Anonymous dissent: Protest,privacy,and photographic surveillance in digital media

Abstract

Protesters in recent years have been making a somewhat novel demand: they are asking journalists to blur their faces in news coverage of public demonstrations. This article investigates this demand to explore how new surveillance technologies and the political economy of media are complicating the ethics of visual journalism. Reviewing 26 articles from news outlets, trade publications, and blogs published between May 2020 and October 2024 that discussed protesters’ demand, the study considers three themes: visibility and surveillance in digital media; the ethical contradictions that visual journalists navigate while documenting dissent; and the relationships among journalists, movements, and political-economic power structures. The article contrasts Enlightenment ideals with an ethic of care to understand journalists’ views on transparency and truth, concluding that the uneven power dynamics among protesters, journalists and the state raise important questions about the documentation, preservation and circulation of dissent.

Keywords

Ethics facial recognition technology privacy protest surveillance visual journalism

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Arguedas

Mukherjee

Nielsen

(2024) Women and leadership in the news media 2024: evidence from 12 markets. Available at: https://reutersinstitute.politics.ox.ac.uk/women-and-leadership-news-media-2024-evidence-12-markets (accessed 12 December 2024).

Benjamin

(2019a) Assessing risk, automating racism. Science 366(6464): 421–422.

Benjamin

(2019b) Race after Technology: Abolitionist Tools for the New Jim Code. Cambridge; Malden, MA: Polity Press.

Berkowitz

(2000) Doing double duty: paradigm repair and the Princess Diana what-a-story. Journalism 1(2): 125–143.

Blackstock

(1988) COINTELPRO: The Fbi’s Secret War on Political Freedom. Atlanta, GA: Pathfinder Press. Available at: https://www.pathfinderpress.com/products/cointelpro-fbis-secret-war-on-political-freedom_by-nelson-blackstock (accessed 4 November 2024)

Bock

(2021) Seeing Justice: Witnessing, Crime and Punishment in Visual Media. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Bock

Lough

Fadnis

(2017) “Her” photographer: the Roanoke live-shot murders and visual communication’s place in the newsroom. Visual Communication Quarterly 24(3):162–173.

Bonilla-Silva

(2021) Racism without Racists: Color-blind Racism and the Persistence of Racial Inequality in America. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

Boudana

(2016) Impartiality is not fair: toward an alternative approach to the evaluation of content bias in news stories. Journalism 17(5): 600–618.

10.

Bratich

(2007) Popular secrecy and occultural studies. Cultural Studies 21(1): 42–58.

11.

Bristow

(2023) Enlightenment. In: Zalta

Nodelman

(eds) The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy. Fall 2023. Metaphysics Research Lab, Stanford University. Available at: https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2023/entries/enlightenment/ (accessed 26 October 2024).

12.

Brown

Harlow

(2019) Protests, media coverage, and a hierarchy of social struggle. The International Journal of Press/politics 24(4): 508–530.

13.

Brown

Mourão

(2021) Protest coverage matters: how media framing and visual communication affects support for black civil rights protests. Mass Communication and Society 24(4): 576–596.

14.

Brown

Mourao

Sylvie

(2019) Martin to brown: how time and platform impact coverage of the Black Lives Matter movement. Journalism Practice 13(4): 413–430.

15.

Browne

(2015) Dark Matters: On the Surveillance of Blackness. Durham, NC: Duke University Press. Available at: https://www.dukeupress.edu/dark-matters (accessed 30 October 2024)

16.

Canella

(2017) Social movement documentary practices: digital storytelling, social media and organizing. Digital Creativity 28(1): 24–37.

17.

Carlson

(2016) Metajournalistic discourse and the meanings of journalism: definitional control, boundary work, and legitimation. Communication Theory 26(4): 349–368.

18.

Carlson

(2017) Journalistic Authority: Legitimating News in the Digital Era. New York: Columbia University Press.

19.

Chan

Lee

(1984) The journalistic paradigm on civil protests: a case study of Hong Kong. In: Arno

Dissanayake

(eds) The News Media in National and International Conflict. London: Westview Press, pp. 183–202.

20.

Chapnick

(1994) Truth Needs No Ally: Inside Photojournalism. Columbia, MO: University of Missouri Press.

21.

Churchill

Vander Wall

(2002) The COINTELPRO Papers: Documents from the Fbi’s Secret Wars against Dissent in the United States. Cambridge, MA: South End Press. Available at: https://africaworldpressbooks.com/the-cointelpro-papers-by-ward-churchill-jim-vander-wall/ (accessed 4 November 2024).

22.

Cookman

(1985) A Voice Is Born: The Founding and Early Years of the National Press Photographers Association Under the Leadership of Joseph Costa. Durham, NC: National Press Photographers Association.

23.

Culver

McLeod

(2023) “Anti-Riot” or “Anti-Protest” legislation? Black lives matter, news framing, and the protest paradigm. Journalism and Media 4(1): 216–230.

24.

Deane

(2024) Americans’ deepening mistrust of institutions. Pew, 17 October. Available at: https://www.pewtrusts.org/en/trend/archive/fall-2024/americans-deepening-mistrust-of-institutions (accessed 1 April 2025).

25.

Do No Harm: Photographing Police Brutality Protests (2020) Authority Collective, 1 May. Available at: https://bit.ly/DoNoHarm_AC

26.

Douglas

(2020) Journalists face record attacks during Black Lives Matter protests. The Reporters Committee for Freedom of the Press. Available at: https://www.rcfp.org/black-lives-matter-press-freedom/ (accessed 11 December 2024).

27.

Duffy

(2014) Anonymous sources: a historical review of the norms surrounding their use. American Journalism 31(2): 236–261.

28.

Durham

(2024) Decolonizing bodies and the ethics of care: on the significance of embodied vulnerability as the future of cultural studies. International Journal of Cultural Studies 27(3): 291–301.

29.

Emerson

Fretz

Shaw

(2011) Writing Ethnographic Fieldnotes. 2nd ed. (Chicago Guides to Writing, Editing, and Publishing). Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press. Available at: https://press.uchicago.edu/ucp/books/book/chicago/W/bo12182616.html (accessed 10 March 2023).

30.

Fairclough

(2003) Analysing Discourse: Textual Analysis for Social Research. New York: Routledge. Available at: https://www.routledge.com/Analysing-Discourse-Textual-Analysis-for-Social-Research/Fairclough/p/book/9780415258937 (accessed 22 November 2024).

31.

Federman

(2024) The war on protest is here. In These Times, 17 April. Available at: https://inthesetimes.com/article/war-protest-standing-rock-cop-city-repression-criminalize-dissent-political-rights-first-amendment (accessed 30 October 2024).

32.

Ferrucci

(2019) The end of ombudsmen? 21st-century journalism and reader representatives. Journalism & Mass Communication Quarterly 96(1): 288–307.

33.

Geller

(2025) Private groups work to identify and report student protesters for possible deportation. Associated Press, 29 March. Available at: https://apnews.com/article/trump-foreign-students-campus-gaza-protests-deportation-9e2d4abc1c158454da1f68c01062c9ef (accessed 31 March 2025).

34.

Gillham

Noakes

(2008) ‘More than a march in a circle’: transgressive protests and the limits of negotiated management. Mobilization: An International Quarterly 12(4): 341–357.

35.

Gilligan

(1993) In a Different Voice: Psychological Theory and Women’s Development. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press.

36.

Gitlin

(1980) The Whole World Is Watching: Mass Media in the Making and Unmaking of the New Left. Berkeley, CA: University of California Press.

37.

Godden

(2020) “Can i take your photo?” The practicalities of managing informed consent with vulnerable populations. In: Dodd

(ed.) Advances in Research Ethics and Integrity. Leeds: Emerald Publishing Limited, pp. 67–91. Available at: https://www.emerald.com/insight/content/doi/10.1108/S2398-601820200000005009/full/html (accessed 25 March 2025).

38.

Hau

Savage

(2022) Building coalitions on Facebook: “social media unionism” among Danish bike couriers. New Technology, Work and Employment 38(3): 529–547.

39.

Held

(2005) The Ethics of Care: Personal, Political, and Global. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

40.

Hill

(2020) The secretive company that might end privacy as we know it. The New York Times, 18 January. Available at: https://www.nytimes.com/2020/01/18/technology/clearview-privacy-facial-recognition.html (accessed 21 November 2024).

41.

Kilgo

(2021) Police violence and protests: digital media maintenance of racism, protest repression, and the status Quo. Journal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media 65(1): 157–176.

42.

Koliska

Moroney

Beavers

(2023) Trust through relationships in journalism. Journalism Studies. Epub ahead of print 10 May. DOI: 10.1080/1461670X.2023.2209807.

43.

Koopmans

(2004) Movements and media: selection processes and evolutionary dynamics in the public sphere. Theory and Society 33(3/4): 367–391.

44.

Lester

(1991) Photojournalism: An Ethical Approach. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.

45.

Lowrey

(2002) Word people vs. picture people: normative differences and strategies for control over work among newsroom subgroups. Mass Communication and Society 5(4): 411–432.

46.

Marin

(2024) Failure to enroll: the blurring rhetorical power of anonymizing tools and photographs in making in/visible black lives. Surveillance & Society 22(3): 212–226.

47.

McDowell

O’Neill

(2006) America and Enlightenment Constitutionalism. New York: Springer.

48.

McLaren

(2002) Feminism, Foucault, and Embodied Subjectivity. Albany, New York: State University of New York Press.

49.

Mellinger

(2013) Chasing Newsroom Diversity: From Jim Crow to Affirmative Action. Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press.

50.

Muñoz-Torres

(2012) Truth and objectivity in journalism. Journalism Studies 13(4): 566–582.

51.

Nelson

(2021) Imagined Audiences: How Journalists Perceive and Pursue the Public (Journalism and Political Communication Unbound). Oxford, New York: Oxford University Press.

52.

Newton

(2000) The Burden of Visual Truth: The Role of Photojournalism in Mediating Reality. 1st ed. Mahwah, NJ: Routledge.

53.

Nicholls

(2017) NPPA adds anti-harassment standard to code of ethics. Available at: https://petapixel.com/2017/07/27/nppa-adds-anti-harassment-standard-code-ethics/ (accessed 11 December 2024).

54.

NPPA.org (n.d.) NPPA Code of Ethics. Available at: http://www.nppa.org/professional_development/business_practices/ethics.html

55.

Ojala

(2021) Is the age of impartial journalism over? The neutrality principle and audience (Dis)trust in mainstream news. Journalism Studies 22(15): 2042–2060.

56.

Online News Association (n.d.) ONA and social newsgathering ethics code. Available at: https://journalists.org/tools/social-newsgathering/ (accessed 4 April 2025).

57.

Perry

(2020) How to blur people’s faces in protest photos—and why you should do it. Available at: https://mashable.com/article/how-to-blur-faces-protest-photographs (accessed 4 November 2024).

58.

Rouch

(2003) Ciné-ethnography (ed. & tran. S.

Feld

). Minneapolis, MN: University of Minnesota Press. Available at: https://www.upress.umn.edu/book-division/books/cina-c-ethnography (accessed 25 May 2023)

59.

Savedoff

(1997) Escaping reality: digital imagery and the resources of photography. Journal of Aesthetics and Art Criticism 55(2): 201–214.

60.

Schudson

(1981) Discovering the News: A Social History of American Newspapers. 50922nd edition. New York: Basic Books.

61.

Schwartz

(1999) Objective representation: photographs as facts. In: Brennen

Hardt

(eds) Picturing the past: Media, History & Photography. Urbana, IL: University of Illinois Press, pp. 158–181.

62.

Shrum

Duque

Brown

(2005) Digital video as research practice: methodology for the millennium. Journal of Research Practice 1(1): 1–19.

63.

Smith

(2019) In Hong Kong, protesters fight to stay anonymous. The Verge, 22 October. Available at: https://www.theverge.com/2019/10/22/20926585/hong-kong-china-protest-mask-umbrella-anonymous-surveillance (accessed 4 November 2024).

64.

Society of Professional Journalists (SPJ) (n.d.) SPJ’s Code of Ethics. Available at: https://www.spj.org/spj-code-of-ethics/ (accessed 4 April 2025).

65.

Swain

(1978) Reporters’ Ethics. Ames, IA: Iowa State University Press.

66.

Treisman

(2024) A journalist shot by police while covering the 2020 protests is dying of her injuries. NPR, 21 June. Available at: https://www.npr.org/2024/06/21/nx-s1-5015030/linda-tirado-journalist-shot-police-2020-george-floyd-protests-hospice-care (accessed 11 December 2024).

67.

Tuchman

(1978) Making News: A Study in the Construction of Reality. London: The Free Press.

68.

Vos

Moore

(2020) Building the journalistic paradigm: beyond paradigm repair. Journalism 21(1): 17–33.

69.

Vos

Singer

(2016) Media discourse about entrepreneurial journalism: implications for journalistic capital. Journalism Practice 10(2): 143–159.

70.

Vos

Thomas

(2019) The discursive (Re)construction of journalism’s gatekeeping role. Journalism Practice 13(4): 396–412.

71.

Wilkins

Painter

(2018) Media Ethics: Issues and Cases. Lanham, MD: Rowman & Littlefield.

72.

Wilson

Serisier

(2010) Video activism and the ambiguities of counter-surveillance. Surveillance & Society 8(2): 166–180.

73.

Wolfe

Shakil

(2022) U.S. Settles with Black lives matter protesters violently cleared from white house park. Reuters, 13 April. Available at: https://www.reuters.com/world/us/us-justice-dept-settles-cases-related-police-response-dc-anti-racism-protests-2022-04-13/ (accessed 30 October 2024).

74.

Wulfemeyer

(1983) Use of anonymous sources in journalism. Newspaper Research Journal 4(2): 43–50.

75.

Zalcman

(2019) Yes, we can reach gender parity in photojournalism. Nieman Reports. Available at: https://niemanreports.org/yes-we-can-reach-gender-parity-in-photojournalism/ (accessed 11 December 2024).

76.

Zelizer

(1993) Journalists as interpretive communities. Critical Studies in Mass Communication 10(3): 219–237.

77.

Zelizer

(2005) Journalism through the camera’s eye. In: Allen

(ed.) Issues in Journalism. Maidenhead: Open University Press, pp. 167–176.