As of 2018, thirty-one states granted collective bargaining rights to police officers that require local government management to recognize and collectively bargain in good faith with police unions. Although scholars have identified factors related to police fatalities, the influence of police unions has gone understudied. Research in other occupational areas shows that union strength is associated with fewer workplace injuries and fatalities. This research analyzes the influence of union strength and collective bargaining rights on police fatalities. Using state-level data from 1990 to 2018, a rare-event analysis of police fatalities indicates that states with strong public employee unions experience fewer accidental line-of-duty deaths of police officers. Further, this analysis shows that states which grant collective bargaining rights to police officers have fewer felonious line-of-duty deaths of police officers compared with those that do not grant police collective bargaining rights. This article concludes with a discussion of the policy implications and the role of collective bargaining in police safety.
AnziaSMoeTM (2016) Do politicians use policy to make politics? The case of public -sector labor laws. American Political Science Review110(4): 763–777.
4.
AshenfelterOHyslopD (2001) Measuring the effect of arbitration on wage levels: the case of police officers. Industrial and Labor Relations Review54(2): 316–328.
5.
Baker v. Carr, 369 U.S. 186 (1962).
6.
BattonCWilsonS (2006) Police murders: an examination of historical trends in the killing of law enforcement officers in the United States, 1947 to 1998. Homicide Studies10(2): 79–97.
7.
BerryFSFordingRCRingquistEJ, et al. (2010) Measuring citizen and government ideology in the United States: a re-appraisal. State Politics & Policy Quarterly10(2): 117–135.
8.
BerryFSFordingRCRingquistEJ, et al. (2013) A new measure of state government ideology, and evidence that both the new measure and old measure are valid. State Politics & Policy Quarterly13(2): 164–182.
9.
BrandlSG (1996) In the line of duty: a descriptive analysis of police assaults and accidents. Journal of Criminal Justice24: 255–264.
10.
BrandlSGStroshineMS (2003) Toward an understanding of the physical hazards of police work. Police Quarterly6(2): 172–191.
11.
BrandlSGStroshineMS (2012) The physical hazards of police work revisited. Police Quarterly15(3): 262–282.
12.
BrunnerEJJuA (2019) State collective bargaining laws and public-sector pay. ILR Review72(2): 480–508.
CanterburyC (2010) Testimony of Chuck Canterbury National President Fraternal Order of Police on H.R. 413, the Public Safety Employer-Employee Cooperation Act before the Subcommittee on the Health, Education, Labor, and Pensions House Committee on Education and Labor. Fraternal Order of Police.
15.
CaugheyDWarshawC (2015) The dynamics of state policy liberalism, 1936–2014. American Journal of Political Science60(4): 889–913.
City of Columbus and Fraternal Order of Police Capital City Lodge No. 9 (2017). Agreement between City of Columbus and Fraternal Order of Police Capital City Lodge No. 9.
18.
City of Jersey City and Jersey City Police Officers Benevolent Association (2013). Agreement between City of Jersey City and Jersey City Police Officers Benevolent Association.
19.
ClarkeRV (1995) Situational crime prevention. Crime and Justice19: 91–150.
20.
CunninghamJPGillezeauR (2021) Don’t shoot! the impact of historical African American protest on police killings of civilians. Journal of Quantitative Criminology37: 1–34.
21.
DippelCSauersZ (2019) Does increased union power cause pension underfunding in the public sector? Working paper.
22.
DiSalvoD (2015) Government Against Itself: Public Union Power and Its Consequences.New York: Oxford University Press.
23.
DiSalvoD (2022) Interest groups, local politics, and police unions. Interest Groups & Advocacy.
24.
DoernerWMDoernerWG (2010) Collective bargaining and job benefits: the case of Florida deputy sheriffs. Police Quarterly13(3): 367–386.
25.
EdwardsTD (1995) Felonious killing of state police and highway patrol officers: a descriptive and comparative evaluation. American Journal of Police14: 89–105.
26.
FarberHS (1988) The evolution of public sector bargaining laws. In: FreemanRBIchniowskiC (eds). When Public Sector Workers Unionize. Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, pp. 129–166.
FelsonMEckertMA (2019) Crime and Everyday Life. 6th edn. Los Angeles, CA: Sage.
31.
FredericksonGHSmithKBLarimerCW, et al. (2012) Public Institutional Theory. In The Public Administration Theory Primer. 2nd ed. Boulder, CO: Westview Press, pp. 67–96.
32.
FreemanRBMedoffJL (1984). What Do Unions Do?New York, NY: Basic Books.
33.
FridellLFaggianiDTaylorB, et al. (2009) The impact of agency context, policies, and practices on violence against police. Journal of Criminal Justice37: 542–552.
34.
GarnerJClemmerE (1986) Danger to police in domestic disturbances. Washington, DC: U.S. Department of Justice.
35.
GrayWBMendeloffJM (2005) The declining effects of OSHA inspections on manufacturing injuries, 1979–1998. Industrial and Labor Relations Review58(4): 571–587.
36.
GrossmannMJordanMPMcCrainJ (2021) The correlates of state policy and the structure of state panel data. State Politics & Policy Quarterly21(4): 430–450.
37.
GundersonM (2005) Two faces of union voice in the public sector. Journal of Labor Research26(3): 393–413.
38.
GustafsonBG (2015) State-level differences in fatal law enforcement officer collisions. Policing: An International Journal38(3): 436–457. DOI 10.1108/PIJPSM-03-2015-0043.
39.
HirschBTMacphersonDA (2003) Union membership and coverage database from the current population survey: note. Industrial and Labor Relations Review56(2): 349–354.
40.
HoglerRShulmanSWeilerW (2004) Right-to-work legislation, social capital, and variations in state union density. The Review of Regional Studies34(1): 95–111.
41.
IchniowskiCFreemanRBLauerH (1989) Collective bargaining laws, threat effects, and the determination of police compensation. Journal of Labor Economics7(2): 191–209.
42.
JacobsDCarmichaelJT (2002) Subordination and violence against state control agents: testing political explanations for lethal assaults against the police. Social Forces80: 1223–1251.
43.
KaminskiRJ (2004) The murder of police officers. New York: LFB.
44.
KaminskiRJ (2008) Assessing the county-level structural covariates of police homicides. Homicide Studies12(4): 350–380.
45.
KaminskiRJMarvellTB (2002) A comparison of changes in police and general homicides, 1930–1998. Criminology40: 701–720.
46.
KaminskiRJSorensenDW (1995) A multivariate analysis of individual, situational and environmental factors associated with police assault injuries. American Journal of Police14: 3–48.
47.
KaminskiRJJefferisESGuJ (2003) Community correlates of serious assaults on police. Police Quarterly6: 119–149.
48.
KearneyRCMareschalPM (2014) Labor Relations in the Public Sector. 5th edn. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press.
49.
KingGZengL (2001) Explaining rare events in international relations. International Organization55(3): 693–715.
50.
KoKMendeloffJGrayW (2010) The role of inspection sequence in compliance with US Occupational Safety and Health Administration’s (OSHA) standards: interpretations and implications. Regulation & Governance4(1): 48–70.
51.
KoganV (2017) Do anti-union policies increase inequality? Evidence from state adoption of right-to-work laws. State Politics & Policy Quarterly17(2): 180–200.
52.
LesterD (1981). Occupational injuries, illnesses, and fatalities in police officers. The Police Chief48(10): 43–63.
53.
MarchJGOlsenJP (1984) The new institutionalism: organizational factors in political life. American Political Science Review78(3): 734–749.
54.
MorabitoM (2014) American Police unions: a hindrance or help to innovation?International Journal of Public Administration37: 773–780.
MumfordEATaylorBGKubuB (2015) Law enforcement officer safety and wellness. Police Quarterly18(2): 111–133.
57.
MustardDB (2001) The impact of gun laws on police deaths. Journal of Law and Economics22: 635–657.
58.
National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (2020). Fatal crashes by state and first harmful event. https://cdan.dot.gov.
59.
OrtolanoJ (2015). Testimony of John Ortolano President and National Trustee, Arizona State Lodge, Fraternal Order of Police on training and education before the President’s Task Force on 21st Century Policing. National Fraternal Order of Police.
60.
PaglayanAS (2019) Public-sector unions and the size of government. American Journal of Political Science63(1): 21–36.
SanesMSchmittJ (2014) Regulation of Public Sector Collective Bargaining in the States. Washington, DC: Center for Economic and Policy Research, pp. 1–68.
ShjarbackJAWhiteMD (2016) Departmental professionalism and its impact on indicators of violence in police-citizen encounters. Police Quarterly19(1): 32–62.
68.
ShorBThurberJAYoshinakaA (2015) Polarization in American state legislatures. In ThurberJAYoshinakaA (eds) American Gridlock: The Sources, Character, and Impact of Political Polarization. New York: Cambridge University Press.
69.
SiegelMGoder-ReiserMDuweG, et al. (2020) The relation between state gun laws and the incidence and severity of mass public shootings in the United States, 1976–2018. Law and Human Behavior44(5): 347–360.
StaffordSL (2017) Pipeline performance and safety in a federal system. Journal of Transport Economics and Policy51(3): 193–207.
72.
TeismanHMHendricksSABellJ, et al. (2010) Eleven years of occupational mortality in law enforcement: The census of fatal occupational injuries, 1992-2002.
73.
TeskeP (2004) Regulation in the states. Washington, D.C.: The Brookings Institution.
74.
The City of Chicago Department of Police and the Fraternal Order of Police Chicago Lodge No. 7 (2012) Agreement between the City of Chicago Department of Police and the Fraternal Order of Police Chicago Lodge No. 7. Chicago, IL, pp.1–158.
75.
ThomasMPTuftsS (2020) Blue solidarity: police unions, race and authoritarian populism in North America. Work, Employment and Society34(1): 126–144.
ValettaRGFreemanRB (1988) The NBER public sector collective bargaining law data set. In FreemanRBIchniowskiC (eds) When Public Employees Unionize appendix B. Chicago, IL: University of Chicago Press.
78.
WadeM (2018) Targeting teachers while shielding cops? The politics of punishing enemies and rewarding friends in American state collective bargaining reform agendas. Journal of Labor & Society21(2): 137–157.
79.
WalkerAN (2014) Labor’s enduring divide: the distinct path of public sector unions in the United States. Studies in American Political Development28: 175–200.
80.
WalkerS (2008) The neglect of police unions: exploring one of the most important areas of American policing. Police Practice and Research9(2): 95–112.
81.
WellsDD (2021) From Collective Bargaining to Collective Begging: How Public Employees Win and Lose the Right to Bargain. Philadelphia, PA: Temple University Press.
82.
WellsDD (2022) Do collective bargaining rights save lives? A rare event analysis of firefighter fatalities in the United States. Risk, Hazards & Crisis in Public Policy13(2): 100–117.
83.
WhiteMDDarioLMShjarbackJA (2019) Assessing dangerousness in policing: an analysis of officer deaths in the United States, 1970–2016. Criminology & Public Policy18: 11–35.
84.
WillitsDW (2014) The organisational structure of police departments and assaults on police officers. International Journal of Police Science & Management16(2): 140–154.
85.
WilsonMCPiazzaJA (2013) Autocracies and terrorism: conditioning effects of authoritarian regime type on terrorist attacks. American Journal of Political Science57(4): 941–955.
86.
WilsonSBucklerK (2010) The debate over police reform: examining minority support for citizen oversight and resistance by police unions. American Journal of Criminal Justice35: 184–197.
87.
ZoorobM (2018) Does “right-to-work” imperil the right to health? The effect of our labour unions on workplace fatalities. Occupational & Environmental Medicine75(10): 736–738.
88.
ZoorobM (2019) Blue endorsements matter: how the Fraternal Order of Police contributed to Donald Trump’s victory. Political Science & Politics52(2): 243–250.
89.
ZulloR (2011) Right-to-Work laws and fatalities in construction. Journal of Labor and Society14: 225–234.
