This article examines the growth, influence and limits of penal populism in New
Zealand. In this country, it argues, there were four crucial factors associated with
this: disenchantment with the existing democratic process; the dynamics of crime and
insecurity in a period of considerable social change; the growth and influence of
‘victimization groups’; the emergence of a new kind of penal expertise.
ACT NZ
(2002a) Crime and justice. Available at
http://www.act.org.nz/action/campaigns/manifesto2002/crime.html (last
accessed 1 July 2002).
2.
ACT NZ
(2002b) Will this criminologist debate the issues?Wellington: ACT NZ
, press release 30 September.
3.
Aimer, Peter
and
Raymond Miller
(2002) ‘New Zealand politics in the
1990s’, in
Jack Vowles
,
Peter Aimer
,
Susan Banducci
,
Jeffrey Karp
,
Raymond Miller
and
Ann Sullivan
(eds) Proportional representation on trial: The 1999 New Zealand general
election and the fate of MMP, pp. 1-16.
Auckland: Auckland University Press
.
4.
Bauman, Zygmunt
(1997) Postmodernity and its discontents.
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
Bottoms, Anthony E.
(1995) ‘The philosophy and politics of
punishment and sentencing’, in
Chris Clarkson
and
Rod Morgan
(eds) The politics of sentencing reform, pp.
15-49.
Oxford: Clarendon
.
7.
Braithwaite, John
(1999)
‘Restorative justice: Assessing optimistic and pessimistic accounts’
, Crime and Justice25:
1-110
.
8.
Christie, Nils
(1993) Crime control as industry.
London: Routledge
.
9.
Church, Stephen
(2000) ‘Crime and punishment: The referenda to
reform the criminal justice system and reduce the size of
parliament’, in
Jonathon Boston
,
Stephen Church
,
Stephen Levine
,
Elizabeth McCleay
and
Nigel Roberts
(eds) Left turn: The New Zealand general election of 1999, pp.
184-199.
Wellington: Victoria University Press
.
10.
Daly, Kathy
(2002)
‘Restorative justice: The real story’
, Punishment & Society4(1):
55-79
.
11.
Department of Corrections
(2001) About time: Turning people away from a life of crime
and reducing re-offending.
Wellington: Department of Corrections
. Available at
http://corrections.govt.nz/objects/ps/33/633.url.pdf (last accessed 28
September 2002).
12.
Freiberg, Arie
(2003)
‘The four pillars of justice’
, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology36(2):
223-230
.
13.
Fukuyama, Francis
(1995) Trust: The social virtues and the creation of
prosperity.
New York: Free Press
.
14.
Garland, David
(1996)
‘The limits of the sovereign state: Strategies of crime control
in contemporary society’
, British Journal of Criminology36(4):
445-471
.
15.
Garland, David
(2001) The culture of control.
Oxford: Oxford University Press
.
16.
Garland, David
(2002)
‘The cultural uses of capital punishment’
, Punishment & Society4(4):
459-487
.
17.
Giddens, Anthony
(1990) The consequences of modernity.
Cambridge: Polity Press
.
18.
James, Colin
(1986) The quiet revolution.
Auckland: Penguin
.
19.
Karp, Jeffrey
and
Peter Aimer
(2002) ‘Direct democracy on trial: The
citizens-initiated referendums’, in
Jack Vowles
,
Peter Aimer
,
Susan Banducci
,
Jeffrey Karp
,
Raymond Miller
and
Ann Sullivan
(eds) Proportional representation on trial: The 1999 New Zealand general
election and the fate of MMP, pp. 146-159.
Auckland: Auckland University Press
.
20.
Karp, Jeffrey
and
Susan Banducci
(1998) ‘Voter satisfaction after electoral
change’, in
Jack Vowles
,
Peter Aimer
,
Susan Banducci
and
Jeffrey Carp
(eds) Voters’ victory? New Zealand’s first election
under proportional representation, pp. 150-164.
Auckland: Auckland University Press
.
21.
Kelsey, J.
(1995) The New Zealand experiment.
Auckland: Auckland University Press
.
22.
Labour Party
(2002) Labour on justice and law and order. Available
at
http://www.labour.org.nz/fb.asp?url+http://www.liveupdater.com/labourparty/LABOURpol-justice.asp
(last accessed 1 July 2002).
23.
McGregor, Judy
(1993) Crime news as prime news in New Zealand’s
metropolitan press.
Auckland: Legal research foundation
.
24.
Ministry of Justice
(2002) Reforming the criminal justice system.
Wellington: Ministry of Justice
.
25.
Ministry of Justice
(2003) Attitudes to crime and punishment: A New Zealand
study.
Wellington: Ministry of Justice
.
26.
Morris, Allison
and
Gabrielle Maxwell
(1993)
‘Juvenile justice in New Zealand: A new paradigm’
, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology26(1):
72-90
.
27.
Morris, Allison
and
James Reilly in collaboration with Sheila Berry and Robin Ransom
(2003) New Zealand national survey of crime victims
2001.
Wellington: Ministry of Justice
.
28.
MRL Research Group
(1993) Public attitudes towards policing.
Wellington: New Zealand National Headquarters
.
29.
National Party
(2002) Law and order policy. Available at
http://www.national.org.nz/wcontent.asp?PageID=100006904 (last accessed 1
July 2002).
30.
New Zealand First
(2002) Law and order. Available at
http://www.nzfirst.org.nzpolicy/law.htm (last accessed 1 July 2002).
31.
New Zealand Yearbook (1984)
Wellington: Government Printer
.
32.
Parker, Lynne
(2002) New Zealand expands official recognition of
restorative justice.
Auckland: Restorative Justice Trust
.
33.
Perry, Paul
and
Alan Webster
(1994) ‘Against the tide: A government failure in
popular persuasion’, unpublished paper.
Palmerston North: Massey University
.
34.
Pratt, John
(1998) Governing the dangerous.
Sydney: Federation Press
.
35.
Pratt, John
(2002) Punishment and civilization.
London: Sage Publications
.
36.
Pratt, John
and
Philip Treacher
(1988)
‘Law and order and the 1987 New Zealand election’
, Australia and New Zealand Journal of Criminology21(3):
253-268
.
37.
Quarterly labour force statistics (2000)
Wellington: Government Printer
.
38.
Report of the Royal Commission on Social Policy (1988)
Wellington: Government Printer
.
39.
Report of the Royal Commission on Violence (1987)
Wellington: Government Printer
.
40.
Roberts, Julian
,
Loretta Stalans
,
David Indermaur
and
Mike Hough
(2003) Penal populism and public opinion.
New York: Oxford University Press
.
41.
Robinson, Jan
,
Warren Young
and
Steve Haslett
(1990) Surveying crime.
Wellington: Institute of Criminology, Victoria University
.
42.
Simon, Jonathan
(1995)
‘They died with their boots on: The boot camp and the limits of
modern penality’
, Social Justice22(1):
25-48
.
43.
Simon, Jonathan
(1997) ‘Governing through
crime’, in
L. Friedman
and
G. Fisher
(eds) The crime conundrum, pp. 171-189.
New York: Westview Press
.
44.
Statistics New Zealand
(2002) Immigration patterns.
Wellington: Government Printer
.
45.
Taylor, Ian
(1995)
‘Private homes and public others: Analysis of talk about crime in
suburban south Manchester in the mid 1990s’
, British Journal of Criminology,!35(2):
263-285
.
46.
United Future New Zealand
(2002) Position papers - law and order. Available at
http://www.united.org.nz/law.html (last accessed 1 July 2002).
47.
Vowles, Jack
(2002) ‘The puzzle of
turnout’, in
Jack Vowles
,
Peter Aimer
,
Susan Banducci
,
Jeffrey Karp
,
Raymond Miller
and
Ann Sullivan
(eds) Proportional representation on trial: The 1999 New Zealand general
election and the fate of MMP, pp. 99-113.
Auckland: Auckland University Press
.
48.
Young, Warren
,
Allison Morris
,
Neil Cameron
and
Steve Haslett
(1997) New Zealand national survey of crime victims
1996.
Wellington: Ministry of Justice
.
49.
Zimring, Franklin
(1996)
‘Populism, democratic government, and the decline of expert authority’
, Pacific Law Journal28(1):
243-256
.
