Private Security and its Contribution to Policing: Under-Researched,Under-Utilised and Underestimated

Abstract

Policing has become increasingly associated with what the police do by academics, practitioners and policy makers. Yet there is a wide range of individuals and organisations, other than the police, engaged in policing. These include other public bodies such as Customs and Excise, trading standards officers, vigilantes and private security firms to name a few. One of the most significant of these is the latter. This paper assesses the contribution of private security to policing by analysing some of the main activities undertaken and comparing them to those pursued by the police. It also argues that private security is under-researched in comparison to the police, particularly given the significant roles that are undertaken. It also argues private security is under-utilised in its potential contribution to policing and crime prevention. Finally, the paper considers how private security is often underestimated when some of the potential causes for concern are considered.

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Association of Chief Police Officers (ACPO) (1988) ‘A review of the private security industry’, unpublished report.

ACPO (1995a) ‘Memorandum of evidence’, in Home Affairs Committee, ‘The private security industry’, HC 17-II, Vol. II, HMSO, London.

ACPO (1995b) ‘National intruder alarm statistics 1994’, Sussex Police, Lewes.

Biles

Vernon

(eds) (1994) ‘No. 22 private sector and community involvement in the criminal justice system’, proceedings of a conference held 30th November-2nd December, 1992, Wellington, New Zealand, Australian Institute of Criminology, Canberra.

Boothroyd

(1988) ‘Safe as houses’, Police Review, 9th September.

Borodzicz

E. P.

(1966) ‘Security and risk: A theoretical approach to managing loss prevention’, International Journal of Risk, Security and Crime Prevention, Vol. 1, No. 2, pp. 131–143.

British Entertainment and Discotheque Association (BEDA) (1995) ‘Memorandum of evidence’, in Home Affairs Committee (1995) ‘The private security industry’, HC 17-II, Vol. II, HMSO, London.

British Retail Consortium (1998) ‘Retail crime survey 1997’, British Retail Consortium, London.

British Security Industry Association (BSIA) (1994) ‘The UK manned guarding market’, BSIA, Worcester.

10.

Button

(1998) ‘Beyond the public gaze: The exclusion of private investigators from the British debate over regulating private security’, International Journal of the Sociology of Law, Vol. 26, No. 1, pp. 1–16.

11.

Button

George

(1998) ‘Why some organisations prefer contract to in-house security staff’, in Gill

(ed.) ‘Crime at work: Increasing the risk for offenders’, Perpetuity Press, Leicester.

12.

Campbell

Reingold

(1994) ‘Private security and public policing in Canada’, Juristat Service Bulletin, Vol. 14, No. 10.

13.

Clayton

(1967) ‘The protectors’, Oldbourne, London.

14.

Cornwall

(1991) ‘The industrial espionage handbook’, Century, London.

15.

Cunningham

W. C.

Strauchs

J. J.

Van Meter

C. W.

(1990) ‘Private security trends 1970–2000, Hallcrest Report II’, Butterworth-Heinemann, Stoneham (USA).

16.

Cunningham

W. C.

Taylor

(1985) ‘Private security and police in America’, ‘The Hallcrest Report’, Chancellor Press, Portland.

17.

Draper

(1978) ‘Private police’, Harvester Press, Sussex.

18.

George

Button

(1995) ‘Crime in Walsall — The first report: The town centre’, unpublished report.

19.

George

Button

(1996) ‘The case for regulation’, International Journal of Risk, Security and Crime Prevention, Vol. 1, No. 1, pp. 53–57.

20.

George

Button

(1997) ‘Regulating private security — Lessons from abroad for the United Kingdom’, International Journal of Risk, Security and Crime Prevention, Vol. 2, No. 3, pp. 109–121.

21.

George

Button

(1998) ‘Too little too late: A critique of recent policy proposals for the private security industry in the United Kingdom’, Security Journal, Vol. 10, No. 1, pp. 1–7.

22.

Gill

Hart

(1997) ‘Exploring investigative policing’, British Journal of Criminology, Vol. 37, No. 4, pp. 549–567.

23.

Home Affairs Committee (1995) ‘The private security industry’, HC 17 I and II, Vols I and II, HMSO, London.

24.

Home Affairs Committee (1998) ‘Policing disciplinary and complaints procedures’, HC 258 I and II, Vols I and II, HMSO, London.

25.

Home Office (1979) ‘The private security industry: A discussion paper’, HMSO, London.

26.

Home Office (1993) ‘Police Reform White Paper’, Cm 2281, HMSO, London.

27.

Home Office (1995) ‘Review of police core and ancillary tasks. Final report and appendices’, HMSO, London.

28.

Home Office (1996a) ‘Annual Report 1996’, Cm 3208, HMSO, London.

29.

Home Office (1996b) ‘Regulation of the contract guarding sector of the private security industry’, Home Office, London.

30.

Home Office Research and Statistics Department (1995) ‘Digest on information on the criminal justice system in England and Wales’, Home Office Research and Statistics Department, Croydon.

31.

Hunt Saboteurs Association (1994) ‘Public order, private armies’, Hunt Saboteurs Association, Nottingham.

32.

Hunter

(1998) ‘Professional queries’, Security Gazette, February.

33.

Johnston

(1992) ‘The rebirth of private policing’, Routledge, London.

34.

Jones

Newburn

(1995) ‘How big is the private security industry?’ Policing and Society, Vol. 5, pp. 221–232.

35.

Jones

Newburn

(1998) ‘Private security and public policing’, Clarendon Press, Oxford.

36.

Kakalik

Wildhorn

(1971a) ‘Private police in the United States, findings and recommendations’, Vol. 1, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.

37.

Kakalik

Wildhorn

(1971b) ‘The private police industry: Its nature and extent’, Vol. 2, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.

38.

Kakalik

Wildhorn

(1971c) ‘Current regulation of private police: Regulatory agency experience and views’, Vol. 3, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.

39.

Kakalik

Wildhorn

(1971d) ‘The law and private police’, Vol. 4, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.

40.

Kakalik

Wildhorn

(1971e) ‘Special purpose public police’, Vol. 5, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.

41.

Liberty (1995) ‘Memorandum of evidence’, in House of Commons Home Affairs Committee, ‘The private security industry’, Vol. II, HMSO, London.

42.

McKenzie

I. K.

Gallagher

G. P.

(1989) ‘Behind the uniform policing in Britain and America’, Harvester Wheatsheaf, Hemel Hempstead.

43.

McManus

(1995) ‘From fate to choice: Private bobbies, public beats’, Avebury, Aldershot.

44.

Morgan

Newburn

(1997) ‘The future of policing’, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

45.

Moyle

(ed.) (1994) ‘Private prisons and police — Recent Australian trends’, Pluto Press, Leichhardt, Australia.

46.

Murray

(1993) ‘Enemies of the state’, Simon and Schuster, London.

47.

National Advisory Committee on Criminal Justice Standards and Goals (1976) ‘Private security, report of the task force on private security’, Government Printing Office, Washington, DC.

48.

Northumbria Community Safety (1996) ‘Annual report 1995–96’.

49.

Police Foundation and Policy Studies Institute Independent Inquiry (PF/PSI) (1996) ‘The role and responsibilities of the police’, PF/PSI, London.

50.

Reiner

(1992) ‘The politics of the police’, Harvester Wheatsheaf, Hemel Hempstead.

51.

Reiner

(1994) ‘Policing and the police’, in Maguire

Morgan

Reiner

(eds) ‘The Oxford handbook of criminology’, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

52.

Sarre

(1994) ‘The legal powers of private police and security providers’, in Moyle

(ed.) ‘Private prisons and police — Recent Australian trends’, Pluto Press, Leichhardt, NSW.

53.

Saulsbury

Mott

Newburn

(eds) (1996) ‘Themes in contemporary policing’, Policy Studies Institute, London.

54.

Shearing

C. D.

Stenning

P. C.

(1981) ‘Modern private security: Its growth and implications’, in Tonry

Morris

(eds) ‘Crime and justice: An annual review of research’, Vol. 3. University of Chicago Press, Chicago.

55.

Shearing

C. D.

Stenning

P. C.

Addario

S. M.

(1985) ‘Police perceptions of private security’, Canadian Police College Journal, Vol. 9, No. 2, pp. 127–153.

56.

Stenning

P. C.

(1989) ‘Private police and public police: Toward a redefinition of the police role’, in Loree

D. J.

(ed.) ‘Future issues in policing symposium proceedings’, Canadian Police College, Ottawa.

57.

Stenning

P. C.

Shearing

C. D.

(1980) ‘The quiet revolution: The nature, development and general legal implications of private security in Canada’, Criminal Law Quarterly, Vol. 22, pp. 220–248.

58.

South

(1988) ‘Policing for profit’, Sage, London.

59.

Straw

(1997) Home Secretary's speech to BSIA Annual Lunch, 15th July, 1997.

60.

Wilson

(1994) ‘The Australian private security industry: The need for accountability, regulation and professionalisation’, in Biles

Vernon

(eds) ‘No. 22 private sector and community involvement in the criminal justice system’, proceedings of a conference held 30th November-2nd December, 1992, Wellington, New Zealand, Australian Institute of Criminology, Canberra.