Bad news is bad news: let's not make it worse

Abstract

There is no painless way of breaking bad news. However, providing patients and their relatives with information which may be very distressing to them is an important contribution to their coming to terms with a tragedy. Clinicians often seek to avoid being the bearers of ill-tidings, not through malice or a lack of concern but, particularly, through their anxiety about being able to deal with the consequences of giving such information and a natural reluctance to avoid causing distress to others. While confirmatory research data are sparse, clinical experience suggests a number of guidelines for breaking bad news. These always have to be used flexibly and tailored to meet the specific needs and circumstances of those who are to be told.

Keywords

communication trauma bad news

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Alexander DA. 1990. Psychological intervention for victims and helpers after disasters . Br J Gen Pract 40: 345-348 .

Alexander DA. 1993. Burns victims after a major disaster: reactions of patients and their care-givers . Burns 19: 105-109 .

Alexander DA. 1997. Psychological aspects of trauma. In: Greaves I , Porter K , Burke D eds. Key topics in trauma. Oxford: Bios , 249-257.

Alexander DA. 1999. Human reactions to trauma. In: Greaves I , Porter K eds. Prehospital medicine. London: Arnold , 537-547.

Argyle M. 1967. The psychology of interpersonal behaviour. Baltimore, MD: Penguin .

Buckman R. 1993. Communication in palliative care: a practical guide. In: Doyle D , Hanks GWC , Macdonald N eds. Orford textbook of palliative medicine. Oxford: Oxford University Press , 47-61.

Cathcart F 1988. Seeing the body after death . Br Med J 297: 997-998 .

Doyal L , Wilsher D. 1994. Withholding and withdrawing life sustaining treatment from elderly patients; towards formal guidelines . Br Med J 308: 1689-1692 .

General Medical Council Education Committee . 1993. Tomorrow's doctors: recommendations on undergraduate medical education. London: General Medical Council .

10.

Gilhooley MLM , Berkeley JS , McCann K , Gilding F , Murray K. 1988. Truth telling with dying cancer patients . Pall Med 2: 64-71 .

11.

Joseph S , Williams R , Yule W 1997. Understanding posttraumatic stress. Chichester: Wiley .

12.

Maguire P , Faulkner A. 1988. How to do it: communicate with cancer patients. 1. Handling bad news and difficult questions . Br Med J 297: 907-909 .

13.

Marrow J. 1997. Sudden death in a family member. In: Hind CRK ed. Communication skills in medicine. London: BMJ Publishing Group , 126-141.

14.

Maynard D. 1989. Breaking bad news in clinical settings. In: Dervin B ed. Progress in communication sciences. New Jersey: Alex Publishing Company , 161-163.

15.

McLauchlan CAJ. 1990. ABC of major trauma. Handling distressed relatives and breaking bad news . Br Med J 301: 1145-1149 .

16.

McLauchlan CAJ. 1996. Handling distressed relatives and breaking bad news. In: Skinner D , Driscoll P , Earlam R eds. ABC of major trauma, 2nd edn. London: BMJ Publishing Group , 88-92.

17.

Mitchell MH , Lynch MB. 1997. Should relatives be allowed in the resuscitation room? J Accid Emerg Med 14: 366-369 .

18.

Myerscough PR. 1992. Talking with patients, 2nd edn. Oxford: Oxford Medical Publications .

19.

Parkes CM. 1993. Bereavement. In: Doyle D , Hanks GWC , Macdonald N eds. Oxford textbook of palliative medicine. Oxford: Oxford University Press , 665-678.

20.

Robinson SM , Mackenzie-Ross S , Campbell Hewson GL , Egleston CV , Prevost AT. 1998. Psychological effect of witnessed resuscitation on bereaved relatives . Lancet 352: 614-617 .

21.

Sherwood SJ , Start RD. 1995. Asking relatives for permission for a post-mortem examination . Postgrad Med J 71: 269-272 .

22.

Speck P. 1978. Loss and grief in medicine. London: Baillière Tindall .

23.

Stroebe W , Stroebe MS. 1987. Bereavement and health. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press .

24.

van der Woning M. 1997. Should relatives be invited to witness a resuscitation attempt? A review of the literature . Accid Emerg Nurs 5: 215-218 .

25.

Watson ON , Graves TD. 1966. Quantitative research in proxemic behaviour . American Anthropologist 68: 971-985 .

26.

Working Group of the British Association for Accident and Emergency Medicine and the Royal College of Nursing . 1995. Bereavement care in A & E departments. London: Royal College of Nursing .