This article explores the nature of professional accounting knowledge via an exposé of the recent history of the Australian accounting profession and the means it employed to defend its privileged status in the face of widespread criticisms of its technical practices. Central to the profession's survival strategy was the imposition of particular accounting practices by fiat ('accounting standards') in order to coerce occupational unity and construct an appearance of cognitive authority. Subsequently, the accounting profession has succeeded in effectively redefining its role to accom modate better its epistemological circumstances. This has involved subsuming its traditional concern with the portrayal of a 'true and fair' view of underlying economic phenomena in favour of merely ensuring compliance with regulations of increasing number and complexity. The narrative highlights the ability of this profession to re create its knowledge base to serve its own interests and to draw on the support of other powerful institutions in achieving this outcome.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Abbott, A.D. (1988) The System of Professions: An Essay on the Division of Expert LaborChicago: University of Chicago Press.
2.
Accounting Handbook1997Sydney: Prentice Hall.
3.
Allen, K.A. (1991) 'In Pursuit of Professional Dominance: Australian Accounting 1953-1985' Accounting, Auditing and Accountability Journal4(1): 51-57.
4.
American Accounting Association Committee on Concepts and Standards for External Reporting (1977) Statement on Accounting Theory and Theory AcceptanceFlorida: American Accounting Association.
5.
Atkinson, P. and S. Delamont (1990) 'Professions and Powerlessness: Female Marginality in the Learned Occupations' The Sociological Review38(1): 90-110.
6.
Australian Corporations Law (1997 edition) Sydney: Butterworths.
7.
Baer, W.C. (1986) 'Expertise and Professional Standards' Work and Occupations13(4): 532-52.
8.
Baxter, W.T. (1978) 'Accounting Standards: Boon or Curse?' republished in S. A. Zeff and B. G. Dharan (eds) (1994) Readings and Notes on Financial Accounting: Issues and Controversies (4th ed.) New York: McGraw-Hill: 9-22.
9.
Begum, R. and B. West (1996) 'Non-Current Asset Valuation: An Australian Survey'Charter67(1): 49-51.
10.
Belkaoui, A. (1991) 'The Context of the Contemporary Accounting Profession ' Advances in Public Interest Accounting4: 83-97.
11.
Birkett, W.P. and R.G. Walker (1971) 'Responses of the Australian Accounting Profession to Company Failures in the 1960s'Abacus7(2): 97-136.
12.
Boreham, P. (1983) 'Indetermination: Professional Knowledge, Organization and Control' The Sociological Review31(4): 693-718.
13.
Boreham, P., A. Pemberton and P. Wilson (1976) (eds) The Professions in Australia: A Critical AppraisalBrisbane: University of Queensland Press.
14.
Brewer, L. (1996) 'Bureaucratic Organisation of Professional Labour ' Australian and New Zealand Journal of Sociology32(3): 21-38.
15.
Burchell, S., C. Clubb and A.G. Hopwood (1985) 'Accounting in its Social Context: Towards a History of Value Added in the United Kingdom' Accounting, Organizations and Society10(4): 381-413.
16.
Burchell, S., C. Clubb, A.Hopwood, J. Hughes and J. Nahapiet (1980) 'The Roles of Accounting in Organizations and Society' Accounting, Organizations and Society5(1): 5-27.
17.
Carr-Saunders, A.M. (1928) 'Professions: Their Organization and Place in Society' republished in H. M. Vollmer and D. L. Mills (eds) (1966) ProfessionalizationEnglewood Cliffs N.J.: Prentice-Hall : 3-9.
18.
Carr-Saunders, A.M. and P.A. Wilson (1933) The ProfessionsLondon: Oxford University Press.
Chua, W.F. (1986b) 'Theoretical Constructions of and by the Real' Accounting, Organizations and Society11(6): 583-98.
29.
Chua, W.F. (1988) 'Of Gods and Demons, Science and Ideology'Advances in Public Interest Accounting2: 29-46.
30.
Chua, W.F. and A. Sinclair (1994) 'Interests and the Profession-State Dynamic: Explaining the Emergence of the Australian Public Sector Accounting Standards Board'Journal of Business Finance and Accounting21(5): 669-705.
31.
Clarke, F.L., G.W. Dean and K.G. Oliver (1997) Corporate Collapse: Regulatory, Accounting and Ethical BehaviourCambridge: Cambridge University Press.
32.
Colebatch, T. (1997) 'Sweeping Audit Reforms Urged' The Age September 24: B3.
33.
Collins, R. (1990) 'Market Closure and the Conflict Theory of the Professions' in M. Burrage and R. Torstendahl (eds) Professions in Theory and History: Rethinking the Study of the ProfessionsLondon : Sage: 24-43.
34.
Cooper, D.J. and T.M. Hopper (1987) 'Critical Studies in Accounting' Accounting, Organizations and Society12(5): 407-414.
35.
Cooper, D. and M. Sherer (1984) 'The Value of Corporate Accounting Reports: Arguments for a Political Economy of Accounting'Accounting, Organizations and Society9(3/4): 207-232.
36.
Crompton, R. (1987) 'Gender and Accountancy: A Response to Tinker and Neimark'Accounting, Organizations and Society12(1): 103-110.
37.
Deegan, C., P. Kent and C.J. Lin (1994) 'The True and Fair View: A Study of Australian Auditors' Application of the Concept'Australian Accounting Review4(1): 2-12.
38.
Dent, M. (1993) 'Professionalism, Educated Labour and the State: Hospital Medicine and the New Managerialism' The Sociological Review41(2): 244-73.
39.
Derber, C. (1982a) 'The Proletarianization of the Professional: A Review Essay' in C. Derber (ed.) Professionals as Workers: Mental Labour in Advanced CapitalismBoston: G. K. Hall: 13-34.
40.
Derber, C. (1982b) 'Toward a New Theory of Professionals as Workers: Advanced Capitalism and Postindustrial Labor' in C. Derber (ed.) Professionals as Workers: Mental Labour in Advanced CapitalismBoston: G. K. Hall: 193-208.
41.
Elliott, P. (1972) The Sociology of the ProfessionsLondon: Macmillan.
42.
Fallshaw, R. (1993) 'Getting it Wrong by Following the Rules'Business Review Weekly15(11): 105.
43.
Feller, B. (1974) 'Accounting Standards: Objectives, Problems, Achievements ' The Australian Accountant44(7): 392-401.
44.
Freidson, E. (1983) 'The Theory of Profession: State of the Art' in R. Dingwall and P. Lewis (eds) The Sociology of the ProfessionsLondon: Macmillan.
45.
Freidson, E. (1986) Professional Powers: A Study of the Institutionalization of Formal KnowledgeChicago: University of Chicago Press.
46.
Gambling, T. (1977) 'Magic, Accounting and Morale' Accounting, Organizations and Society2(2): 141-51.
47.
Gerboth, D.L. (1973) 'Research, Intuition, and Politics in Accounting Inquiry' The Accounting Review48(3): 475-82.
48.
Gibson, K. and M. Goyen (1996) 'Financial Measurement and Australian Accounting Standards' Accounting Research Journal9(1): 56-73.
49.
Godfrey, J., A. Hodgson and S. Holmes (1997) Accounting Theory (3rd ed.) Brisbane: John Wiley.
50.
Goldstein, J. (1984) 'Foucault Among the Sociologists: The "Disciplines" and the History of the Professions' History and Theory23(2): 170-92.
51.
Green, S. (1997) 'Auditor-General Lashes Out at Changes to His Office'The Age October 31: A1.
52.
Greenwood, E. (1957) 'Attributes of a Profession' republished in H. M. Vollmer and D. L. Mills (eds) (1966) ProfessionalizationEnglewood Cliffs N.J.: Prentice-Hall : 10-19.
53.
Grice, R. (1993) 'Message From the President'Charter64(2): 4.
54.
Guthrie, J. and L. English (1997) 'Guarding the Independence of the Victorian Auditor-General and the Public Interest' Australian Accounting Review7(1): 12-15.
55.
Halliday, T.C. (1985) 'Knowledge Mandates: Collective Influence by Scientific, Normative and Syncretic Professions' The British Journal of Sociology36(3): 421-47.
56.
Henderson, S. (1985) 'The Impact of Financial Accounting Standards on Auditing'The Australian Accountant55(3): 50-53.
57.
Henderson, S. (1993) 'Financial Accounting in Australia: Retrospect and Prospect'Accounting Forum17(3): 4-18.
58.
Hines, R. (1983) 'Economic Consequences of Accounting Standards: A Good Reason for a Representative ASRB' The Chartered Accountant in Australia54(1): 24-27.
59.
Hines, R. (1987) 'Financial Accounting Standard Setting: From Truth to Due Process'The Chartered Accountant in Australia58(1): 30-33.
60.
Hines, R. (1988) 'Financial Accounting: In Communicating Reality, We Construct Reality' Accounting, Organizations and Society13(3): 251-62.
61.
Hines, R. (1991) 'The FASB's Conceptual Framework, Financial Accounting and the Maintenance of the Social World' Accounting, Organizations and Society16(4): 313-31.
62.
Hines, R. (1992) 'Accounting: Filling the Negative Space' Accounting, Organizations and Society17(3/4): 313-41.
63.
Hoggett, J. and L. Edwards (1990) Accounting in Australia (2nd ed.) Brisbane: John Wiley.
64.
Hopper, T., J. Storey and H. Willmott (1987) 'Accounting for Accounting: Towards the Development of a Dialectical View' Accounting, Organizations and Society12(5): 437-56.
65.
House, E.R. (1993) Professional Evaluation: Social Impact and Political ConsequencesNewbury Park: Sage .
66.
Jamous, H. and B. Peloille (1970) 'Professions or Self-Perpetuating Systems? Changes in the French University-Hospital System' in J. A. Jackson (ed.) Professions and ProfessionalizationCambridge: Cambridge University Press: 109-152.
67.
Johnson, P. (1995) 'Towards an Epistemology for Radical Accounting: Beyond Objectivism and Relativism' Critical Perspectives on Accounting6(6): 485-509.
68.
Johnson, T.J. (1972) Professions and PowerLondon : Macmillan.
69.
Johnson, T.J. (1980) 'Work and Power' in G. Esland and G. Salaman (eds) The Politics of Work and OccupationsMilton Keynes : Open University Press: 335-71.
70.
Johnson, T.J. (1982) 'The State and the Professions: Peculiarities of the British' in A. Giddens and G. Mackenzie (eds) Social Class and the Division of Labour: Essays in Honour of Ilya NeustadtCambridge : Cambridge University Press: 186-208.
71.
' Joint Submission of the Australian Accounting Profession to the National Companies and Securities Commission' (1982) reproduced in The Australian Accountant52(5): 308-310.
72.
Jonson, P.D. and E.P. Jonson (1994) 'Financial Regulation and Moral Suasion'Quadrant38(7/8): 85-89.
73.
Kerr, A., S. Cunningham-Burley and A. Amos (1997) 'The New Genetics: Professionals' Discursive Boundaries'The Sociological Review45(2): 279-303.
74.
Kuhn, T.S. (1970) The Structure of Scientific Revolutions (2nd ed.) Chicago: University of Chicago Press.
75.
Larson, M.S. (1977) The Rise of Professionalism: A Sociological AnalysisBerkeley: University of California Press.
76.
Lawson, M. (1995) 'What's in a Phrase? A Certain Confusion' Australian Financial Review May 22: 3.
77.
Lee, T.A. (1991) 'A Review Essay: Professional Foundations and Theories of Professional Behaviour'The Accounting Historians Journal18(2): 193-203.
78.
Loft, A. (1986) 'Towards a Critical Understanding of Accounting: The Case of Cost Accounting in the U.K., 1914-1925' Accounting, Organizations and Society11(2): 137-69.
79.
MacDonald, J. (1995) 'Pain for Auditors Increases: $6 Billion in Suits Now Outstanding' The Age January 2: 13.
80.
Macdonald, K.M. (1995) The Sociology of the ProfessionsLondon: Sage.
81.
Makkai, T. (1991) 'The Formation and Evolution of Professional Engineering Values'The Australian and New Zealand Journal of Sociology27(3): 332-50.
82.
McGregor, W. (1985) 'Legal Backing for the Profession's Standards'The Australian Accountant55(11): 67-69.
83.
McGregor, W. (1989) 'The New Standard Bearer' Chartered Accountant60(8): 48-49.
84.
McGregor, W. (1992) 'True and Fair View: An Accounting Anachronism'Australian Accountant62(1): 68-69.
85.
McInerney, B.F. (1979) 'A Practitioner's View'The Chartered Accountant in Australia50(1): 21-26.
86.
Meiksins, P.F. and J.M. Watson (1989) 'Professional Autonomy and Organizational Constraint: The Case of Engineers'The Sociological Quarterly30(4): 561-85.
87.
Middleton, K. (1997) 'Doctors in Bush Carry Heavy Load'The Age 26 July: A8.
88.
Miller, M. (1995) 'The Credibility of Australian Financial Reporting: Are the Co-regulation Arrangements Working?' Australian Accounting Review5(2): 3-16.
89.
Mitchell, A., A. Puxty, P. Sikka and H. Willmott (1991) Accounting for Change: Proposals for Reform of Audit and AccountingLondon: Fabian Society.
90.
Montagna, P. (1986) 'Accounting Rationality and Financial Legitimation'Theory and Society15(1/2): 103-38.
91.
Most, K.S. (1993) The Future of the Accounting Profession: A Global PerspectiveWestport Conn.: Quorum Books.
92.
Naser, K.H.M. (1993) Creative Financial Accounting: Its Nature and UseLondon: Prentice Hall.
93.
Olson, W.E. (1982) The Accountancy Profession: Years of Trial: 1969-1980New York: American Institute of Certified Public Accountants.
94.
Orlikowski, W.J. (1988) 'The Data Processing Occupation: Professionalization or Proletarianization?' Research in the Sociology of Work4: 95-124.
95.
Parker, R.H., C.G. Peirson and A.L. Ramsay (1987) 'Australian Accounting Standards and the Law'Company and Securities Law Journal5(November): 231-46.
96.
Parkin, F. (1979) Marxism and Class Theory: A Bourgeois CritiqueNew York: Columbia University Press .
97.
Paton, G. (1993) 'From the President'Australian Accountant63(10): 1.
98.
Paton, W.A. (1971) 'Earmarks of a Profession—and the APB'Journal of Accountancy131(1): 37-45.
99.
Peirson, G. and A.L. Ramsay (1983) 'A Review of the Regulation of Financial Reporting in Australia'Company and Securities Law Journal1(November): 286-300.
100.
Perks, R.W. (1993) Accounting and SocietyLondon : Chapman and Hall.
101.
Preston, A.M., D.J. Cooper, D.P. Scarborough and R.C. Chilton (1995) 'Changes in the Code of Ethics of the U.S. Accounting Profession, 1917 and 1988: The Continual Quest for Legitimation' Accounting, Organizations and Society20(6): 507-545.
102.
Prosser, V. (1991) 'Unification: The Crucial Question' Charter62(1): 11-12.
103.
Rahman, A.R. (1992) The Australian Accounting Standards Review Board: The Establishment of its Participative Review ProcessNew York: Garland Publishing.
104.
Richardson, A.J. (1987) 'Accounting as a Legitimating Institution'Accounting, Organizations and Society12(4): 341-55.
105.
Robson, K. and D. Cooper (1990) 'Understanding the Development of the Accountancy Profession in the United Kingdom' in D. J. Cooper and T. M. Hopper (eds) Critical AccountsLondon: Macmillan : 366-90.
106.
Roth, J. (1974) 'Professionalism: The Sociologist's Decoy'Sociology of Work and Occupations1(1): 6-23.
107.
Ryan, F.J.O. (1967) 'A True and Fair View'Abacus3(2): 95-108.
108.
Ryan, F.J.O. (1974) 'A True and Fair View Revisited' TheAustralian Accountant44(1): 8-16.
109.
Saks, M. (1983) 'Removing the Blinkers? A Critique of Recent Contributions to the Sociology of Professions' The Sociological Review31(1): 1-21.
110.
Scott, A. (1988) 'Imputing Beliefs: A Controversy in the Sociology of Knowledge'The Sociological Review36(1): 31-56.
111.
Shaw, K.E. (1987) 'Skills, Control and the Mass Professions' The Sociological Review35(4): 775-94.
112.
'Significant Agreement on Accounting and Standard Setting' ( 1995) Australian Accountant65(9): 5.
113.
Solomons, D. (1978) 'The Politicization of Accounting'Journal of Accountancy146(5): 65-72.
114.
'Statements on Recommended Accounting Practice' (1971) Editorial The Australian Accountant41(6): 245.
115.
Studdy, J.B. (1979) 'Self Regulation or Government Regulation'The Chartered Accountant in Australia50(1): 16-20.
116.
Sykes, T. (1990) 'True, Fair or False?' Australian Business10(36): 42-46.
117.
Sykes, T. (1994) The Bold Riders: Behind Australia's Corporate CollapsesSydney: Allen and Unwin.
118.
Tinker, T. and T. Puxty (1995) Policing Accounting Knowledge: The Market For Excuses AffairPrinceton: Markus Wiener .
119.
Torstendahl, R. (1990) 'Essential Properties, Strategic Aims and Historical Development: Three Approaches to Theories of Professionalism' in M. Burrage and R. Torstendahl (eds) Professions in Theory and History: Rethinking the Study of the ProfessionsLondon: Sage: 44-61.
120.
Waldron, B. (1991) 'From the President'Australian Accountant61(4): 5.
121.
Walker, F. (1981) 'Regulation of the Accounting Profession'The Australian Accountant51(4): 235.
122.
Walker, R.G. (1987) 'Australia's ASRB. A Case Study of Political Activity and Regulatory Capture' Accounting and Business Research17(67): 269-86.
123.
Walker, R.G. (1993) 'A Feeling of Deja Vu: Controversies in Accounting and Auditing in Australia'Critical Perspectives on Accounting4(1): 97-109.
124.
Watts, R.L. and J.L. Zimmerman (1979) 'The Demand for and Supply of Accounting Theory: The Market for Excuses'The Accounting Review54(2): 273-305.
Wells, M. (1976) 'A Revolution in Accounting Thought?'The Accounting Review51(3): 471-82.
127.
West, B.P. (1995) 'The Liability of Company Auditors: Injustice or the Failure of Professionalism?' Journal of Australian Political Economy35(June): 24-40.
128.
West, B.P. (1996) 'The Professionalisation of Accounting. A Review of Recent Historical Research and its Implications' Accounting History NS1(1): 77-102.
129.
Whittred, G., I. Zimmer and S. Taylor (1996) Financial Accounting: Incentive Effects and Economic Consequences (4th ed.) Sydney : Harcourt Brace.
130.
Wilensky, H. (1964) 'The Professionalization of Everyone?' American Journal of Sociology70(2): 137-58.
131.
Willmott, H. (1986) 'Organising the Profession: A Theoretical and Historical Examination of the Development of the Major Accountancy Bodies in the U.K .' Accounting, Organizations and Society11(6): 555-80.
132.
Wolnizer, P.W. (1987) Auditing as Independent AuthenticationSydney: Sydney University Press.
133.
Zeff, S.A. (1973) Forging Accounting Principles in AustraliaMelbourne: Australian Society of Accountants .
134.
Zeff, S.A. (1978) 'The Rise of "Economic Consequences"'Journal of Accountancy146(6): 56-63.
135.
Ziman, J. (1968) Public Knowledge: The Social Dimension of ScienceCambridge: Cambridge University Press.
