This paper traces the development of women's formal integration into policing in Australia with an emphasis on the role of legislation in affecting change. Grudging compliance with the requirements of anti-discrimination has occurred in the last two decades with a limited application of the more demanding requirements of legislation oriented towards affirmative action. This paper sets up a model for effective management of equal employment opportunity (EEO) responsibilities and tests the level of current application of the model with reference to EEO reports and other data on the status of women. Despite significant progress, specific problems remain and the percentage of sworn female officers will increase only very slowly and will not reach parity with men unless more dynamic efforts are made to improve participation. The main areas of concern are physical ability entry tests, low application rates, lack of union support, managerial indifference and inadequate diagnostic review. Two key strategies for improvement derived from this analysis are targeted promotion in recruitment and the application of a systematic ‘problem oriented’ approach to EEO management.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
AAA (Affirmative Action Agency) (1990) ‘The Triple A List’, Australian Government Publishing Service, Canberra.
2.
AFP (1996) ‘Report to Public Service and Merit Protection Commission on Equal Employment Opportunity, 1996’, Australian Federal Police, Canberra.
3.
AinsworthM.BellD.FroylandI. (1996) ‘Working with Women: The Male Perspective’, paper presented to the First Australasian Women Police Conference, Sydney, July.
4.
AndersonR.BrownJ.CampbellE. (1993) ‘Aspects of Sex Discrimination within the Police Service in England and Wales’, Police Research Group, Hampshire Constabulary.
5.
BinghamM. (1996) ‘Report on the Review of the Queensland Police Service’, Minister for Police, Brisbane.
6.
BrownJ. (1995) ‘Adverse Impacts Experienced by Police Officers Following Exposure to Sex Discrimination and Sexual Harassment’, Stress Medicine, Vol. 11, pp. 221–228.
7.
ClarkeR. (1993) ‘Situational Crime Prevention’, Harrow and Heston, Albany, NY.
8.
ClarkeR.HomelR. (1997) ‘A Revised Classification of Situational Crime Prevention Techniques’, in LabS. (Ed) ‘Crime Prevention at the Crossroads’, Anderson, Cincinnati, OH.
9.
CornsC. (1988) ‘Policing and Social Change’, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Sociology, Vol. 24, No. 1, pp. 32–46.
10.
de Vries-BauerC. (1991) ‘Europe, Here We Are’, Police (European Network for Policewomen Newsletter), pp. 8–11, August.
11.
DraperM. (1985) ‘Affirmative Action in Victoria’, in SawerM. (Ed) ‘Program for Change: Affirmative Action in Australia’, Allen and Unwin, Sydney.
12.
EEB (Employment Equity Branch, Queensland Public Sector Management Commission) (1992) ‘Guidelines to Assist Agencies in Developing and Implementing EEO Management Plans’, Government Printer, Brisbane.
13.
EisensteinH. (1985) ‘Affirmative Action at Work in New South Wales’, in SawerM. (Ed) ‘Program for Change: Affirmative Action in Australia’, Allen and Unwin, Sydney.
14.
FelkenesG.PeretzP.SchroedelJ. (1993) ‘An Analysis of the Mandatory Hiring of Females: The Los Angeles Police Department Experience’, Women and Criminal Justice, Vol. 4, No. 2, pp. 31–62.
15.
FitzgeraldM. (1991) ‘Can a Policewoman Combine Family and Career?’, The Police Journal (Australia), pp. 10–12, December.
16.
GibsonG. (1996) ‘New Zealand National Women's Consultative Committee’, paper presented to the First Australasian Women Police Conference, Sydney, July.
17.
GoldsteinH. (1990) ‘Problem-oriented Policing’, McGraw-Hill, New York.
18.
HaleD. (1992) ‘Women in Policing’, in CordnerG.HaleD. (Eds) ‘What Works in Policing?’, Anderson, Cincinnati, OH.
19.
HeidensohnF. (1996) ‘The Impact of Police Culture: Setting the Scene’, paper presented to the First Australasian Women Police Conference, Sydney, July.
20.
HiggsP.BettessC. (1987) ‘To Walk a Fair Beat: A History of the South Australian Women Police 1915–1987’, Past and Present Women Police Association, Lockleys, SA.
21.
HillM. (1986) ‘In the Line of Duty: 100 Years of the New Zealand Police’, Endeavour, Auckland.
22.
HochstedlerE. (1984) ‘Impediments to Hiring Minorities in Public Police Agencies’, Journal of Police Science and Administration, Vol. 12, No. 2, pp. 227–240.
23.
HomeP. (1980) ‘Policewomen and the Physical Aspects of Policing’, Law and Order, pp. 83–89, September.
24.
HotchkissS. (1992) ‘Policing Promotional Difference: Policewomen in the Queensland Police’, unpublished MA thesis, Griffith University, Brisbane.
25.
JonesS. (1986) ‘Policewomen and Equality’, Macmillan, Houndmills, Hampshire.
26.
LunneborgP. (1989) ‘Women Police Officers: Current Career Profiles’, Charles Thomas, Springfield, IL.
27.
MartinS. (1990) ‘On the Move: The Status of Women in Policing’, Police Foundation, Washington, DC.
28.
MatthewsL. (1994) ‘Why Our Women are Copping Out’, Sunday Star-Times, p. A5, 3rd April.
29.
McDermottH.RaymentM. (1996) ‘Women and Police Unions’, paper presented to the First Australasian Women Police Conference, Sydney, July.
30.
NSWPS (1995) ‘1994–1995 Equal Employment Opportunity Annual Report and Management Plan’, New South Wales Police Service, EEO Branch, Sydney.
31.
NTPS (1995) ‘Northern Territory Police, Fire and Emergency Services Equal Opportunity Management Plan 1995–2000’, NTPFES, Darwin.
32.
NZPEEOU (1990) ‘Directions for the Future: EEO and Pay Equity’, New Zealand Police Equal Employment Opportunities Unit, Wellington.
33.
OsbornB. (1997) ‘ “I'm Not Mad — I'm a Policewoman!” Historical Notes and Anecdotes of Women in Federal Policing’, Australian Federal Police Museum, Canberra.
34.
PottsL. (1983) ‘Equal Opportunity and Female Employment in Police Agencies’, Journal of Criminal Justice, Vol. 11, pp. 505–523.
35.
PrenzlerT. (1994) ‘Women in Australian Policing: An Historical Overview’, Journal of Australian Studies, Vol. 42, pp. 78–88.
36.
PrenzlerT. (1995) ‘Equal Employment Opportunity and Policewomen in Australia’, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology, Vol. 28, No. 3, pp. 258–277.
37.
PrenzlerT. (1996a) ‘Rebuilding the Walls? The Impact of Police Pre-Entry Physical Ability Tests on Female Applicants’, Current Issues in Criminal Justice, Vol. 7, No. 3, pp. 314–324.
38.
PrenzlerT. (1996b) ‘Obstacles to the Advancement of Women in Policing’, paper presented to the First Australasian Women Police Conference, Sydney, July.
39.
PrenzlerT. (1997) ‘A Problem Oriented Approach to Preventing Sex Discrimination in Police Recruitment’, Crime Prevention Studies, Vol. 7, pp. 207–222.
40.
PrenzlerT. (1998) ‘Concession and Containment: The Establishment of Women in the Queensland Police, 1931–1965’, Australian and New Zealand Journal of Criminology, Vol. 31, No. 2, in press.
41.
PrenzlerT.WimshurstK. (1997) ‘Women and Politics in the Queensland Police, 1970–1987’, Journal of Australian Studies, Vol. 52, pp. 88–101.
42.
QPS (1996) ‘EEO Management Plan 1996–2000’, Queensland Police Service, EEO Unit, Brisbane.
43.
SteelB.LovrichN.Jr (1987) ‘Equality and Efficiency Tradeoffs in Affirmative Action — Real or Imagined? The Case of Women in Policing’, The Social Science Journal, Vol. 24, No. 1, pp. 53–70.
44.
SuttonJ. (1996) ‘Survey of New South Wales Policewomen’, paper presented to the First Australasian Women Police Conference, Sydney, July.
Tasmania Police (1997) ‘Review of the Equal Employment Opportunity Management Plan 1995–97’, Tasmania Police, Hobart.
47.
ThorntonM. (1990) ‘The Liberal Promise’, Oxford University Press, Melbourne.
48.
TynanM. (1994) ‘Police Unions and Women Police: The Perfect Couple?’, unpublished paper.
49.
TynanM. (1995) ‘Eighty Years of Women in Policing: New South Wales, 1915–1995’, New South Wales Police Service, Sydney.
50.
Victoria Police (1990) ‘The Impact of Equal Opportunity on Policing in Victoria’, Research and Development Department, Melbourne.
51.
Victoria Police (1997) ‘Victoria Police Public Sector Merit and Equity Annual Evaluation 1996–1997’, Personnel Department, Melbourne.
52.
WAPS (1994) ‘Equal Employment Opportunity Management Plan’, Western Australia Police Service, Employee Relations Branch, Perth.
53.
WeisheitR. (1987) ‘Women in the State Police: Concerns of Male and Female Officers’, Journal of Police Science and Administration, Vol. 15, No. 2, pp. 137–144.
