To assess how Finland, Norway and Sweden reorganised their alcohol policies after the travellers import quotas for alcoholic beverages were abolished in 2004.
Data & Methods
Alcohol taxation, alcohol programs and other alcohol policy changes, as well as common alcohol policy initiatives by the Nordic Alcohol monopoly countries are examined. In addition to relevant research literature, the main sources used are public reports and documents as well as interviews with nine key informants in the field of alcohol policy.
Results
Finland is characterized as the country with the highest alcohol consumption and an alcohol policy that is different from the policies in Norway and Sweden. Typical for Norway, apart from an increased availability of alcoholic beverages, is an active engagement in international alcohol policy issues, whereas Sweden is characterized by big administrative alcohol policy changes, and by the rulings of the EC-court in alcohol policy matters.
Conclusions
Alcohol policy in Finland has not been as prioritized as in Norway and Sweden, and there has not been an active political support for restrictive social alcohol policy in Finland. Despite clear similarities, the differences in Finland's, Norway's and Sweden's alcohol policies have increased since 2004, and it has become increasingly difficult to talk about a common Nordic alcohol policy.
AndersonP. & BaumbergB. (2006): Alcohol in Europe. London: Institute of Alcohol Studies
8.
BaborT. & CaetanoR. & CasswellS. & EdwardsG. & GiesbrechtN. & GrahamK. & GrubeJ. & GruenewaldP. & HillL. & HolderH. & HomelR. & Österberg, E. & RehmJ. & RoomR. & RossowI. (2003): Alcohol: No Ordinary Commodity. Research and Public Policy. Oxford: Oxford and London: University Press
9.
BomanU. & EngdahlB. & Gustafsson,N.-K. &, HradilovaSelin, K. & RamstedtM. (2006): Alkoholkonsumtionen i Sverige fram till år 2005. SoRAD Rapportserie, nr 39. Stockholm: Stockholms Universitet, SoRAD
10.
BruunK. & EdwardsG. & LumioM. & Mäkelä,K. & PanL. & Popham,R. E. & RoomR. & SchmidtW. & Skog,O.-J. & SulkunenP. & Österberg,E. (1975): Alcohol Control Policies in Public Health Perspective. The Finnish Foundation for Alcohol Studies. Volume 25. Helsinki: The Finnish Foundation for Alcohol Studies
11.
BryhniA. (red.) (2006): Rusmidler i Norge. Det norske drikkemønsteret – under endring?Oslo: Statens institutt for rusmiddelforskning, SIRUS. [Ref. 30.11.2007. Online: http://www.sirus.no/files/pub/332/rin_2006_eng.pdf]
BullB. (2005): The Nordic countries and the WHO Resolution on Alcohol. Nordisk alkohol- & narkotikatidskrift20 (English Supplement): 163–166
14.
CisnerosÖrnberg, J. & Ólafsdóttir,H. (2007): Hur sälja alkohol? Nordiska alkoholmonopol i en tid av förändring. Nordisk alkohol-& narkotikatidskrift24 (4): 371–394
15.
EdwardsG. & AndersonP. & Babor,T. F. & CasswellS. & FerrenceR. & GiesbrechtN. & GodfreyC. & Holder,H. D. & LemmensP. & Mäkelä,K. & Midanik,L. T. & Norström,T. & Österberg,E. & Romelsjö,A. & RoomR. & SimpuraJ. & Skog,O.-J. (1994): Alcohol Policy and the Public Good. Oxford: Oxford University Press
16.
En vurdering av særavgiftene (2007): Utredning fra et utvalg oppnevnt av Finansdepartementet 1. desember 2006. Avgitt 22. juni 2007. Norges offentlige utredninger (NOU 2007:8). [Ref. 30.11.2007. Online: http://www.regjeringen.no/Upload/FIN/nou/NOU_2007_8.pdf]
Horverak,Ø. (2006): Norwegian Drinking Patterns –Undergoing Change? I: Bryhni,A. (red.): Rusmidler i Norge. Det norske drikkemønsteret – under endring?Oslo: Statens institutt for rusmiddelforskning, SIRUS. [Ref. 31.11.2007. Online: http://www.sirus.no/files/pub/332/rin_2006_eng.pdf]
21.
Innst.O.nr.22 (2002–2003) Innstilling fra sosialkomiteen om lov om endring i alkoholloven (likebehandling av øl og annen drikk med lavere alkoholinnhold enn 4,76 volumprosent). [Ref. 30.11.2007. Online: http://www.stortinget.no/inno/2002/200203-022-002.html]
22.
KarlssonT. (1999): A Tax Paradise in the Making? Alcohol Regulations in the Åland Islands. Contemporary Drug Problems26 (Spring): 3–30
23.
KarlssonT. & TigerstedtC. (2004): Testing new models in Finnish, Swedish and Norwegian alcohol policies, Nordisk alkohol- & narkotikatidskrift21 (English supplement): 77–90
KOM (2006) 625. Meddelande från kommissionen till rådet, Europaparlamentet, Europeiska Ekonomiska och sociala kommittén samt regionkommittén.En EU-strategi för att stödja medlemsstaterna i arbetet med att minska de alkoholrelaterade skadorna.Bryssel, 24.10.2006
26.
Kühlhorn,E. & HibellB. & LarssonS. & RamstedtM. & ZetterbergH. L. (2000): Alkoholkonsumtionen i Sverige under 1990-talet. Alkoholinspektionen, FHI, Svenska Bryggarföreningen och Vin & Sprit AB, Stockholm
27.
LeifmanH. (2001): Estimations of unrecorded alcohol consumption levels and trends in 14 European countries, Nordisk alkohol- & narkotikatidskrift18 (English supplement): 54–70
RP 38/2008 rd. Regeringens proposition till Riksdagen med förslag till lag om ändring av alkohollagen. 11.4.2008
40.
Rusmedelsstatistisk årsbok 2000 (2000): Alkohol och droger. Helsingfors: Forskningsoch utvecklingscentralen för social- och hälsovården, STAKES
41.
Statistisk årsbok om alkohol och narkotika 2007 (2007): Alkohol och droger. Helsingfors: Forsknings- och utvecklingscentralen för social- och hälsovården, STAKES
42.
Statsrådets principbeslut om riktlinjerna för alkoholpolitiken (2003): Social- och hälsovårdsministeriets broschyrer 2003:6. Helsingfors: Social- och hälsovårdsministeriet
43.
SulkunenP. & SuttonC. & TigerstedtC. & WarpeniusK. (Eds.) (2000): Broken Spirits. Power and Ideas in Nordic Alcohol Control. NAD Publications No: 39. Helsinki: NAD
44.
Særavgifter og grensehandel (2003): Rapport fra Grensehandelsutvalget. Utredning fra et utvalg oppnevnt av regjeringen22. januar 2003. Avgitt til Finansdepartementet 30. april 2003. Norges offentlige utredninger (NOU 2003:17). [Ref. 30.11.2007. Online: http://www.regjeringen.no/Rpub/NOU/20032003/017/PDFS/NOU200320030017000DDDPDFS.pdf]
45.
TigerstedtC. (2001a): The dissolution of the alcohol policy field: Studies on the Nordic countries. Helsinki: University of Helsinki.
46.
TigerstedtC. (2001b): En lans för upplösning-en. Nordisk alkohol- & narkotikatidskrift18 (5–6): 495–498
47.
TigerstedtC. (2005): Miten alkoholipolitiikkaa johdetaan (Hur styrs alkoholpolitiken?). (opublicerad manuscript)
48.
TigerstedtC. & KarlssonT. & Mäkelä,P. & Österberg,E. & TuominenI. (2006): Health in alcohol policies: The European Union and its Nordic Member States. In: Ståhl,T. et al. (Eds.): Health in All Policies. Prospects and potentials. Ministry of Social Affairs and Health & European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies, 111–127
49.
TigerstedtC. & KarlssonT. (2003): Svårt att kasta loss. Finlands och Sveriges alko-holpolitiska kursändringar efter år 1990. Nordisk alkohol- & narkotikatidskrift20 (6): 409–425
50.
TigerstedtC. & Österberg,E. (2007): Alkoholskadorna är fortfarande finska men har också blivit franska. Nordisk alkohol- & narkotikatidskrift24 (4): 414–418
51.
UglandT. (2002): Policy re-categorization and integration: Europeanization of Nordic alcohol control policies. Report No 3. Oslo: ARENA
