Authenticity is frequently seen as crucial in archaeology. In this paper, we examine the nature of authenticity and question by implication whether so much attention should be given to determining the actual age and thus the genuineness of archaeological objects. We show that numbers of authenticated objects are potentially fakes. There is an acceptance that many archaeological sites and reconstructions are not actually really old, although the acceptability of this view depends on one's flexibility towards the concept of authenticity. It is clear that the public does not necessarily put the same value on genuineness as do archaeologists. We suggest that certain aspects of the past have always been a potentially renewable resource. We suggest that a more relaxed approach to genuineness and authenticity is acceptable today and is already accepted by the public as consumers of the past.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
BAGNALL, G., 1996. Consuming the past. In S. Edgell, K. Hetherington and A. Wade (eds), Consumption Matters.: the Production and Experience of Consumption: 227-247. Oxford: Blackwell .
2.
BALE, J., 1999. Art world corrupted by £250 fakes. The Times, 13 February 1999.
3.
BAZELMANS, JOSPETER VAN DOMMELEN, JAN KOLEN and MICHAEL SHANKS, 1994. A ruined past: experience and reality. An archaeological dialoge with Michael Shanks . Archaeological Dialogues1: 56-76 .
BLATHERWICK, S. and A. GURR, 1992. Shakespeare's factory: archaeological evaluations on the site of the Globe Theatre at 1/5 Anchor Terrace, Southwark Bridge Road, Southwark . Antiquity66: 315-333 .
6.
BOWMAN, M., 1994. The commodification of the Celt: New Age/Neo-Pagan consumerism. In T. Brewer (ed.), The Marketing of Tradition: Perspectives on Folklore, Tourism and the Heritage Industry: 143-152. Middlesex: Hissarlik Press .
7.
BOWSHER, J., 1998. The Rose Theatre: an Archaeological Discovery. London: Museum of London .
8.
CHIPPINDALE, C. and D.W.J. GILL, 1993. Material and intellectual consequences of esteem for Cycladic figurines . American Journal of Archaeology97: 601-601, 659-659 .
9.
CLEERE, HENRY (ed.), 1989. Archaeological Heritage Management in the modern world . One World Archaeology, vol. 9. London: Unwin Hyman .
10.
COHEN, ERIC, 1988. Authenticity and commoditization in tourism . Annals of Tourism Research15: 371-386 .
11.
COPE, JULIAN, 1998. The Modern Antiquarian: a Pre-millennial Odyssey through Megalithic Britain. London: Thorsons .
12.
ECO, UMBERTO, 1990 [1986]. Fakes and forgeries. In U. Eco, The Limits of Interpretation: Ch. 12. Bloomington: Indiana University Press .
13.
FEES, CRAIG, 1996. Tourism and the politics of authenticity in a North Cotswold town. In T. Selwyn (ed.), The Tourist Image: Myths and Myth Making in Tourism: 121-146. Chichester: Wiley & Sons .
14.
GILBERTSON, D., 1984. Late Quaternary Environments and Early Man in Holderness. BAR 134. Oxford: British Archaeological Reports .
15.
GURR, A. 1997. Shakespeare's Globe: a history of reconstructions and some reasons for trying. In J.R. Mulryne and M.R. Shewring (eds), Shakespeare's Globe rebuilt: 27-47. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
16.
HARBISON, P., 1975. Guide to the National Monuments in the Republic of Ireland. Dublin: Gill and Macmillan .
17.
HEWISON, ROBERT, 1987. The Heritage Industry. London: Methuen .
18.
HEWISON, ROBERT, 1991. Commerce and culture. In J. Corner and S. Harvey (eds), Enterprise and Heritage: Crosscurrents of National Culture: 169-177. London: Routledge .
19.
HOLTORF, CORNELIUS, 1992. Der Stein. Eine Dokumentation über den Menhir von Tübingen-Weilheim. Photocopied report.
20.
HOLTORF, CORNELIUS, forthcoming. Is the past a non-renewable resource? In R.'Layton, P. Stone, J. Thomas (eds), The Destruction and Conservation of Cultural Property. One World Archaeology Series. London: Routledge .
21.
ICOMOS, 1966. International Charter for the Conservation and Restoration of Monuments and Sites (The Venice Charter). Available at http://www.icomos.org/docs/venice_charter.html (accessed 15 March 1999).
22.
JOKILEHTO, JUKKA, 1995. Authenticity: a general framework for the concept. In K.E.'Larsen (ed.), Nara Conference on Authenticity. Proceedings of the Conference in Nara, Japan, 1-6 November 1994: 17-34. Trondheim: Tapir .
KARLSSON, HÅKAN, 1998. Re-Thinking Archaeology. GOTARC Serie B. Göteborg: Göteborgs universitet, Institutionen för arkeologi.
25.
LARSEN, KNUT EINAR (ed.), 1995. Nara Conference on Authenticity. Proceedings of the Conference in Nara, Japan, 1-6 November 1994. Trondheim: Tapir .
26.
LARSEN, KNUT EINAR and NILS MARSEIN (eds), 1994. Conference on Authenticity in Relation to the World Heritage Convention. Proceedings of the Preparatory Workshop in Bergen, Norway, 31 January-2 February 1994. Oslo: Riksantikvaren .
27.
LOWENTHAL, DAVID, 1985. The Past is a Foreign Country. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
28.
LOWENTHAL, DAVID, 1989. Art and authenticity. In I. Lavin (ed.), World of Art: Themes of Unity in Diversity: 843-847. University Park, PA: Pennsylvania University Press .
29.
LOWENTHAL, DAVID, 1994. Criteria of authenticity. In K. E. Larsen and N. Marstein (eds), Conference on Authenticity in Relation to the World Heritage Convention. Proceedings of the Preparatory Workshop in Bergen, Norway, 31 January-2 February 1994: 35-64. Oslo: Riksantikvaren .
30.
LOWENTHAL, DAVID, 1995. Changing criteria of authenticity. In K. E. Larsen (ed.), Nara Conference on Authenticity. Proceedings of the Conference in Nara, Japan, 1-6 November 1994: 121-135. Trondheim: Tapir .
31.
MACCANNELL, DEAN, 1973. Staged authenticity: arrangements of social space in tourist settings . American Journal of Sociology79(3): 589-603 .
32.
NEIDHARDT, MARKUS, 1998. Das Geschmeyde unserer Ahnen. Katalog Juli 1998. Nidderau: Replikate and Schmuckdesign Markus Neidhardt.
33.
PETZET, MICHAEL, 1995. 'In the full richness of their authenticity' - The test of authenticity and the new cult of monuments. In K. E. Larsen (ed.), Nara Conference on Authenticity. Proceedings of the Conference in Nara, Japan, 1-6 November 1994: 85-99. Trondheim: Tapir .
34.
RANDSBORG, KLAVS, 1993. Kivik. Archaeology and iconography. Acta Archaeologica 64(1).
35.
RIEGL, ALOIS, 1982 [1903]. The modern cult of monuments: its character and its origin . Oppositions25(Fall 1982): 21-51 .
SCHADLA-HALL, R.T., 1989. Tom Sheppard: Hull'S Great Collector. Beverley: Highgate Publications .
38.
SCHADLA-HALL, R.T., 1999. Shakespeare's Globe-'as faithful a copy as scholarship... could get...','... a bit of a bastard...'. In P.G. Stone and P.G. Planel (eds), The Constructed Past: Experimental Archaeology, Education and the Public: 216-226. London: Routledge .
39.
SHANKS, MICHAEL, 1992. Experiencing the Past. On the Character of Archaeology. London: Routledge .
40.
SHANKS, MICHAEL, 1995. Archaeological experiences and a critical romanticism. In M.Tusa and T.Kirkinen (eds), Nordic TAG. The Archaeologist and His/Her Reality. Report from the fourth Nordic TAG conference Helsinki 1992: 17-36. Helsinki Papers in Archaeology 7. University of Helsinki Department of Archaeology .
41.
SHANKS, MICHAEL, 1998. The life of an artefact in an interpretive archaeology . Fennoscandia Archaeology15: 15-30 .
42.
SHANKS, MICHAEL and CHRISTOPHER TILLEY, 1987. Re-Constructing Archaeology. Cambridge University Press .
43.
SHEPPARD, T., 1932. Fact and Fictin in Geology. Hull Museum Publications 179. Hull: Hull Museum .
44.
THOMAS, JULIAN, 1993. Authenticity temporality and the past . Manuscript of a lecture prepared for the University of Wales, Lampeter.
45.
TRIGGER, BRUCE G.,1989. A History of Archaeological Thought., Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .
46.
TROTZIG, GUSTAV, 1998. As good as old/new: problems of adjusting the modern archaeological heritage to modern society . Paper given at the WAC Inter-Congress, Brač, Croatia, May.
47.
TUNBRIDGE, J.E. and G.J. ASHWORTH, 1996. Dissonant Heritage: the Management of the Past as a Resource in Conflict. Chichester: Wiley & Sons .
48.
VON DROSTE, BERND and ULF BERTILSSON, 1995. Authenticity and World Heritage. In K.E. Larsen (ed.), Nara Conference on Authenticity. Proceedings of the Conference in Nara, Japan, 1-6 November 1994: 3-15. Trondheim:Tapir .
49.
WHEELER, R.E.M., 1943. Maiden Castle, Dorset. Oxford: Oxford University Press .
50.
WILSON, J., 1997. The Great Globe itself Sam Wanamaker's 'Shakespeare's Globe' . Antiquity71: 738-744 .
