Obsession Plus Pseudo-Science Equals Fraud: Sir Cyril Burt,Intelligence,and Social Mobility

Abstract

Get full access to this article

View all access options for this article.

References

Bodmer, W.F. and Cavalli-Storza, L.L. 1976 Genetics, Evolution, and Man. San Francisco: W. H. Freeman and Co.

Burt, Cyril 1912-13 'The inheritance of mental characters'. Eugenics Reoiew, 4: 168-200.

1917 The Distribution and Relations of Educational Abilities . Printed for the London County Council: P. S. King and Son Limited, 88-93.

1924a 'The principles of vocational guidance (II)'. British Journal of Psychology, 14: 347-9.

1924b 'The mental differences between individuals'. Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science , 213-239.

1943a 'Ability and income'. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 13: 83-98.

1943b 'The education of the young adolescent: the psychological implications of the Norwood report'. British Journal of Educational Psycholosp, 13: 126-140.

1946 'Intelligence and fertility'. Occasional Paper on Eugenics No. 2 (March): 3-43.

1950 'The trend of national intelligence'. British Journal of Sociology, 1: 154-168.

10.

1952 'Cyril Burt'. Pp. 53-73 in Edward G. Baring , Herbert S. Langfeld , Heinz Werner and Robert M. Yerkes (eds), A History of Psychology in Autobiography, Volume IV. Worcester: Clark University Press.

11.

1954 'The differentiation of intellectual ability'. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 24: 76-90.

12.

1955a The Subnormal Mind. London: Oxford University Press. Third edition.

13.

1955b 'The evidence for the concept of intelligence'. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 25: 158-77.

14.

1957 'The distribution of intelligence'. British Journal of Psychology, 48 (August): 161-175.

15.

1958a 'The inheritance of mental ability'. The American Psychologist, 13: 1-15.

16.

1958b 'Comments and criticisms: A note on the theory of intelligence '. British Journal of Educational Psychology, 28: 282-91.

17.

1958c 'Definition and scientific method in psychology'. The British Journal of Statistical Psychology, 11 (May): 31-69.

18.

1961 'Intelligence and social mobility'. The British Journal of Statistical Psychology, 14 (May): 3-24.

19.

1962 'Francis Galton and his contribution to psychology'. British Journal of Statistical Psycholosy, 14 (May): 1-49.

20.

1963 'Is intelligence distributed normally?'. The British Journal of Statistical Psychology, 16 (November): 175-90.

21.

1966a 'The genetic determination of differences in intelligence: a study of monozygotic twins reared together and apart'. The British Journal of Psychology, 57: 137-53.

22.

1966b 'Parapsychology and its implications'. International Journal of Neuropsychiatry, 2 (Sept.-Oct.): 363-77.

23.

1972 'Inheritance of general intelligence'. American Psychologist, 27 (March): 175-90.

24.

Burt, Cyril and W.L. Gregory 1958 'Scientific method in psychology: II'. The British Journal of Statistical Psychology, 11 (November): 105-128.

25.

Burt, Cyril and Margaret Howard 1956 'The multifactorial theory of inheritance and its application to intelligence'. The British Journal of Statistical Psychology, 8 (November): 95-131.

26.

1957a 'Heredity and intelligence: a reply to criticisms'. The British Journal of Statistical Psychology, 10 (May): 33-63.

27.

1957b 'The relative influence of heredity and environment on assessments of intelligence'. The British Journal of Statistical Psychology, 10 (November): 99-104.

28.

Clarke, Ann M. and A. D. B. Clarke (eds) 1975 Mental Deficiency: The changing outlook. New York: The Free Press. Third edition.

29.

Conway, J. 1958 'The inheritance of intelligence and its social implications' . The British Journal of Statistical Psychology , 11 (November): 171-90.

30.

1959 'Class differences in general intelligence: I'. The British Journal of Statistical Psychology, 12 (May): 5-33.

31.

1961 'Review of Behaviour Genetics'. British Journal of Mathematical Statistics, 14 (May): 190-1.

32.

Dorfman, D.D. 1978 'The Cyril Burt question: new findings'. Science, 201 (September): 1177-86.

33.

Eysenck, H.J. 1972 'Obituary: Sir Cyril Burt'. The British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology, 25 (May): i-iv.

34.

1977 'Sir Cyril Burt'. American Psychologist , 32 (August): 674-6.

35.

Fisher, R.A. 1918 'The correlation between relatives on the supposition of Mendelian inheritance'. Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh, 52: 399-433.

36.

1936 'Has Mendel's work been rediscovered'. Annals of Science, 1: 115-37

37.

1958 [1930] The Genetical Theory of Natural Selection. Second revised edition. New York: Dover Publication Inc.

38.

Floud, J. E. (ed.), A.H. Halsey and F.M. Martin 1957 Social Class and Educational Opportunity. Melbourne, London, Toronto: William Heinemann Ltd.

39.

Gaw, Frances , Lettice Ramsey , May Smith , and Winifred Spielman 1926 A Study in Vocational Guidance , Medical Research Council, Industrial Fatigue Research Board, Report No. 33.

40.

Gillie, Oliver 1977 'Did Sir Cyril Burt fake his research on heritability of intelligence? Part I'. Phi Delta Kappan, 58 (February): 469-92.

41.

1978 'Sir Cyril Burt and the great IQ fraud'. New Statesman (24th November): 688-94.

42.

Halsey, A.H. 1958 'Genetics, social structure and intelligence'. British Journal of Sociology, 9 (March): 15-28.

43.

1959 'Class differences in general intelligence: I'. A reply to Miss Conway. The British Journal of Statistical Psychology , 12 (May): 1-4.

44.

Halsey, A. H. (ed.) 1977 Heredity and Environment. London: Methuen and Co. Ltd.

45.

Hearnshaw, L.S. 1972a 'Obituary: Emeritus Professor Sir Cyril Burt (1883-1971)' . British Psychological Society Bulletin, 25 (January): 31-3.

46.

1972b 'Sir Cyril Burt and the NIIP'. Occupational Psychology, 46: 35-7.

47.

1972c 'Cyril Lodowic Burt'. Proceedings of the British Academy, 58: 475-92.

48.

Hogben, Lancelot 1933 Nature and Nurture. London: George Allen and Unwin.

49.

Hogben, Lancelot (ed.) 1938 Political Arithmetic. London: George Allen and Unwin.

50.

Howard, M. 1962 'Frequency curves and the ability of nations'. British Journal of Statistical Psychology, 15 (May): 80-92.

51.

Jensen, Arthur 1972 'Sir Cyril Burt'. Psychometrika , 37 (June): 115-117.

52.

1974 'Kinship correlations reported by Sir Cyril Burt'. Behaviour Genetics, 4: 1-28.

53.

Kamin, Leon J. 1974 The Science and Politics of I.Q. Maryland : Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, Publishers .

54.

1977 'Burt's IQ Data'. Science, 195 (January): 246-48.

55.

Loehlin, John C. and Robert C. Nichols 1976 Heredity, Environment, and Personality: a study of 850 sets of twins. Austin and London: University of Texas Press.

56.

McAskie, Michael and Anne M. Clarke 1976 'Parent-offspring resemblances in intelligence: theories and evidence'. British Journal of Psychology, 67: 243-73.

57.

Page, Ellis B. 1972 'Comment: "Behaviour and Heredity" '. American Psychologist, 27 (July): 660-1.

58.

Peaker, G.F. 1964 'Is intelligence normally distributed?'. The British Journal of Statistical Psychology, 17 (May): 89-90 (with reply by Cyril Burt).

59.

Rovere, Richard 1960 Senator Joe McCarthy. London : Methuen.

60.

St James-Roberts, Ian 1976 'Cheating in Science'. New Scientist , 25 November: 466-9.

61.

Valentine, Charles 1965 'Cyril Burt: A biographical sketch and appreciation' . Pp. 11-20 in Charlotte Banks and M. Broadhurst (eds), Stephanos, Studies in Psychology Presented to Cyril Burt, London: University of London Press.

62.

Wade, Nicholas 1976 'IQ and Heredity: suspicion of fraud beclouds classic experiment' . Science, 194: 916-19.

63.

Wisdom, J.O. 1971 'Four contemporary interpretations of the nature of science' . Foundations of Physics, 1: 269-84.