The question is posed: can social activists be assisted by a conceptual scheme that is intelligent about the internal complexities of the social action process? A theoretical analysis considers the dialectic mode and the domination mode of social action. With the aid of two case studies (Three Mile Island nuclear accident and the Newport power controversy) the analysis concludes that the process of social action is an inter-mix of dialectic and domination modes. A new consciousness is called for which encompasses the need for strong action and the requirement to understand how dominance is often far more complicated than the caricatures that prevail in the minds of activists.
Get full access to this article
View all access options for this article.
References
1.
Acton, H.B. (1967), 'Dialectic', in P. E. Edwards (ed.), Encyclopaedic of Philosophy, Vol., 2, New York, Macmillan.
2.
Ball, R.A. (1979), The Dialectic Method: Its Application to Social Theory', Social Forces, 57, 3, 785-98.
3.
Barr, L.R. (1978), 'Conflict Resolution in Environmental Management: The Newport Power Station Controversy', Australian Geographical Studies, 16, 43-52.
4.
Bird, G.H. (1962), Kant's Theory of Knowledge, London, Routledge & Kegan Paul.
5.
Boccabella, L. (1981), 'High Court—Relics Have Standing', Legal Services Bulletin, 6, 5, 262-3.
6.
Browne, K. (1981), 'Schooling, Capitalism and the Mental/Manual Division of Labour,'Sociological Review, 29, 3.
7.
Burke, K. (1962), A Rhetoric of Motives, New York, Meridian.
8.
Colletti, L. (1975), 'Marxism and the Dialectic', New Left Review, 93.
9.
DeMaria, W. (1982), The Dreaming and the Doing: Utopian Foundations of Social Action', Journal of Sociology and Social Welfare , 9, 2, 186-202.
10.
Dwyer, J. (1981), 'Public Interest Litigation: Who Can Start Proceedings?'Legal Services Bulletin, 6, 5, 219-24.
11.
Engels, F. (1962), Ludwig Feuerbach and the End of Classical German Philosophy in K. Marx and F. Engels, Selected Works , Vol., II, Moscow, Foreign Languages Publishing House.
12.
Fredricks, R.W. (1972), 'Dialectical Sociology Towards a Resolution of the Current Crisis in Western Sociology', British Journal of Sociology, 23.
13.
Hall, R. (1967), 'Dialectic' in P. E. Edwards (ed.), Encyclopaedia of Philosophy, Vol., 2, New York, Macmillan.
14.
Hartnett, B. (1980), 'Newport: A Conflict over Power', in S. Encel et al., Decisions: Case Studies in Australian Public Policy, Melbourne, Longman Cheshire.
15.
Hegel, G.W.F. (1949), The Phenomenology of Mind, 2ndedition, revised, London, George Allen and Unwin.
16.
Hook, S. (1939), 'Dialectic in Social and Historical Inquiry', The Journal of Philosophy, XXXVI, 14.
17.
Kapp, E. (1942), Greek Foundations of Traditional Logic , New York, Columbia University Press.
18.
Kneale, W. and M (1962), The Development of Logic, Oxford, Clarendon Press.
19.
Kvale, S. (1976), 'Facts and Dialectics', in J. F. Rychlak (ed.), Contributions to Human Development, Vol., 2, Basel, Karger, Chapter 9.
20.
Lenin, V.I. (1961), 'On the Question of Dialectics', in Philosophical Notebooks published as Collected Works , Moscow, Foreign Language Publishing House.
21.
Mancuso, J.C. (1976), 'Dialectic Man as a Subject in Psychological Research' , in J. F. Rychlak (ed.), Contributions to Human Development , Vol., 2., Basel Karger, Chapter 9.
Martin, D. (1980), Three Mile Island: Prologue or Epilogue? , Cambridge, Mass., Ballinger.
24.
Mates, B. (1953), Stoic Logic, Berkeley .
25.
Mathieson. (1980), Law, Society and Political Action, London , Academic Press.
26.
Meehan, M. (1981), 'A Verdict in the Ploughshares Eight Case', Commonwealth, 28, 468-469.
27.
Mussachia, M.M. (1977), 'On Contradiction in Dialectical Materialism' , Science and Society, XLI, 1, 257-280.
28.
Nelkin, D. (1981), 'Some Social and Political Dimensions of Nuclear Power: Examples from Three Mile Island', American Political Science Review, 75, 1, 132-145.
29.
Nelkin, D. and M. Pollak, (1981), 'Nuclear Protest and National Policy', Society, 18, 5, 34-38.
30.
Norman, R. (1980), 'On the Hegelian Origins', in R. Norman and S. Sayers, Hegal, Marx and Dialectic: A Debate , Sussex, Harvester Press.
31.
Novak, G. (1978), The Logic of Marxism, 5thedition, New York, Pathfinder.
32.
Popper, K. (1965), Conjectures and Refutations, London, Routledge and Kegan Paul.
33.
Quinney, R. (1980), Class, State and Crime, London, Longman Cheshire.
34.
Robinson, R. (1953), Plato's Earlier Dialectic, 2ndedition, New York, Ithaca.
35.
Rychlak, J.F. (1976), 'The Multiple Meaning of 'Dialectic" in J. F. Rychlak (ed.), Contributions to Human Development , Vol., 2., Basel Karger, Chapter 9.
36.
Sayers, S. (1980), 'On the Marxist Dialectic' in R. Norman and S. Sayers, Hegel, Marx and Dialectic: A Debate , Sussex, Harvester Press.
37.
Sayers, S. (1981-82), 'Contradiction and Dialectic in the Development of Science', Science and Society, XLV, 4, 409-436.
38.
Schneider, L. (1971), 'Dialect in Sociology', American Sociological Review, 36, 667-678.
39.
Simon, M.A. (1978), 'Action and Dialectics', Philosophy and Phenomenological Research, Vol., XXXIX, 465-479.
40.
Stenzel, J. (1964), Plato's Method of Dialectic, tr., D. J. Allan, New York, Russell and Russell.
41.
Van den Berghe, P. (1963), 'Dialectic and Functionalism: Toward a Theoretical Synthesis', American Sociological Review , 28.
42.
Walsh, E.J. (1981), 'Resource Mobilization and Citizen Protest in Communities Around Three Mile island', Social Problems , 29, 1, 1-21.
