A 10-year review of pain management practices for rib fractures at a lead trauma hospital: Are we adopting all multimodal pain management strategies?

Abstract

Objective

Rib fractures lead to altered breathing mechanics, impaired gas exchange, and in some patients to respiratory failure. Multimodal analgesia has become one of the pillars of management; however, barriers toward widespread adoption remain. We reviewed the trends in multimodal pain management strategies and their drivers over a 10-year period at a lead trauma hospital in Canada.

Methods

This is a cross-sectional study in which demographic, injury, pharmacological, as well as outcome data were collected for all adult patients admitted with rib fractures. Data were collected retrospectively and the study period was divided into three eras (2011–2014; 2015–2018; 2019–2022). Multimodal pain management was defined as either patient-controlled (PCA) or regional analgesia (epidural or continuous plane block) in combination with acetaminophen or non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs). All patients received pro re nata (PRN) narcotics. Data were stratified based on rib fracture severity, age, and intubation on arrival.

Results

We identified 2586 patients with rib fractures (mild non-flail 32.6%; moderate non-flail 50.2%; flail 17.2%). The use of standing acetaminophen and NSAIDs increased over time for all groups. Regional analgesia use increased while PCA use reduced, particularly in the flail group. Only 7% of flail patients intubated on arrival received regional analgesia. Among those not intubated on arrival, only 35% of flail and 23% of non-flail patients received multimodal pain management. Over time, multimodal pain management decreased in the non-flail group due to a reduction in PCA use without an equal rise in regional anesthesia. Those without multimodal pain management were older and the mechanism of injury was more likely a fall. Among those with a flail, who were non-intubated at presentation, only 31% of those aged >65 received multimodal pain regimens compared to 45% in those ≤65y.

Conclusions

Although multimodal pain management strategies have improved over time, a large proportion of patients, even among those with flail chest, still do not receive multimodal pain management. Elderly patients, at highest risk of adverse outcomes, were less likely to receive multimodal pain management strategies and should be the target of performance improvement initiatives.