Carvalho

Chamberlen

(2018) Why punishment pleases: Punitive feelings in a world of hostile solidarity. Punishment & Society 20(2): 217–234.

16.

Cohen

(2016) The death penalty is alive and well. Available at: https://www.themarshallproject.org/2016/11/09/the-death-penalty-is-alive-and-well (accessed 9 November 2016).

17.

Costelloe

Chiricos

Gertz

(2009) Punitive attitudes toward criminals: Exploring the relevance of crime salience and economic insecurity. Punishment & Society 11(1): 25–49.

18.

Dardis

Baumgartner

Boydstun

, et al. (2008) Media framing of capital punishment and its impact on individuals' cognitive responses. Mass Communication & Society 11(2): 115–140.

19.

Death Penalty Information Center (n.d.(a)) Nebraska fact sheet. Available at: https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/nebraska-1 (accessed 21 January 2017).

20.

Death Penalty Information Center. (n.d.(b)) States with and without the death penalty. Available at: https://deathpenaltyinfo.org/states-and-without-death-penalty (accessed 21 January 2017).

21.

Dillman

Smyth

Christian

(2014) Internet, Phone, Mail, and Mixed-Mode Surveys: The Tailored Design Method. Hoboken, NJ: John Wiley & Sons, Inc.

22.

Ditton

Bannister

Gilchrist

, et al. (1999) Afraid or angry? Recalibrating the ‘fear’ of crime. International Review of Victimology 6(2): 83–99.

23.

Doob

Webster

(2014) Creating the will to change: The challenges of decarceration in the United States. Criminology & Public Policy 13(4): 547–559.

24.

Dowler

(2003) Media consumption and public attitudes toward crime and justice: The relationship between fear of crime, punitive attitudes, and perceived police effectiveness. Journal of Criminal Justice and Popular Culture 10(2): 109–126.

25.

Duggan

(2016) Judge dismisses lawsuit claiming death penalty voter petition drive is invalid. Omaha World-Herald, 1 February. Available at: http://www.omaha.com/news/nebraska/judge-dismisses-lawsuit-claiming-death-penalty-voter-petition-drive-is/article_d4277670-fd98-5624-a96b-8a75ba6036d0.html

26.

Duggan J, Hammel P, Nitcher E, et al. (2018) A monumental day: Nebraska executes Carey Dean Moore in state's first lethal injection. Omaha World-Herald, 15 Aug. Available at: https://www.omaha.com/news/crime/nebraska-executes-convicted-killer-carey-dean-moore-in-its-first/article_83cf2f84-9894-5de8-b58f-8140dcfd11f1.html.

27.

Elchardus

De Groof

Smits

(2008) Rational fear or represented malaise: A crucial test of two paradigms explaining fear of crime. Sociological Perspectives 51(3): 453–471.

28.

English

O’Muircheartaigh

Dekker

, et al. (2012) Predicting when to adopt given frame construction methods: Modeling coverage and cost benefits. Proceedings of the Survey Research Methods Section, American Statistical Association. Available at: http://ww2.amstat.org/sections/srms/proceedings/y2012/Files/400232_500672.pdf

29.

Enns

(2016) Incarceration Nation. New York: Cambridge University Press.

30.

Frost

(2010) Beyond public opinion polls: Punitive public sentiment & criminal justice policy. Sociology Compass 4(3): 156–168.

31.

Gallup (n.d.) Death penalty. Available at: http://www.gallup.com/poll/1606/death-penalty.aspx (accessed 31 January 2017).

32.

Garland

(2005) Capital punishment and American culture. Punishment & Society 7(4): 347–376.

33.

Garland

(2010) Peculiar Institution: America’s Death Penalty in an Age of Abolition. Cambridge, MA: Belknap Press.

34.

Goidel

Freeman

Procopio

(2006) The impact of television viewing on perceptions of juvenile crime. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 50(1): 119–139.

35.

Goodall

Slater

Myers

(2013) Fear and anger responses to local news coverage of alcohol‐related crimes, accidents, and injuries: Explaining news effects on policy support using a representative sample of messages and people. The Journal of Communication 63(2): 373–392.

36.

Gottschalk

(2014) Caught: The Prison State and the Lockdown of American Politics. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press.

37.

Gramlich

(2017) Five facts about crime in the U.S. Available at: http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2017/02/21/5-facts-about-crime-in-the-u-s/ (accessed 1 March 2017).

38.

Green

(2013) Penal optimism and second chances: The legacies of American Protestantism and the prospects for penal reform. Punishment & Society 15(2): 123–146.

39.

Green

(2015) U.S. penal-reform catalysts, drivers, and prospects. Punishment & Society 17(3): 271–298.

40.

Hammel

(2016) Nebraskans vote overwhelmingly to restore death penalty, nullify historic 2015 vote by state legislature. Omaha World-Herald, 9 November. Available at: http://www.omaha.com/news/politics/nebraskans-vote-overwhelmingly-to-restore-death-penalty-nullify-historic-vote/article_38823d54-a5df-11e6-9a5e-d7a71d75611a.html

41.

Hartnagel

Templeton

(2012) Emotions about crime and attitudes to punishment. Punishment & Society 14(4): 452–474.

42.

Johnson

(2009) Anger about crime and support for punitive criminal justice policies. Punishment & Society 11(1): 51–66.

43.

Jones

Saad

(2014) Gallup poll social series: Crime. Available at: http://www.gallup.com/file/poll/178823/141023DeathPenalty.pdf (accessed 1 March 2017).

44.

Kammer

(2011) Public opinion is more than law: Popular sovereignty and vigilantism in the Nebraska territory. Great Plains Quarterly 31(4): 309–324.

45.

Karstedt

(2002) Emotions and criminal justice. Theoretical Criminology 6(3): 299–317.

46.

Kelley

(2015) A century of death penalty support leads to historic repeal vote. Available at: http://netnebraska.org/article/news/975268/century-death-penalty-support-leads-historic-repeal-vote (accessed 21 May 2016).

47.

Kleck

Jackson

(2017) Does crime cause punitiveness? Crime & Delinquency 63(12): 1572–1599.

48.

Kort-Butler

Sittner

KJH

(2011) Watching the detectives: Crime programming, fear of crime, and attitudes about the criminal justice system. Sociological Quarterly 52(1): 36–55.

49.

Lambert

Camp

Clarke

, et al. (2011) The impact of information on death penalty support, revisited. Crime & Delinquency 57(4): 572–599.

50.

Laurison

(2015) The willingness to state an opinion: Inequality, don't know responses, and political participation. Sociological Forum 30(4): 925–948.

51.

Lehmann

Pickett

(2016) Experience versus expectation: Economic insecurity, the great recession, and support for the death penalty. Justice Quarterly 34(5): 873–902.

52.

Lowry

Nio

TCJ

Leitner

(2003) Setting the public fear agenda: A longitudinal analysis of network TV crime reporting, public perceptions of crime, and FBI crime statistics. Journal of Communication 53(1): 61–73.

53.

Luskin

Bullock

(2011) Don’t know means don’t know: DK responses and the public’s level of political knowledge. The Journal of Politics 73 (2): 547–557.

54.

Lynch

(2002) Capital punishment as moral imperative: Pro-death penalty discourse on the internet. Punishment & Society 4(2): 213–236.

55.

Lyons

Scheingold

(2000) The politics of crime and punishment. In: LaFree

(ed.) The Nature of Crime: Continuity and Change, Criminal Justice 2000, vol. 1. Washington, DC: United States Department of Justice, pp. 103–149.

56.

McCarthy

(2015) More Americans say crime is rising in U. S. Available at: http://www.gallup.com/poll/186308/americans-say-crime-rising.aspx (accessed 1 March 2017).[Mismatch]

57.

The Marshall Project (2018) The next to die: Watching death row. Available at: https://www.themarshallproject.org/next-to-die/ne/tcn43xcn (accessed 17 August 2018).

58.

Menard

(2010) Lest we forget: The lynching of Will Brown, Omaha’s 1919 race riot. Nebraska History 91: 152–165. Available at: http://www.nebraskahistory.org/publish/publicat/history/full-text/NH2010Lynching.pdf[Mismatch]

59.

Messner

Baumer

Rosenfeld

(2006) Distrust of government, the vigilante tradition, and support for capital punishment. Law & Society Review 40(3): 559–590.

60.

National Research Council (2014) The growth of incarceration in the United States: Exploring causes and consequences. In: J

Travis

Western

Redburn

(eds) Committee on Law and Justice, Division of Behavioral and Sciences and Education. Washington, DC: The National Academies Press.

61.

Nebraska Legislative Bill 268 (2015) Available at: http://nebraskalegislature.gov/FloorDocs/104/PDF/Final/LB268.pdf (accessed 1 October 2015).

62.

Nebraska Secretary of State (2016) Revised official report of the Board of State Canvassers. Available at: http://www.sos.ne.gov/elec/2016/pdf/2016-canvass-book.pdf (accessed 1 December 2016).

63.

Nohr

(2016) Nebraska Catholic conference launches campaign urging voters to retain repeal of death penalty. Omaha World-Herald, 29 September. Available at: http://www.omaha.com/news/politics/nebraska-catholic-conference-launches-campaign-urging-voters-to-retain-repeal/article_12fcabac-48f8-5c3d-bbf1-392010bc6391.html

64.

Oliphant

(2016) Support for death penalty lowest in more than four decades. Available at: http://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/09/29/support-for-death-penalty-lowest-in-more-than-four-decades (accessed 1 October 2016).

65.

Oravecz

Faust

Batchelder

(2014) An extended cultural consensus theory model to account for cognitive processes in decision making in social surveys. Sociological Methodology 44(1): 185–228.

66.

Peffley

Hurwitz

(2007) Persuasion and resistance: Race and the death penalty in America. American Journal of Political Science 51(4): 996–1012.

67.

Pew Research Center (2015) Less support for death penalty, especially among Democrats. Available at: http://www.people-press.org/2015/04/16/less-support-for-death-penalty-especially-among-democrats/ (accessed 16 April 2015).

68.

Phelps

(2016) Possibilities and contestation in twenty-first-century us criminal justice downsizing. Annual Review of Law and Social Science 12: 153–170.

69.

Pickett

(2016) Reintegrative populism? Public opinion and the criminology of downsizing. Criminology & Public Policy 15(1): 131–135.

70.

Rosenberger

Callanan

(2011) The influence of media on penal attitudes. Criminal Justice Review 36(4): 435–455.

71.

Seiver

(2015) Life after Nebraska’s death penalty: How other states dealt with their death rows after killing capital punishment. Available at: https://www.themarshallproject.org/2015/08/13/life-after-nebraska-s-death-penalty (accessed 31 August 2015).

72.

Soss

Langbein

Metelko

(2003) Why do white Americans support the death penalty?. The Journal of Politics 65(2): 397–421.

73.

Suh

(2015) Democracy and the making of contentious policy: The role of democracy in the abolition of the death penalty, 1950–201. International Journal of Comparative Sociology 56(5): 314–337.

74.

Surette

(2003) The media, the public, and criminal justice policy. Journal of the Institute of Justice and International Studies 2: 39–52.

75.

Thielo

Cullen

Cohen

, et al. (2015) Rehabilitation in a red state: Public support for correctional reform in Texas. Criminology & Public Policy 15(1): 137–170.

76.

Travis

(2014) Assessing the state of mass incarceration: Tipping point or the new normal? Criminology & Public Policy 13(4): 567–577.

77.

Tyler

Weber

(1982) Support for the death penalty: Instrumental response to crime, or symbolic attitude. Law & Society Review 17(1): 21–46.

78.

Unnever

Cullen

(2010) The social sources of Americans' punitiveness: A test of three competing models. Criminology 48(1): 99–129.

79.

Unnever

Cullen

Roberts

(2005) Not everyone strongly supports the death penalty: Assessing weakly-held attitudes about capital punishment. American Journal of Criminal Justice 29(2): 187–216.

80.

Vollum

Buffington-Vollum

(2010) An examination of social-psychological factors and support for the death penalty: Attribution, Moral disengagement, and the value-expressive function of attitudes. American Journal of Criminal Justice 35(1–2): 15–36.

81.

Vollum

Longmire

Buffington-Vollum

(2004) Confidence in the death penalty and support for its use: Exploring the value-expressive dimension of death penalty attitudes. Justice Quarterly 21(3): 521–546.

82.

Weitzer

Kubrin

(2004) Breaking news: How local TV news and real-world conditions affect fear of crime. Justice Quarterly 21(3): 497–520.

83.

Worthen

MGF

Rodgers

Sharp

(2014) Expanding the spectrum of attitudes toward the death penalty: How non-dichotomous response options affect our understandings of death penalty attitudes. Criminal Justice Review 39(2): 160–181.

84.

Wozniak

(2016a) Ontological insecurity, racial tension, and confidence in the police in the shadow of urban unrest. Sociological Forum 31(4): 1063–1082.

85.

Wozniak

(2016b) Public opinion and the politics of criminal justice policy making: Reasons for optimism, pessimism, and uncertainty. Criminology & Public Policy 15(1): 179–186.

86.

Wozniak

(2017) The relationship between perceptions of prison and support for the death penalty versus life without parole. Journal of Crime and Justice 40(2): 222–237.

87.

Young

(2015) Ricketts, McCoy declare support for death penalty referendum. Lincoln Journal Star, 2 June. Available at: http://journalstar.com/news/state-and-regional/govt-and-politics/ricketts-mccoy-will-support-for-death-penalty-referendum/article_f0208970-4c28-523d-822f-9adc741b85e2.html

88.

Zimring

(2003) The Cultural Contradictions of American Capital Punishment. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

89.

Zimring

Hawkins

Kamin

(2001) Punishment and Democracy: Three Strikes and You’re out in California. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.