This essay offers a critical rereading of the western theological and legal doctrine of illegitimacy or bastardy. The author traces the western stigma against bastards to the Bible, particularly to the story of Ishamel, the illegitimate son of Abraham and Hagar. He then shows the systematic discrimination against bastards in classic canon law and in early modern Anglo-American common law, and the slow amelioration of their plight in legal reforms in the United States in the past century. The author concludes that the western doctrine of illegitimacy is theologically illegitimate and suggests a few historically-informed legal remedies, notably adoption, that would help mitigate the plight of illegitimates today.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abrahamson, Mark (1998) Out of wedlock birth: The United States in comparative perspective. Westport, CT/London: Praeger .
2.
Abrams, Douglas E. and Sarah H. Ramsey (2000) Children and the law: Doctrine, policy, and practice. St Paul, MN: West Group .
3.
Adair, Richard (1996) Courtship, illegitimacy and marriage in early modern England. Manchester: Manchester University Press .
4.
Aquinas, Thomas (1948) Summa theologica, 5 vols. Trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province. Allen, TX: Christian Classics .
5.
Ayer, John C., Jr (1902) `Legitimacy and marriage' , Harvard Law Review16: 22-42 .
6.
Bacon, Matthew (1798) A new abridgement of the law, 5th edn, 7 vols. London: A. Strathan .
7.
Blackstone, William (1884) Commentaries on the law of England, 3rd rev. edn. Ed. Thomas H. Cooley. Chicago, IL: Callaghan & Company .
8.
Blankenhorn, David (1995) Fatherless America: Confronting our most urgent social problem. New York: Basic Books .
9.
Boswell, John (1988) The kindness of strangers: The abandonment of children in Western Europe from late antiquity to the Renaissance. New York: Pantheon Books .
10.
Brinton, Crane (1936) The French revolutionary legislation on illegitimacy. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
11.
Browning, Don S., Bonnie J.Miller-McLemore, Pamela D. Couture, K. Brynolf Lyon and Robert Franklin (1997) From culture wars to common ground: Religion and the American family debate. Louisville, KY: Westminster John Knox Press .
12.
Brundage, James A. (1987) Law, sex, and Christian society in medieval Europe. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press .
13.
Brydall, John (1703) Lex spuriorum, or the law relating to bastardy. London: Atkins .
14.
Burn, Richard (1797) Ecclesiastical law, 6th edn, 4 vols. London: A. Strathan .
15.
Clark, Homer H. (1988) The law of domestic relations in the United States, 2nd edn. St Paul, MN: West Publishing Co.
16.
Couvreur, Gilles (1961) Les pauvres ont-ils des droits? Rome: Libraria editrice dell'Universita Gregoriana .
17.
Généstal, Robert (1905) Histoire de la légitimation des enfants naturales en droit canonique. Paris: E. Lourex .
18.
Godolphin, John (1687) Reportorium canonicum, 3rd edn. London: Assigns of R. & E. Atkins .
19.
Hartley, Shirley (1975) Illegitimacy. Berkeley/Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press .
20.
Helmholz, R.H. (1969) `Bastardy litigation in medieval England' , American Journal of Legal History13: 360-383 .
21.
Helmholz, R.H. (1977) `Support orders, church courts, and the rule of Filius Nullius: A reassessment of the common law' , Virginia Law Review63: 431-448 .
22.
Hendrix, Lewellyn (1996) Illegitimacy and social structures. Westport, CT: Bergin & Garvey .
23.
Jackson, Mark (1996) New-born child murder: Women, illegitimacy, and the courts in eighteenth-century England. Manchester: Manchester University Press .
24.
Jackson, Timothy P. (1999) Love disconsoled: Meditations on Christian charity. Cambridge/New York: Cambridge University Press .
25.
James, T.E. (1957) `The illegitimate and deprived child: Legitimation and adoption', in A Century of Family Law: 1857-1957, pp. 39-55. London: Sweet & Maxwell .
26.
Kent, James (1827) Commentaries on American law, 2 vols. New York: O. Halsted .
27.
Krause, Harry D. (1971) Illegitimacy: Law and social policy. Indianapolis: The Bobbs-Merrill Company, Inc.
28.
Laslett, Peter (1977) The family and illicit love in early generations. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
29.
Laslett, Peter, Karla Oosterveen and Richard M. Smith, eds (1980) Bastardy and its comparative history: Studies in the history of illegitimacy and marital non-conformism in Britain, France, Germany, Sweden, North America, Jamaica, and Japan. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press .
30.
Mackin, Theodor (1982) Marriage in the Catholic Church: What is marriage? New York: Paulist Press .
31.
Malinowski, Bronislaw (1962) Sex, culture, and myth. New York: Harcourt, Brace & World .
32.
Popenoe, David and Barbara DaFoe Whitehead (1998-2000) The state of our unions. Rutgers, NJ: National Marriage Project .
33.
Post, Stephen G. (2000) More lasting unions: Christianity, the family, and society. Grand Rapids, MI: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing Co.
34.
Reekie, Gail (1998) Measuring immorality: Social inquiry and the problem of legitimacy. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
35.
Rose, Lionel (1986) The massacre of the innocents: Infanticide in Britain 1800-1939. London/Boston, MA: Routledge & Kegan Paul .
36.
Schaberg, Jane (1987) The illegitimacy of Jesus. San Francisco, CA: Harper & Row .
37.
Schmugge, Ludwig and Béatrice Wiggenhauser, eds (1994) Illegitimität im spätmittelalter. Munich: R. Oldenbourg Verlag .
38.
Thomas, Mason P., Jr (1972) `Child abuse and neglect. Part I: Historical overview, legal matrix, and social perspectives' , North Carolina Law Review50: 293-349 .
39.
Tierney, Brian (1959) Medieval poor law: A sketch of canonical theory and its application in England. Berkeley/Los Angeles, CA: University of California Press .
40.
Vernier, Chester G. (1938) American family law: A comparative study of the family law of the forty-eight American states, Alaska, the District of Columbia, and Hawaii, vol. 4 (1936, 1938 supplement). University of California: Stanford University Press . [1931-8. London: H. Milford, Oxford University Press.]
41.
Witte, John, Jr (1997) From sacrament to contract: Marriage, religion, and law in the western tradition. Louisville: Westminster/John Knox Press .
42.
Witte, John, Jr. (2002) Law and Protestantism: The Legal Teachings of the Lutheran Reformation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
43.
Zainaldin, Jamil S. (1979) `The emergence of a modern American family law: Child custody, adoption, and the courts, 1796-1851' , Northwestern University Law Review73(6): 1038-1089 .
44.
Zingo, Martha T. and Kevin E. Early (1994) Nameless persons: Legal discrimination against non-marital children in the United States. Westport, CT: Praeger .
