Recent improvements in technology and telecommunications have resulted in renewed interest in telemedicine [1]. The UK’s National Health Service (NHS) Executive has recently published an ‘Information for Health’ strategy which states that ‘telemedicine and telecare will undoubtedly come to the fore as a way of providing services in the future. They have a key role to play in the Government’s plans to modernize the NHS’ [2]. Within the current climate, the future success of telemedicine will depend on patient and provider acceptance of such technologies. It is, therefore, imperative that the views and experiences of the users and providers of healthcare services are sought to enable problems to be resolved and issues addressed before telemedicine is fully implemented: ‘Information about the patients’ experiences can be an important lever for change, both highlighting where, and what sort of quality improvements are needed’ [3].
This paper provides an overview of telemedicine and patient satisfaction and considers the satisfaction studies to date. It finally discusses some of the problems in assessing patient satisfaction within telemedicine and how future studies may be improved in light of the findings. It is based upon work that is presently being carried out at the School of Health and Related Research (ScHARR) at the University of Sheffield as part of a Randomized Controlled Trial of telemedicine in dermatology, funded by the NHS Executive Research and Development Programme.
References
1.
Thrall J H, Boland G.Telemedicine in Practice. Seminars in Nuclear Medicine1998; 28(2): 145-157.
2.
Department of Health. The New NHS: Modern and Dependable. London: HMSO, 1998.
3.
Department of Health. A First Class Service: Quality in the New NHS. London: HMSO, 1998.
4.
Perednia D, Allen A.Telemedicine technology and clinical applications. The Journal of the American Medical Association1995; 273 (6): 483-488.
5.
Preston J, Brown P W, Hartley B.Using telemedicine to improve health care in distant areas. Hospital Community Psychiatry1992; 43: 25-31.
6.
Burdick A E, Berman B.Teledermatology. Advances in Dermatology1997; 12: 19-46.
7.
Wittson C L, Affleck D C, Johnson V.Two-way television group therapy. Mental Hospital1961; 12 November: 22-23.
8.
Jutra A.Teleroentgen diagnosis by means of videotape recording. American Journal of Roentgenology1959; 82: 1099-1102.
9.
Foote D R.Satellite communication for rural health care in Alaska. Journal of Communication1977; 27(4): 173-182.
10.
House A M, Roberts J M.Telemedicine in Canada. Canadian Medical Association Journal1977; 117(4): 386-388.
11.
Stevens I, Rasmussen W T.Remote medical diagnosis system (RMDS) concept. Journal Medical Systems1982; 6: 519-529.
12.
Michaeis E.Telemedicine: the best is yet to come experts say. Canadian Medical Association Journal1989; 141: 612-614.
13.
Allen A, Cox R, Thomas C.Telemedicine in Kansas. Kansas Medicine1992; 93: 323-325.
14.
Alpay L, Heathfield H.A review of telematics in health-care: evolution, challenges and caveats. Health Informatics Journal1997; 3: 81-92.
15.
Department of Health and Social Security. NHS Management Enquiry. The Griffiths Report, London, 1983.
16.
Department of Health. The Patient’s Charter. London: HMSO, 1991.
17.
Hall J A, Roter D L, Katz N R.Meta-analysis of correlates of provider behaviour in medical encounters. Medical Care1988; 26: 657-675.
18.
Fitzpatrick R.The Experience of Illness. London: Tavistock, 1984.
19.
Ware J E, Davies A, Stewart A L.The measurement and meaning of patient satisfaction: A review of the recent literature. Health and Medical Care Services Review1978; 1, 1-15.
20.
Pascoe G C.Patient satisfaction in primary health care. Evaluation and Program Planning1983; 6: 185-210.
21.
Ware J, Davis A.Behavioural consequences of consumer dissatisfaction with medical care. Evaluation and Program Planning1983; 6(3): 291-297.
22.
Ho P S, Herzberg Stegall M B, Wan T T H.Modelling two dimensions of patient satisfaction: a panel study. Health Services Management Research1994; 7: 72-75.
23.
Fitzpatrick R.Surveys of patient satisfaction 1 - important general considerations. British Medical Journal1991; 302: 887-889.
24.
Larsen D E, Rootman I.Physicians’ role performance and patient satisfaction. Social Science and Medicine1976; 10: 29-32.
25.
Institute of Medicine (US).Telemedicine: a guide to assessing telecommunications in health care. In: M J Field (ed.) Committee on Evaluating Clinical Applications of Telemedicine, Division of Health Care Services, National Academy Press, 1996.
26.
Locker D, Dunt D.Theoretical and methodological issues in sociological studies of consumer satisfaction with medical care. Social Science and Medicine1978; 12: 283-291.
27.
Ware J E, Snyder M K, Wright R, Davies A R.Defining and measuring patient satisfaction with medical care. Evaluation and Program Planning1983; 6: 247-263.
28.
Fox J G, Storms D M.A different approach to sociodemographic predictors of satisfaction with health care. Social Science and Medicine1981; 15A: 557.
29.
Carr-Hill R A.The measurement of patient satisfaction. Journal of Public Health Medicine1992; 14: 236-249.
30.
Williams B.Patient satisfaction: A valid concept?Social Science and Medicine1994; 38: 509-516.
31.
Gutek B.Strategies for studying client satisfaction. The Journal of Social Issues1978; 34: 44-56.
32.
Linder-Pelz S.Toward a theory of patient satisfaction. Social Science and Medicine1982; 16: 583-589.
33.
Hulka B S, Zyzanski S J, Cassel J C, Thompson S J.Scale for the measurement of attitudes toward physicians and primary medical care. Medical Care1970; 8 (5): 429-435.
34.
Attkisson C C, Roberts R E, Pascoe G C.The Evaluation Ranking Scale: clarification of methodological and procedural issues. Evaluation and Program Planning1983; 6: 349-358.
35.
Attkisson C C, Zwick R.The client satisfaction questionnaire: psychometric properties and correlation’s with service utilisation and psychotherapy outcome. Evaluation and Program Planning1982; 5: 233-237.
36.
Wolf M H, Putnam S M, James S A, Stiles W B.The medical interview satisfaction scale: development of a scale to measure patient perceptions of physician behaviour. Journal of Behavioural Medicine1978; 1(4): 391-401.
37.
Parasuraman A, Keithaml V A, Berry L L.SERVQUAL: a multiple-item scale for measuring consumer perceptions of service quality. Journal of Retailing1988; 64(1): 12-40.
38.
Di Matteo M R, Hays R.The significance of patients’ perceptions of physicians conduct: a study of patient satisfaction in a family practice centre. Journal of Community Health1980; 6: 18-34.
MacKeigan L D, Larson L N.Development and validation of an instrument to measure patient satisfaction with pharmacy services. Medical Care1989; 27(5): 522-536.
41.
Health Policy Advisory Unit. The Patient Satisfaction Questionnaire. Sheffield: HPAU, 1989.
42.
Hearnshaw H, Robertson N.Quality health care and psychologists. The Psychologist1998; 11(9): 421-422.
43.
Robertson N, Hearnshaw H.Managing quality in health care: the opportunities. The Psychologist1998; 11(9): 423-425.
44.
Baker R, Firth-Cozens J.Evidence, quality of care and the role of psychology. The Psychologist1998; 11(9): 430-432.
45.
Aharony L, Strasser S.Patient satisfaction: what we know about and what we still need to explore. Medical Care Review1993; 50: 1.
46.
Owens D J, Batchelor C.Patient satisfaction and the elderly. Social Science and Medicine1996; 42 (11): 1483-1491.
47.
Meredith P, Wood C.Aspects of patient satisfaction with communication in surgical care: confirming qualitative feedback through quantitative methods. International Journal for Quality in Health Care1996; 8(3): 253-264.
48.
Avis M, Bond M, Arthur A.Questioning patient satisfaction: an empirical investigation in two out-patient clinics. Social Science and Medicine1997; 44: 85-92.
49.
Conrath D W, Puckingham P, Dunn E V, Swanson J N.An experimental evaluation of alternative communication systems as a use for medical diagnosis. Behavioural Science1975; 20: 296-305.
50.
Fuchs M.Provider attitudes toward STARPAHC, a telemedicine project on the Papago reservation. Medical Care1979; January 17: 59-68.
51.
Graham M A.Telepsychiatry in Appalachia. American Behavioural Scientist1996; 39(5): 602-615.
52.
Pedersen S, Holand U.Tele-endoscopic otorhinolaryngological examination: preliminary study of patient satisfaction. Telemedicine Journal1995; 1(1): 47.
53.
Harrison R, Clayton W, Wallace P.Can telemedicine be used to improve communication between primary and secondary care?BMJ1996; 313: 1377-1380.
54.
Blackmon L A, Kaak H O, Ranseen J.Consumer satisfaction with telemedicine child psychiatry consultation in rural Kentucky. Psychiatric Services1997; 48 (11): 1464-1466.
55.
Itzhak B, Weinberger T, Berkovitch E, Reis S.Telemedicine in primary care in Israel. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare1998; 4 (1): 11-14.
56.
Coururier P, Tyrrell J, Tonetti J, Rhul C, Woodward C, Franco A. Feasibility of orthopaedic teleconsulting in a geriatric rehabilitation. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare1998; 4(1): 85-87.
57.
Brennan J A, Kealy J A, Gerardi L H, Shih R, Allegra J, Sannipoli L, Lutz D.A randomised controlled trial of telemedicine in an emergency department. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare1998; 4(1): 18-20.
58.
Allen A, Hayes J.Patient satisfaction with teleoncology: a pilot study. Telemedicine Journal1995; 1(1): 41-46.
59.
Huston J L, Burton D C.Patient satisfaction with multi-specialty interactive telecommunications. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare1997; 3(4): 205-208.
60.
Lowitt M H, Kessler I I, Kauffman C L, Hooper F J, Siegel E, Burnett J W.Teledermatology and in-person examinations: a comparison of patient and physician perceptions and diagnostic agreement. Archives of Dermatology1998; 134 (4): 471-476.
61.
Whitten P, Mair F, Collins B.Home telenursing in Kansas: patients’ perceptions of uses and benefits. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare1997; 3(1): 61-69.
62.
Loane M A, Gore H E, Corbett R, Steele K, Mathews C, Bloomer S E, Eedy D J, Telford R W, Wootton R.Patient satisfaction with realtime teledermatology in Northern Ireland. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare1998; 4(1): 36-40.
63.
Jones D H, Crichton C, Macdonald A, Potts S, Sime D, Toms J, McKinlay J.Teledermatology in the Highlands of Scotland. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare1996; 2 (1): 7-9.
64.
Wilkin D, Hallam L, Doggett M A.Measures of Need and Outcome for Primary Health Care. Oxford Medical Publications, 1992.
65.
Cartwright, A.Human Relations and Hospital Care. London: Routledge and Kegan Paul, 1964.
66.
French, K.Methodological considerations in hospital patient opinion surveys. International Journal of Nursing Studies1981; 18: 7-32.
67.
Sitzia J, Wood N.Response rate in patient satisfaction research: an analysis of 210 published studies. International Journal for Quality in Health Care1998; 10 (4): 311-317.
68.
Mahon, P.An analysis of the concept ‘patient satisfaction’ as it relates to contemporary nursing care. Journal of Advanced Nursing1996; 24(6):1241-1249.
69.
Abramowitz, S, Cote A A, Berry E.Analysing patient satisfaction: a multianalytic approach. Quality Review Bulletin1987, 13(4): 122-130.
70.
Raphael W.Patients and their Hospitals: A Survey of Patients’ Views of Life in General Hospitals. London: King Edward’s Hospital Fund for London, 1969.
71.
Ware J E Jr. Effects of acquiescent response set on patient satisfaction ratings. Medical Care1978; 16(4): 327-336.
72.
Crump W J.A telemedicine primer: an introduction to the technology and an overview of the literature. Archives of Family Medicine1995; 4(9) Sept: 796-803.
73.
Allely E B.Synchronous and asynchronous telemedicine. Journal of Medical Systems1995; 19(3): 287-294.
74.
Puskin D S, Sanders J H.Telemedicine infrastructure development. Journal of Medical Systems1995; 19(2): 125-129.
75.
Office of Rural Health Policy. Health Resources and Services Administration, US Department of Health and Human Services. Exploratory Evaluation of Rural Applications of Telemedicine, 1996.
76.
Zelickson B D, Homan L.Teledermatology in the nursing home. Archives of Dermatology1997; 133: 171-174.
77.
Kvedar J C, Edwards R A, Menn E R, Mofid M, Ganzalez E, Dover J, Parrish J A.The substitution of digital images for dermatologic physical examination. Archives of Dermatology1997; 133: 161-167.
78.
Grigsby J, Kaehny M M.Analysis of expansion of access to care through use of telemedicine and mobile health services, report 1: literature review and analytic framework. Denver, CO: Center for Health Policy research; 1993. DHHS contract 500-92-0046.
79.
Grigsby J, Sanders J H.Telemedicine: where it is and where it is going. Annals of Internal Medicine1998; 129(2): 123-127.
80.
Bashshur R L, Scott J, Silva J.Report on a Working Party Conference on Telemedicine Policy for the NII. Airlie House, 7-9 August 1994. Arlington, VA: Center for Public Service Communications, 1994.
81.
Doolittle G C, Allen A (1997) Practising oncology via telemedicine. Journal of Telemedicine and Telecare1997; 3: 63-70.
